Broadway Breakdown: So. Let's Talk WICKED (PART 1) with Joel Guerrero-Sparks
Release Date: December 2, 2024
Introduction
In this highly anticipated episode of Broadway Breakdown, host Matt Koplik welcomes theater enthusiasts to delve deep into the phenomenon that is Wicked. Requested avidly by listeners on the podcast's Discord channel, this episode marks the first part of a two-part series focusing on the recent Wicked movie release. Joined by his esteemed guest, Joel Guerrero-Sparks, Matt navigates through listener feedback, personal anecdotes, and a comprehensive analysis of the movie adaptation.
Listener Reviews ([00:50] - [08:12])
Before diving into the main discussion, Matt dedicates a segment to appreciating the podcast's audience. He reads heartfelt five-star reviews from listeners who commend the show's in-depth analysis, engaging discussions, and Matt's vast knowledge of Broadway history. Notable comments highlight how the podcast rekindled listeners' passion for theater, prompting them to attend Broadway shows after a hiatus.
Notable Quote:
Nick_v1 expresses, "My apartment has never been cleaner because of Matt and this show... three hours have passed which felt like 30 minutes and the place is spotless."
Introducing Joel Guerrero-Sparks ([08:12])
Matt warmly introduces his guest, Joel Guerrero-Sparks, referring to him as a "dear friend" and a "bosom Buddy sister." Joel brings a fresh perspective to the discussion, given his extensive background in theater and personal connection to Wicked.
Deep Dive into Wicked Movie Adaptation
Relationship with Wicked ([09:00] - [21:05])
Joel shares his longstanding affinity for Wicked, recounting how the musical captivated him during his high school drama days. He emphasizes the show's influence on his career choice, stating, "Wicked was Bible... this could be a career. This is what I want to train in."
Matt echoes Joel's sentiments, adding his own experiences of watching various Wicked performances and highlighting the exceptional nature of the original cast. They discuss the challenges of adapting a beloved stage musical to film, noting that the rigidity of Wicked's Broadway production makes recapturing its magic on screen a formidable task.
Notable Quote:
Joel remarks at [12:33], "Wicked at its core is nostalgic... now 20 years later, it's even more special."
Analyzing the Movie's Changes ([21:05] - [43:52])
Structural Adjustments and Storytelling ([21:05] - [37:03])
Joel and Matt delve into the necessity of splitting the movie into two parts, arguing that Wicked's expansive narrative warrants the extended runtime. They discuss pacing, character development, and the economic decisions behind scene alterations. Joel points out, "They carved out a large chunk of time... so we didn't want to eat up our minutes... can't have unlimited time when we record."
Performance Critique ([37:03] - [61:36])
The conversation shifts to the performances of the lead actresses portraying Elphaba and Glinda. Joel praises Cynthia Erivo's portrayal, highlighting her vocal control and emotional depth. In contrast, he provides a critical yet respectful analysis of Ariana Grande's interpretation, noting her lighter vocal approach and unique stylistic choices.
Notable Quote:
Cynthia comments at [43:37], "It's a powerful move... Elphaba is fully coming into her own."
Listener Questions and Inquiries ([61:36] - [98:15])
Matt and Joel address various listener-submitted questions concerning the movie's cinematography, casting decisions, and musical arrangements. They debate the effectiveness of lens flare usage, color grading, and the balance between staying faithful to the source material versus introducing cinematic innovations.
Notable Quote:
Joel states at [77:07], "It's a great way to do the songs, having it all be in Roxy's imagination... the songs would feel like they were just stopping the momentum... Everything has a layer of intention."
Most Successful Numbers Tally ([111:32] - [124:53])
Matt and Joel present the results of a listener poll determining the top three most successful numbers in the Wicked movie adaptation. The tally reveals:
- "What is This Feeling?" – Garnering nine votes, this song stands out for its dynamic choreography and effective storytelling.
- "Defying Gravity" – With six votes, listeners applaud its iconic status and powerful execution.
- "No One Mourns the Wicked" – Securing five votes, this number is praised for its emotional depth and narrative significance.
Notable Quote:
Cynthia shares at [120:45], "Wicked on stage makes zero attempt at creating the world of wizard of Oz... this movie honors the wizard of Oz."
Closing Thoughts ([124:44] - [127:07])
In concluding the episode, Matt and Joel reflect on the balance of honoring the original musical while embracing the cinematic medium. They express excitement for the upcoming Part 2, anticipating further exploration of character development and thematic resolutions.
Notable Quote:
Matt concludes at [125:03], "So, like, do what you want to do. But if you want my take, I'm like, can we up the coloring just 10%, just a little, like a skosh?"
Conclusion
This episode of Broadway Breakdown offers a comprehensive exploration of the Wicked movie adaptation, balancing fan enthusiasm with critical analysis. Matt Koplik and Joel Guerrero-Sparks provide valuable insights into the challenges and triumphs of translating a beloved Broadway classic to film, enriched by listener interactions and thoughtful discussion.
Where to Listen
Stay tuned for Part 2 of this series, where Matt and Joel will continue their in-depth discussion on Wicked, delving further into character arcs, thematic elements, and the film's overall impact on the Broadway legacy.