The Wisdom of Being Bored

Summary

---

Podcast Summary: Breakpoint – "The Wisdom of Being Bored"

Host: John Stonestreet
Date: April 30, 2026

---

Overview

In this episode of Breakpoint, John Stonestreet explores the surprising value of boredom in human flourishing, drawing on ideas from Harvard professor Arthur Brooks. Stonestreet challenges the cultural aversion to boredom and makes a case for embracing moments of stillness—not only for personal wellbeing, but as a spiritual practice anchored in the Christian tradition. The discussion weaves together scientific insight, biblical reflection, and practical suggestion, highlighting a countercultural path toward meaning and mental health.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Society’s War on Boredom

• Arthur Brooks' Argument: Boredom isn’t a problem; it’s a necessary practice we should cultivate.
  • “Far from being something to overcome, boredom is necessary for human flourishing.” – John Stonestreet summarizing Brooks [00:20]
• The compulsion to avoid boredom is linked to “many of our worst habits, worst problems, and biggest anxieties.”
• Modern culture’s drive to eliminate boredom runs deep; most people in a 2014 Harvard study preferred physical pain to boredom.
  • “Most people would prefer even pain to boredom… a big majority of the participants gave themselves shocks instead of thinking about nothing.” [00:41]

2. The Science of Boredom: The Default Mode Network

• Brooks' Neuroscience Note: When unoccupied, the brain switches to the Default Mode Network.

  • “The default mode network… is a bunch of structures in your brain that switch on when you don't have anything else to think about. So you forgot your phone and you're sitting at a light, for example. That's when your default mode network goes on.” – Arthur Brooks via John Stonestreet [01:23]

• Boredom is not just a lack of entertainment, but an opportunity for essential cognitive activity.

3. Boredom and the Search for Meaning

• Modern Crisis: Stonestreet observes a “profound reason” to seek boredom: it allows us to wrestle with meaning.
  • “One of the reasons we have such an explosion of depression and anxiety in our society today is because people actually don't know the meaning of their lives.” [01:54]
• Our avoidance of boredom, especially via technology (“the thing in your pocket with the screen”), stifles this deeper reflection.

4. Biblical Perspective: Silence, Stillness, and Meditation

• Scriptural Roots: The Psalms and other texts commend silence and waiting on God.
• Distinguishing biblical meditation from “emptying of the mind” in Eastern practice:
  • “In biblical meditation, the heart and mind are to be full of truths that God has revealed to us about himself and his world… not inward into the void of our own empty souls.” [03:11]
• Examples shared: Sabbath rest, long contemplative walks, and seeking God in creation.

5. The Danger of Perpetual Distraction

• Cultural Temptation: Our technological and cultural context “perpetually” distracts us, keeping us from uncomfortable but necessary questions.

• Memorable Quote from Literature:

  • “As T.S. Eliot warned decades ago, ‘endless invention, endless experiment brings knowledge of motion, not of stillness. Constant noise and distraction will bring knowledge of speech, but not of silence, knowledge of words but ignorance of the Word—capital W.’” – John Stonestreet quoting Eliot [03:52]

6. Boredom as Spiritual and Mental Exercise

• Practical Encouragement: Boredom and intentional silence are not just escapism from noise, but an invitation “to think more deeply about the things that matter most.”
• Developing these practices is “about cultivating a habit that we all need, especially in a culture like ours.” [04:33]

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• “Most people would prefer even pain to boredom.” [00:41]
• “We've been able almost completely to shut off the default mode network in our brains… The answer is the thing in your pocket with the screen.” [02:27]
• “In biblical meditation, the heart and mind are to be full of truths that God has revealed to us about himself and his world.” [03:11]
• “Endless invention, endless experiment brings knowledge of motion, not of stillness… knowledge of words but ignorance of the Word.” – Quoting T.S. Eliot [03:52]
• “Boredom can be a tool that makes us think more deeply about the things that matter most… It's about cultivating a habit that we all need, especially in a culture like ours.” [04:33]

---

Important Timestamps

• 00:20 — Introduction to Arthur Brooks’ thesis on boredom
• 00:41 — Reference to the 2014 Harvard pain vs. boredom study
• 01:23 — Neuroscience of boredom: the Default Mode Network explained
• 01:54 — Boredom, meaninglessness, depression, and anxiety
• 02:27 — Technology and the elimination of boredom
• 03:11 — Biblical meditation: substance vs. void
• 03:52 — T.S. Eliot’s warning about perpetual distraction
• 04:33 — Value of boredom and the call to embrace the habit

---

Tone and Delivery

• The episode maintains an earnest, slightly urgent tone, blending science, cultural critique, and biblical reflection.
• Stonestreet is direct, rooted in faith, and intent on challenging listeners to counter the modern drift toward distraction and meaninglessness.

