Loading summary
A
Welcome to Breakpoint, a daily look at an ever changing culture through the lens of unchanging truth. For the Coulson Center, I'm John Stonestreet. About a decade ago, buzzfeed posted a video with testimonials that all began, quote, I'm Christian, but I'm not fill in the blank. Now, the videos mostly trumpeted progressive virtues, claiming things like I'm Christian but I'm not homophobic, I'm not ignorant, I'm not closed minded, etc. Etc. Christianity, the video basically concluded, is all about love and acceptance. Now of course, Christianity is certainly centered on the of God in Christ. But that love, like every central tenant of the Christian faith, has been revealed to us by God as such. These are foundational truths that come to us predefined. They're not open to infinite interpretations and reinterpretations. Having wrestled with these foundational truths, the Church formulated the essentials of Christian belief in the creeds, an invaluable tool for the faithful. For thousands of years, the various creeds of the Christian faith emerged when individuals or groups would claim some new word from God or would innovate some new doctrine, doctrine or practice. Often Christians were led astray and they needed to be pulled back to the truth. That happened when the new teaching was recognized to be out of alignment with accepted Church practice or belief. In other words, the creeds clarified for the Church and for Christians what was true. Now, some today see creeds as kind of man made obstacle between believers and the word of God, or as an antiquated way to interfere with the working of the Spirit. Secular critics of Christianity often suggest that each new creed was a way for the powerful to triumph and suppress other equally valid versions of the faith. None of those claims are true. The best known creed is the oldest. An old legend is that the Apostles Creed came from the Apostles who each while gathered together after the Ascension, contributed a line. That story is probably not true, but the Creed does faithfully record the Apostles teaching. Historian Justo Gonzalez noted in his book the Story of Christianity that the very first version of the Apostles Creed in came in Rome around the year 150. That's early enough for the older people in that church to have actually heard it from the Apostles themselves. The Apostles Creed distinguished Christianity from paganism. It was likely what a new convert would declare at their baptism. It contains the basics of Christian doctrine. There is one, I believe, for every member of the Trinity. The focus is on the Father as Creator, the Son as Redeemer. A mention of the Spirit as well. It also challenged groups who were trying to claim Jesus for their own movements like the Marcionites, who wanted a Jesus without judgment, or the Gnostics, who wanted a God who wasn't really the Creator of the universe, or the Docetics who wanted a Christ without flesh. Each are excluded by the words of the Apostles Creed. It was a few centuries later that the Nicene Creed distinguished Trinitarian Christians who believe Jesus to be fully divine, from those who did not. Despite the rehashed claims of Dan Brown fiction, the Council of Nicaea was not when the Romans imposed their view of a divine Jesus on the rest of the church. Christians believed that Jesus was God way before anyone had even heard of Constantine. The text of the Nicene Creed further elaborated on the Apostles Creed with the same structure and the same Trinitarian focus. It opposed the new ideas that had emerged not from pagan sources this time, but from within the church. There was an Egyptian teacher named Arius who preached that Jesus was not really God, but his divinity was more honorary than actual. That might have been easier for philosophers to grasp, but it was not what Christ and the Apostles taught. And so the Nicene Creed spelled out the truth about Jesus Christ in response to the rise of error. In other words, the creeds did not create new doctrine, nor do they fully express everything that Christians believe. Rather, they really serve as fences to show where believers can safely disagree while also clarifying which new ideas stray too far. Clear lines are still needed now, as in all times, because there are still individuals and religious groups who claim the name of Christ while adding or subtracting from what he said or from what he revealed Himself to be. Creeds are also needed whenever second or even third tier doctrine is made to be some kind of litmus test of salvation. In Mere Christianity, C.S. lewis offered a very helpful image of Christianity as a house with hallways and rooms. Throughout the history of the Church, the creeds have marked the boundaries of Christian belief, showing who's in one of the rooms of the Christian house and who is clearly in another house entirely. In that same way, the creeds remain useful and essential to Christians today. For the Colson Center, I'm John Stonestreet with Breakpoint. Today's Breakpoint was co authored by Dr. Timothy Padgett. If you appreciate Breakpoint, please leave us a review wherever you download your podcast. And for more resources like this one, Visit us@breakpoint.org.
