
The Bills plan for free agency
Loading summary
Shopify Announcer
Shopify's point of sale system helps you sell at every stage of your business. Need a fast and secure way to take payments in person? We've got you covered. How about card readers you can rely on anywhere you sell?
Mike Catalana
Thanks.
Shopify Announcer
Have a good one. Yep, that too. Want one place to manage all your online and in person sales? That's kind of our thing. Wherever you sell. Businesses that grow grow with Shopify. Sign up for your $1 a month trial at shopify.com listen shopify.com listen in.
Hyundai Advertiser
The time it takes you to actually board that flight from Group 8.
Dan Fates
Now boarding Premier Altitude Elite club members.
Hyundai Advertiser
You could have bought a Hyundai on Amazon. Yes, that Amazon, where you buy everything else.
Dan Fates
Mid tier Altitude Elite. Feel free to board now.
Hyundai Advertiser
So while you're waiting for them to make up new boarding groups, you can order your dream car and the dealer will have it ready in no time.
Dan Fates
Now boarding groups one through seven.
Jenna Cottrell
So close.
Hyundai Advertiser
Visit HyundaiUSA.com or call 562-314-4603 for more details. Limited availability pickup through participating Hyundai dealer in select markets.
Mike Catalana
It's time for the Buffalo plus podcast.
Dan Fates
Now and again.
Mike Catalana
Rolls on the move, lets it fly. Oh, what a catch.
Dan Fates
All right. Welcome back to the Buffalo plus podcast, presented by Connors and Ferris. Mike Catalana. Dan Fates. I'm Jenna Cottrell. Please, before we get started, check out our hoodies and sport coats. Dan's not even doing it right now, which I feel like kind of.
Jenna Cottrell
That was the whole bit that you guys did. It was the whole bit before we got on there. They're like, hang on, I gotta go get something. And they both left the frame and then came in the screen at the same time. It was adorable.
Dan Fates
Are we doing it right?
Jenna Cottrell
You guys are hilarious.
Dan Fates
Dude, I don't know how you do this. It's so many layers of clothing.
Mike Catalana
I love it.
Dan Fates
I was trying to find the perfect hoodie to go.
Mike Catalana
I wanted the. I wanted to make sure it's coordinated.
Jenna Cottrell
This is cute.
Dan Fates
Mike came to me today. He's like, you know what we should do? Like, what got him? Before we get started, please be sure to, like, comment and most importantly, subscribe if you enjoy our stuff. Let's talk about it, guys. Free agency is shortly approaching again. It's so many layers, Dan. I don't know how you do it. Free agency approaching. The Bills not use any tags on Tremaine Edmonds. Jordan Poyer. What we expect from him. The Bills Bill's plan of attack now going forward as well. We could talk about that, Michael. I Always start with you.
Mike Catalana
Yeah.
Dan Fates
So let's keep it going. What do you expect from this team as we move closer to March 15th?
Mike Catalana
All right, no big secret. Poyer's gone and I think he signs quickly. I think there's teams out there that are very interested, interested in him. I think he's going to have a market and I think he signs and moves on. As far as Tremaine Edmonds is concerned, I don't know why I, I will say this. I thought as it gets closer and I guess it still could happen that they could sign Edmunds to a deal if they have a plan. I think he reaches free agency, but I just have this feeling because of the affinity they have for him, how much they wanted him to be there and how much it's felt like he's wanted to stay. There's no guarantee that if that guy hits free agency, he couldn't come back. Yes, I know there's going to be teams out there looking to spend money, but I don't know if that money is spent quickly on a linebacker. There are some other positions. You see teams letting guys go now. So I'm going to hold on to this. He may reach free agency, but I don't think that guarantees that Tremaine Edmonds does not come back in a bill's uniform. Go ahead, Dan.
Jenna Cottrell
Well, I liked it. We recorded something for the newscast and you said something on there that, that I really liked and that was. Dan was right.
Dan Fates
I think he said Dan was right.
Jenna Cottrell
He goes, I think Tremaine Edmonds is leaning closer to not coming back. Which is something I've been saying for, which is not.
Dan Fates
Dan is right here.
Jenna Cottrell
But I agree with Mike that especially some of these guys that have become free agents now that can sign now, I think the Bills should jump on and two guys that, that pop out to me are middle linebackers are Bobby Wagner or Eric Kendricks. Now, I know they're both big name guys and I know they both will be not cheap. Yeah, that's fine. The salary cap isn't real. But what I think they would provide is, is a bridge to whoever the next linebacker could be and can learn from that. So while it's like, well, you know, you always have to have an experiment or some project, you know, like say, I don't know if, you know, Terrell Bernard becomes a project and eventually starts at middle linebacker. Like there's got to be somebody else in there in between because there's. This isn't a full on re blowing up the defense and starting Over. You still have a really good defense with young pieces in place, too. So I kind of want to bring in a veteran. Doesn't necessarily need to be an all pro middle linebacker, but those are just two guys that stand out to me to really improve the whole that. I think Tremaine will leave.
Mike Catalana
Yeah.
Dan Fates
Okay, real quick, before you jump in, Mike, I was thinking about this in terms of, like, the situation with Matt Milano and how we talked about when Milano was becoming a free agent and Dan is just shaking his head, so I'm going to continue talking. But we talked about how, you know, you usually traditionally only one linebacker, and we. We talked about how. Wow, like, when the Bills made his extension, we said that kind of is an interesting thing to do at this point in the season. Now I was looking at it because I felt like we kind of were. Were thinking this way about Milano, that he signed late. And I'm curious when he did sign because I feel like it was right around, like, this time, right now, like we were approaching free agency and. Yeah, it says March 11th.
Mike Catalana
Yeah.
