
Loading summary
A
Saying with the Bills offense to change it up a little bit. And one of those things to me is more James Cook. I'll take my chances with the other stuff.
B
Brave of you.
A
Yes.
C
Mike wants the Bills to change it up and throw it to A.J. brown and Devonte.
A
Hey, but they didn't do that.
C
That would. That would. Yeah.
A
Yes. Yes. It's like I'm saying is you have those guys on your team.
C
That's what's driving me nuts.
A
Oh, you mean they don't have those guys?
B
Yeah, they don't have those guys.
C
None of any guys.
B
All right, welcome back to the Buffalo plus YouTube channel. We are here in the Connors and Fairies podcast studio. Mike Catalana, Dan Fates. I am Jenna Cottrell. Please be sure to, like, comment, subscribe, and of course, share. We're doing the league podcast presented by stellar roofing, windows and Siding. We're going to get into the NFL, the top five, the bottom five, and also how the Bills square up and shake up and stack up with the rest of the league. After Buffalo coming off the bye week, we're gonna get all into it as the Bills had the week off to kind of rest, reset and Mike, where do you think this team is at now heading into another week?
A
They needed the rest.
B
Yes, we needed the rest.
A
And you needed the rest. You, you, you. You needed the rest of the. It was a bad two weeks, right? It was a bad two weeks. And I'm not positive, I'm not negative. I'm realistic. I think I know what this team is. I think they can get incrementally better on one side of the ball and substantially better on the other.
B
Okay.
C
Oh, I'm fascinated to hear this.
A
I think Joe Brady needs to go back to being Joe Brady. Okay. No more cute. That would help play into the strengths and get Josh Allen back going. Like Josh Allen. The last two weeks, he hasn't really looked like Josh Allen moments, but not looking like Josh Allen. The defense, I'm hoping they go from bad to decent. That's my hope. Bad to decent also. I'm also hoping it's more Sean McDermott win this defense. And I know there's a lot of people out there that just want to crush Sean. Like, he's never coached good defense before in his life. But I think more on this defense may help them, especially in. In game adjustments.
C
Yeah, I. We were just talking about this before we came on and I was like you said, the pulse of the fan base is that, like, they've never seen this team struggle and you were saying panic like they're in full panic mode. Right. I wasn't here for the Hot Ones. Hand up. Was not feeling well. It. I wouldn't say it was the worst time. I like doing those. Those are some of the funnest videos. If you haven't already. Be sure to check out the Hot Ones. One, we're still recovering. Yeah, we needed to. But I didn't get to fire off some of my. Oh, my take.
B
Go for it.
C
And like, I think go off.
B
King.
C
This is. I don't know if the defense can get any better with the personnel. And I know Hoyt coming back. And again, we can talk all we want about what Hairston could be or bring to this offense. Like, I think that's a pipe dream that you hope and are looking at for next year. They have issues on the defensive line. They have issues at the safety. All of these things, which I'm not I thought about, am I? Prisoner of the moment. Two losses in a row. They lost two games in early October last year and then rattled off seven wins. All of those things. But all of these issues that have been highlighted over these last few weeks are issues we had in training camp, are issues we had going into the offseason. None of this is hindsight. All of these were just the problems that I thought this team could have, and they have been put on full display. That's where I worry when I look around the rest of this league and I see, like, oh, like I think that the Green Bay packers will get their offense going eventually.
A
Why?
C
Because they have a really good offensive head coach and their pieces are injured and they're getting there. I don't see the pieces on the Bills.
A
If you're a Green Bay fan, you're. It's just an example. That's a good example to put out there. It feels like they're good.
C
Yeah, Correct.
A
They're not that good. I thought they were better than they were going to be.
C
But don't you see that they're a team that is just getting by right now that you can see going, hey, Micah Parsons, three sacks last week. Yeah, that's going to get going. That defense, Rashad, they have Jordan Love.
A
They don't have Josh Allen.
C
Agreed. But all these things where you sit there and go, I think this offense will get better as the season goes on, as they get more healthier, as they include Matthew golden into the offense more like I see them as a team, you're going, hey, that's good. Like, the Commanders are a team that is floundering because of injuries, because of quarterback play, has regressed all those kind of things that the defense that wasn't good last year. Shocking. Isn't good again this year. Like, that isn't one of those things where you're like, oh, you're just a prisoner of the moment saying that the commander's defense isn't good. They weren't good last year. So a lot of these issues that I see, especially even on this offense, Janet, where I go, these were all of the things. And I go, no, I don't think a trading for a Chris Olave necessarily saves this offense.
