Loading summary
Ariana Grande
Hi, I'm Ariana Grande. Hi, I'm Cynthia Erivo and you're listening to the Broadway Podcast Network. Visit BPM FM to discover more. This episode is brought to you by State Farm. You might say all kinds of stuff when things go wrong, but these are the words you really need to remember. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there. They've got options to fit your unique insurance needs, meaning you can talk to your agent to choose the coverage you need, have coverage options to protect the things you value most, file a claim right on the State Farm mobile app, and even reach a real person when you need to talk to someone. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there at Lowe's Pros save big on the supplies you need to get the job done with the new Myloes Pro Rewards program. Get member only deals every week and access to free standard shipping. Plus members earn points toward exclusive rewards. Join for free today. Lowe's we help you save. Points are awarded on eligible purchases. Programs subject to terms and conditions. Free standard shipping not available in Alaska and Hawaii. Exclusions and more terms apply. Details@lowe's.com Terms subject to change. Money makes the world go around the world go around the world go around Money makes the world go around it makes the world go around.
Cynthia Erivo
The soil.
Ariana Grande
That makes a world go around that clinking glass.
Cynthia Erivo
Hello all you theater lovers both out and proud and on the DL. And welcome back to Broadway Breakdown, a podcast discussing the history und legacy of American theater's most exclusive address, Broadway. I'm your host Matt Koplik, the least famous and most opinionated of all the Broadway podcast hosts. And this is like a weird review episode we are doing today talking about a whole bunch of different stuff somb Broadway, some not Broadway, as well as just overall feelings on the general theme of the reviews of today's episode. I also want to make sure that we cover a new review that we got. So I'm going to do that. Before we head into the lion's den, I also just want to give a little update about sort of what the next couple of weeks are going to look like. We are seeing quite a bit more theater before the Tony deadline as well as leading into the Tony nominations. So there will be some joint reviews for Just In Time. Floyd Collins Pirates I think there will be a joint review for Real Women have Curves, Old Friends and Dead Outlaw and that will be the end of the Broadway season. Dead Outlaw I will not be seeing until May 2nd. That is the day after the nominations come out and Old Friends I am seeing the night before the nominations. So those reviews will be coming out after our nomination reaction episode, there will be one more Tony nomination prediction episode which is in accordance with the Broadway Breakdown Discord channel. So if you haven't joined yet, now's a great time to do so. The link will be in the description box for this episode. We have over 250 members now. It's a super awesome space. People have been getting to know each other, have been sharing information, sharing, you know, theater information. They've been promoting their own works. There's a channel for, like, random stuff. So if there's like random, anything random in your life or, you know, in the news or on the Internet that you want to sort of share, that's a great spot to do it. There is always an issue with Discord. I will say when we do the invite link, we set them to not expire, but Discord has other plans. So if you are trying to join the Discord and you are having difficulty, you know, with the links, please reach out to me on Instagram, acopolik, usual spelling, and I will send you a personal link for the Discord. Plenty of listeners have done that, so that is that. We will be doing, as I said, the rest of those reviews, the final sort of Tony nomination prediction episode. Then we'll do a response to the actual nominations. There will be some predictions of winners. We're going to have a couple of sort of retrospectives on the Tonys. We'll include some favorite guests on the pod to come back and sort of talk about past Tony winners and things like that. And I'm also going to London in the middle of May, like dead smack in the middle of the season. So my mom and I are going to London with my sister for a little bit May 12th through the 20th. We will do a London episode about that as well. But just sort of letting you guys know that that is going to sort of, you know, tussle things up. And I'll sort of keep putting in that reminder in future episodes for any London listeners who want to reach out while I'm out there. And that is that I don't think I have any other news that I needed to get into today. But let me do our newest review on Apple Podcast. We are at 298 right now in terms of total rankings and reviews, and we would love to hit 300. We would love to do that before we submit the podcast to the Broadway League. So you don't have to write a review. But if you want to give us a Nice five star rating. We really appreciate it. Okay, cue the light of The Piazza Overture. 5 stars. A podcast for the F. I discovered this podcaster a few months ago and since then I have been changed for the better. His smart, insightful and in depth commentary has made me a better theater goer. I could listen to him talk for hours and I admire his wealth of knowledge and information about the art of theater. This show is for the true fans. Listen and enjoy. Thank you, Nate. And depending on the episode, sometimes you do listen for hours. Not just Nate, but all of you. So, as I said, this is going to be sort of a weird hodgepodge of reviews because there's a general theme I kind of wanted to talk about with all of these shows that I've recently seen in terms of the Broadway season. We went and saw Glengarry Glen Ross. We saw Stranger Things. Stranger Things, the first shadow, is its official title. As well as Goodnight and Good Luck and Othello. We also saw two off Broadway musicals and I want to give them their dues in just a second. But. But the reason why this episode felt like a good one to jumble these all together is what these four shows have in common is they are all quite expensive tickets. Now, Stranger Things for a Shadow, it's a little easier to get not super expensive tickets for it is, you know, it is a major IP that people know. It is absolutely a spectacle. It's similar in a lot of ways to Harry Potter and the Cursed Child. And I'm sure the producers of Stranger Things Foreshadow are hoping that fans of the Netflix show will come in enough droves to keep them sort of in the black for a very long time. This was a show that I did have to pay to see. This was not a press seat. So I am releasing this before, technically speaking, opening night. That said, this is a British transfer and there are absolutely no changes being made to this text, not even to the staging. Performances might, you know, develop over time, but what I saw a few days ago is absolutely the show that's going to be on opening night. So I have no qualms about talking about it, nor should you guys. Everything else that I'm talking about has already opened. And also other than Othello, I paid to see Glengarry Glen Ross and I paid to see Good Night and Good Luck. Goodnight and Good Luck remains the most expensive ticket that I've paid to see a Broadway show. I really don't want to pay that ever again for a Broadway show. I don't have the Finances to do it all the time. And even though it was the most I've ever paid, it was still the cheapest seat that they had. And it was, you know, last row of the mezzanine to the side. So nobody think that I'm sitting here on a throne. And judging from up on high, I am talking based on the time commitment that I spent on all of these shows, as well as financially, stranger things I'll just sort of do in a quick sum, which is that I actually quite enjoyed this production. I don't want to say I enjoyed this play just because as a piece of writing, it's not bad, it's just not really play. It felt more like three episodes of the TV show strung together. And it's very long. It clocks in about two hours and 50 minutes. And there's just a lot of stuff happening and yet not a lot happens. In terms of plot, it's a lot. And similar to how the Netflix show would do it. I grant I only saw the first two seasons, but from what I recall when I would watch it was it always felt like they were teasing bigger reveals and information. It was like as if at the end of every season, there were two major pieces of information that had to be told to the characters and the show would take all season long to reveal both pieces of information. And they would do little hints, they would do little clues as to what that information was going to be. But it often just felt extraordinarily dragged out. And that ultimately is how I felt about the play is that it was a very stretched out story that could have been told tighter. For sure. The cast is doing a very Good job. Lewis McCartney, who came over from London and is the lead of this, is pretty fantastic and doing a lot of physical elements that are mighty impressive. He also has a hard part of a role that from what I understand, goes on to become the big bad of the fourth season of Stranger Things. This is sort of that character's origin story and knowing he has to get to a point where he does truly become evil, have that evil within inside him, while also trying to grapple and, you know, turn away from his evil instincts. So he's. He does a really great job with that inner conflict and the design team and Stephen Daldry do a really phenomenal job with obviously the special effects. But I would also say just like on a piece of theatrical storytelling level, it was very well done. Three part turntable. You know, we love those. You know, they did not. It doesn't it physically, it did not feel Super. Like a theme park. There are definitely elements that are a little too literal in