Buffalo Plus Podcast Summary

Episode: The BILLS new VISION under JIM LEONHARD and JOE BRADY
Date: February 6, 2026
Hosts: Mike Catalana, Jenna Cottrell, Dan Fetes

Episode Overview

This episode focuses on major changes within the Buffalo Bills’ coaching staff—primarily the first impressions of new defensive coordinator Jim Leonhard and the dynamics under head coach/offensive coordinator Joe Brady. The team also discusses additional staff changes, expectations for player roles, and thoughts on general manager Brandon Beane’s recent comments. The discussion blends in-depth football analysis with behind-the-scenes perspective, keeping a conversational, occasionally humorous, and knowledgeable tone throughout.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. First Impressions of Jim Leonhard (New Defensive Coordinator)

• Leadership Qualities: The hosts were unanimous—Leonhard has a head coach aura: “Jim Leonard is going to be a head coach someday. He's got that to him” (Mike, 02:16).
• Calm, Confident Approach: He’s seen as measured and disciplined, with an emphasis on respecting players’ experience.
  • “He seemed very mature, very buttoned up, very disciplined. It was about respecting the players. He has been one. He knows what is appreciated in that room.” (Jenna, 04:20)
• Aggressive but Flexible Philosophy: Leonhard emphasized an attacking, adaptable defensive style, stating, “We want to be the type of defense that the NFL doesn't want to face…forcing offenses to react to them and not counter punch us.” (Dan, 03:22)
• Building on Success, Not Overhauling: He respects the existing framework—“It wasn’t all broken…there’s elements we’ll build off of. This will continue to evolve. It might look a lot different in year two than year one, and that’s OK.” (Dan, 05:27)
• Realism about Roster Challenges: Acknowledgment that improving the defense depends on both scheme and getting better players. “It’s great to say you’re going to be aggressive, but you need guys who can get after the quarterback.” (Mike, 06:10)
• NFL Trends and Adaptability: Lauded for his modern approach, like embracing ‘positionless’ defenders and referencing the adaptability of the NBA.
  • “He talks about how, like, the NBA has changed…and your players are now kind of have to be positionless to be successful.” (Dan, 10:16)

2. Scheme Philosophy and Play Calling

• Flexible System vs. Fixed System: The idea that schemes must fit player strengths, not the other way. This may be a shift from the more rigid approach McDermott once favored.
• Postseason Adaptation: Leonhard notes aggression remains, but acknowledges the stakes and quality of opposition rise in the playoffs: “Your system and your mentality has to be adaptable.” (Dan, 08:59)
• Early-Stage Challenges: Leonhard has yet to call an NFL play but brings collegiate experience from Wisconsin. The personnel learning process is ongoing (see Max Hairston references, 07:14 and 18:15).

3. Notable Personnel & Role Evaluations

• Key Defensive Players: Discussion on Cam Lewis stood out; Leonhard surprisingly prioritized finding him a role:
  • “Finding out a perfect role for a player like that is, quote, very high on our priority list. That was surprising.” (Dan, 15:55)
• Other Defensive Notes: Cole Bishop praised as “a jack of all trades” and excitement to “see where he can help him get to the next level.” (15:21). Benford’s “travel” history also acknowledged.
• Coaches’ Familiarity with Players: Leonhard’s Wisconsin ties could influence free-agent and depth-player signings.
  • “There’s guys around that he’s interested in...sometimes it’s not even the bigger name guy. Guys who can come in and help teach this system.” (Mike, 19:30)

4. Joe Brady: Head Coach and Offensive Vision

• Leadership Scope: Brady, despite his offensive background, stated, “I don’t have a side of the ball”—prompting debate.
  • Dan: “You can’t distance yourself from this offense when you’re going to be... Just let it go.” (Dan, 27:12)
  • Mike: “He’s making a point that I’m coach of the whole team.” (Mike, 27:57)
• Autonomy for Assistants: Brady says he trusts Leonhard to run the defense, but the team expects/understands he’ll be generally involved on both sides.