B
The fear is that it runs very deep. Is that what you're saying?
C
The fear is that all of the things that I was worried about before the season are still here right now and are now magnified.
A
But last year, there were not really worries about it being a regular season offense. Right. I mean, they scored 30 points a game. Our concern with that offense, or maybe I'm wrong, was what do they do in those big moments in the biggest games, which is still there. I don't think there's any question.
C
Carolina's a very big game.
A
Well, yeah, I think it's like as we're. We're into mid to late October, I think.
B
Yeah. All these games, I think it's easy on other points to look over or overlook a Carolina game. Like, I. I agree with what you're saying. This is a big game because it's one of the. You need this game.
A
Oh, there's 100. The Bills aren't good enough to overlook anyone.
B
That's.
A
That's jets, but really no one.
B
And you bring up the jets and I think back to last season when they did lose those two in a row. But at least you could go back to the fact that at other points earlier on in the year, they were dominant. They were taking care of teams. The Bills have played six games. One of those games, they have looked dominant.
A
Yeah.
B
And the other. The other four that they've won. It was a situation or three that they've won. Three. Yeah.
C
Because they're 42.
B
The other three that they've won, it feels like the Bills have had to will their way, grind it out. Like everything was a struggle in that. And that's what scares me, is you saw the. The moments of brilliance in those. In. In last year and this year, it's like everything feels like a slogan.
C
And even in the Houston loss, it was like, well, Josh played bad. Like, chalk it up. Nobody's perfect. It's A bad loss, I think. I don't think Josh has played that bad where I'm sitting there going, well, once Josh gets it figured out, then everything's going to be fine. I think this offense has fundamental flaws, whether Josh is great or not.
A
Are you more concerned about the offense getting their act together or the defense?
B
I think the ceiling is higher for the offense.
C
I think the offense is. I think the defense is what the defense is. I think this is who they are struggling with the run. That is nothing new. Under Sean McDermott, these kind of things. I've always kind of said that the offense needs to score 30 a game to win. And I look at the last few weeks and I went, they would have scored 30, they would have won. So I have concerns that the blueprint to some respects, to slow down this Bill's team is out there. That's what I'm concerned about.
A
I don't disagree with being concerned. I'm saying is I'm more confident in Joe Brady to just wake up and say, I'm Joe Brady. This is what works for us. And get Josh Allen back to playing the way Josh Allen plays. They still don't have good enough wide receivers. We all know that. But they do have a very good offensive line. They have James Cook and a quarterback that's a good place to start. And they're healthy at at least not the wide receiver position as much. They, they lose Josh Palmer, but they're healthy enough at the other spots. The defense is where it's going to. It. It will eliminate them. It will take them out. And I, I guess it's funny, when we looked at the two suspended guys, it does feel like trade deadline acquisitions that they desperately need.
C
Yep.
A
You need a tackle because you just don't have the numbers. And you need a guy who can get to the quarterback. They don't have to be superstars to, to make this team decent on defense. They just need to be better than the guys brought up from the practice squad. Yeah. In terms of that.
B
But I do have fear that people think that, oh, these, these are huge reinforcements coming in and this will completely change the dynamic of the Bills defense. And Michael Hoy, like, had some nice moments during training camp. You can't deny that. But he also hasn't been around the team for months. Like, I, I just think that sometimes I hear people talk about this guy's coming back and this guy's coming back, and it's like, yeah, I think they can make a difference. You talk about numbers, especially a defensive tackle, but I don't expect them to be. My expectations for them are like a plus starter.
A
That's a good point. I think of it more like the floor coming up, not necessarily the ceiling. Yeah, like, like, because they've played like practice squad guys have been out there. So that's the only part.
B
So nice like having this weekend to just not think about like, are the Bills ass.
C
But what was so frustrating was I watch teams offensively go down the field and score points when they needed to and they had guys making plays and I went, man, that would be nice. Like, like. And I'm not. And I'll go to the one extreme. You have Flacco Flaco, and he's just throwing the ball a hundred times to Jamar Chase.
A
It is Jamar Chase. But yes, I agree with your point.
