Buffalo Plus Podcast Summary

Episode: Bills BULLY the Steelers in BOUNCEBACK WIN: O-line, JAMES COOK & the DEFENSE lead the way
Date: December 1, 2025
Hosts: Jenna Cottrell (In Pittsburgh), Dan Fates, Mike Catalana (both in Rochester)

Episode Overview

This episode covers the Buffalo Bills’ crucial 26–7 bounce-back win against the Pittsburgh Steelers. The hosts break down how the Bills executed a physical, resilient game, examining standout performances from the offensive line, James Cook, the defense (notably Shaq Thompson), and Josh Allen's milestone. The conversation mixes in-depth analysis, sideline observations, and lively banter, capturing the mood both on the field and in the locker room.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Significance of the Win

• Playoff implications and morale:
  • This victory moves the Bills to 8-4, improving their playoff standing and tiebreaker position.
  • The team rebounded from a tough loss in Houston, regaining both confidence and energy.
  • Jenna Cottrell (00:31): “This to me is a hindsight win. I think that you can learn from this game... just the smiles… you could tell how dejected this team was [last week], to get a big win on the road...”
  • The mood shift is highlighted by Sean McDermott’s “road warriors” theme and evident postgame joy.

2. Offensive Line Shines Without Starters

• Depth steps up:
  • Buffalo played without starting tackles Dion Dawkins and Spencer Brown, plugging in Alec Anderson and Ryan VanDemark.
  • Despite early false start penalties, the line settled and imposed its will, especially in the run game.
  • Dan Fates (02:54): “Credit to Alec Anderson and Ryan Vandermark… after the game they had [in Houston]... what they did tonight was impressive.”
  • Standout: The typically fearsome TJ Watt was “barely noticeable” due to the Bills’ O-line dominance.
  • Josh Allen’s appreciation (04:42):

    "Those are two guys you never, ever have to worry about their work ethic or their want or their love for their teammates… for us to go in there against that defensive line, that’s some special stuff. I could not be more proud of them."

3. Running Game Dominance & Offensive Strategy

• Rushing attack leads the way:
  • Bills rushed for 249 yards, with James Cook starring and Ray Davis contributing key carries.
  • Jenna Cottrell (07:12): "James Cook continues to have a phenomenal season."
  • The attack gave Allen breathing room and compensated for a limited passing game.
  • James Cook led the team in both rushing and receiving (33 yds), and Ty Johnson made big plays.
  • Dan Fates (06:02): “[Cook] told us he texted those guys [O-line] before the game and told them he loves them... That’s a different kind of leadership.”
  • Passing-wise, only three WRs caught passes, but the run game controlled the tempo.

4. Defensive Takeover in Second Half

• Physicality & turnovers tilt the game:
  • Christian Benford returned a forced fumble for his first NFL touchdown on the opening play of the second half.
  • Steelers’ offense was ineffective, and the Bills’ aggressive defense was led by Shaq Thompson, who delivered a players-only challenge after the Houston loss.
  • Jenna Cottrell (11:25): “Shaq Thompson is a guy that… we don’t really talk about all that much. But he made a move – that’s what a leader does.”
  • Dan Fates (12:32): “You can talk, but I don’t think he’d be talking unless he was playing… when you see guys go backwards when they hit him, it’s Shaq.”
  • The team responded to physicality and a questionable late hit on Allen.

5. Josh Allen’s Record-Setting Night & Attitude

• Milestone:
  • Passed Cam Newton for most rushing touchdowns by an NFL QB (76).
  • Dan Fates (14:46): “Josh setting the record for quarterback touchdowns with 76, passing K. Newton… That is NFL history.”
  • Allen displayed fire, jawing with Cam Heyward and inciting an unsportsmanlike penalty, which energized the team.
  • Jenna Cottrell (15:12): “This is the most I’ve ever seen Josh jawing with another player… They were going at it.”
  • Both hosts remark on Allen’s infectious spirit and willingness to mix it up physically and verbally.

6. Passing Game Limitations & Formula for Success

• Passing attack struggles, but the plan worked:
  • Allen made key throws (notably TD to Keon Coleman), but the passing offense was otherwise pedestrian, partly due to weather and backup linemen.
  • The hosts express concern for future games where passing might be necessary.
  • Jenna Cottrell (20:00): “My fear… is that if you’re in a game where you need to pass the ball, you’re gonna be severely limited…”
  • Confidence in adapting the formula—running, O-line physicality, Allen making timely plays—as needed for different opponents.

7. Locker Room Energy and Leadership

• Culture boost and emotional moments:
  • The postgame scene was joyful, with McDermott shaking hands and the whole team celebrating.
  • Allen’s demeanor was “revitalized” after a tough stretch, perhaps helped by his trip to Wyoming.
  • Dan Fates (18:36): “I thought he played like a guy with more energy, but a little more of a joy, like spirit. He likes to talk shit.”
  • Hosted note that Allen’s personality is well-known among pros, even if fans see his community-focused side more.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• [04:42] Josh Allen:

  "Those are two guys you never, ever have to worry about their work ethic or their want or their love for their teammates… for us to go in there against that defensive line, that’s some special stuff.”

• [14:46] Dan Fates on Allen’s milestone:

  “Josh setting the record for quarterback touchdowns with 76… that is so impressive… that is NFL history, and not like the kind of stats where… they cherry pick the stats. That’s awesome.”

• [15:12] Jenna Cottrell on Allen’s competitive fire:

  “This is the most I’ve ever seen Josh jawing with another player. Cam Heyward… They were both jawing at each other for a while.”

• [12:00] Jenna Cottrell on Shaq Thompson’s leadership:

  “Sean McDermott said that essentially, Shaq Thompson challenged the team last week… about, ‘we need us to be better.’”

Highlighted Timestamps

• 00:53 — Dan Fates describes how the Bills "were the more physical team."
• 02:55 — Praise for backup tackles Anderson & VanDemark's resilience.
• 04:42 — Josh Allen’s heartfelt praise for O-line fill-ins.
• 07:28 — Discussion of James Cook’s connection with the O-line and his leadership.
• 09:53 — Benford’s defensive touchdown to open the second half.
• 12:00 — Shaq Thompson’s player challenge and resultant impact.
• 14:46 — Josh Allen breaks NFL QB rushing touchdown record; team emotion.
• 15:28 — Sideline observation on Allen and Cam Heyward’s trash talk and impact.
• 17:42 — Dissecting Allen’s day as a passer amid the run game focus.
• 18:36 — Allen’s revitalized spirit and his trademark edge.
• 20:00 — Concerns about the passing offense ceiling and need for further adjustments ahead.

Final Takeaways

• The Bills won an ugly, physical contest—exactly the type of game they needed after Houston.
• Offensive line depth, powerful ground game, and energizing defense set the tone.
• Josh Allen’s energy, leadership, and milestone added an extra spark.
• Passing game needs to evolve, but the current formula was perfect for beating the Steelers.
• Team chemistry, veteran leadership, and resilience shine through, fueling optimism for the challenging stretch ahead.

For more coverage and updates, subscribe to Buffalo Plus or visit the Buffalo Plus Link Tree.