---

Summary

This episode argues for the crucial—yet often overlooked—wisdom of boredom. Drawing on scientific research, scriptural principles, and cultural analysis, Stonestreet and Brooks assert that time spent in stillness and boredom opens the door to reflection, meaning, and spiritual health. In a world that fills every gap with noise and screens, Christians are invited to reclaim silence as a context for encountering God and rediscovering purpose.

Transcript

[A]

Welcome to Breakpoint, a daily look at an ever changing culture through the lens of unchanging truth. For the Colson Center, I'm John Stonestreet. Well, according to Arthur Brooks, you need to be bored. In a short, straightforward YouTube mini talk, the Harvard professor and best selling author insists that far from being something to overcome, boredom is necessary for human flourishing. It is, in fact, a practice we need to cultivate. And the commitment we seem to have to avoid boredom at all costs is what is behind many of our worst habits, worst problems, and biggest anxieties. Now, to say that that kind of thinking runs against societal norms, quite the understatement. In fact, according to a Harvard study from 2014, most people would prefer even pain to boredom. Placed in a room with nothing to do for 15 minutes but push a button that delivers an electric shock, a big majority of the participants gave themselves shocks instead of thinking about nothing. In the video, Brooks first described how boredom works on our minds. Boredom is a tendency for us to not be occupied otherwise cognitively, and that switches over our thinking system to use a part of our brain that's called the default mode network. It sounds fancy. It's really not. The default mode network, he said, is a bunch of structures in your brain that switch on when you don't have anything else to think about. So you forgot your phone and you're sitting at a light, for example. That's when your default mode network goes on. End quote. In other words, boredom cannot just be explained by a desire we have, especially in modern Western culture, to be entertained. After all, movies, music, plays, games. These are often welcome respites for the weariness of work and stress. Instead, Brooks argues, it is essential for us to seek times of stillness, quiet, and even boredom for a much more profound reason. One of the reasons we have such an explosion of depression and anxiety in our society today is because people actually don't know the meaning of their lives, much less so in previous generations. Tons of data show this, and furthermore, we're not even looking. Why not? I'll tell you why not, he said. Because we figured out a way to eliminate boredom. We've been able almost completely to shut off the default mode network in our brains. How? The answer is the thing in your pocket with the screen, which you take out even when you're standing on the street corner waiting for the light to change. It's like, I might have to wait here for 15 seconds. Now, of course, before Brooks said any of this, plenty of biblical authors spoke out about silence and meditation. The psalms are full of calls to be silent, to wait on the Lord. In both the Old and New Testaments, we learn of God's people, even Christ himself, regularly seeking times of stillness and meditation. According to Isaiah, it is in rest and quietness that strength is found. Now to be clear, the meditation called for in the Bible and practiced by Christians is distinct, or at least should be distinct, from the emptying of the mind that characterizes Eastern religions and Eastern religious practice. You see, in biblical meditation, the heart and mind are to be full of truths that God has revealed to us about himself and his world. We are to think outward and upward in honor and awe of him, not inward into the void of our own empty souls. This can take the form of a weekly Sabbath day, rest from screens and buying. Perhaps it involves cultivating a habit of taking long walks in a world that was created in the first place to scream out to us the glory of God. But instead, especially in a world like ours, struggling so much with meaninglessness, the temptation is to perpetually distract ourselves, to avoid silence, to push away the questions we do not even want to face. As T.S. eliot warned decades ago, endless invention, endless experiment brings knowledge of motion, not of stillness. Constant noise and distraction will bring knowledge of speech, but not of silence, knowledge of words but ignorance of the word capital W. But boredom can be a tool that makes us think more deeply about the things that matter most. And silence can be a context for exercising the mind and the imagination in a way that scripture invites. It's more than just avoiding the noise of life. If Brooks is right, it's about cultivating a habit that we all need, especially in a culture like ours. For the Colson Center, I'm John Stonestreet with Breakpoint. Today's Breakpoint was co authored with Dr. Timothy Padgett. If you appreciate these daily commentaries bringing clarity to a confusing culture, leave us a review wherever you download your podcast that helps more people to find us. And for more resources or to share this commentary with others, go to BreakPoint.org

[B]

Hey BreakPoint listeners, the Colson center is coming to Knoxville, Tennessee. Join John Stonestreet and Os Guinness at the Knoxville Convention center on May 27th for a truth Rising Watch party. Truth Rising is a groundbreaking documentary about courageous faith in this civilizational moment. It tells the stories of Christians like Chloe Cole, Seth Dillon and Jack Phillips choosing courage over fear, making a difference where God has called them. We'll have free popcorn and soda at the Watch Party, and we'll enjoy a live Q and A with John Stonestreet and Os Guinness after the film register today at colsoncenter.org Knoxville that's colsoncenter.org Knoxville.