C
But like, but I, I look around just getting guys open and this goes back to the. I was. We were talking to some people over the weekend and you know, family members, what's going on with the Bills and stuff that. And you're trying to explain to them. I remember having the conversation with like Joe Brady and being like, who I still like, who I still have faith in. But like, what plays are you drawing up? Is it to get Keon open? Are you drawing up plays to get like there nothing. Remember a few years ago I used to talk about like freebies, like when settling Josh down, giving him easy throws that he doesn't have to think because right now he is having to think so much and make chicken soup out of chicken shit.
A
Check. Oh, hold on. There's breaking news. The Bill's roster is not good enough. How's that?
C
And that's what we were saying in training camp. Like we can go back and find these clips and say, man, Keon's having an up and down training camp, you know.
A
Well said.
C
That's where I'm sitting there. And it's like, well, Keon's gonna, you know, the second half is what Keon's gonna step up or one good game from Kincaid, who's. Who's seems to be progressing in the right areas. But I've seen like people talking about like, well, Joe Brady, you know, get Kincaid more involved in the offense. You can't build the offense around Dalton Kincaid.
A
You can get him more involved without building the offense around him. The offense should be built around Josh Allen and James Cook. That's where you build the offense round. This is where I'm saying, If I'm Sean McDermott, I say to Joe and hey, Joe, you Didn't hear me the last time with the cute right? Cut that out. Play the way we play. Let Josh Allen get going. Let James Cook. Don't take on the. I meant it that way. Let James Cook and put him in the. On the field. I don't know in the fourth quarter when you need a play. That's where I think they had. They had an identity last year and that identity has been kind of gone for a couple of weeks.
C
So let me. And again, I do want to get. We will get to the rest of the league and kind of where they stack up. I know we're kind of.
A
Because I have another hot take on that.
C
Okay. But I go back to the James Cook thing. The Falcons blitz like we talked about so heavily. And I don't think the Bills trust James Cook enough to protect Josh Allen. So that's. You're dictating what the Bills can do. Opposing defenses are. That's what I'm saying is that they went with Ty Johnson because he's better in pass protection.
A
He is.
C
Than James Cook. That's not a knock on James. It's just the fact. And eventually it got to that point in the Atlanta game, it felt like preservance, purse.
B
Perseverance.
C
Nope.
B
Preservation.
C
Thank you. That's the one preservation for Josh.
B
I speak Dan.
C
Like where he was getting blitzed so much and was under so much pressure.
A
It's like, well, I have an idea for you. Instead of using James Cook as a blocker, why don't you dump the ball off to James Cook with. You're getting pressure. Other teams do that. That's how you use your playmakers. I do think. I do think the time off could settle the offense back down and understanding. I still don't like their. Their weapons. There's still a lot that I don't like about the higher end of the offense in those key moments, but I think it can be a lot better than it was the last two weeks.
B
Well, when you talk about the talent on the roster, like, what can you do? Because if. If we're, you know, we're entering week eight, what. What is there to share? A trade deadline, acquisition or something like that?
A
I just think he's. I don't. I'm not excited about any deal they make at the deadline.
C
Nope.
A
Because it just. We haven't seen it work.
C
I've seen this story. I've seen this story.
A
Douglas.
B
Douglas.
A
That was a good move.
B
That was. That was a good move.
A
I think the other ones have been so little impact.
C
I think I Remember, like joking around at training camp like about the wide receivers and it's like, oh, they're going to be fine. All this stuff. I was like, they're going to make a dead, they're going to give away a third round pick at the deadline because they're going to realize, oh crap, we don't have enough guys for Josh. I don't know. I, I know I am definitely sounding negative. I get that. And I don't want to be. I've just seen this story and I've seen these flaws that have not been addressed.
B
No.
C
And injuries are absolutely a part of it with the defense and where they're at. But man, I, I, I'm, now I'm questioning the offensive line because teams are blitzing and sending more than five guys and it's, it's disrupting what they do, it's dictating what the Bills are doing and Carolina just blitzed the J the crap out of the jets. And I'm sitting there. If you're some of these teams that go, well, we can man up like what the Patriots did and get pressure on Josh and play man coverage. The Bills don't have skill position guys that can win.
A
Yeah, but there's ways to take advantage of things when they play man coverage that the Bills did not do against the Patriots. The other part is I see some teams that had a lot of success or and let's be honest, Bills offense had a lot of success last year. Yeah, they lead the league in points per game or second in the league in points per game and then other teams see it. So I was sitting home watching the Eagles play and it's like, huh, we have AJ Brown and Devontae Smith. Why don't we throw them the ball, just be nice. But they're in their case, they were a run first team that opened things up for the other guys. So they kept sticking with, well, this is what we do and it wasn't working and it's still not working. So they're finally to the point and they get to this game and go, well, maybe we need to change it up. And I do think that may be the point where I'm saying with the Bills offense to change it up a little bit and one of those things to me is more James Cook. I'll take my chances with the other stuff. I want more James Cook on the field.