Dan Fates
Which is surprising considering. But I also think it hasn't been done, this deal with Tremaine Edmonds. But I feel like the Bills. It's just really, the Bills have made him their guy in terms of, like, the media. He is the quarterback of the defense, all this stuff. I think they didn't tag him, obviously, which is not surprising considering the money it would take him being lumped with, you know, pass rushers as well in terms of the linebacking core. But I just. I don't know if it's a done deal that he is not back with the team, because I think there's just so much that the Bills have done to kind of propel him up and make him be a staple of this team. Now, that doesn't mean that Tremaine Edmonds doesn't want to test free agency himself. But I just. I do think there is some more. I don't want to say Hope, but I don't think the door is shut yet.
Mike Catalana
Yeah, I don't want to. Yeah. I was going to say Jenna's point is that he seemed like one of their core guys.
Dan Fates
Yeah.
Mike Catalana
The whole time he's been there.
Dan Fates
But they've made him that, like, they've. They've put him in front of the media. They've had him do all those things which he didn't need to do.
Mike Catalana
Hey, draft, develop and resign has been their way. And he was really Bean's second pick, his first defensive pick in 2018. With the draft. And I guess he's. He's done a lot of things. Dan, to your point, about guys like, and I agree with you, I would love to see a guy like Bobby Wagner, you know, to come in here, but if you start getting into bigger money for guys like that, then it's less of a bridge and it's more of, well, we didn't give Tremaine, you know, four years with basically three years guaranteed at 12 million a year. We gave Bobby Wagner, you know, two years at 24 million, like, guaranteed. Like, if you're going to do that, it might make more sense to resign Tremaine in that case, because if you're going to go cheaper at that linebacker position, there's also going to be a series of guys that don't have as big names, but can absolutely play that position and would be more of a bridge guy. So while it would be nice to think of an All Pro, I'm not going to say hall of Famer, but Bobby Wagner is pretty darn good.
Jenna Cottrell
Yeah.
Mike Catalana
Coming in. It could be. It could be somebody that you go, oh, this guy's been a nice player in the league. Let's bring him in here. And here's the other thing, philosophically, I think, around the league, while defense is, you know, it doesn't win championships, okay? Two stops wins championships in defense. That's what you need in games. I mean, it's almost comical. You know, I'm watching the Eagles defense going to be somewhat dismantled in free agency. I think that's what's going to happen. And there's a lot of talk there of saying, keep building up the offense, because to win big in the playoffs, sometimes you need two or three stops, which is crazy to think, but that's kind of the way it's gone. So in that case, you know, maybe you just keep sort of. You start retooling on defense. You have a few guys, you think you can make those plays, and you go out and do what you should have been doing in the first place, which is start retooling this offense and get more weapons for Josh Allen.
Jenna Cottrell
But Bobby Wagner, to me, could be one of those guys that wants a chance for two years to be in a Super bowl contending team, because that's obviously why he went to the Rams. Things went terribly wrong there in la, and then it was like a mutual agreement, like, yeah, guys, we're good, right? Like, I can leave, right? We're all. We're all moving on. So I think that there could be a little Bit of how many super bowl contending teams are legitimate and have a hole at middle linebacker where I can come in and be a factor. I think that that could be part of it. To Jenna's point about Milano and when he signed and those things, Covid. The Bills got lucky because of COVID in that sense, that the salary cap went down and there wasn't big money for linebackers that offseason. Because we went into that going, man, Milano's just. He's playing too well. And then all of a sudden we saw that, like the money that was supposed to be for offensive linemen like Daryl Johnson. That was the year the Bills got Darrell Williams and he was. They got him so cheap and all these things. So I. I think Milano is a little bit of a different situation. I know what you're saying about the fact of it doesn't. There still is a thought, because we all thought Milano would get big money and then it wasn't there. I think that in Tremaine. Still young, still young, there will be bigger money out there and.
Mike Catalana
Yeah, and. And real quick on that, Jenna, I've been saying to you guys all along, I thought, you know, we've heard Poyer with the Dolphins, maybe the Giants, Honestly, I could see Tremaine Edmonds with the Giants. They are in desperate need of linebacker help. They have some money to spend now that they've figured out how they're going to handle, you know, the quarterback and Barkley on his thing, you know, and Joe Shane certainly is very well aware of. Of Edmonds, so that can be the case. But sure. This is a different one, though. You know, that's why I keep going back to this. And I. I know I'm stuck on it. But Tremaine Edmonds, we make the jokes about his age, but he's going into his second contract, right. That's not normally the guys you let walk. It's when the guys get to a certain age and they're ready to go. Right. It's especially a guy who has played well for you. It's not like he hasn't been. So in terms of like Poyer, Poyer's played great football, did everything you want. If he wasn't 32, he'd be coming back, I think.
Dan Fates
I agree.
Mike Catalana
That's the difference. That is the difference in this is where you're potentially letting go of a player that has done not everything, certainly, because you want to see some more impact, but has done certainly a lot and played almost every game for you. And that would be different that would be a different kind of thing.
Dan Fates
Well, I have a question, too. Like, if you're Sean McDermott and essentially it's expected, you know, I believe that he's going to be kind of taking over the defense in terms of play calling and stuff like that. Like, wouldn't you want to know? Wouldn't you?
Mike Catalana
I think he already knows, right? He's gotta already know, right?
Dan Fates
No, but I'm saying, wouldn't you want to know? That piece is locked in.
Mike Catalana
Yeah.
Dan Fates
Like, that is a big piece of the puzzle. And wouldn't you want to know, like, what is it? The saying is, like, it's the devil you do, not even the devil you do know versus the one you don't. But, like, you're right.
Mike Catalana
Yeah.
Dan Fates
There is a tremendous amount of upside for him. I don't know. It's just interesting.
Mike Catalana
Well, it's also that level of stability, because things have changed a lot. I don't know.
