Blood Vines: The Grape Broker – Episode 2 Summary

Blood Vines delves deep into one of California’s most notorious wine scandals, uncovering the intricate web of deceit, betrayal, and ambition that defined the rise and fall of the Licciardi family. In "The Grape Broker: 2," host Chris Walker, alongside federal prosecutor Steve Lapham and key players like Anthony Scotto Jr., unravels the complexities of the largest grape fraud in U.S. history.

1. The Sweet Taste of Success: White Zinfandel’s Dominance

The episode opens by revisiting the booming popularity of White Zinfandel in the 1980s. By 1987, White Zinfandel was a dominant force in the wine market, selling over 8 million cases annually. Marketers capitalized on its appeal, positioning it as America’s gateway wine and fueling a nationwide obsession.

Steve Lapham highlights the economic pressures of the time:

"White zinfandel was an inexpensive wine, and the economics of it were difficult. If your grape pricing got much above $500 a ton, he was murdered with a .22 caliber bullet to the head, which is a very mafia type way of doing it. I could see that it involved a fraud on a pretty large scale. Multimillion dollar fraud." [00:11]

This surge in demand led to a grape shortage, as wineries scrambled to secure adequate supplies of Zinfandel and other varieties, exacerbating supply chain issues across the industry.

2. Enter Jack Licciardi: The Godfather of Grapes

At the heart of the crisis is Jack Licciardi, a master grapebroker whose influence over California’s vineyards was unparalleled. Known as the "godfather of grapes," Jack possessed an encyclopedic knowledge of the state’s vineyards and had the power to make or break wineries based on his grape allocations.

Chris Walker sets the stage:

"Jack Licciardi... had the opportunity to be the hero California needed. But there was also a chance that he might also be its villain." [02:04]

Jack’s reputation was built on integrity and reliability, making him a respected figure in the tightly-knit wine industry. However, his extensive control over grape distribution placed him in a pivotal position when grape mislabeling began to surface.

3. Federal Scrutiny: Steve Lapham’s Investigation

Federal prosecutor Steve Lapham spearheaded the investigation into widespread grape mislabeling. Initially, the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) deemed the case low-stakes, believing that minor discrepancies in grape varieties wouldn't significantly harm the industry:

"Wines having slightly different grapes in them was still wine, right? What was the harm?" [05:15]

However, Lapham recognized the broader implications, understanding that mislabeling threatened the integrity of California’s wine reputation. His persistence led him to focus on Jack Licciardi, suspecting the grapebroker’s central role in the fraud.

4. The Licciardi-Scotto Relationship

Anthony Scotto Jr., a fourth-generation winemaker, becomes a pivotal character as his interactions with Jack Licciardi reveal the personal dimensions of the scandal. Despite never having met Jack in person, Scotto developed a close, almost familial relationship with him.

During their first meeting, Scotto observes the guarded demeanor of Jack’s sons:

"He couldn’t move... So you know the son, Robert, he can’t move." [10:40]

Jack's struggle with muscular dystrophy added layers of complexity to his character, fostering a genuine bond with Scotto, who admired Jack’s integrity and business acumen. However, underlying tensions surfaced as Scotto sensed unease within the Licciardi family, particularly concerning Michael Licciardi’s questionable actions.

5. The Bavaro Brothers: Catalysts of the Fraud

The emergence of Nick and Frank Bavaro, two young and ambitious brothers from Escalon, marked a significant escalation in the grape fraud. Nick’s prodigious business skills quickly caught Jack’s attention, leading to his recruitment to manage the Licciardi family’s LB Ranch vineyard.

Steve Lapham explains the initiation of the scheme:

"Licciardi approached Bavaro and asked him to deliver low sugar grapes. And without field tags." [16:10]

Field tags, essentially the grapes' birth certificates, were omitted to disguise the origins of the varietals being delivered. This allowed the Bavaro brothers to substitute Zinfandel grapes with cheaper alternatives like Carignan and Grenache, which were then mislabeled to meet the high demand and inflated pricing of Zinfandel.