the design, a little too back to the future of like, let's put what people know up on the stage as elaborately as we can. But there was a lot of creativity put into the production side of this piece, which I appreciated. It didn't feel like I was just being force fed content that I knew or that everyone else knew. It did feel like if they could not hone in the script, they could at least embellish on the staging and the design. And that was much appreciated. Again, I. I could not tell you that this is a phenomenally written play. I think it has a lot of interesting stuff going on in it ultimately, because it does drag out for far too long. It. I can't say that it was brilliant, but I was very rarely bored considering how long it is. Without giving too much away, if you aren't familiar with Stranger Things, obviously that show takes place in the 1980s in a small town in, I believe, the Midwest, and follows a few boys who find themselves in what is called the Upside down with a young girl named Eleven who is a child who has escaped from a testing center run by the government. And they learn of these creatures that sort of live in a parallel universe in the landscape of their town that is picking off members of their town one by one. And each season sort of delves into how much more complicated it all gets. And season four of Stranger Things has again what we know as the Big Bad. I think his name is Valkone or something like that. And his real name, his human name is Henry. And so Stranger Things, the first shadow, is the origin story of that Big Bad. And a lot of the other minor characters are the teenage versions of the parents. On Stranger Things again, we mostly follow these preteens into their early teens and their parents are sort of like on the sidelines, Winona Ryder being one of them. That's actually how I got into Stranger Things is due to my love of Winona Ryder. And the play has those parents as teenagers. Their big thing is that they're dealing with a play that they're trying to put on in their high school and they don't want it. Winona Ryder's character, Joy, I think, is the character's name. She's the head of the drama program and she won't do Oklahoma. She refuses. She wants to do something more interesting. So she says that they'll do the Dark side of the Moon, which is about a witch boy. And, you know, very. It's like kind of Crucible meets Streetcar Named Desire meets, like, Fairy Dust. And so they were putting that on as well as all these other stuff happening. And the play is ultimately more of the comedic relief of the show, but it ultimately, it doesn't even really matter. It's. It's. It's there again, it's there to relieve you, but it's not there for any other major purpose. And it just adds to the runtime. But that is also, in my opinion, where Stephen Daltrey is his most inventive with his staging, especially with the turntable. So I was always happy to see was actually a relatively respectful audience. People were very into seeing it. The show also, I think, understands what people are coming for. And they try to give them what they want with a little bit of the unexpected. And then they end it on a very cheeky note. And that's not something that's going to work for everybody. Without giving too much away, there's a projection that they do at the very end of the play that I found very funny. Some people are going to find it in poor taste because this is theater. But I thought it was nice, a nice touch, and sort of showed that everyone involved understood not only what they were, but everyone thought that they were. And they lean into it a little bit, so that was appreciated. So stranger things. It's a very impressive spectacle. I imagine plenty of people will be underwhelmed by it. I'm sure that there are gonna be a lot of theater people underwhelmed by it because, again, the meat of it is just not super there. But there is stuff to it beyond the spectacle. I will say that as well. Next up on the list, I want to talk quickly about Glengarry Glen Ross, the Pulitzer Prize winning play by David Mamet, which is. This is the third time Glengarry Glen Ross has been on Broadway in the 21st century. And I was really hoping I could see it. This is where, like, my princess side is showing, because we are trying to cover the entire Broadway season, see absolutely every show. And this is a very hot ticket. It sells out every night at full price. And I knew I couldn't get a press seat for it. We are too small potatoes to get press seats for things like this. And a friend of the POD who does get press seats, like they're on the Broadway League list. They go. They get to see everything. Actually invited me and I couldn't go because of a family commitment. I was very, very upset. So I knew in order to properly cover the season, I Had to bite the bullet and go. And I was able to get a seat day of the show. It is far less than what I paid for Good night and good luck. But it is more than I was wanting to pay just because I don't like putting money in David Babbitt's pocket. He is not a favorite person of mine. I don't think he's a good person. He has said some really wild things the last few years and is committed to them. And he hasn't even done any good creative work in the last, you know, two decades to make anyone really turn a blind eye to it. Best you can say is that we have a couple of his plays from the 80s and early 90s that keep getting revived, like American Buffalo and Speed the Plow and Glengarry Glen Ross. And it's frustrating. The existence of this play is frustrating to me. And the only reason why it's such a big seller, because they're in the palace, by the way, a very large musical house that many musicals have been unable to fill. And granted, Glengarry Glen Ross has closed off the balcony, so they're just selling the mezzanine and the orchestra. But at this rate, they probably could sell the balcony if they really wanted to. And it's selling because it is a known property with three big names in Kieran Culkin, who just won his Oscar for A Real Pain as well as an Emmy for succession, Bob Odenkirk of Better Call Saul and Breaking Bad fame, and Bill Burr, who is a very famous comedian. And that has sort of become the theme of this season as we eventually get into Othello and Good Night and Good Luck is recognizable title with a very large name. Sometimes lesser known titles with a very large name, such as Robert Downey Jr. With McNeil, but we see this with Kit Connor and Rachel Zegler with Romeo and Juliet, Jim Parsons as well as the entire mishmash of cast in Our Town, Denzel and Jake Gyllenhaal in Othello, Glengarry Glen Ross, what have you. And we're seeing it pop up again even more down the line with Alex Winters and Keanu Reeves with Winnie for Gado and things like that. And listen, star casting in revivals is nothing new. You know, you look back to the 80s and you see Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton doing Private Lives, cashing in on the media attention that they've always had as a couple, even though they were twice divorced by this point. And it's not so much that I resent producers for still doing It. It's. It's a ticket that sells, and you sometimes need to put something like this up in order to then invest or produce lesser known works. Some producers are doing that. I have friends who are producers on Glengarry Glen Ross who are also producing Buena Vista Social Club and works that at the time felt a little more of a gamble. And in order to keep investors happy, you do kind of have to have shows that return something. And something like this is an easy bet. I think they all were a little surprised just how lucrative it's been, but no one thought that this was going to be a tough sell. Not with three very recognizable names, one of whom has, you know, never been more relevant than he is right now. Again, in a play that a lot of people in theater know very well and consider to be good. And a movie version that has also kept the play's title in pop culture. And if you don't know the plot, Glengarry Glen Ross follows real estate salesman. And it's a struggling real estate firm. Everyone is looking to land leads from their corporate office so they can get more sizable commissions, because the leads that they've been getting have been duds, and they just have been. They've been unable to move any property. And the first act, which is, I think 40 minutes, is three different salesmen from the agency, each sort of talking about their predicaments separately to either a client or a co worker. The first is Bob Odenkirk, the second is Bill Burr. The third is Kieran Culkin. And that's all at a Chinese food restaurant. Then the curtain comes down and we have intermission. And then act two is the office. And I think it's the office the next day or two days later, and the office has been robbed, and they're doing a police investigation. Donald Webber Jr. Is the manager. And, you know, Kieran Culkin is sort of like the star salesman there, Roma. And he's nervous about his leads. He also just sold a commission to a very pricey property to basically an unsuspecting fuck from act one. And he wants to make sure that that goes through. Bob Odenkirk, Shelley Levine, he's a more senior salesman in the agency, and he comes in all happy because he's made a whole bunch of commissions that has sort of broken his losing streak. And Bill Burr is just sort of, you know, flustered all over. He's both lost and not lost, and just basically says, peace out. He doesn't want to deal with any of this anymore. On Michael McKean is also in it. And the play ultimately is. It's not Death of a Salesman so much as it is the death of the Career of the Salesman, as done through extraordinarily biting dialogue. Like very poisonous, viperish dialogue. That is what Mamet has always been known for. Mamet got his acclaim for portraying the toxicity of mankind in a very entertaining and very quotable way. I mean, just watch Alec Baldwin's monologue in the movie on YouTube. Coffeeist for Closers. Fuck