Dan Fates
But maybe Tremaine also wants to test free.
Mike Catalana
Dan is just waiting for the Adam Schefter tweet that Tremaine, cup of coffee and then we get him.
Dan Fates
Yeah, I'm gonna call up Dean and be like, look, between you and me, like, we gotta get this done. I can't have Dan do another lap.
Mike Catalana
And this.
Jenna Cottrell
This is maybe, like, Jen always is. Like, these are all these hot takes. Like, I don't know where Dan gets all these hot takes. I think we're romanticizing a little bit of Tremaine Edmonds. Like, it wasn't that long ago that we were looking at this guy going, man, he's got a.
Mike Catalana
You know.
Jenna Cottrell
Yeah, he's. He's played well, but he's, you know, hasn't played well enough. And now all of a sudden, we're like, you can't let him go. It's like, I think they'd be okay.
Dan Fates
Well, I think that.
Jenna Cottrell
I think that's how the Bills look at it.
Dan Fates
Well, I think that's because you see the. Like, we thought this team was, like, a couple pieces away in terms of, like, defensively. That was always their bread and butter. But, like, you kind of see, like, it looks like the Bills will not have that stability with Jordan Poyer being back and Micah High. There's going to be younger players in the secondary. What is their pass rush going to look like? You kind of want a guy that you know what to expect. He is also coming off his best year as a pro as well. Like, and again, he is, like, I know we joke, but he's young 25. Gotten better. Yeah. So I just, I think when the Bills drafted him, they expected him to be the cornerstone of their defense.
Mike Catalana
Yeah.
Dan Fates
And everything has not gone according to plan, but at the same point it would. I'm not. I wouldn't be surprised if he signed somewhere else, but I also would be a little bit like. Okay, like that means. That's another thing Brandon Bean has to do though. And he's already got a pretty long list of stuff that of, of upgrades essentially that he needs to make on this roster.
Jenna Cottrell
Yeah, I, I, like I said, I think Tremaine's a good player. I think some team will pay him to be a great player. And I think that's a, that that's a tough. And I guess it's just because I'm not looking and that this is to Mike's point about, about Gabe Davis. It's a similar point to this. It is very tough to evaluate young players when development and success is not linear. That and, and how do you judge. How do you put into perspective the whole picture and not Gabe Davis's one playoff game in Kansas City and trade Edmonds three seasons that were h. What.
Mike Catalana
Mike, first of all, timeout. Tremaine Edmonds is the definition of linear improvement. That's he is. He's gotten better each year. It's just a matter of we wanted to see more than incremental increases in what he did for them. He's maybe not going to that top. He's not had the four touchdown, 200 yard game that Gabe Davis did. But I think Tremaine Edmonds has been that guy may. And maybe it's not enough. And maybe they deep down say to themselves he's a good player. But I, I'll give you a good example. Devin Singletary. I was looking at Singletary's numbers. He's made $6 million with the bills. His expected average season value in his new contract would be 5 million a year. Now, I know that's small numbers, you know, based on other players in the NFL, but I'm thinking to myself, you know, you've had four years of them, total of $6 million. He's a good player at that number. And then you go to 5 million a year is what's expected. He's going to get paid. So to dance. You know, sometimes teams will pay that because they've seen this guy produce and they want to give it to him. And I wonder what the Bills really think. I mean that's what I guess what we'll find out. I wonder if they say to themselves, we're going to lose a lot of other stuff in another year, we're going to lose Hyde, and we need that guy in the middle and we're going to pay him because we are really going to make him the cornerstone. I don't know. I don't know.
Jenna Cottrell
And Mike, to your point, I guess I just also go back to the point of sometimes where you said, you know, Tremaine hasn't had that big. That big game. But I would also look at it and say Tremaine hasn't had very few plays, if any of those. And I go, I remember us sitting here going into last offseason going, what is Tremaine Edmond's big play? And we were like, oh, it was that one safety against Cleveland. Like, we haven't. He hasn't had. And they go, that was the big thing was this splash plays. So I guess that's where I'm looking at it. I'm not sitting here saying, train Evans isn't a good player. I'm not. Not saying that. But like, all of a sudden, like, the thought of losing him, you're like, oh, he was so great. And it's like, yeah, he was.
Mike Catalana
He.
Jenna Cottrell
He's good. He's. But he's gonna get. Is. Is he great?
Mike Catalana
And this go. But this goes back to not being prepared for him to leave.
Jenna Cottrell
That's. That's also.
Mike Catalana
And that goes on. That goes on. The draft pick. Now, again, you know, they. They could go the route of a, you know, TJ Edwards one year. Yeah. You know, kind of two year deal, whatever. And then you draft a guy and you hope that he moves in or you hope Bernard moves into it in a year. But when you're letting these guys go, you got. And they've known it. Right. And I guess that you would think that that draft pick was for that purpose, so that might play into it, too. Well.
Dan Fates
I mean, there. There's just. No, it's just. I mean, there. There is so much that, like, we. We talk about, like, linear progression, all this stuff. Like, you think of the Bills and where they're at now. Like, I mean, the team, it feels like they took a little bit of a step back. Remember last season, we're like, they're just a couple pieces away. And now it's like, again, the super bowl will always be open when you have Josh Allen, but it leads a lot to what to think about in terms of what direction they go. And Dan, like, free agency starts March 15th. We're a week out what do you expect them to do in terms of targeting free agents?
