BroadwayRadio Podcast Summary: Class Notes with Christopher James Tamayo on “Maybe Happy Ending Sometimes”

Episode Title: Class Notes: Christopher James Tamayo “Maybe Happy Ending”
Host: Lauren Klaus Schneider
Release Date: March 26, 2025

Introduction

In this episode of BroadwayRadio, host Lauren Klaus Schneider welcomes Christopher James Tamayo, who portrays Oliver in the Broadway production of “Maybe Happy Ending Sometimes”, a role originally originated by Darren Criss. The conversation delves into Christopher’s approach to his character, his journey to joining the cast, his educational background, and the collaborative rehearsal process that brought the show to life.

Diving into the Role of Oliver

Lauren opens the discussion by describing the premise of “Maybe Happy Ending Sometimes” and asks Christopher about his approach to embodying Oliver, a “Helper Bot 3” living a secluded life in Korea.

Christopher James Tamayo shares his creative process:

“We draw a lot on as far as the physicality is concerned. So many different resources. Animation to Charlie Chaplin to Commedia dell'arte... Oliver is just like an amalgamation of all these things that I grew up watching.”
(00:59)

He elaborates on his inspirations, citing animated robots from films like Wall-E and Big Hero 6, as well as comedians like Robin Williams and Jim Carrey. Christopher relates Oliver’s personality to his own love for media consumption and his identity as a listener, emphasizing the character’s core purpose:

“At his core, he loves to help people, and he is all, you know, his purpose as a helper bot is to help.”
(02:50)

Journey to “Maybe Happy Ending Sometimes”

Lauren inquires about Christopher’s path to joining the show. He recounts a serendipitous journey:

Christopher James Tamayo describes how the opportunity arose while he was touring with Les Misérables:

“I was reading for Oliver, and she [his friend] was reading for Claire... I had to be a part of it. I read the script, I read the sides, filmed it the next day... I get a call from my agent, and we go out to the car. You've got the job off of a single tape.”
(03:22 - 06:02)

This swift and somewhat unexpected audition process underscores the importance of being prepared and open to new opportunities.

Educational Background and Its Impact

Lauren shifts the focus to Christopher’s academic background, noting his recent graduation from the University of Michigan and his role in a national tour.

Christopher James Tamayo reflects on his time at the University of Michigan:

“Michigan, it just prepares its students really well... My favorite courses were often the ones outside of the musical theater department... History especially.”
(07:12 - 09:00)

He emphasizes the value of a well-rounded education, highlighting how courses in philosophy, psychology, and even video game music enriched his perspective as an actor. Christopher also stresses the importance of respecting writers:

“Treasure your writers, because it's not easy to do that stuff... honor their work as best you can.”
(08:30)

Collaborative Rehearsal Process

The conversation transitions to the dynamics within the rehearsal studios and the collaborative environment of the production.

Christopher James Tamayo expresses both excitement and nervousness about working closely with the writers and directors:

“It's terrifying because you don't want to disappoint the writers... but we were able to have this open dialogue, and we were able to be very participatory in the creative process.”
(10:05)

He describes the intimate setting of the rehearsal space, where a small team collaborates closely, fostering an environment where ideas can be rapidly tested and refined. The director, Michael Arden, often encourages the team to question and improve upon the work:

“He would ask, like, investigate, does this work? The writers would talk about it, and they'd be like, yeah, we can change that to more organically fit what's going on in the scene.”
(10:45)

This dynamic allows for a vibrant and evolving production, with Christopher actively engaged in capturing every detail:

“Furiously in the corner, like, taking notes, like, making sure I get everything down. It's a whirlwind time...”
(10:15)

Closing Remarks

Lauren wraps up the conversation by thanking Christopher for his insights, to which he responds gratefully.

“Thank you for having me. Really, really a pleasure.”
(11:48)

Lauren concludes by highlighting Christopher’s role and contributions to the Broadway scene.

Key Takeaways

• Character Development: Christopher approaches Oliver by blending various influences from animation, comedy, and classical performance arts, creating a multi-faceted character grounded in a love for helping others.

• Auditioning Success: His journey to the role was marked by timing, preparation, and a supportive network, demonstrating the unpredictable nature of theater casting.

• Educational Influence: A comprehensive education at the University of Michigan provided Christopher with diverse knowledge and skills, enhancing his performance abilities and appreciation for the collaborative art of theater.

• Collaborative Rehearsals: The intimate and interactive rehearsal process allowed for meaningful contributions from all members, fostering a creative and dynamic production environment.

“Maybe Happy Ending Sometimes” stands as a testament to innovative storytelling on Broadway, with Christopher James Tamayo’s portrayal of Oliver bringing depth and charm to the beloved role originally held by Darren Criss.