Buffalo Plus Podcast: Bills vs Ravens Playoff PRESSURE METER, Josh Allen v Lamar Jackson, Game of the Year Preview

Date: January 17, 2025
Hosts: Mike Catalana, Jenna Cottrell, Dan Fates
Main Theme:
A deep dive into the high-stakes Divisional Round playoff matchup between the Buffalo Bills and Baltimore Ravens. The episode examines the immense pressure on both franchises, the contrasting legacies of quarterbacks Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson, head coach Sean McDermott’s role, matchups to watch, keys to victory, and lighthearted debates on fan behavior.

Episode Overview

The Buffalo Plus team offers in-depth, experienced analysis ahead of this “Game of the Year” Divisional Round clash. The discussion tackles the immense playoff pressure facing both teams—especially the Bills after recent postseason disappointments—and amplifies the Allen vs. Jackson narrative. They dissect team health, tactical matchups, what’s changed since the regular season blowout, and what it all means for the franchise, while also keeping it light with jokes and behind-the-scenes anecdotes.

1. The Playoff Pressure: Big Picture

[00:00–05:13]

• Bills’ Divisional Round Hump:
  The Bills need to get past this round—past failures (esp. at home) add weight to this game.

  “The Bills need to be past this round. … They have this at home.” — Mike Catalana [01:36]

• How Quarterbacks Are Judged:
  Both Allen and Jackson have lost to Mahomes in AFC Championship games, but Allen’s playoff losses are often seen as less his fault.

  “Josh Allen … is going to be judged [by getting to the Super Bowl].” — Mike Catalana [03:46]

• Elevated Expectations:
  Despite a rocky start to the season, the Bills have exceeded expectations and are now judged by postseason success.

  “The goalpost has been moved back because you outperformed where we thought you were going to be heading into the season.” — Jenna Cottrell [05:05]

2. Allen v Jackson: Legacies and Pressure

[02:28–08:46]

• Who Faces More Pressure?

  • Mike and Dan agree Lamar has more to prove due to postseason disappointments and a loaded roster.
  • Josh has largely met the postseason moment, while Lamar's playoff performances have lagged.

  “Josh has been so dynamic, and he has been the best player on the field in postseason losses. ...Lamar hasn't.” — Dan Fates [00:19, 07:54]

• MVP as a ‘Weighted Vest’:
  If Lamar fails, MVP accolades can feel like a burden.

  “The MVP will be a weighted vest on Lamar if you cannot perform in the playoffs.” — Jenna Cottrell [08:10]

• Playoff Performance Context:
  They revisit both QBs’ historical playoff struggles and moments where the outcome hinged on coaching or supporting cast as much as on QB play.

3. Sean McDermott Under the Microscope

[10:29–13:38]

• Heaviest Pressure Lies on McDermott:

  • Defensive-minded coach facing an MVP QB and Derrick Henry after getting punished by the Ravens earlier in the year.
  • Praises McDermott for adapting more than in years past, especially using three linebackers, getting healthier players back.

  “Far and away the most pressure on anybody in this game is Sean McDermott.” — Mike Catalana [07:02]

• Matchup Adjustments:
  Bills are healthier than in Week 4 blowout (Taron Johnson, Matt Milano, Terrell Bernard back).

• Aggressive Mindset Needed:

  “If I'm Sean McDermott … I am aggressive the entire game and that doesn't mean reckless. … I'm going to live and die with 17 [Josh Allen] as best I can.” — Mike Catalana [12:37]

4. Bills Team Vibe & Locker Room Intel

[13:32–18:45]

• Quiet Confidence:
  Players and coaches appear calm, process-oriented, and unified, apparently embracing underdog motivation.

  “There is a lot of confidence that comes with that situation. … Quiet confidence is… the two words to come to mind for this group.” — Jenna Cottrell [17:01]

• This Year vs Previous Playoff Exits:
  Locker room wasn’t mentally prepared vs. Bengals last year, but loss to Chiefs hurt more due to missed opportunity at home.

• Motivation and Doubt:
  Underdog status, lack of All-Pro respect, and being written off earlier in season are fueling the team.

5. Ravens vs. Bills: What’s Different Since Week 4?

[22:24–28:24]

• Teams Are Changed:

  • Bills have seven new starters since blowout loss.
  • Ravens defense moved Kyle Hamilton, have improved but schedule context matters.

• Ravens Defensive Statistics Contextualized:
  Ravens defense stats are slightly inflated due to weak opposing offenses late in the year.

  “There needs to be some context into how good the Ravens defense has been and how pathetic the opposing offenses have been.” — Dan Fates [26:40]

  • Their best opponent after Week 11 was the Chargers (13th in offensive DVOA).

• Buffalo’s Edge:
  Home field, improved health, and a more cohesive offense.