Jenna Cottrell
I. I still think that Josh Allen is a great recruiter and having 17 is. Is a guy. You know, it's funny just going to the combine, Mike and I just getting back, and the fact of, I mean, you're not. You're not going to find a single player on offense that isn't going to light up with the. The possibility of playing with Josh Allen. I mean, that's. That is a really good recruiting tool to have. So you need to add pieces around them. And while Mike, like you said, like, you have to have young talent that you're developing and getting ready to fill roles, I understand the super bowl window will be open as long as Josh Allen's there, but, man, I would get some players now that could make a direct impact and not need. Not need a learning curve and not. We'll give him time and he'll get there. And like I said, I know they're linked to, you know, there's thought there's a lot of people. It's what I'm hearing. It's what we're hearing. It's what national, you know, analysts are saying about B John Robinson and just adding more skill players around him. Like, I guess I go back to this, too. If you don't think that these guys are going to be aggressive and Bean's going to be aggressive in free agency. He called the panthers about Christian McCaffrey. So, like, he's. He was looking to add players at the end of last season. I think he's going to be even more aggressive in adding more players to the offense this offseason.
Mike Catalana
Yeah, I think that's a good point. I mean, he called about Christian McCaffrey because he's Christian McCaffrey.
Jenna Cottrell
Right.
Mike Catalana
It's not like he just needed a back. So that's where a guy like Bijan Robinson comes out. Because the thought is he's that guy. I'm going to say this, Jenna. I think when free agency starts, I think the first 48 hours are going to be painful to Bill's fans. I think there's going to be not crickets, but not a lot of noise. And then you're going to see Bill's news and it's going to be underwhelming. It's going to be an offensive lineman, you know, who was, you know, a draft pick of the Bears in 2019, you know, one of those kind of guys.
Jenna Cottrell
Yeah.
Mike Catalana
And he plays guard and center and, you know, and all that kind of stuff. And Then you're going to be like, really? And then you're going to see Miami sign somebody. The jets, the Patriots, whoever it is. Right. The Chiefs. How are the Chiefs doing it? This is what is going to happen. And then day two, I said 48 hours, because we know it's the legal tampering time, but. And then he'll make some moves. I think it'll be those kind of things. I. I say, he told us last year no splashes, and then he came up with a billion dollars for Von Miller. I do think it's a no splashes year in free agency.
Dan Fates
Oh, I wasn't expecting you to say that. So you think. Wait, so you think that there's not going to be much move? Like, not much.
Mike Catalana
Oh, they'll make moves. They're going to make moves, but it's not. It's going to be flashy guys. People are going to be googling the guys they sign.
Dan Fates
Okay, that's. No, that's fair.
Mike Catalana
Right? You're going to be like, wait a minute, which guy is that? Oh, well, let's. We found some highlights of him. He, you know, was injured. I. I just see him signing those type of free agents. I see him going to. I don't see. And I know people want to hear that they're going after DeAndre Hopkins, you know, that they're going to make a deal for. I just don't see that happening. I really don't. And part of this, it's frustrating, but I think maybe they. They're going to need some quantity to go with the quality because they got a lot of their own free agents, too. So that's interesting. That's kind of the way I see Bean handling free agency this year.
Dan Fates
Now, Vaughn Miller posted a picture with Derrick Henry. Like, that's not. There's no. I don't. I would be shocked. Or Dan, you. I feel like you.
Jenna Cottrell
Well, it's like, I go back to it. It's like everybody's like, well, James Cook is going to be the guy. And it's like, well, if James Cook was the guy, two months ago, he was. He was calling about Christian McCaffrey. Like, well, no, I. So, so, so, so the thought of, like, well, no way they would be in on him. It's like, why wouldn't they be in there?
Dan Fates
I feel like Derrick Henry wouldn't fit the system because you have Josh Allen. Like, Derrick Henry needs a lot of touches. I don't think it's a mistake to take, you know, a running back. That's a Very good point, Jenna, at player number 27. Because that's, you know, near the top of the second round, all that stuff. And you've been actively trying to get a playmaker now at that position for multiple drafts, but I know some people are very anti taking a running back in the first round as well.
Jenna Cottrell
Jenna, that's a phenomenal point because I'm sitting there going, please, what do you mean? It's Derek Henry. It's a phenomenal point for you to say. You're right. Derrick Henry is great. Late in games when defenses are worn down and tired, and he's on his 26, 27, 28th touch. Phenomenal point. I no longer want Derrick Henry.
Mike Catalana
Yeah.
Jenna Cottrell
Cottrell has convinced me that I don't want Derrick Henry.
Mike Catalana
Okay, well, he's a different kind of player. Jen is right. I mean, he. He gets better as the game goes on. His 18th carry is better than his eighth, but he needs that, and that's the way he's been. And I don't think you're taking that much out of Josh Allen's game. He needs help in the running game. And look, could they make it work? Sure. He's Derrick Henry. He's still a great player, but I think he'll find another home.
Jenna Cottrell
Mike, to your point, too, I feel like the Bills have already made one of those signings where you go, huh? All right. Last week, I think it was. They resigned, like, Butker, which I loved it. No, I really think. But again, it's nothing that anybody's going to be tweeting about being like, oh, hell yeah, we got Ike back.
Mike Catalana
But Jersey.
Jenna Cottrell
Yeah. Like, he's still. I think he's gonna have a chance to. To start. And he was playing really well at the end of 2021. He tore his Achilles in around Christmas in Foxborough.
Mike Catalana
Yep.
Jenna Cottrell
And I just remember, like, a picture of, like, you know, how much Josh and those. Him and Josh got along so well. And. And other things, too. When players make comments or tweets and things like that, like, they don't always have to. So when I see guys like Mitch Morrison, Spencer Brown going out of their way, they can be, like, great to have Ike back. But it's another thing when they're, like, so jacked up. One of the best guys in the room, like, yeah, they don't. That doesn't seem fake to me. That seems genuine of we really like the guy. So I think he's had a chance to start a guard. I. Mike, I know what you're gonna say. Don't Give me that Jared Stidham. Don't give me the Jared.