you. That's my name and no, or you're fired. Do I have your attention now? A character in a monologue, by the way, that's not in the play, added for the film makes the film an improvement on the stage show. And you miss it when you watch the play. But it is ultimately a play that has some heft to it. But because it is a very lean play, about hour and 45, including the intermission, and ultimately an entertainment, it can feel slight in the wrong hands. This production ultimately feels slight. It's very dry. It's not offensive. It's not a total misfire so much as that it just sort of exists. There are some very good performances. Bill Burr is exceptional in Glengarry Glen Ross, as is Donald Webber Jr. Bill Burr's character's name, by the way, is Dave Moss. And Donald Weber Jr. Is John Williamson. And the first scene is between him and Bob Odenkirk, Ashelli Levine. Bob Odenkirk is much better in Act 2, Act 1. I found he was a little stiff, and you could argue that's the character. And in some ways he is. But it just sort of felt like he didn't know how to crack that first act, but he did know how to crack the second act. So he was really great in Act 2. Bilber was great in both acts. Donald was great in both acts. Michael McKean did a very nice job. The only character, only actor in the show who I found to be really a misfire was Kieran Culkin as Roma. I just think he's miscast in the role. This is a role that's been played by Al Pacino, Bobby Cannavale, Liev Schreiber. I think Joe Mantegna did it in the original. Like, this is someone who has a bit more gravity to their personhood and a graveliness to their presentation and their speech and has to sort of be slick, but also have. I hate to say it, but like, cojones and has to. And. And the Mamet speech has to kind of roll off your tongue again in a very fluid but venomous way. And Kieran Culkin is still sort of in succession mode. I felt the same way about him in real pain, if I'm being honest. I thought he was very good in real pain. But he was playing sort of the sweeter version of Ronan in succession, and he's still sort of in that mode. In Glengarry Glen Ross, he's not playing Roma. He's playing the parts he's played before and trying to broadcast it to such a large theater. And it's not as if it makes the whole production terrible. It just makes the whole production sort of feel okay. You walk out and you go, you know, I've seen worse. I've definitely seen worse. It is a good play that's given a perfectly respectable production. Considering the price tag on it, considering how much people are going to see it, you expect a bit more. Why do I bring that up, though? Because again, this sort of goes into the theme of this episode, which is, what is it that we do expect when we go see theater? Broadway in particular, because theater is everywhere. Theater can be accessible, and there's far more financially easier pieces of theater, you know, easier on the wallet than Broadway. Broadway is an expensive price tag and just get. Keeps getting more expensive. And with these shows, it's really. It can get really obscene. And we'll get to the super obscene ones after the commercial break. But the question is, what is it you want when you go see a show? Fundamentally, because there's various genres, various mediums, right? Like, a musical is different from a play, but musicals have different subcategories. Some are reviews, some are, you know, paparettas, like a Les Mis, or like just more of a dance piece like Illinois. If it is a structured story musical, there can be a jukebox musical, There can be an original score. It can be a Death Becomes her, or it can be a fun home, right? And the same is also true of plays. You can have something like Glengarry Glen Ross or Stranger Things. You can have How I Learned to Drive or Picture of Dorian Gray. So each show you go in to see, you're sort of going in on its terms, right? You are not going into Boop expecting My Fair Lady. You're not going into Les Miserables expecting Chicago. You have to get an idea of what it is you're signing up for. And then you become discerning of is it delivering what I signed up for? I think I said this in an earlier episode. I'm going to say it Again, because I want to put a pin in it for a possible post I do for a writing piece at some point. But I personally find that the most unique, powerful and long lasting works shares something in common, which is that it gives an audience what it needs inside of a package of what it wants. By that I mean an audience going in saying we want to be entertained and giving them the entertainment, but inside the entertainment is a message that can challenge them, even if it's just slightly or give them a character that they might have empathized with that they didn't, that they never thought they would have beforehand. Same thing with the drama of I'm going to see something that's going to challenge me. Okay, you're going to get challenged, but how we're going to challenge you is very different. Well, how I Learned to Drive, I've said it before Think is such a brilliant piece because the predator of that play is ultimately our protagonist's only ally in the play. And you watch him be her ally while also being her predator. And you watch how it affects her in real time as well as in the future. And you watch how she becomes somewhat of a mess of a person, which makes her hard sort of to root for, but we see the causes of those problems for her coming from him. Right? And your mind goes in a bunch of different directions because your empathy is getting manipulated and your willingness to like someone who's likable gets manipulated because the person who's likable is doing this really disgusting monstrous thing. And the people who aren't doing the monstrous thing are very toxic and awful and you don't want to be around them. And so when I go see shows again, I go to every show with a blank slate. Ultimately, I want to be engaged. And if you're going to engage me, you have to a establish to me what it is I'm signing up for and then do the work for me. So even when you are being a dumb entertainment, you have to do all the math for me so I can turn my brain off. Don't expect me to actively power off my brain the entire time and just ignore all of the messiness because that's, that's just not. Theater is too expensive and our time is too fleeting and there is not, there are too few theaters for these things. For me to just accept blindly messiness or slop or badness for the sake of just going, oh, I want two hours to escape. I can escape anywhere. I can go home and watch four episodes of Grey's Anatomy back to back. And that is an escape. Okay? That's the other thing is that theater is competing with tv, streaming movies, sports, concerts. The actual whole real world is constantly challenging theater. And theater is not going to ever go anywhere. It's one of the oldest forms of entertainment we have. But Broadway is slow to understand what it is that keeps it relevant. It's not just a tourist destination in New York. It actually has importance. It has cultural cachet and it used to be at front and center of the zeitgeist. So believe it or not, there used to be plays that would premiere on Broadway that the whole country knew about within a year because they made such an impression. Streetcar Named Desire, who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? Death of a Salesman. We talked about it with Rob Schneider and Angels in America. Angels in America is an American play that the whole country knew about by the time it closed on Broadway a year and a half later. How many plays can you say that about with Broadway in the last 15 years? Maybe a handful. That some people might go, oh, that name sounds familiar. But very few that everyone has heard of. Hamilton is one of the few musicals in the last 17 years. I would say maybe even 20 that the whole country, the whole world knows. And I'm getting to a point with this, but I don't want to get to the point too soon before I get to these next two shows after the break. So just say think about that for a hot second and then we're gonna come back to Othello and Goodnight and good luck as well as a positive connection I want to make to the two off Broadbent musicals. And we'll do all of that after this break.
Ariana Grande
Billy, I beg to differ with you. How do you mean? You're the top. Yeah, you're an arrow collar. You're the top. You're a coolidge dollar. You're the nimble tread of the feet of Fred Astag. Ever go on a date so bad you need an everything shower? Luckily for you, Billie makes products for that. A loofah full of nourishing body wash can scrub off the cringe from that extremely awkward hug. A full body shave with Billie's award winning razor will remind you what going smoothly actually feels like. And hydrating body lotion can delete dryness faster than you can delete the dating apps. You've got your reasons. Billy's got your routine shop in store. And@mybilli.com spring savings are in the air. And at Ross where they have savings on all the brands you love from the latest fashion to outdoor decor and even pet supplies.
Cynthia Erivo
Savings are in every aisle.
Ariana Grande
Go to ross and save 20 to 60% off other retailers prices on your favorite spring finds. This episode is brought to you by Pluto tv. Pluto TV has all the shows and movies you love streaming for free. That means laughter is free with gut busting comedies like the Neighborhood Key and Peele and Fair Harris Bueller's Day Off Mystery is free with countless cases to crack from Criminal Minds Tracker and Matlock. And thrills are free with heart pumping hits like the Walking Dead and Defiance. Feel the free Pluto TV stream now. Pay Never Eczema isn't always obvious, but it's real. And so is the relief from Ebglis. After an initial dosing phase of 16 weeks, about 4 in 10 people taking EBGLIS achieved itch relief and clear or almost clear skin. And most of those people maintained skin that still more clear at one year with monthly dosing.