B
Brave of you.
A
Yes.
C
Mike wants the Bills to change it up and throw it to AJ Brown and devontae.
A
Hey, but they didn't do that.
C
That Would that would. Yeah.
A
Yes, yes. It's like I'm saying is you have those guys on your team.
C
That's what's driving me nuts.
A
Oh, you mean they don't have those guys?
B
Yeah, they don't have those guys.
C
None of any guys.
A
They have. Keon.
C
Saw a real this week. It wasn't good, but he was just getting his best plays. Are these back shoulder throws that he just isn't making and say that again.
B
Who is this Keon?
C
I saw a reel that was talking about the flaws of Keon and you've talked about before, like that he was a project and things like that, but he had some strengths.
A
It wasn't sold as a project.
C
Nope.
A
Okay.
B
So this makes me sad.
A
I heard somebody recently say the Carolina game's a big game. It is for them.
C
It's not just a must win. Like, I will go that far. I will say can't lose. No, it's a must win. It's a must win. Impressively.
A
Yeah, it's a must.
B
No, it's a must.
A
It's a must win. Nobody cares.
B
The.
C
No, no.
B
Can it be gonna be somewhere in the middle of an impressive win and have to win it? You just.
A
If it's impressive, that's great. Win the game, Move on to the next week.
B
But if they eek at a win, it's still going to be the same.
A
It is. Unless they go play well against the Chiefs. That's the game.
B
I don't have confidence in that. We can get into that.
A
Do you want to do the top five, bottom five now? At least top five.
B
Let's do top five.
A
Let's do top 5. All right.
C
I think we have the same, Same number one, Michael.
A
Let's. Let's start with five. Okay, so here, this part is interesting to me because, full disclosure, we're recording this on Monday. It's actually a great Monday night for games.
B
Yeah.
A
Yeah. Double header games, including Bucks and Lions.
C
Are we just doing afc?
A
No.
C
Or we're doing okay.
A
I, I, this is, this is what we do.
B
Okay.
A
The reason we're doing this top five is because that's fair. The NFC is pretty obvious. The NFC is better than the afc, right? By far.
B
Yeah.
A
Yeah.
B
Which is interesting because coming into this season, it was like, oh, the AFC.
A
Part of it is everybody gets sold on the quarterbacks. Burrows hurt.
B
No, no, that I understand why.
A
No, I'm saying is, wow.
B
And you have them in there if they.
A
They.
C
Yeah, them.
B
No. Them.
C
Yeah. In the afc.
B
Yeah, I guess you're right.
A
If they were both healthy. Even with their records. I think you would still say, well, if the Bengals just got to win, we'll see when Burrow comes back. I love seeing Joe Flo do that. I don't know how sustainable.
C
Steelers stink. Yeah, stinks.
A
So I did this for the whole league. So I. I have to.
C
The AFC 5 and 4.
A
5 and 4 for me are the Bucks and the Lions.
B
Okay.
A
Is what I have five and four for me. So. So tonight will be. Yeah, tonight will be. Put them higher. And if one of them. I think actually the. Actually the game is in Tampa, but. Or in Detroit. Excuse me. Is in Detroit. I think Detroit can look really good. The problem is their secondary is all beaten up. So let's see how this game plays out. This is my five, those two. I have the Rams number three.
B
Yeah.
A
Rams are. When they're good, they're really good.
B
Yeah.
A
The Jags are a fraud. We know that. 2. I have the Chiefs.
C
Yep.
B
You have the Colts.
A
And the Colts are number one.
B
I hate that you had this take weeks ago about.
A
And I was so right.
C
And it was such a joke. Now.
B
Yeah.
C
Now you're like to fruition.
A
You mean I was right. Yeah. Now I will say this. I don't think anybody right now is afraid of the Colts in January. But we'll see. What they know is their defense. Hm. Got a lot better. They hired the guy from the Bengals. Isn't that something? He couldn't coach anymore. Maybe it's because the Bengals had shitty players on defense. Very much right. 2 Daniel Jones escaped from New York. That's what that movie was about. Escape from New York. It's getting away from the jets and the Giants and you look at them and they have right now the best running back in the NFL. And Jonathan Taylor, he is killing it. So. And they blow people out. They score points.