Mike Catalana
No, no, no. That's not what I was gonna say, because Jared Stidham, they actually said he could play, and he had a chance to help the Bills at the end of the year. And, you know, you saw what happened. But here's no great guy. He is a great guy. There's a lot of great guys on the team. Tommy Sweeney is one of the most like guys on the team.
Jenna Cottrell
Great guy.
Mike Catalana
Great guy. But you got to be able to play. I think Ike Buck.
Dan Fates
I think that's different, though.
Jenna Cottrell
I think Ike Bucker can play. Absolutely.
Dan Fates
Yeah, I agree.
Mike Catalana
Plus, you know, on the defensive side, when they're bringing guys in, they're going to have a nastiness. To them, Sean McDermott means little nastiness.
Jenna Cottrell
Nasty edge.
Mike Catalana
Yeah, nasty.
Dan Fates
Dan, how would you. How was it described to you.
Mike Catalana
Though?
Dan Fates
That's not.
Jenna Cottrell
That clip is gone forever. It's. It's the.
Dan Fates
Explain that, because people are gonna be like, what?
Jenna Cottrell
One of the greatest clips that. That is.
Mike Catalana
Hold on.
Jenna Cottrell
It's there.
Mike Catalana
It's there. Mike Giardi, Buffalo plus reoccurring honorary member, reoccurring guest. And he was at the news conference for. Who was it for? Oh, it was for Ron Rivera. And Ron Rivera said, he's a Sean Bow. Sean is a play caller. He's aggressive. Dan heard aggressive. It's one of those words you can make into other words. He heard psycho.
Jenna Cottrell
So. So we're doing behind the scenes, we're filming these standups to send back to the newscast. And Mike goes, oh, I'm going to set you up for Ron Rivera's bite. I never heard the bite. I haven't heard anything about it. I just heard that he's aggressive. So Mike sends me up with the toss. He goes, and Dan, what did Ron Rivera have to say about Sean McDermott's defensive style? And I just went, he's a psycho. Mike just looks at me and goes, no, he didn't. That is not what he said. And we just stopped laugh. We just took. I was like, well, I didn't hear the sound bite, by the way. I didn't hear what it was said.
Mike Catalana
Wouldn't have been awesome if that's what Ron Rivera actually said. So we would have had psychos as the offensive and defensive play callers.
Jenna Cottrell
And I. We can't find the clip. I have no idea where that clip.
Mike Catalana
Is, but I'm gonna find it. I think I have it somewhere.
Dan Fates
I feel like you weren't even recording. I Feel like you guys go out of it.
Mike Catalana
Oh, yeah.
Dan Fates
I don't know. Do you think what they do with Devin Singletary could be indicative of their draft. Future draft plans?
Mike Catalana
Devin Singletary's gone.
Dan Fates
But here's my thing. Like, if the price is right, I mean, there's gone. Okay.
Jenna Cottrell
Edmonds. He's gone. He's just like.
Mike Catalana
He's not a foundational guy again.
Dan Fates
You're so annoying.
Mike Catalana
He's gone. I think he's gone. I think he'll. He'll find another home in the league because he's a good football player, but he's gone.
Dan Fates
I. I don't know. I feel like if you can get good value for him. What's. I don't. You talk. I don't know.
Jenna Cottrell
This is just where I love Jenna. Where she likes the players that have just been around and she feels sad for them that they have to go somewhere else.
Dan Fates
No, I just. I feel like, look, if Devin Singletary is gonna get paid $5,000 or 5 million. 5,000. Yeah. $5 million a year. No, but if you can get them.
Mike Catalana
Back, if Devin Singletary leaves, can I get a coffee from you, too?
Dan Fates
No, I'm not willing to take that bet.
Jenna Cottrell
Jenna. That was. It's funny now looking back at it, but it was last year when you were like, well, they gotta resign Jerry. Like, I really thought.
Dan Fates
Honestly, I wanted them after. I wanted them to. Him to come back after the season.
Jenna Cottrell
Yeah. Like I said. But we're sitting there.
Dan Fates
They needed him, though.
Jenna Cottrell
Correct.
Dan Fates
Did they not need Jerry Hughes last season?
Jenna Cottrell
Correct. But at the time, we're like, he had, like, three sacks. He was old, he was injured, all these things. And Jenna's like. But he's always been here like, he's Jerry Hughes.
Mike Catalana
Okay.
Jenna Cottrell
All of a sudden he goes. It has, what, 10 sacks with Houston?
Dan Fates
Yeah.
Mike Catalana
All right, I'm going to go. I just want. No need to discuss. I'm going to go down their list of free agents.
Dan Fates
Okay. Should we just do a thumbs down? Up. Thumbs down.
Mike Catalana
Just. Well, we can say it, too, because this is also going to be played in the audio podcast. I'm going to start at the top. Here we go. Not at the top. This is based on positions here. So Dane Jackson back. Jenna.
Jenna Cottrell
Oh, Jenna's mic. Jenna, your mic is cut out. You're muted.
Dan Fates
There we go. Yes. I think you always need depth at corner.
Mike Catalana
Okay. Cam Lewis.
Jenna Cottrell
Back. Yes. Yes.
Dan Fates
I say no.
Mike Catalana
Yeah. Jordan Phillips.
Jenna Cottrell
Yes. No, I take it back. No, no.
Dan Fates
I say maybe. Yes.
Mike Catalana
All right.
Dan Fates
He didn't have a Good statistical year last year. But he's played for the Bills before.
Mike Catalana
Maybe. I say yes on Dane, no on Cam, no on Jordan Phillips. Shaq Lawson.
Dan Fates
I think he'll probably get too much money.
Mike Catalana
I'm with you. I think he's going to get paid again.
Dan Fates
Yeah, I do too.
