Buffalo Plus Podcast — Episode Summary

Episode Title:

The BILLS make CUTS: INITIAL REACTION to the 53-man roster

Date:

August 27, 2025

Hosts:

Mike Catalana (B), Jenna Cottrell (C), Dan Fetes (A)

Overview

This episode of the Buffalo Plus Podcast provides an immediate reaction and deep dive into the Buffalo Bills’ 2025 initial 53-man roster following cutdown day. The team — Mike, Jenna, and Dan — offer insight on roster surprises, injury updates, position group strengths and weaknesses, and speculate on possible future transactions. The episode is delivered with a mix of inside information, humor, and candid fan analysis.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Roster Cutdown Process and Initial Takeaways

• The Bills delayed their official 53-man announcement (“taking your grand old time,” as Mike says), though many moves were anticipated by insiders ([02:04]).
• Main areas of discussion: secondary depth, decisions at cornerback, and the special teams/receiver group.

Mike:

“I go right to the cornerbacks… Max [Hairston] is not practicing, he's not ready. It makes total sense. He goes on the four week IR… It's an indication, I think, that Trey White should be okay.” [02:09]

• Dane Jackson was released, likely to return on the practice squad.
• Mike calls for readiness from young backups: "Hey, Dorian. Strong, be ready. Jamarcus Ingram, be ready if Trey's not." [02:58]

2. Injuries and the Defensive Back Situation

• Hairston to IR: Consensus that there's no need to rush recovering rookies or leave the secondary shorthanded. Jenna and Dan appreciate the cautious approach.
• Trey White: Encouragement drawn from his absence on the initial IR — anticipated to be ready for week one or soon after.

3. Wide Receiver Group — Surprise Moves

• Six Receivers Kept: Surprising, since previous years saw the Bills keep only five.
• Tyrell Shavers Makes the Roster: Universal agreement this was a high point.

Dan:

“Tyrell Shavers earned a spot. More than anything, he didn't make it because of injuries…his play earned it.” [05:10]

Jenna:

“Hard work and patience has paid off for Tyrell Shaver… the phrase ‘earned it’ really does come to mind.” [06:20]

• Elijah Moore or Curtis Samuel: Discussion about both players lingering as depth/insurance, partly for health reasons ([08:52]).
• Dan outright admits: “I’ve been on the anti-Elijah Moore train… I just never have bought into the hype since they signed him.” [09:22]

4. Fluidity of the Roster and Looming Moves

• All emphasize the “fluidity” of the 53-man roster, with Mike in his “professor” mode stressing, “Things could change even now.” [10:47]
• Players like Hoyt and Ogunjobi are due to return from suspension, which will require further roster moves.
• Shaq Thompson's inclusion discussed as a sign they’re not sold on Joann Driessen as primary backup at linebacker.

5. Veteran Presence vs. Youth

• Shaq Thompson is seen as a cerebral veteran and insurance at middle linebacker, but questions remain about his physical readiness. “You see the cognition piece... what is left in the tank…?” [12:13] — Jenna
• Comparison made to the former “AJ Klein role” — plug-and-play insurance policy.

6. Defensive Line Depth Concerns

• Mike highlights real concern about edge rusher depth behind starters Bosa and Rousseau ([14:02]).

“Bosa and Russo better be really good because I just don’t see a lot coming off the bench.” [14:59]

• Uncertainty about Dwayne Carter's future following recent defensive tackle signings—Dan wonders if a tackle-for-end swap is coming.

7. Return Specialist Position

• Codrington making the roster as a return specialist: hosts note he’s not a true cornerback but believe his big-play potential justifies his spot for now.
• Chanell released, Ty Johnson or Ray Davis could also be in the mix for return work.

8. General Youth and Inexperience

• Broad observation that this roster has a lot of “kids” and untested players, especially in secondary and defensive front.
• “You are very inexperienced beyond the starters in those positions.” [18:39] — Mike

9. Final Thoughts: Defensive Worries and Upcoming Moves

• Cautious optimism about some new faces, but anxiety about trusting so many young defenders.
• Mike: “I’m not saying these guys can’t be good. I’m saying is, like, they're gonna have to trust them if they go out there on the field.” [19:16]

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Mike: “I said to you guys that things could change even now.” [00:12, and again at 10:47]
• Dan (on roster surprises): “The best news, I think, of the entire training camp off season. Tyrell Shavers making the roster.” [05:28]
• Jenna (on Shavers): “It was like hard work and patience has paid off for Tyrell Shaver.” [06:10]
• Mike (on thin edge depth): “Bosa and Russo better be really good because I just don’t see a lot coming off the bench.” [14:59]
• Jenna (on Shaq Thompson): “You see the cognition piece… what is left in the tank in terms of him physically.” [12:13]
• Dan (on upcoming possible trades): “I wonder if a team has a surplus of defensive ends and they're a little short on defensive tackles… if there could be a move… over these next four to five days…” [16:12]
• Dan (humor): “Just put my daughter to bed. And I was like, 1, 2. Are we going upstairs now?” [04:25]
• Re: Podcast Energy
  Jenna: “All right, we should wrap up because we got Hard Knocks soon.” [19:46]
  Mike: “We carry in this podcast.” [20:20]

Timestamps for Important Segments

• [02:04] — Official roster reaction begins; focus on secondary and Trey White
• [05:10] — Tyrell Shavers’ story and receiver breakdown
• [08:52] — Curtis Samuel, Elijah Moore discussion: health, redundancy, and roster logic
• [10:47] — “Fluidity of the roster” lecture and future roster moves preview
• [12:02] — Shaq Thompson as insurance at linebacker; comparison to AJ Klein
• [14:02] — Defensive line depth discussion and concerns
• [16:12] — Speculation on upcoming roster trades
• [17:29] — Return specialist/backup corner dynamics (Codrington, Chanel)
• [18:39] — Overall roster youth and inexperience
• [19:46] — Concluding worries about defensive depth/Hard Knocks shoutout

Conclusion and Tone

An engaging, insider-rich, and often lighthearted breakdown of the Bills’ first 53-man roster, with clarity on which decisions signal confidence (or unease) at certain positions, a celebration for unexpected earners like Tyrell Shavers, and acknowledgment of looming moves due to injuries, suspensions, and youth. The group brings experience, honest skepticism, and trademark banter, making the episode accessible both for hardcore Bills observers and casual fans.

For More

Subscribe to Buffalo Plus on YouTube and join their upcoming live show (September 4th at the Thirsty Turtle, Victor, NY, 5–7 PM).