C
They score on every drive.
A
Yeah. They're really right now. Really, really good. Let's see how it plays out. And I have the Chiefs too. I could have made the Chiefs. One of the Chiefs have looked good the last couple of weeks.
C
Raiders stink.
B
The Raiders. Myself, I'm like, the Raiders usually play him tough. That'll be. And then I was like.
A
Once it was 14.
B
Yeah, you're like o.
A
And the Chiefs were very efficient. And I don't know if you noticed this about the Chiefs. They're fast.
B
They have what you would call speed.
A
Speed.
B
Do you think that's a mismatch?
A
They have a few of them on the field. So that's my five. And I know you just have give me your AFC if you have your top five.
C
So I'm a sucker for Denver.
B
Oh really?
A
Oh you're complaining about Bo Nix?
C
He stinks. I finally watched a full game. Bonix stinks. Bonix is not good.
B
Love how Dan's like you never shy away.
C
Nope. So but our good friend Matt Beauvais had a take back in like week three that the Patriots were better than the Denver Broncos and so just you.
A
Crushed him for that.
C
Correct. So just on principle I have New England 5 I Denver 4 just on principal alone there I I would been all set on what I think that Denver and Bonix may not be good but I've like had the faith in Sean Payton and I've had faith that their defense is so good that you can get average quarterback play and still win a lot of games and surprisingly they're still five and two and they feels like they've been a bad team so I had to put Denver 4 after that insane game. Buffalo 3 Kansas City 2 Indy 1 here's my question for you guys.
A
Who, who.
C
Skill position player wise who would start on the Bills for the.
A
Colts who would start on Josh Allen?
C
Okay.
B
Yeah that's.
C
I mean take the quarterback like I think of skill position as the weapons around the quarterback.
A
So you're saying Josh doesn't have skill? Is that your hot take? I don't know enough to say their whole offensive line you're just talking about pass catchers skill position. Well you just disregarded the quarterback and that's a big skill position.
C
When you say skill position do you think quarterback? Yeah, I don't think quarterback. That's quarterback.
A
When I think offense we're only talking about running back. Are we taking tight ends?
C
We are taking tight ends.
A
They don't have a tight end starting.
B
Yeah.
A
Nope. And they might not have a wide receiver signing and they probably and this is unfair to James because that's this guy is playing. They do just fine with James Cook.
C
Yes.
A
So yes it would be Daniel Jones and the the Colts starters. Yeah. There's no Bills that would start I.
C
Don'T think isn't that mind boggling Michael Pittman like those guys. Tyler Warren like Tyler rookie good rookies making immediate impacts on the team. Yeah it's just I guess maybe Shakir would start in the slot over Josh Downs but that's a coin flip.
A
Yeah.
C
Like that's where I'm sitting there like Daniel Jones is not. He's playing the position better than Josh. He's playing the position probably as good as anybody in the league right now, besides, outside of Baker.
A
Dak.
C
Dak as well. But, like.
B
Yeah.
A
Not asked this year.
C
No, but I look at those guys and it's like, well, you're throwing a cd Lamb and George Pickens.
A
Pickens is.
C
And you have a. You have a top five tight end in Jake Ferguson. Like, man, playing quarterback with all those weapons must be really fun and easy.
B
Yeah. I know I've said this on the. On the channel before, but my fear has always been, like, 10 years down the line. Like, if you look back and with hindsight, you're like, we didn't do enough to get Josh weapons. That's always.
C
You're just a prisoner of the moment. Like, we haven't been saying that.
B
Always. My fear.
C
We haven't been seeing that for three years.
B
And it's. It's like, why do you want to handcuff your best player?
A
And it's. Well, you can't say it's money because they spent more money on these wide receivers than they would have with young players.
B
Yeah.
A
You spend more.
B
So you don't think the Patriots. You know, you're not buying.
C
I'm still not buying the page.
A
I have the. I had the Patriots 5.
B
I could. I could see you having that.
C
Who'd you put four?
A
Well, I. In this case, I had the. Because I had both the Bucks and the Lions, because I think they. And I just. And Baker, my other hot take, obviously ended. He's been tremendous. Better than Joe Burrow.
C
One of them is.
A
Healthy. Joe Burrow. I would disagree there.