B
Hi Breakpoint listeners. You've probably heard us talk about the Colson Fellows Program on Breakpoint. I'm excited to let you know that the Colson Fellows Team is hosting a one hour live informational webinar on November 12th at 1pm Eastern. These webinars allow you to hear an overview of the program and get your questions answered. The webinars are hosted by our Vice President and Dean of the Colson Fellowship, Michael Craven. Here at Breakpoint, we work hard to help you consider current events through a Christian worldview. If you want to go deeper to discover how to develop the wisdom and skills needed to walk wisely in this cultural moment, then the Colson Fellows Program might be for you. This ten month program takes you on a deep dive into Christian worldview through readings, devotionals, monthly cohort meetings, and more. If you're interested, an informational webinar is a great next step to learn more. Again, the webinar will be Wednesday, November 12th at 1pm Eastern Time. Register today at colsonfellows.orgwebinar that's colsonfellows.orgWebinar.
Host: John Stonestreet
Date: November 11, 2025
Theme: The Enduring Importance of the Christian Creeds for Doctrine and Unity
In this episode, John Stonestreet explores why creeds remain vital in the Christian faith, especially as society and even some Christian circles question or reinterpret foundational doctrines. Drawing on historical context, contemporary challenges, and influential analogies, Stonestreet defends the necessity of the creeds as boundary-markers that protect and clarify the essence of Christianity.
Stonestreet opens by referencing a BuzzFeed video featuring people declaring, "I'm Christian, but I'm not..." (00:10)—each person filling the blank with a quality they wish to distance from, such as "homophobic" or "closed-minded."
The video suggests Christianity is about love and acceptance without boundaries.
Stonestreet emphasizes that while Christianity centers on the love of God in Christ, that love and other foundational truths are divinely defined and not endlessly open to reinterpretation.
"These are foundational truths that come to us predefined. They're not open to infinite interpretations and reinterpretations."
— John Stonestreet (00:32)
Historically, creeds emerged when new doctrines or "words from God" arose, sometimes misleading believers.
"For thousands of years, the various creeds of the Christian faith emerged when individuals or groups would claim some new word from God or would innovate some new doctrine or practice. Often Christians were led astray and they needed to be pulled back to the truth."
— John Stonestreet (01:20)
The creeds acted as reference points, clarifying accepted beliefs and correcting deviations.
Some today view creeds as man-made obstacles that limit personal connection with God or hinder spiritual "openness."
Secular critics argue creeds were tools of power to suppress diversity within Christianity.
Stonestreet strongly refutes these claims:
"None of those claims are true."
— John Stonestreet (02:34)
While legends claim the Apostles themselves wrote it together, Stonestreet clarifies its actual historical roots:
"The Apostles Creed distinguished Christianity from paganism. It was likely what a new convert would declare at their baptism. It contains the basics of Christian doctrine. ... Each are excluded by the words of the Apostles Creed."
— John Stonestreet (03:05)
The Nicene Creed clarified disputes about Christ's nature, countering teachings from within the church, such as Arianism (which denied Jesus’ full divinity).
Stonestreet debunks the misconception that the Council of Nicaea was about imposing power or inventing new doctrine.
"Despite the rehashed claims of Dan Brown fiction, the Council of Nicaea was not when the Romans imposed their view of a divine Jesus on the rest of the church. Christians believed that Jesus was God way before anyone had even heard of Constantine."
— John Stonestreet (03:40)
The Nicene Creed built on the Apostles’ Creed, countering heresy and reinforcing orthodoxy with clear, scriptural boundaries.
Stonestreet references C.S. Lewis's "house with many rooms" image from Mere Christianity:
"The creeds have marked the boundaries of Christian belief, showing who's in one of the rooms of the Christian house and who is clearly in another house entirely."
— John Stonestreet (04:48)
On creeds as essential boundaries:
"Creeds did not create new doctrine, nor do they fully express everything that Christians believe. Rather, they really serve as fences to show where believers can safely disagree while also clarifying which new ideas stray too far."
— John Stonestreet (04:25)
On the Church's ongoing need for creeds:
"Clear lines are still needed now, as in all times, because there are still individuals and religious groups who claim the name of Christ while adding or subtracting from what he said or from what he revealed Himself to be."
— John Stonestreet (04:34)
On the creeds and Christian unity:
"The creeds remain useful and essential to Christians today."
— John Stonestreet (04:56)
Stonestreet concludes that creeds are not relics or barriers but God-given tools that have guided the Church through controversy, doubt, and division. Rather than being outdated, they continue to define what it means to be "in the house" of Christianity.
"The creeds remain useful and essential to Christians today."
— John Stonestreet (04:56)
Co-authored by Dr. Timothy Padgett. For more resources, visit breakpoint.org.