Jenna Cottrell
Yes.
Mike Catalana
Dan's got him back. Jordan Poyer. I think we're all in agreement. No, he's getting paid. Roger Seinfeld.
Jenna Cottrell
No, I hope not. No, I. I just hope not.
Mike Catalana
I don't know about. Greg Van Rotten wrote and he's. He had signed a one year deal. I, I say no.
Dan Fates
Sure.
Mike Catalana
Bobby Hart.
Dan Fates
I think they bring him back.
Jenna Cottrell
Yeah, they bring back Bobby Hart.
Mike Catalana
I say no because I think they're going to have a two tight end set way more often instead of the extra offensive lineman.
Jenna Cottrell
Gross.
Mike Catalana
I think they'll be great with the two tight end set.
Dan Fates
Why do you hate that so much, Dan?
Mike Catalana
No, here's what I'm saying to you, Dan. It's going to replace the extra offensive lineman which has been a mess. I think they're going to get a beast as a blocker and I think they need that at times. This is what.
Jenna Cottrell
Beast of a blocker. That's a. If they want a tight end that's a beast of a blocker. Just have an offensive lineman who's a blocker.
Mike Catalana
Now. It changes defenses. When you have. When you have another tight end on the field. Tyler Matakevich, they'll sign him because. Because they love teams love.
Dan Fates
Yeah, yeah, they do. They do. Isaiah.
Jenna Cottrell
I'm skipping Tremaine.
Dan Fates
Tyrell Dodson, I could see him being.
Mike Catalana
Yeah, well he actually could in a pinch play linebacker and especially if Tremaine is gone.
Jenna Cottrell
Yep.
Mike Catalana
A.J. klein. No, but they'll sign him back mid season.
Jenna Cottrell
Agreed.
Dan Fates
As history tells.
Mike Catalana
Sam Martin.
Jenna Cottrell
Sure, sure.
Dan Fates
I was gonna say. I don't, I don't, I don't.
Mike Catalana
I'm not like immediately known they're not drafting this year. Case Kingdom's an interesting one. He will have limited to very limited market.
Dan Fates
Yeah.
Mike Catalana
Around the league there's still a few spots and maybe Kansas City because they just got rid of what's. They just retired. So they'll want another guy that's been around. I think he's in that same kind of club. I think it's got to be at a similar kind of money.
Dan Fates
Yeah.
Jenna Cottrell
You know, I say no.
Dan Fates
Who? Who? The Bills.
Mike Catalana
Well, I tell you what. Yeah, it could be now. I think Sam Darnold's still being priced a little too high. Even with what's happened, I could see Keenum being back. Yeah. Taiwan Jones. Yeah, they love him. David Questenberry?
Dan Fates
I don't think so.
Mike Catalana
Nope. Nope.
Dan Fates
Dan.
Mike Catalana
Josh Allen's elbow right there. Jenna.
Dan Fates
What?
Mike Catalana
Jaquan Johnson? No, No, I don't think so. Dean Marlowe again. He'll come back in November.
Jenna Cottrell
They'll trade for him again.
Dan Fates
Yeah.
Mike Catalana
Justin Murray. Maybe. I don't know. I don't.
Jenna Cottrell
I don't know.
Mike Catalana
He was a guy they signed late. Tommy Sweeney. Nope.
Dan Fates
Oh, I think the road is run out. You do?
Jenna Cottrell
Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah.
Mike Catalana
Nope. Tommy Sweeney's not bad.
Jenna Cottrell
Practice squad. Oh, he's.
Mike Catalana
He's absolutely Jameson Crowder.
Dan Fates
See, that's interesting because I feel like we really didn't see.
Mike Catalana
He's gonna be a camp.
Dan Fates
I think he will too. And he should know the offense considering time on.
Jenna Cottrell
Yeah, I'd like him back. I liked what he showed.
Mike Catalana
And last one, future New York Jet Jake Kumaro.
Dan Fates
Oh, I could definitely see that.
Jenna Cottrell
Yeah.
Dan Fates
Yeah.
Mike Catalana
He's going with the Jets.
Dan Fates
The jets or the Giants?
Mike Catalana
Oh, no, the Jets.
Dan Fates
Oh, because of. Yes, because of. Touchdown. Jesus.
Mike Catalana
Yes. Yes.
Dan Fates
We should talk about the division vision is going to be. It used to be boring. Ish.
Mike Catalana
It is interesting. The Dolphins, basically, at least according the reports are saying they're all in onto it, which I kind of get. Like, you've got him there. You're going to see what he. You know, if he's coming back, they're going to do that. No flirting with Brady and all that kind of stuff. I've heard some wild rumors. Mac Jones traded to the Raiders.
Dan Fates
Yeah.
Mike Catalana
How about this? I'm going to throw one out there. How about if the Patriots go after Lamar and try to deal with Baltimore, which would be hilarious as those organizations hate each other. None of this will ever happen.
Dan Fates
That doesn't seem likely.
Mike Catalana
I would love to see teams be a little more aggressive.
Dan Fates
Where do we think Lamar ends up?
Mike Catalana
I said this. I would be more worried in the division over the next five years if. Well, three years if. If the jets got Lamar as opposed to getting Aaron Rodgers.
Dan Fates
Same.
Mike Catalana
I think Lamar with that jets team could be really good. Yeah, but I don't know. I don't think they'll make a play.
Dan Fates
You know, do we think a Rod actually go. Aaron Rodgers actually goes to the jets.
Mike Catalana
Right here as I feel like he loves flirting. Wednesday at what, 2:30 in the afternoon? I say yes. I think he's going there.
Jenna Cottrell
I agree.
Mike Catalana
Yeah, they need. I don't see a lot of other.
Jenna Cottrell
They need to Fix that line.
Dan Fates
Yeah, that's fair.