Cynthia Erivo
EBGLIS Lebricizumab LBKZ, a 250mg injection, is a prescription medicine used to treat adults and children 12 years of age and older who weigh at least 88 pounds or 40 kilograms with moderate to severe eczema, also called atopic dermatitis that is.
Ariana Grande
Not well controlled with prescription therapies used.
Cynthia Erivo
On the skin or topicals, or who cannot use topical therapies. Ebglis can be used with or without topical corticosteroids. Don't use if you're allergic to Ebglis. Allergic reactions can occur that can be severe.
Ariana Grande
Eye problems can occur.
Cynthia Erivo
Tell your doctor if you have new or worsening eye problems. You should not receive a live vaccine when treated with Epglis. Before starting Epgliss, tell your doctor if.
Ariana Grande
You have a parasitic infection searching for real relief? Ask your doctor about epglis and visit epgliss.lily.com or call 1-800-lilyrx or 1-800-545-5979. Out here, there's no one way of doing things, no unwritten rules, and no shortage of adventure. Because out here, the only requirement is having fun. Bank of America invites kids 618 to golf with us for a limited time. Sign them up for a free one year membership, giving them access to discounted Tetons at thousands of courses. Learn more@bankofamerica.com golf with us what would you like the power to do? Bank of America restrictions apply. CBFA.com Golf with US for complete details Copyright 2025 bank of America Corporation.
Cynthia Erivo
And we're back. So our last two expensive tickets are goodnight and good luck and Othello. Now, I will say right here, right now, I was very fortunate that I got invited to see Othello. And the truth is that if I hadn't been, I would not have been able to see it. And thus my coverage of the season would have been fully blown to smithereens. Good night and good luck. I had to bite the bullet, find my ticket and just deal with the consequences later. Before we get to that, though, on a sort of palate cleanser as we tie into all of this, I want to give props to friend of the pod, Rob Schneider and J2 spotlights production of Smile, which at the time of this recording will be wrapping up its run. Don't bother to see it anyway. It's fully sold out. I was very, very fortunate to see this production. Rob invited me for their first weekend and listen, J2 Spotlight, they've been around for a while. They have a budget, they, they pull in good talent. They are in a very nice theater. The AMT on, I think it's 44th Street. 44th or 45th. And the truth is that, you know, they put on really lovely, intelligent, you know, and creative productions with not a lot of resources and smiles. It's not like, you know, wicked, but it's a big show and it's big for them. So what they were able to pull off with as little time as they had, with as little money as they had, with as little space as they had, I found very impressive. I already was, you know, a sucker to see it because I got to finally see songs like Shine and Until Tomorrow Night and Young and American, you know, live. And in front of me, it was fully a dead Sunday matinee audience. There were a couple of other homosexuals there around my age who I guess had not known Smile super well. And so they were laughing at the all the right jokes and they were appreciating the intelligence of the lyrics. But a lot of other audience members, while they said as they were walking out how much they enjoyed it, they were just very, very quiet. So if anyone involved in Smile is listening to this, know that I, the keeper of the keys of what makes Smile good. I'm telling you, you guys did a great job and you understood the comedy, you understood the, the themes of the show. Honestly, like it, it works very well. It's also kind of jarring. I don't think that the audience was expecting. This is sort of what we're tying into. The audience wasn't really expecting it to be as biting as it was and to go as harsh as it does in Act 2. I think they expected a comedy musical about a beauty pageant from the 1980s, and they were like, oh, pretty girls dancing around. It should be fun. And maybe, like, I'll get a chuckle here and there from the 1980s references. And then we're very thrown by the Maria plot line. Not because it's racist, because it's not. And we've talked about it. But what Howard Ashman is saying by having her character in there about the unfairness in the world at large, but especially this country and the false promises that this country keeps on feeding people and how it just. It's this. The deck is stacked against anyone who is not white, cisgender, preferably male, and honestly of a certain tax bracket. Right. It does it in a comedic tone. It does it with very fun music and characters that you are interested in watching. But that's ultimately what it's getting down to. And I think that it's actually a very clever example of giving an audience what they think they want by opening with songs like Typical High School Senior, which is very catchy, with really great, clever lyrics, and then sneaking in little bits of satiric edge at the beginning. For those of you who know the show, the opening song is Girls Introducing what a Young American Miss Is, which is, she's a typical high school senior and she's got a 3.0, she's on student council and she likes to bake and blah, blah, blah. And then the lyrics then include, you know, she frequently smokes, but not in front of her folks and puts rum in her Cokes like me and. And I. It starts off light and cheeky like that, and then it gets just darker as it goes on. And it was fun to see that show done so well. And it was very soothing to see people who cared, people who weren't willing to settle for just okay and went for the best of their abilities and what their company could accommodate and accomplish and really just, like, go for the gold as often as they could. And I thought that that was very admirable, and everyone evolved to be very proud of themselves. The other show that I got to see, I was invited to see the Keen Company's premiere production of a new musical that's been developed by Adam Guan called All the World's A Stage. I didn't realize that I had heard rumblings about this show. We had an interview with Andrea Grady. Grody. Sorry, let me look this up. Andrea Grody the music director from Suff. We had an interview with her about a year ago, and she had mentioned, I believe, that she was working on this show. And she was, you know, she was the music director for this production. And it was, as I said, produced by the King Company at Theater Row. I don't know how long it runs till, but check out if you can. I'll say right now, look into tickets if you can, because spoiler alert. I really, really enjoyed this production, as I said, written by Adam Guan. It stars Matt Rhoden, Elizabeth Stanley, and then who are the other two performers? Elizabeth Pagel. Pagel, and then John Michael Rees. And it ultimately is a musical about a young man who moves to a small town to teach math. He's, you know, very passionate about math and very passionate about teaching. And apparently the school that he's going to or like the county he's in, has a really great program and is very prestigious for math, but he's gay. And it's not specified what year it is, at least, I don't recall if they specify it, but it felt like it was the late 90s to me, maybe early 2000s. It's around the time that the book that the Notebook is released, so maybe 2000, 2001. And Matt Rhoden plays the young man who is a closeted homosexual in this small town and becomes very friendly with Elizabeth Stanley, who also teaches at the school. And her brother is a pastor at a very religious church in the county. We learned that the town that he's teaching in is a very religious town. And he lived, you know, he lives in a neighboring town that's a little more progressive, but not much more progressive. And he comes across a female student in the high school who desperately wants to submit herself for this theater competition, for this scholarship to. So she can go to college and go to a liberal arts program and get out of her town and maybe pursue her dreams and not be sort of what's going for. Bound by the confines of her town, by her school, by her parents, and the sort of the religious dictatorship of the church's leanings, right? And Matt Rodin's character is at first very hesitant to sponsor her for this competition. He kind of doesn't want to ruffle any feathers. He then meets a man who runs a bookstore in the town that he's living in. And even though the bookstore isn't necessarily queer, the man is queer, and he definitely has some queer displays in the bookstore. So they start to kind of have a thing. Matt Ronin ends up sponsoring the high school girl, she eventually finds out that he's gay and has her own sort of grappling issues with that. Not because she's homophobic so much as that he's keeping it from her. And she doesn't know what she is. She just knows that she's weird and different from all the other kids. She's not well liked by the other kids. Elizabeth Stanley is trying to be an ally to the student as well as to Matt Rodin, while not knowing that he's gay. And it's 100 minutes, no intermission, with a lot of really phenomenal songs. And it's very funny, it's very cute. It shades the Notebook a lot. Adam Guan has a lot of things to say about the Notebook, but it also has a lot of heart. And it is also very well constructed. It's very intelligent, and it's very nuanced. No one is made into a stereotype. And it's the benefit of the show zeroing in on these four characters. Elizabeth Stanley and the other two actors who are not Matt Rodin, they double as sort of like a Greek chorus, sometimes playing other members of the town and the principal and things like that as a bundle in addition to the three specific roles that they play. And by having such a narrow focus by so specific in the story, it allows Adam the time to develop these characters and their arcs and give each of them moments to flesh out their stories. So we care, and it feels earned in any changes that they have, any pivots that their story takes, we buy. Listen, is the show perfect in my eyes? No. I have some feedback. All constructive, because as I said, I really did love this. And everything that I have is more. Every piece of feedback I have is more just about. Mostly