6. Executing the Deception: Mislabeling and Fictitious Entities

To maintain the facade, the conspirators employed several deceptive tactics:

• Fictitious Companies: They created fake vineyard names such as "Rihanna Farms" and used aliases like "George Garcia" to mask the true origins of the grapes.
• Field Tag Manipulation: By removing or falsifying field tags, they ensured that the substituted grapes were incorrectly identified as Zinfandel, complying superficially with California’s 75% rule.

Steve Lapham details the financial incentives:

"With zinfandel writing near $500 a ton at the time, and Valdepena and Carignan down around 100, he and Michael stood to make $400 in profit for every ton of mislabeled grapes they delivered." [16:31]

By 1987, the scheme had yielded nearly half a million dollars in illicit profits, with Nick delivering 1,200 tons of misrepresented grapes.

7. Industry Implications: Undermining Trust and the 75% Rule

The fraudulent activities had far-reaching consequences for the wine industry. California had recently enacted the 75% rule in 1983, mandating that a labeled grape variety must constitute at least 75% of the wine. This rule was intended to bolster consumer trust and distinguish California wines from European counterparts.

Jancis Robinson, a famed wine writer, explains:

"It was embraced by the consumer because it made wine so much simpler. And it did distinguish California wine... from slightly fusty European wine at that stage." [21:53]

Grape mislabeling directly contravened this regulation, jeopardizing the credibility of all Californian wines. The scandal threatened to erode consumer trust, casting doubt on even the most reputable labels and undermining the hard-earned reputation of the state’s wine industry.

8. Personal Vendettas and Family Discord

As the fraud unraveled, tensions within the Licciardi family intensified. Michael Licciardi, facing looming exposure, attempted to conceal his illicit activities from his father, Jack. Meanwhile, Frank Bavaro and other young conspirators grew increasingly brazen, confident in their ability to evade detection.

Steve Lapham sheds light on Michael’s motivations:

"He's due to inherit a multi million dollar a year business and his father is very stingy... So he's impatient, I think, to inherit the business and start living the good life." [13:02]

This impatience fueled Michael’s determination to secure his financial future, even at the expense of his family's legacy and the broader wine industry.

9. The Looming Confrontation: Betrayal and Exposure

As federal authorities closed in, the Licciardi family's empire teetered on the brink of collapse. The impending confrontation forced Jack to reassess his relationships and confront the possibility of betrayal from within his own ranks.

Steve Lapham narrates the unfolding crisis:

"And then all of a sudden one day, you know, some feds showed up and things kind of came to a screeching halt." [25:44]

Jack’s unwavering commitment to honor and integrity clashed with his sons’ deceitful maneuvers, setting the stage for a dramatic showdown that would determine the future of the Licciardi dynasty and the integrity of California’s wine industry.

10. Teasing the Next Chapter

The episode concludes by hinting at the intensifying drama awaiting in the next installment:

"What’s a powerful patriarch to do when the empire he built is starting to crumble?" [26:26]

Listeners are left anticipating the government's strategic maneuvers and the inevitable family confrontations that will further unravel the scandal.

Notable Quotes:

• Steve Lapham [00:11]: "White zinfandel was an inexpensive wine, and the economics of it were difficult... a fraud on a pretty large scale. Multimillion dollar fraud."

• Jack Licciardi [20:36]: "This is what I call an eye roll drink. You order it, you get an eye roll."

• Anthony Scotto Jr. [19:23]: "Just sugar and water and alcohol."

• Jancis Robinson [21:43]: "It was embraced by the consumer because it made wine so much simpler."

Conclusion

"The Grape Broker: 2" masterfully intertwines personal narratives with broader industry implications, painting a vivid picture of ambition gone awry. Through meticulous investigation and compelling storytelling, Blood Vines exposes the vulnerabilities within California’s wine industry, questioning the very trust consumers place in what they drink. As federal scrutiny intensifies and family loyalties are tested, the Licciardi saga promises to deepen, revealing the true cost of greed and deception.

Blood Vines is available on the Wondery app and other major podcast platforms. For an ad-free experience, listeners can subscribe to Wondery+.