Mike Catalana
Yeah.
Jenna Cottrell
Because he is. He's.
Dan Fates
Scared. That's scary.
Mike Catalana
Yeah, certainly. Hey, but keep this in mind. We were talking about it yesterday off the air. You know, everybody says W. You know, the jets would be a lot better. That also makes them better when they play the Dolphins. It also makes them better when they play the Patriots. It sort of makes the division. You know, that jets game is tougher for everybody, not just for the Bills. So the jets were tough last year. Heck, the whole division was spelled still much better.
Dan Fates
Bills split with the Jets.
Mike Catalana
Yeah, and the jets hung in there with him in the second game and the Dolphins hung in there with them all three times. So, yeah, they still won the division, but it's already tight.
Jenna Cottrell
So I think that I would also be okay. And I know we've talked about this before, like, I'm okay with trading the first. The first round pick and getting impact player right away. I'm also totally for the right player.
Mike Catalana
Yeah. Yeah.
Jenna Cottrell
I mean, I know we look at it like I was going through the draft picks of. You know, Brandon Bean has drafted more corners than any other position since he took over in 2018. He hasn't drafted a wide receiver in the first three rounds. There needs to be in.
Mike Catalana
In fairness, I'll give him traded a one.
Jenna Cottrell
Right. That's. And that's what I was kind of getting at. Like, that's.
Mike Catalana
But don't you want a wide receiver on a rookie contract? Doesn't that work?
Dan Fates
That's pretty nice too.
Mike Catalana
I don't know. I mean, they're gonna. You know what? They're gonna take that. Was it easy. Georgia tight end, big blocking.
Dan Fates
Tight. Yeah.
Mike Catalana
In the first round.
Dan Fates
How would you feel if they took a tight end?
Jenna Cottrell
No, Bowers can't come out till next year. Right.
Dan Fates
Georgia guy. I know who you're talking about.
Mike Catalana
Yeah. Made a big.
Dan Fates
So many names.
Mike Catalana
Yeah, well, we'll get to all those names. Last thing I want to ask. I want to ask you guys, I. We've said this in the last three podcasts. Is the dig stuff anything to worry about?
Dan Fates
I don't think so. Is it just digs? I'm gonna say I feel like it drums up a lot of attention for his brand. Like, yeah, I think he knows how to play social media. Dan, what did you post yesterday?
Jenna Cottrell
Yeah, it was him after he had posted something along the week that Josh had the elbow injury and he posted like good news or like an exciting emoji and we all took that as, oh, Josh is playing this week. And when we asked him at his press conference, he said, stay off my social media. I. You're reading into too much. And then he laughed about it. And it's a very funny clip.
Mike Catalana
Go to Dan Fates on Twitter.
Jenna Cottrell
Like, well, it's funny because, Mike, you talked about it, like, oh, he doesn't follow the Bills on Instagram. Still follows Josh Allen. Still follows, like, every other player.
Mike Catalana
No, what I said about him following is. It's Instagram. It's like, whatever reason. I don't even know. It's just. It's just. It's just been a lot of him. Just been a lot. I thought just enough bubbling, you know, he's not going to the Cowboys, first of all. They got enough problems. And you want to play with Dak Prescott. God bless you. You know, that ball's gonna be sailing over your head most of the time.
Jenna Cottrell
But also, his brother Travion doesn't follow the Cowboys, so Steph does. Travion doesn't.
Mike Catalana
So maybe Travion's coming to the bells.
Jenna Cottrell
Like, for anybody that reads too much into this, it is like, we could all put on our tinfoil hats and be like, did you see that tweet? And who is he following? It's like this league. So I love. I. I find it amusing. I also found it. It was like the J.J. watt saga when you guys were like, I'm so sick and tired of talking about it. And I was like, this is who he is.
Mike Catalana
Yeah, he.
Jenna Cottrell
They like the attention. He's a wide receiver. He's really good. He.
Mike Catalana
It's just. It's different than his normal attention. It seems like it's a little too much off the reservation here a little bit. But I just. He's not going anywhere. I just wish.
Jenna Cottrell
He's not going anywhere.
Mike Catalana
Enough of it. He's not.
Dan Fates
He's not. He's not going anywhere.
Mike Catalana
God. Again, Dan has said it. We still have said it. Salary cap's not real when you're signing somebody. But once you've signed them and now you. You make a mist. You say, oh, we didn't really like what we just did last year. We're going to trade the guy now and take a $40 million dead cap hit. No. Then it's real.
Jenna Cottrell
Then you're just real. Salary cap is fake and not real and can be manipulated.
Mike Catalana
Well, yeah, dead cap is part of the salary cap, but I know what you're saying.
Jenna Cottrell
No, it's different.
Dan Fates
You are just incredulous.
Jenna Cottrell
Yeah.
Dan Fates
Is that. Is that the right word?
Jenna Cottrell
Go get Bobby Wagner. Go be super bowl favorites again.
Dan Fates
No, now I'm on team. Signed Tremaine Foreign.
Jenna Cottrell
I'll take Venti. Salted caramel cold foam.
Mike Catalana
Oh, my God.
Dan Fates
You can't order.
Jenna Cottrell
Yeah, I'm gonna go Venti. If I. If I'm gonna get a free coffee from. From Cat Brew.
Dan Fates
Dan, are you okay? Is everything okay at home?
Mike Catalana
By the way, speaking of your Starbucks orders, which are both ridiculous, we ordered the same thing. I saw this comedian, and he said, I go up and I order a black coffee, and they say, what name should I put on it? And he says, I tell them, you don't need to put on a name. You turn around with the cup, you pour coffee in it, I'm still going to be standing right here. That's me.
Dan Fates
I don't think.
Jenna Cottrell
Starbucks, black coffee and a stone for Catalana.