B
That's. You know, I.
A
Considering we saw Joe Flacco go in there and light it up. I'm just. Then I had Lions and Ra.
B
That might be a bit prisoner of the moment with your.
A
Baker's been really good.
B
He's been. That's literally the definition of prisoner of the moment.
A
No, I mean, he's been good for, like, the last three years. Good. Yeah. And he was doing it with Mike Evans, and then Mike Evans got hurt. Anyhow, I think the Patriots are good, and I think. I think Drake May throws the ball really well, and we thought he would come into this year with the 2019. Josh. Yeah. @ the moment. And they haven't had that many.
C
He's 2020, Josh.
A
He is at another level there.
B
Their schedule is also incredibly easy, but you can only play who's on your schedule.
A
And their win in Buffalo was very impressive for them.
B
It was. I was talking to my uncle today. Big, big Patriots fan. He lives in New England. He was saying. He was. He was pumped. And he literally said. He said, they went in to Buffalo, give me something. They weren't scared.
A
How did he say it?
B
He says everything like Uncle John trying to think what he said.
A
The kids got it, the kids got it.
B
The kids got it.
C
I look at that and I just say, the funniest thing about all this with this Patriot stuff is I can't wait for Josh McDaniels to get another head coaching job. I don't know. It's going to be so good. It's going to be so good. Josh, just wait. Just wait. There's going to be an owner that is going to throw another bag at him because he's working with a young quarterback. He's got Drake Mail figured out. He's going to get another head coaching job.
A
Yeah.
B
Okay. Do you want to do bottom five?
C
I got him Dolphins. Dolphins and Dolphins. Some jets and Dolphins.
B
No, you got to go all Dolphins, man. It's bad.
A
It is bad. And I. Mike or Mike McDaniel wants to get fired. Obviously. Some of the stuff he says, he look like he got run over before the game.
B
Yeah.
A
He's standing there, he's saying stuff, and they just won't fire him. Like, what are they waiting? Seriously, what are they waiting for?
B
Hey, don't worry. Tua will start for the Dolphins in week eight. I just saw a report.
A
Yeah, they. They. He's.
B
Yeah.
C
There are no changes.
A
They're not. Are they gonna put Zach Wilson in? I put the Raiders.
B
Yeah. Quinn, yours.
A
I put the Raiders number four because Titans. They're bad.
C
They're bad.
A
They're bad.
B
Yeah.
A
They hung in there for like two minutes against the Patriots. I was like two, and the Dolphins won. That's how little I think of the Dolphins because they obviously have more talent, overall talent than the Jet. Well, I shouldn't say. Obviously, they have a few guys. Sauce left the game.
B
Man.
A
If you're Sauce, I know those guys signed Garrett Wilson and Sauce. Yeah, those are two really good players.
B
You got to be like, yeah, just take those two.
A
Make a deal for those two.
B
I'm sure they would want to do an in division trade.
A
Yes. Anyhow, that's pretty big needs on both cases, but yeah.
C
Just.
A
Yes, it's.
B
We're entering week eight, though, so there's. There's time for improvement.
A
To your point, though, of. Of saying this is an important game. It is. This team needs to get back to playing the way they can play, take care of business on the road. They're seven And a half point favorites. Carolina doesn't score a lot. They play.
B
Neither do the Bills.
A
Well, they've had, yes, they've done this the last two and it's looked bad. But this team will run the ball down your throat. They are old school Carolina and they will try to run it against the Bills and I think you take your chances.
C
Good.
B
That's good.
A
Yeah, that's good.
B
Why don't you tell everyone what we have coming up on the channel?
A
I don't know. What do we have coming up on the kitchen?
B
Well, you did. Yes.
A
Spoke with Tim Donnelly. He is a talk show host in North Carolina and covers all the teams down there. Also was a quarterback at the University of Delaware. Knows Joe Flacco personally.
C
Yes.
A
And he was great. Great. I think you'll really enjoy it. I think that's coming out Wednesday morning. We'll put that out for Wednesday morning. And good insight into what this team is like. He goes, everybody else is trying to do more. They're going old school. Run the ball, play defense, don't make mistakes and see if it can work. They're undefeated at home. They have not lost at home.
C
They're three. They've won three in a row.
A
Three in a row. He, you know, his point was they've, they beat Atlanta. Like that's the one that really sticks out because the Bills saw a very good version of Atlanta and then, or maybe the Bills made that a very good version of Atlanta in that game.