  “This is a different challenge to come to Orchard Park.” — Mike Catalana [28:02]

6. Matchups, Game Plan and Conditions

[28:24–34:59]

• Derrick Henry & RPO Challenge:

  • Bills' front seven (especially linebackers) needs to be excellent to contain Henry and the Lamar-Henry run game.
  • Henry’s style and Lamar’s unique running threat demand discipline.

• Weather’s Role:

  • Forecast: ~16°F at kickoff, which may favor the Bills' experience in cold.

  “It is a little different for guys. It's a mindset… when you've done it multiple times.” — Mike Catalana [29:36]

• Offensive X-Factors (Bills):

  • Khalil Shakir, Amari Cooper, Curtis Samuel, Dalton Kincaid need to make big plays.

  “It's not about the stats at this point. It's about making plays.” — Jenna Cottrell [38:11]

  • Amari Cooper’s chemistry with Allen called into question, but playoffs are the moment to deliver.

• Defensive X-Factors (Bills):

  • Linebackers are central; safety play less critical this week.
  • Front seven must prevent Henry/Jackson from reaching the open field.

7. Strategies, Keys to Victory, and Score Predictions

[34:59–46:54]

• Aggression over Caution:

  • Both offense and defense must generate explosive plays; playing it safe won’t win this game.

  “Be aggressive, not reckless, Mike. But… we gotta take shots, our wide receivers have to win.” — Dan Fates [36:17]

  • Expect a “track meet”; likely winner reaches 30+ points.

• Time of Possession Still Matters:

  • Listener question noted: Ravens have won time of possession in all recent Allen-Jackson matchups. Hosts still say: “Don’t play scared, play to win.”

• Injury Concerns:

  • Cold increases risk; Bills already banged up last postseason.

• Final Predictions:

  • Jenna: Bills 31, Ravens 24

    “It comes down to simply who do I trust more in this moment. I trust Josh Allen.” [45:28]

  • Dan: Bills 31, Ravens 27
  • Mike: Bills 30, Ravens 27

    "When she said, 'I trust Josh Allen in this spot'… I just think that's where it's different on the road in this case." [46:54]

8. Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Legacy Pressure:

  "To be a three time MVP… and not get it done in the playoffs… it's a weighted vest." — Jenna Cottrell [08:10]

• On Bills Locker Room Mood:

  “They just feel more cohesive than they have in years past… quiet confidence.” — Jenna Cottrell [17:01]

• On Baltimore’s Defense:

  "Their defensive numbers are a little inflated... six out of eight games were against some of the worst offenses in the league." — Dan Fates [26:40]

• On Game Flow:

  “Whoever forces one or two more punts is going to be the winner of this game." — Dan Fates [36:24]

• On Weather:

  "When it gets down as single digits, you guys know, on the field, it is brutal down there." — Mike Catalana [29:25]

• On Josh Allen's Playoff Impact:

  "The most impressive performance for a losing quarterback I have ever seen in the playoffs was in Kansas City." — Mike Catalana [10:14]

9. Light-Hearted Banter & Behind-the-Scenes

• Bills/Ravens Fan Behavior:
  Raven fans jumping into opposing team chats is called “cringy but their prerogative.”
• Vacuum Rants:
  Jenna raves about her new cordless vacuum and obsessively cleaning the house—audience joins in on the laughter. [50:04]
• "Credit to Me" Section:
  • Each host brags about personal/parental victories or correct season predictions for a dose of humility and humor.
• Listener Interaction:
  • Several super chats and clever user comments (e.g., "credit to me, I have the cleanest house", "Bills by a ba-dillion", etc.).

Key Timestamps

• Pressure on QBs & Teams: [00:00–05:13]
• Allen v Jackson Legacies: [02:28–08:46]
• Pressure on McDermott: [10:29–13:38]
• Bills Locker Room Insights: [13:32–18:45]
• How Teams Have Changed Since Week 4: [22:24–28:24]
• Matchups & Weather: [28:24–34:59]
• Offensive/Defensive Keys: [34:59–39:00]
• Game Predictions: [45:26–46:54]
• Listener Q&A, Banter, and Picks: [49:41–58:08]

Summary Takeaway

This episode delivers sharp, nuanced football analysis blended seamlessly with locker room insights and familiar banter. The Bills are portrayed as quietly confident, evolved, and determined not to be defined by previous heartbreak—though the panel is under no illusions about the threat posed by the dynamic Ravens duo of Lamar Jackson and Derrick Henry. Above all, this divisional round is framed as a crossroad for stars and coaches alike, with the chance to rewrite legacy narratives hinging on one electric playoff night in Orchard Park.

Subscribe to Buffalo Plus on YouTube / visit buffaloplus.com for more coverage and post-game analysis.