trims I would do. Because While it is 100 minutes, it could probably be like an even tighter 95. Just that my rule of thumb is always, like, when you think it's finished, just know that there's probably five minutes you can shave off somewhere. But I say this because ultimately the bones of the show are there and it's set, the story is set, the characters all make sense to me. The songs are so good. At this point, it's just about killing your darlings and being even more precise about when we need idiot time, when we need serious time. How much time are we giving a character alone on stage for this turning point in their arc? But for a show that is ultimately about acceptance and coming into your power and coming into your strength and owning your identity, and you know, trying to be both pragmatic while also brave. I think that the show does a really adult, nuanced and intelligent job of displaying that no one does a total 180 in a second like some characters do in other shows. There's no message falling out of characters mouths. That feels like political propaganda. And I say that just because it doesn't matter if you agree with what the propaganda is, it is still, technically speaking, a lot of ways propaganda. It feels forced into. It can feel forced into a story. I talked about this a little bit in my BOOP review, right. Of the elements of girl bossiness that they throw in an act two very shoehorned in. And I took offense to it just because it felt so sloppy and unearned. And the difference between something like a BOOP and an all the World's A Stage is earning that kind of stuff. You don't get to just get away with it because you're saying, well, we're trying to be feel good. You can be feel good, but level, level your butt up. And it's disappointing that something like all the World's A Stage, which has probably been in development a hell of a lot less than BOOP has so much less money than BOOP does and exposure than BOOP does, and fewer people on its creative team has been able to come so much farther than BOOP has in terms of being in entertainment and being moving and being engaging and being very astute and discerning about just how far to go, how long to go, and what it takes to keep your audience engaged and not talk down to them while still being an entertainment. Right. It is the kind of musical that Bob Martin and Rick Ellis and I didn't mention Rick Ellis's name in my Smash review. So I apologize for that. But it's the kind of musical that Bob Martin and Rick Ellis make fun of a lot in Smash. Every time Brooks Ashmansk is his character, the director goes, oh, God. So now we're a musical comedy with a message. And I'm like, yeah, those. A lot of those shows, when done well, can succeed and live on for a very long time. You don't have to have a message in a musical comedy. Right. I would argue Guys and Dolls doesn't really have a message, but it is a well crafted, well constructed story with characters that make sense and we care about and songs that apply to the story and apply to the characters. And that is why we do Guys and Dolls instead of doing Mexican Hayride. That is gonna be my go to every single Fucking time. But it's true over and over again. So ultimately, I want to say bravo to everyone at King Company for doing this show and doing such a wonderful job with it. And I tie this back into Good Night and Good Luck and Othello as well as Glengarry Glen Ross. Right. Of I did not know what to expect with all the worlds of stage. And so part of that is the stigma that these other shows have of me. Kind of feeling like I know what I'm gonna get when I go in. But also the truth is that I did get what I thought I was gonna get going in. How I felt about it altered from show to show, because I did. I enjoyed Good Night and Good Luck more than I thought I would. Or rather I should say I didn't hate it as much as I thought I would. There are pockets of Good Night and Good Luck, the George Clooney play at the Winter Garden that I actually found quite compelling. It is the story of Edward R. Murrow on CBS openly and defiantly defying Senator Joseph McCarthy during the McCarthy era. And it's very, you know, it's prevalent to our times. It's always, it's always going to be prevalent, you know, very close minded people with a lot of charisma and an ability to drum up fear in the masses. It is the story of the world. We see it time and time again. It never lasts. This, this fear mongering and this kind of rallying. How long it lasts varies from century to century. And you want it to die as soon as it begins, if it has to begin at all. But it never overall lasts. But people have short memories and Good Night and Good Luck started off as a movie written and directed by George Clooney that starred David Strathern or Strathairn. And George Clooney is now playing that part on Broadway in what is ultimately not quite a copy paste job from the movie, but not, not a copy paste job from the movie. It is anyone who's seen the movie will see a lot of the characters and the material that they know from the film. It is done respectfully, if not terribly imaginatively. There is intelligence in the writing. There is relevance in this story. It is a large scale production. It is a. It is a big set that takes up the entire stage. It's a large company. I cannot say that the production itself is as inventively done as what Daldry and his team does with Stranger Things. It is overall a pretty literal minded representation of the movie. But because the story resonates and because every time Clooney, as Morrow goes on the air to defy McCarthy, we as an audience get a collective high from it. And that's the part of the show that, for me, makes the most the best case for its existence. But why is this show here? Let's put a pin in that for a second as I talk about Othello for just a quick bit. Othello. Not much to say. It's Shakespeare, it's Denzel Washington, it's Jake Gyllenhaal, directed by Kenny Leon, set in the near future. All I'll really say is that it's long. It's not tragically terrible. It's mostly similar to Glengarry Glen Ross. It's mostly dry. There are a couple of choices that are weird. The scene transition into Desdemona's bedroom before, spoiler alert, Othello kills her. That scene transition is fucking weird. It's bold, but it's weird. Denzel Washington is not a disaster in the role as others have claimed at early previews. He knew his lines. I could understand him. His Othello is. I can't rightfully say that Shakespeare rolls off of Denzel Washington's tongue as fluently as I wanted it to, having seen him in Tragedy of Macbeth on film. Part of it's because Denzel just knows how to be a goddamn movie star. And a good action, I would say, great film actor. I think I expected it to be a little more natural on his body on stage. But I also think that this production in general is just so meandering that he's not really being honed as a performer. He's kind of just doing whatever, not knowing what's working. And it's a shame because there are two performances in the show that do work. One is Jake Gyllenhaal as Iago. And Jake is very good, I would argue, the inverse of Denzel. Reports of Jake being extraordinary are, in my humble opinion, overblown. Jake is very good, and I think compared to Denzel, comes off a lot better. Iago is also just the better part, has always been the better part. Othello we see go into madness, but Iago is just so deliciously evil that that's fucking catnip for any actor. Arguably the best performance in the show for me was Andrew Burnap as Cassio. And yes, I do enjoy Andrew Burnap. I have enjoyed him since the Inheritance. I think he's a very smart, special actor. He's the one for me whom Shakespeare felt alive with. The text came off of his body, naturally, he made it sound. He was able to convey the text that did not feel shortchanged, but also shortchanged in its poetry, I guess, and its floweriness, but also was able to convey its meaning. You understood everything going on with Cassio at every given moment. And I'm not talking about enunciation. I'm talking about genuine energy and character and feeling. 247 with Andrew Burnup on that stage during intermission, I turned to my friend. I was like, since when do we care about Cassio? Which is the joke is just that Othello is supposed to be about Othello and Iago and somewhat about Desdemona. Cassio is a pawn in Iago's plan to take down Othello by telling Othello that his wife, Desdemona, is cheating on him with one of his soldiers, Cassio. Cassio, meanwhile, is, you know, in love with another woman. He does have a thing for Desdemona, but he's ultimately in a relationship with somebody else. Cassio is. Is again, he's not important important. He's not really a powerful character. He is there as a pawn in Iago's plot. So to come out of Othello and go, well, Andrew Burnab as Cassio, like, that was the performance of the production. Something's off. Something is absolutely off. As I said, this is a very. It's not an embarrassingly poor production of Othello. It's just sort of inert. There's enough good in it that it's hard to fully pan, but there's very little great about it that justifies its existence and justifies its ticket price. So why is it that everyone is. Has no problem paying up to $900 to see Othello? And let's also be clear, not everyone is paying that much to see Othello. My friend ran into someone else he knew across the aisle from us, and he had paid a measly $400 to sit in the orchestra. He was able to get a ticket that afternoon for the show. And granted, the ticket he bought probably was going for twice the price three weeks ago, but the theater was full, so they are not. Every seat at Othello is $950. There are seats that are a lot less than that, but also, you can spend a lot less than $400 to see maybe happy Ending, to see Gypsy, to see Picture of Dorian Gray. Hell, you can pay, you know, a fifth of that, maybe even less than that to see all the world's a stage which is so delightful and so Worthwhile. Right. So the question is, why? Why? Why is everyone clamoring for Othello? Why is everyone clamoring for Good Night and Good Luck? It is ultimately to see famous people on stage. And if it's a title that they recognize, a Shakespeare title, sign them up a movie. George Clooney was nominated for multiple Oscars for that. You know, maybe