B
There's a lot. Anything else, Daniel?
C
No, I'm just, I'm down bad. I, I, I am not in a good place with this team. That can obviously change. And again they, so you're saying is.
A
If they do better then it can be better.
C
Yes, that, that is exactly what I'm saying. But right now to like I'm sitting here thinking about what move at the deadline would.
A
I'm not even sharing about the deadline. I don't think I'm saying is they could make a move. I'm going to be negative about the move.
B
He's trying to say his point of view.
A
Oh, why I'm the only one who interrupts.
C
I was like, hey, you know about the trail.
A
I haven't thought it.
C
The trade deadlines, like if I could have finished my sentence, there's nothing that would excite me that the Bills could really do at the trade deadline. That's my. Now, now you talk.
A
I just want to make sure we finish.
B
I hate when you do that.
A
So if they traded for Sauce Gardener, that wouldn't make you happy.
C
I mean, they're not doing that.
A
A realistic moves skill position player.
C
What if they gotten Baker?
A
Yes. I think it's got to be any moves they do make. If they do, it should be defense. It should be defense. They're going to use assets. They need it on defense.
B
But that's ridiculous. Think of how many assets they've used on defense.
A
Comment on here on what you think they need. They need safety and they. Maybe even bigger. They need that other corner. Unless it's. Unless there's somewhat hope that it's Max at some point. But that's a big. Dorian Gas or Dorian.
B
Yeah, I guess.
A
Yeah. If he's back.
C
Yeah.
B
Yeah. IR we'll see about Max Hairston this week.
A
If they open up the window, I think that's big. I. I would be very surprised if they don't open up the window. There's no downside to that. They open it up, he practices. If it's not right.
C
Yeah.
A
They have to be smart. I mean, he's a young player, number one pick. If he's not ready, you can't play him. There's not. You can't just, like, force him out there and then we'll see if at any point then he. I mean, here's the truth. He could always play and if it's not working, you can always put him on IR later.
C
Yeah.
A
I mean, that's just the way it works. But I don't think they want to do that. I think they. If they see how he practices for a few weeks. Different than the two guys coming back from the suspension who I believe are going to be out on the field.
B
Yes. Well, they're also veterans and they're veterans.
A
And they were not injured. Yes, they were suspended.
B
Correct.
C
So.
B
Okay.
A
And maybe Matt Milano coming back.
B
All right, that'll do it here.
A
Trade deadline channel.
B
All right. For Mike Catalana and Dan Fates, I am Jenna Cottrell. Please be sure to like, comment, subscribe and share. And thank you so much for watching the league presented by stellar roofing windows and siding. We'll catch you next time here on Buffalo pl.
Date: October 22, 2025
Hosts: Mike Catalana (A), Jenna Cottrell (B), Dan Fetes (C)
This episode of Buffalo Plus is a deep dive into where the Buffalo Bills stand relative to other top (and bottom) teams in the NFL at the midway point in the 2025 season. The hosts break down the Bills’ performance issues on both sides of the ball, discuss fan panic, personnel decisions, and what realistic expectations should be moving forward. They also debate top five and bottom five teams in the league, with a focus on the AFC and how the Bills might finish the season.
Rest & Reset:
Mike and Jenna agree the bye week came at a crucial time, providing rest for both the team and the fan base after two rough losses.
“They needed the rest.” – Mike (01:14)
“It was a bad two weeks. I’m not positive, I’m not negative. I’m realistic. I think I know what this team is.” – Mike (01:17)
Offensive Struggles:
Mike emphasizes the need for Joe Brady (OC) to “go back to being Joe Brady” and stop getting “cute” with play calls, instead playing to Josh Allen’s strengths.
“Get Josh Allen back going. Like Josh Allen. The last two weeks, he hasn’t really looked like Josh Allen.” – Mike (01:46)
Defensive Concerns & Personnel Limitations:
Dan doubts the defense can improve much with its current personnel, citing issues that date back to training camp and haven't been addressed.
“I think that’s a pipe dream... They have issues on the defensive line. They have issues at safety. All of these things...these issues we had in training camp.” – Dan (03:16) "The fear is that all of the things that I was worried about before the season are still here right now and are now magnified." – Dan (05:39)
Recurring Offensive Flaws:
Jenna notes this year feels different than past slumps; in 2024, the Bills looked dominant in some wins, but so far in 2025, all but one of their wins have felt like grinds.
