Broadway Breakdown: Episode Summary – "THE WOMEN with Adam Elsberry"
Release Date: December 12, 2024
Introduction
In this episode of Broadway Breakdown, host Matt Koplik delves into the intricate world of Claire Booth Luce's classic play, The Women. Joined by returning guest Adam Elsberry, Matt navigates through the play's history, its cinematic adaptation, and various Broadway revivals. Their candid and spirited discussion uncovers the layers of character development, directorial choices, and the enduring legacy of this seminal work in American theater.
Episode Overview
The Women is a cornerstone of American drama, first staged in 1936 and later adapted into a highly acclaimed film. The play offers a satirical glimpse into the lives of affluent New York socialites, exploring themes of friendship, rivalry, and marital strife. Matt Koplik and Adam Elsberry dissect how different productions and adaptations have interpreted these themes over the decades.
Key Discussions
-
Understanding The Women: Play vs. Movie
Adam Elsberry opens the conversation by clarifying the essence of The Women:
“[05:34] Cynthia Erivo: The Women is a play by Claire Booth Luce from 1936. It's about women, but what are they?”
Matt and Adam explore the core narrative—focusing on Mary Haynes, who discovers her husband's affair with a shopgirl, Crystal Allen. They compare how the play emphasizes gossip and social maneuvering, while the movie adaptation offers a more polished and accessible storytelling approach.
-
Character Portrayals and Development
The hosts delve into the nuances of key characters:
-
Mary Haynes: Described as the wealthiest and most secure among her friends, Mary grapples with her husband's infidelity, leading to a quest to reclaim her marriage.
“[07:12] Ariana Grande: Wait, Crystal Allen?”
-
Crystal Allen: Portrayed as the cunning mistress, Crystal's manipulative nature is scrutinized, especially in how she controls her relationship with Steven and undermines Mary's life.
“[08:18] Ariana Grande: Yeah, well, yes and no. She also spends a lot of time morally figuring out what's the right thing to do.”
-
Sylvia Fowler and Edith: The discussion highlights Sylvia as the toxic influence within the friend group, and Edith's role as a secondary character struggling with her own issues.
-
-
Differences Between Play and Film
A significant portion of the episode contrasts the stage play with its film adaptation:
-
Narrative Structure: The movie provides a clearer resolution adhering to the Hays Code, ensuring that immoral actions are punished, thereby giving the storyline a more satisfying closure compared to the play's chaotic ending.
“[11:00] Cynthia Erivo: Because of the Hays Code, a lot of sins that these characters do had to be punished in the end.”
-
Character Arcs: Mary’s transformation in the movie is more pronounced as she gains confidence and seeks to mend her marriage, whereas the play leaves her arc somewhat ambiguous.
“[12:15] Cynthia Erivo: But we don't know for sure.”
-
-
Broadway Revivals and Their Reception
The hosts examine various Broadway revivals, particularly the 2001 Roundabout Theater Company production:
-
Cast and Direction: Cynthia Nixon as Mary, Jennifer Tilly as Crystal, and Kristen Johnston as Sylvia are discussed, with particular emphasis on Scott Elliott's directorial choices that included edgy elements like blackface humor, which were controversial and received mixed reviews.
“[14:18] Cynthia Erivo: And that was great.”
-
Critical Response: Despite a star-studded cast, the revival struggled due to its lackluster direction and failure to capture the original play's sharp wit, leading to its short Broadway run.
“[19:06] Cynthia Erivo: Yeah, which would explain why Candice Bergen was in it.”
-
-
Cultural Impact and Legacy
Matt and Adam reflect on the play's enduring presence in the queer community and its status as a "bitchy entertainment" that paved the way for modern high-society dramas and comedies like Sex and the City and reality shows like Real Housewives.
“[10:34] Ariana Grande: There's a sort of. It's interesting to visit it and see really how much it influenced future comedy of that style.”
Notable Quotes
-
On Directorial Choices and Adaptations:
“[03:43] Ariana Grande: And I will say, you and I both came into this being like, who knows who's going to listen to this?”
-
On Character Complexity:
“[12:59] Ariana Grande: And everyone has opinions and everyone is getting cheated on in some respect.”
-
On the Play's Themes:
“[08:46] Ariana Grande: And the play doesn't have a lot to say. It's mostly meant to sort of be a satire of high society ladies, but ultimately, at the heart of it, it's like, you're a woman, be a wife.”
-
On Revival Failures:
“[20:35] Cynthia Erivo: Just because of the Hays Code, a lot of sins that these characters do had to be punished in the end.”
Conclusions and Insights
Matt Koplik and Adam Elsberry conclude that while The Women holds a significant place in theatrical history, its adaptations and revivals often miss the mark by either diluting the original's sharp satire or mishandling character development. They suggest that modern revivals could benefit from incorporating the film's strengths—clearly defined narratives and character arcs—while maintaining the play's inherent wit and social commentary.
Additionally, they touch upon the potential for innovative reinterpretations, such as drag performances, to breathe new life into the material by leveraging contemporary sensibilities and humor.
Final Thoughts
This episode of Broadway Breakdown offers a comprehensive examination of The Women, providing listeners with a nuanced understanding of its intricate character dynamics and the challenges inherent in adapting stage plays for the screen. Matt Koplik and Adam Elsberry's passionate discussion underscores the play's relevance and prompts reflection on how classic works can be reimagined to resonate with modern audiences.
Find More Episodes
Stay tuned to Broadway Breakdown for more in-depth analyses of Broadway's greatest plays and musicals. Whether you're a seasoned theatre enthusiast or a curious newcomer, Matt Koplik's unapologetic passion promises engaging and insightful explorations every week.
Remember to subscribe and leave a review to support the podcast!