not the whole world saw, but enough people saw that it can fill the winter garden for 10 weeks. Sign them up. And the scarcity of the tickets, because there's only so many seats in the theater, they're going to do eight shows a week for a limited run. So even at full capacity, we're talking like, what, 80,000 people seeing good night and good luck, 70,000 seeing Othello out of not just the whole world, but the whole city. It's not a lot of people. And a lot of people want to pay for the bragging rights of having seen the thing, the thing that's hard to get, the thing that's expensive, and the thing where they got to be in the same room as a major, major celebrity. And if you think that I am being cold about that, when George Clooney came out on stage for his first scene in For Good Night and Good Luck, I shit you not. A third of the audience whipped out their cell phones to take a photo. And those poor ushers were running up and down the aisles trying to catch everybody. And they still were catching people throughout the show. But that's what people were there for. They were there to see George Clooney. People were there to see Denzel Washington, some to see Jake Gyllenhaal. No one was really there to see Othello. No one was there to be challenged by Shakespeare. Now, to a lot of that audience's credit, a lot of people who did not know the story of Othello, who, it felt like, were drawn in by the play, because, spoiler alert, the play is good. Good Night and Good Luck a little less so. I would argue people were not as drawn into it. They were more drawn in every time George Clooney, quote, unquote, went on air as Murrow and, you know, gave his addresses about McCarthy. But where I would vouch that Good Night and Good luck almost kind of justifies its existence is in the last 10 minutes, which has come under a lot of scrutiny for being preachy and obvious. And that is true. It absolutely is. The bottom line is, at the end of the play, Clooney, you know, Clooney goes up against McCarthy. He's one of the few people on air who's speaking openly against him. And it does come at a cost. Not everyone agrees with him. A lot of people are afraid of McCarthy. And it ultimately loses his character, his normal spot on the air. He's still on the air, but less frequently and at a different time. And his friend, played by Clark Gregg, has taken his own life at this point out of fear of McCarthy. And we as a nation got past McCarthyism. We were able to find a way out of it and move on. And I think the biggest revenge is how few younger generations know about McCarthy outside of, you know, just the Red scare of the 50s and early 60s. Right. You know, McCarthy in a lot of ways is a footnote in American history. What he did is vile and. And that is a large chapter. But he himself, the man, less so. His name now is a brand, but he himself is nothing but a skeleton. This is to say, the other thing about the play is sort of the importance and the integrity of journalism and of the truth and of one's principles and morals. And Clooney comes out at the end of the play to give this speech at what looks like a banquet that his character is at. And they then play what's probably a three minute montage that shows the progression, slash regression of media, starting with like I Love Lucy and I think the Honeymooners, going into new shows and reality TV and I think even YouTube culture, finally kind of culminating with January 6th. They show September 11th, they show the recession, they show Covid, they show January 6th, they show Biden, and then it ends with a shot of Elon Musk doing his, let's also say this, his Nazi salute at that press conference. Let's also be other very clear, it was a bad Nazi salute. I watched it. I was like, that's like the Nazi salute meets Richard Nixon's final goodbye off the helicopter. Like, lame, lame, lame, lame, lame. Awful and hideous, but also lame. That said, the entire audience gasped. And I'm sitting there going, we all witnessed this. We all saw this happen when it was happening. Why are we acting brand new? As I said, a lot of people's memories are very short and they forget and they want to forget. They want to move on. They want to move on. And don't we? All right? And sometimes the best revenge you can do is to move on and belittle the people who try to have power over you. But you also can't totally forget. You can move on while still not forgetting. Right? Live your life and succeed and thrive, but also don't forget. And I'm watching and I talked to my dad about this the next day because he, you know, he grew up during this whole thing and he knows everything about this story with Murrow and McCarthy. And of course he saw Goodnight and Good Luck, the movie and probably saw it four or five times. He said to me, no, I probably know as much about this whole endeavor as anyone could because I can't imagine there's anything about this play that would teach me anything or that would excite me. And you know nothing about that. Those final minutes of the play would really make an impact with me because I'm sitting there going like, yeah, I, I concur. It's vile and we have to stand up and be better. But why are you yelling at me about that? Like, why are you hitting me with that? In a weird way, this play is not for my dad. And it sucks that it is so exclusive of a ticket and running so short and is only going to be seen by a certain number of people. But in a way, by having that theater be filled with rich people who want the cloud of having seen the expensive, hard to get thing. So people with millions, some possibly even with billions of dollars, who have been in rooms with, you know, our current president and Musk and others like them who may even have, you know, helped them on the campaign trail with donations, as well as people who saved up just to see a celebrity, because that's what's most important to them. They are who needed to see those last five minutes and to see this story of the importance of conviction and integrity and truth. That doesn't mean that the play itself is exceptional. It's not. The story it's telling is an exceptional one and needs to be reminded, and this is ultimately a fortunate accident, that this play justifies its existence by being the expensive, exclusive ticket that it is. It is not to the credit of any of the producers or any of the. Or any of the creatives on this show, but it ultimately accidentally became a piece of medicine for this audience in a weird way. Again, by total freak of nature accident, goodnight and good luck gave that audience what they wanted and inside of what they wanted was ultimately what they needed. Now, did it do it as impressively as they could have? Probably not. But that is what we will. That is the grace we will give it. The question, I think also then just becomes, is this where we are heading with Broadway? Is it a lot of celebrities coming for 12 to 15 weeks to do a show and not ruffle any feathers? Best case scenario, they surprise everyone. You know, middle of the road scenario is the production itself is fine, usually going to be tested material. A masterpiece like Waiting for Gadot, a masterpiece like Othello, a Pulitzer Prize winner, that's actually a better movie like Glengarry Glen Ross with an established director, David Cromer, Kenny Leon, Patrick Marber, Jamie Lloyd, Sam Gold with, you know, these, these A listers or B listers, if you want to be sketchy or, you know, on the rise. A listers and charging an arm and a leg for these limited runs. What does that actually do for Broadway? It listen, it, it keeps the theater occupied. The actors, the other actors who get to be in those shows, if the shows have a large enough company, they get to be employed for a while. It does, technically speaking, bring eyes to the theater district. But as I said, in shows like Back to the Future, I would argue it doesn't. Actually. This is not a tide that lifts all other boats because those shows are not about the theater. They're about the performer. Hamilton being the sensation it was Rent being the sensation that it was. And shows like that were what helped Broadway because they became sensations, because they were theater, not because of who was in it. And when eyes are on the thing, anything else in its orbit gets, you know, a touch of spotlight osmosis. And you don't get spotlight osmosis when all the news of Good Night and Good Luck is George Clooney. Alana Glaser is in Good Night and Good Luck and no one's talking about it. Clark Gregg, Paul Gross. My God, my beloved Paul Gross from Slings and Arrows, who is looking mighty fine with Silver Hair, by the by. And we support Ilana Glaser's Broadway debut. It's. I support actors going outside of their comfort zone. And this is very much out of her comfort zone. I can't say that I felt she fully succeeded, but that's also because maybe my own prejudice of what I. How I fell in love with her is through Broad City and things like Broad City. And so it's harder for me to see her in a straight laced piece like this. But as, as I was getting at by having these productions happen this way, I can't argue that the audiences are going and falling in love with theater. They might have a good time, but ultimately it's because they wanted to see the person. And if, if they're fortunate, the production is solid enough because the play is going to be good enough. As I said, they're doing tried and true material, but they will be entertained and when they walk away in a few days time, what they'll say is, I saw so and so on stage. I saw Denzel, I saw Jake Gyllenhaal, I saw George Clooney. They're not saying, oh, I saw this wonderful play, this wonderful production of this play. Right. And I want us to think about that when, as we continue the conversation about this season with theater tickets and scarcity and supporting the arts and supporting Broadway. Right? Because you can love this art form and demand more from it. That's okay. We were talking about this, I think, in the. It might have been smash or might have been last five years, I can't remember which one. But the idea of you can love something and it doesn't always live up to your expectations or your standards for it. And the same is true of people, of artists. I mean, you know, people in our lives, of course, but like artists, right? If someone is really a good