Notable Exchange on Coaching Roles (23:58–27:57)

Dan: “You can't separate and say it's not your side of the ball when...we know that. Yes. But he's just still calling plays.” (24:02)

Mike: “He’s making a point that I'm coach of the whole team.” (27:57)

5. Staff Additions and Dynamics

• Pete Carmichael (Assistant/Offensive Advisor): Highly valued for experience and readiness—“the backup quarterback” or “wingman” to Brady; universally respected and supportive, not angling to take over.
• Jeff Rodgers (Special Teams): Limited assessment due to early days, but his lengthy, stable coaching history noted as a plus.

6. General Manager Brandon Beane’s Comments

• Salary Cap & Roster Construction: The hosts express some fatigue with cap complaints, maintaining it’s a necessary challenge for teams with a true franchise QB.
  • “You can't have that and then complain about the cost of having a franchise quarterback. A lot of GMs would flat out trade places.” (Mike, 39:18)
  • “I have felt like GMs use the cap as. As a crutch, as. As an excuse and not a reason.” (Dan, 41:34)
• Drafting Impact: Strong drafting is essential for overcoming cap limitations and sustaining success.
  • Examples: Solid picks like Spencer Brown and O’Cyrus Torrence have enabled other investments.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

On Jim Leonhard’s Introduction

• “I remember him as a player…that little guy, undrafted, and he just kept getting out on the field…He had a plan.” (Mike, 02:16)
• “Aggressive attacking defense…we want to be the type of defense the NFL doesn’t want to face.” (Paraphrased, Dan, 03:22)
• “He seemed very mature, very buttoned up, very disciplined. It was about respecting the players.” (Jenna, 04:20)

On Defensive Flexibility & Modern Trends

• “NBA has changed…and your players now have to be positionless to be successful.” (Dan, 10:16)
• “McDermott…had two safeties immensely successful. They made those two interchangeable—it’s what made the Bills defense, for the longest time, very difficult.” (Mike, 11:31)

The Cam Lewis Moment

• “Finding out a perfect role for a player like that is very high on our priority list. That was surprising.” (Dan, 15:55)

On Joe Brady's Head Coaching Approach

• “He’s making a point that I'm coach of the whole team.” (Mike, 27:57)
• “You can't distance yourself from this offense when you're going to be… Just let it go.” (Dan, 27:12)

On Salary Cap & Franchise QBs

• “You can't have that and then complain about the cost of having a franchise quarterback. A lot of GMs would flat out trade places…It's the price you pay for getting that guy.” (Mike, 39:18)

Memorable Personal Anecdotes

• Mike’s story about traveling with the team during a blizzard after playoff elimination:
  • “Players playing the piano in the lobby...it wasn’t like a party, they were just like, ha.” (Mike, 21:29)
• Dan’s humor about getting nervous speaking to elementary school kids, more than at weddings. (43:00)

Lighter Banter Highlights

• Extended riff on the correct spelling of "piqued your interest." (28:11–29:02)
• Playful analogies about Carmichael as the “wingman” or barbecue grill master. (31:08–31:59)
• Shout-outs to local fans and community appearances, underlining fan engagement.

Timestamps for Key Segments

| Topic | Timestamp (approx.) | |-------|---------------------| | Opening & Leonhard’s First Impressions | 02:16–07:14 | | Defensive Philosophy & Adaptability | 07:14–14:54 | | Player Roles (Hairston, Lewis, Bishop, etc.) | 15:01–19:30 | | Joe Brady’s “No Side of the Ball” Debate | 22:18–27:57 | | Pete Carmichael & Staff Roles | 29:22–32:01 | | Special Teams (Jeff Rodgers) | 34:40–35:35 | | Brandon Beane's Comments & Salary Cap | 37:53–42:25 | | Community & Fan Interactions | 43:52–45:02 |

Takeaways

• New direction, not revolution: Both Leonhard and Brady offer fresh leadership while acknowledging the strengths already present in Buffalo.
• Intelligent adaptation: Emphasis on adapting schemes to player strengths—an evolution from past rigidity.
• Personnel matters: All visions and schemes depend on identifying, acquiring, and properly utilizing the right players.
• Coaching chemistry: Relationships and wisely chosen assistants (Carmichael, Rodgers) are seen as essential to sustaining success.
• Bills culture remains strong: The episode ends with anecdotes and shout-outs, reflecting the team’s deep ties with their community and passionate fan engagement.

For more interviews, exclusive analysis, and Bills coverage, visit Buffalo Plus on YouTube and their LinkTree.