Dan Fates
Okay. I have to say that I tried Mike's wife's scone, the blueberry scone. Incredible.
Mike Catalana
Elite.
Jenna Cottrell
Elite.
Dan Fates
Now, there could be a scone at Starbucks or out. That's probably not going to be as good.
Mike Catalana
Maybe not as good, but, yeah, that.
Dan Fates
Was an elite scone.
Jenna Cottrell
Mike is team Scone.
Mike Catalana
Scone.
Dan Fates
I like muffins, though.
Mike Catalana
Yeah, I used to be. But they're second now. Scone number one.
Dan Fates
A good. But I feel like. I feel like a mediocre just top.
Jenna Cottrell
Is ahead of scone.
Dan Fates
I feel like it's a bad scone is probably really, really bad. Whereas even a bad muffin is like.
Mike Catalana
Yeah, because scones, when they go. It's day three. You can't go day three. Day two is spectacular.
Dan Fates
That's when I had the scone.
Mike Catalana
It was spectacular.
Dan Fates
Is she gonna make some fun?
Mike Catalana
She was gonna. Yeah. There may be some waiting for you. I told her not to make them. Now.
Jenna Cottrell
That was. That was what I got. The one time before we. We went on a trip. Jenna gets scones. I got an apple.
Dan Fates
Hey, what can I say? You're just not me, Dan. Sorry. All right. Actually, you have to go. I know. You have to leave.
Jenna Cottrell
Yep.
Dan Fates
Okay, So. I know.
Mike Catalana
I think I'm gonna do this all the time now.
Jenna Cottrell
I agree.
Dan Fates
You have. I. You rarely wear a hoodie, Mike.
Mike Catalana
I know. This is from Innovation Foods. This is my brother's and my nephew's plant. Oatley by oatley. By the way, can I put a commercial in that?
Jenna Cottrell
We got some in the fridge.
Mike Catalana
Yeah. Buy Oatley. Made it. Innovation, Millville, New Jersey. There we go.
Dan Fates
All right. Thank you for joining us. Please be sure to, like, comment. Just comment. If you think Tremaine Edmonds comes back?
Mike Catalana
Yes. Comment on scones, too.
Dan Fates
Do they make chocolate chip scones?
Mike Catalana
Oh, yeah.
Dan Fates
Oh, yeah.
Jenna Cottrell
Oh, yeah.
Dan Fates
It's over. All right. And please be sure to subscribe.
Mike Catalana
Last.
Jenna Cottrell
The last time we did a podcast, it started off with Bill stuff. And then we got into the grammar lesson when Jenna gave us the word of the day. This one ended with scone talk.
Dan Fates
Yeah. Also incredulous. Yeah is a good word for you, Dan. Unwilling to believe. Okay. All right. Yeah, we'll talk next time. Again, please be sure to subscribe. For Mike and Dan, I am Jenna. See you next time on Buffalo Plus.
Date: March 11, 2023
Hosts: Mike Catalana, Jenna Cottrell, Dan Fetes
This episode dives deep into the Buffalo Bills’ critical free agency period, focusing on the futures of key defensive stars Tremaine Edmonds and Jordan Poyer, replacement strategies, and the team’s broader roster approach. The team provides behind-the-scenes insights, predictions for free agent moves, and discusses the rumors swirling around Stefon Diggs' social media activity. The tone is lively, candid, and occasionally playful, with the trio debating roster philosophy, the viability of splash signings, and navigating the changing dynamics of the AFC East.
At (29:07), Mike reads through a list of current Bills free agents. Highlights include:
On the uncertainty of key Bills leaving:
“This is a different one…Tremaine Edmonds, we make the jokes about his age, but he’s going into his second contract. That’s not normally the guys you let walk.” — Mike (10:44)
Jenna challenging the “fear” of losing Edmonds:
“I think we’re romanticizing a little bit of Tremaine Edmonds…he hasn’t had that big, big game. He’s good, but is he great?” — Jenna (13:07, 17:25)
On Bean’s possible free agent approach:
“He told us last year; no splashes. Then he came up with a billion dollars for Von Miller. But I do think it's a no-splashes year in free agency.” — Mike (21:19)
On Diggs drama:
“He’s not going anywhere. Salary cap’s not real when you’re signing somebody. Once you try to trade them and take a $40 million dead cap hit? Now it’s real.” — Mike (39:47, 40:08)
Playful banter about scones versus muffins (41:32 onwards):
| Segment | Timestamp | | ------- | --------- | | Free Agency Crunch Time & No Tags | 02:43 | | Edmonds and Poyer Departures | 02:48–04:10 | | Potential MLB Replacements | 04:08–07:01 | | Milano Contract Parallel | 05:22–07:01 | | Defensive Shifts & Offensive Prioirty | 08:22–09:20 | | Edmonds' Value, Age, and Impact | 10:44–13:07 | | Bean's Free Agency Strategy | 20:44–21:19 | | RB Room & Derrick Henry Debate | 22:16–23:28 | | Bills’ Own Free Agents (Rapid Fire) | 29:07–33:17 | | AFC East QB Carousel | 34:11–36:19 | | Draft/Trade Philosophy | 36:19–37:20 | | Diggs Social Media Drama | 37:44–40:08 | | Scone vs Muffin Banter | 41:17–42:33 |
This episode provides a comprehensive, realistic look at the 2023 Buffalo Bills’ roster construction process, with thoughtful analysis of free agent risk, opportunities for improvement, and the ecological pressures of the modern AFC East. The hosts strike a balance between insider knowledge and fan-centric discussion, peppered with humor and honest takes. For listeners invested in Buffalo’s direction—or the NFL free agency period in general—this episode is invaluable for its granular detail, tempered optimism, and clear-eyed assessment of the business of football.