artist and a smart artist, they're going to take big swings from time to time just to spice things up, get out of their comfort zone, you know, strengthen their own skills by not just falling into the same routine. And sometimes that is a high risk, high reward situation. And sometimes it's a swing and a miss, and that's okay. It does not take away from all of the wonderful things they've done in the past or that they will in the future. But it also doesn't behoove us to sit there and just go, I'm here to support it. I'm a supporter. And thus it is good and they are good, and I don't want to hear anything about it because that is also complacency. And the last. And I. The last thing you ever want to be is complacent, right? You can understand when something or someone is doing their. Has done their absolute best and it's not enough for you, and you can acknowledge the effort on their end and then walk away. But for something like theater, I really want you guys to think about this. Not just what's been popular in the community, but what has actually broken through outside of Broadway to reach the outer realms. And it's also never been easier to reach the outer realms. Despite all of the competition theater has in the world, in pop culture, with the outreach of the Internet, of social media, it's never been easier for millions around the world to see what you are doing on. On that stage and to be interested in it. Right. Rob and I were talking at intermission. There were people from London coming to see Smile this two week run, not even two weeks. This ten day run at this 120 seat theater on 45th street of a musical that ran five weeks in the 80s. People are coming from around the world to see it. So it's not hard to get the word out. But really think about this. In the last couple of years, what has reached the outer realms? What has once it? What is a show that after it closed is still spoken of with the excitement and reverence it was spoken of when it was running. Because that's also what I think about when I talk about these shows. And then I will get pushback from people. Oh, you don't know what you're talking about. Oh, you're narcissistic. Oh, you're negative, you're a pessimist, whatever. The Times loved it. So what do you know? And I go, okay, Jesse Green's been smoking a lot of things this season. We have all been talking about it. There are a lot of critics picks that he has given out that we've all side eyed, right? And either the Times matters or it doesn't. I ultimately think that the Times doesn't matter. It's just the largest readership of people who read reviews for theater. But I am very okay with people disagreeing. There are times when I sit there and I go, I think that time is gonna prove me right. I really do. Whether positive or negative. I remember seeing light in the piazza at a very sensitive, tender, and in my case, very Sexy, age of 15. No one else is sexy at 15, but I was, I'm just that special. And I saw it with my grandmother, with, with Nanny, and it was, it had just opened and we were, it was playing to like a 70% capacity theater that night. And at intermission we went into the lobby and spoke to some of her friends because Nanny used to work at Lincoln center. And so some of her friends were there and we went into the, you know, members lounge and they were talking about it and 15 year old me was like, that's one of the most beautiful things I've ever seen. And they were like, ugh, I don't know, it's just so dry and whatever. I just don't know what to make of it. They're like, I don't think this is gonna do much. And I remember at 15 going like, just, you know, I just have to wait because I, I can feel it on my bones that this is good and that this is gonna last. And it has, it has lasted. I felt the same way about Caroline or change. I felt the same way about Groundhog Day, messy as it was, I was like, there's enough good here that you know we're gonna remember it. And then there are shows that have run for two or three years or didn't run for very long that had very passionate fan bases when they were running. And I would sit there and I would just go, yeah, that show's gonna close and people are gonna forget about it like that. And that has happened way more often than we're willing to admit. Good night and good luck. Glengarry, Glen Ross and Othello are going to leave Broadway by the summer. And, you know, Glengarry might win a Tony for Bill Burr. They might even win Revival. I don't think they should. I would give it to Yellow Day. To Yellowfacer. Yerka Day over Glengarry. Good night, good luck. Might have some tech nominations. George will probably get nominated. I think Othello has Jake Gyllenhaal nominated. I would love to get Andrew Burnup a nomination. And featured probably won't happen, but here we are. But after the summer, they'll close and we're going to forget about it. That's just the fact. I'm going to keep thinking about all the World's a stage after this episode for a while. I'm going to think about it and I look forward to hopefully seeing it at some point in the future, whether it's at King Company or a new production of it or if Adam does more work on it. And I want to see sort of the new iteration of that in the same way that I'm also looking forward to seeing Zorba at J2 Spotlight and seeing what they come up with with that show. Yeah. That's all I want us to think about ultimately from this episode as we finish this season and look to the next season. And as we once again have major stars coming to Broadway and these known titles and new big splashy musicals and revivals, what is it we want from theater? Think generally first and then specifically with each subcategory of show that you see. And is it. And when you go see the thing, is it delivering that and is that enough? I would argue while ticket prices have never been higher, the quality on Broadway has never been more inconsistent. I think this has been a better season than last, specifically with musicals. But I also thought last season with musicals was pretty anemic plays. It's pretty equal. We've had quite a few plays this season I thought were very good, same as last year, some wonderful performances. But it's been uneven for me. And we'll talk about that more when we do our final wrap up in May. And that's it for now. Thank you for making it this through, guys. I hope any of this made any kind of sense. I put off drinking any evening so I could speak with some sense of cogency. Is that the right word I want to say? Despite the fact that I've had absolutely no alcohol, the words are now just leaving my brain and I am sounding dumber than the book of Smash. Ho ho ho. What an easy punchline I now have. Move Over Finding Neverland, Paradise Square, Back to the Future and Jagged Little Pill. I've got a new punching bag and it's the libretto for Smash. Bob Martin and Rick Ellis. If I ever meet them, I'll tell them that I have no problem saying that. I don't care what Jesse Green says. That book is bad, anywho. And you can have it and you can enjoy it. There are things to enjoy about Smash, but that libretto is objectively bad. And it ultimately tells you that what makes music, what makes a musical go from promising to bad, is allowing actors to have ideas, specifically allowing women to read books. That is a common recurring joke in the show. And it would be less upsetting to me if the whole show were smarter and better, but it's not. And they keep coming to that. Well, and it's the main crux of the drama of that show is that Robyn Herter gets her hands on a book and it turns her into a monster and she turns the whole show bad with her ideas. And I'm sitting here going, fuck you, libretto writers, librettists. I don't want to end on that sour note. Go see all the World's a stage at King Company if you can. It's at Theater Row. I highly, highly, highly recommend it. I know it's on tdf. I'm sure there are some papering sites as well. But also, like, if you have the scratch, like get a nice real ticket. You know, don't save up for the last corner seat of Othello or Good night and good luck. Pay. Use that money to pay for like a real seat for all the world to stage. It's better. I think you'll like it more. And it's sweet and special and reminds you that there are good librettos in musicals. Very lovely. I am going to have us close out because the cast album dropped this week. I'm going to close out with Megan Hilty for Death Becomes Her. No, I take that back. We're going to close out with Jennifer Simard only because while re listening to the album, Jen has this song that I liked in the theater and I love now and it's called let's Run Away Together. So I'll to make it up to Megan. I'll have Megan close us out in a future episode between now and the Tonys because I do love Megan, but I really fell in love with this song on the cast recording. Not every song, but this song I really love and has some amazing lyrics. So that's what we're gonna do. We're gonna close out with Jen Simard singing let's Run Away Together for this episode. Join us for the final round of Tony nomination predictions. I'm gonna hold. I've decided also I'm gonna hold off on announcing what shows we're covering in the next series. Deep dive just for a little bit because we're so in the weeds with Tony stuff right now. I don't want to get, I don't want to announce it and then not do it for two months. I want to announce it a little closer to when we plan to release those episodes. So hang tight. We will be announcing that soon enough. Specifically what shows we're covering. And if you're on the Discord channel, you know at least one of them. Because I already recorded one episode and asked the Discord Channel for topics they wanted us to cover. But that's it. Yeah. Again, five star rating or review if you can. We really want to push past 300 on Apple Podcasts. We're over 100 on Spotify. I don't think we're going to hit 200 by the end of May, but we can hit over 300 on Apple by the end of May, hopefully even by the end of April if we can. And yeah, we've got some more reviews coming out soon. Pirates, Floyd Collins. Just in time. Old friends. Real women have curves. Dead outlaw. It'll be a fun time. Fun time, fun time. And yeah, that's it for now. You guys have a great rest of your weekend and couple of days and I'll see you soon. Take it away, Jen. Bye.
Ariana Grande
It will be quick, just how you like it. Zero mess Unless you've got a bone saw. No, we'll be precise. We'll stage a story of an actress cast out for a rage. They'll think she's cracked Tragic end for all to see her final act. They'll eat it up and we'll be free to us and care my fingers in your hair while Nathan's decomposing in the ground. Let's run away together. Let's run away to Perry. Let's go make love.
Broadway Breakdown: Episode Summary
Title: Matt Saw Broadway's Expensive Shows, But...
Host: Matt Koplik
Release Date: April 19, 2025
In this episode of Broadway Breakdown, host Matt Koplik delves into the high-end Broadway scene, sharing his experiences attending some of the most expensive and star-studded productions of the season. Matt offers an insightful critique of these shows, exploring the balance between spectacle and substance, and reflecting on Broadway's evolving dynamics in the face of escalating ticket prices and celebrity-driven casting.
Matt begins by outlining the upcoming shows slated for review as the Tony Awards approach:
He also announces a new review and a Tony nomination prediction episode, inviting listeners to join the Broadway Breakdown Discord community, which has grown to over 250 members. Matt encourages listeners to engage with the community for discussions, promotions, and shared theater interests.
"We have over 250 members now. It's a super awesome space." [02:15]
Matt emphasizes the importance of community engagement through Discord, highlighting its role in fostering connections among theater enthusiasts. He offers solutions for those experiencing issues joining the Discord channel, directing them to his Instagram for a personal invite link.
Matt shares his thoughts on the British transfer of Stranger Things: The First Shadow, comparing it to the original Netflix series. While he appreciates the spectacle and creative staging, he critiques the play for feeling overly stretched and akin to "three episodes of the TV show strung together."
"It was a very stretched out story that could have been told tighter." [15:50]
He praises lead actor Lewis McCartney for his portrayal of the character's inner conflict but feels that the narrative lacks depth, making it more of a visual spectacle than a compelling theatrical piece.
Addressing the third Broadway revival of David Mamet's Pulitzer Prize-winning play, Matt expresses his frustration with the persistent popularity of Glengarry Glen Ross despite his personal disapproval of playwright David Mamet.
"He is not a favorite person of mine. He has said some really wild things the last few years." [21:10]
Matt critiques the casting, particularly Kieran Culkin's performance as Roma, feeling he is miscast compared to previous actors who embodied the role's gravitas.
"Kieran Culkin is still sort of in succession mode... He's not playing Roma. He's playing the parts he's played before." [24:40]
Despite these criticisms, Matt acknowledges the solid performances of Bill Burr and Donald Webber Jr., though he remains underwhelmed by the overall production quality given its high ticket prices.
Matt discusses Good Night and Good Luck, highlighting its relevance in today's sociopolitical climate. He appreciates George Clooney's performance and the play's portrayal of Edward R. Murrow's stand against Senator Joseph McCarthy.
"Good Night and Good Luck... the importance and the integrity of journalism and of the truth and of one's principles and morals." [40:10]
However, Matt criticizes the play's final montage for feeling preachy and forced, questioning its effectiveness in delivering its powerful message.
In his review of Othello, Matt provides a brief overview, noting the stellar casting of Denzel Washington and Jake Gyllenhaal. While he commends Jake's performance as Iago, he finds Denzel's portrayal of Othello lacking fluidity and naturalism.
"Denzel Washington is not a disaster in the role... but it's long. It's mostly similar to Glengarry Glen Ross." [54:30]
Matt praises Andrew Burnap's performance as Cassio, describing it as the standout of the production, despite Cassio being a minor character.
Matt shifts focus to off-Broadway productions, specifically Smile, produced by Rob Schneider and J2 Spotlight. He commends the production for its intelligent and creative approach despite limited resources.
"They put on really lovely, intelligent, and creative productions with not a lot of resources." [31:50]
Matt appreciates the show's ability to blend comedy with sharp social commentary, highlighting its clever satirical elements that address broader societal issues.
Matt also reviews All the World's A Stage, a new musical developed by Adam Guan and produced by the King Company at Theater Row. He lauds the musical for its heartfelt storytelling and well-crafted songs, though he suggests minor trims for pacing.
"It is a kind of musical that Bob Martin and Rick Ellis make fun of a lot in Smash." [59:45]
He praises the show's focus on character development and the nuanced portrayal of its protagonists, making it a standout in the season's offerings.
Matt provides a broader commentary on Broadway's trajectory, critiquing the trend of casting celebrities to drive ticket sales rather than prioritizing the quality of the production itself.
"Why is everyone clamoring for Othello? Why is everyone clamoring for Good Night and Good Luck? It is ultimately to see famous people on stage." [68:50]
He laments that Broadway is becoming more about the performers and their star power than the stories being told, leading to inconsistent quality and a disconnect between the audience and the theatrical experience.
Matt reflects on the historical significance of Broadway in shaping cultural narratives and expresses concern that the current focus on celebrity-driven shows may detract from Broadway's artistic integrity and ability to resonate broadly.
Matt wraps up the episode by reiterating his support for thoughtfully produced shows like All the World's A Stage and urging listeners to critically assess their theater experiences beyond the allure of star power. He emphasizes the importance of delivering meaningful content that both entertains and challenges audiences, advocating for a return to Broadway's roots as a platform for impactful storytelling.
"Think about what you want from theater. Is it delivering what you signed up for, and is that enough?" [75:30]
Matt encourages listeners to support productions that prioritize quality and substance, ensuring that Broadway remains a vital and revered institution in the arts.
As the episode concludes, Matt expresses his anticipation for future discussions on Tony nominations and upcoming shows, inviting listeners to continue engaging with the Broadway Breakdown community.
"Join us for the final round of Tony nomination predictions." [76:00]
He also shares a personal note about the challenges of maintaining critical discourse while supporting the art form, concluding with a recommendation to attend All the World's A Stage for a fulfilling theater experience.
Notable Quotes:
This episode of Broadway Breakdown offers a critical examination of the current Broadway landscape, blending personal anecdotes with thoughtful analysis. Matt Koplik challenges listeners to consider the true value of their theater experiences, advocating for a balance between star power and meaningful storytelling.