“The other three that they've won, it feels like the Bills have had to will their way, grind it out. Like everything was a struggle in that. And that's what scares me...” – Jenna (06:53)
No Quick Fixes at the Trade Deadline:
The hosts are skeptical that any single trade could solve the Bills' issues, particularly at wide receiver and on defense.
"I don't. I'm not excited about any deal they make at the deadline...we haven't seen it work." – Mike (14:03)
“I’ve just seen this story and I’ve seen these flaws that have not been addressed.” – Dan (14:23)
Return to Identity, Feature James Cook:
There’s a consensus that the offense needs to return to what worked: leaning on Josh Allen and James Cook, and giving Allen easier throws—“freebies”—instead of asking him to do too much.
“The offense should be built around Josh Allen and James Cook.” – Mike (11:55) “Let Josh Allen get going. Let James Cook...put him on the field. I don't know, in the fourth quarter when you need a play.” – Mike (11:55)
Problems with WR Corps and Scheme:
The Bills’ lack of true playmakers at WR compared to contenders is a source of frustration.
“I'm not excited about any deal they make at the deadline...we haven't seen it work.” – Mike (14:03) “You have Flacco and he’s just throwing the ball a hundred times to Jamar Chase… Man, that would be nice.” – Dan (10:04)
Top 5 Teams Debate (18:00 – 24:00):
The hosts share their league-wide top five:
“Rams are, when they're good, they're really good. The Jags are a fraud. Chiefs two, Colts are number one.” – Mike (19:55, 20:04)
AFC/NFC Power Shift:
Agreement that the NFC is stronger than the AFC this year, a reversal from preseason expectations.
“The NFC is better than the afc, right? By far.” – Mike (18:30)
Colts as Surprise #1 – Why?
Mike argues the Colts have become a juggernaut due in large part to a great defense and Jonathan Taylor, and they're blowing out opponents.
"...they have right now the best running back in the NFL. And Jonathan Taylor, he is killing it." – Mike (20:58)
Bills’ Talent vs. AFC Contenders:
Dan and Mike vividly discuss how few Bills skill players would start on the Colts (even setting aside the quarterbacks)—calling out a stark talent gap at weapons positions.
“There’s no Bills that would start [on Colts skill positions]...” – Mike (23:38)
“My fear has always been, like, 10 years down the line...we didn't do enough to get Josh weapons.” – Jenna (24:38)
Clear Bottom Dwellers:
Dolphins are named by multiple hosts as the NFL's bottom team, with the Titans, Jets, and Raiders also mentioned.
“Bottom five? Dolphins, Dolphins and Dolphins. Some Jets and Dolphins.” – Dan (27:25)
Frustration/Venting About Competitors:
Banter about Mike McDaniel’s job in Miami; mutual bemusement at the persistent rumors of coaches like Josh McDaniels getting recycled as head coaches.
Carolina Preview:
Panel universally agrees the upcoming game is a must-win for Buffalo, not just in the standings but to restore confidence—“win impressively.”
"It's a must win. Impressively." – Dan (17:22)
"Win the game. Move on to the next week." – Mike (17:43)
What would excite at the trade deadline?
Jaded skepticism about adding anyone—focus should be on defense if at all.
“If they do, it should be defense. It should be defense.” – Mike (31:44)
“Think of how many assets they've used on defense.” – Jenna (31:55)
Josh Allen Deprivation:
“My fear has always been, like, 10 years down the line…we didn’t do enough to get Josh weapons.” – Jenna (24:38)
On Bills’ Offensive Identity:
"The offense should be built around Josh Allen and James Cook. That's where you build the offense round." – Mike (11:55)
AFC vs. NFC Power Balance:
“The NFC is better than the afc, right? By far.” – Mike (18:30)
Colts as the Standard:
"They blow people out. They score points. They score on every drive. Yeah. They're really right now. Really, really good." – Mike (20:58)
Cynicism about the Trade Deadline:
“I've seen this story and I've seen these flaws that have not been addressed.” – Dan (14:13)
“I'm not excited about any deal they make at the deadline…we haven't seen it work.” – Mike (14:03)
On the Pressure of the Carolina Game:
“It's not just a must win. Like, I will go that far. I will say can't lose.” – Dan (17:22)
On Being Realistic:
“I’m not positive, I’m not negative. I’m realistic. I think I know what this team is.” – Mike (01:17)
For full episode context with exclusive insight, game breakdowns, and more, subscribe to Buffalo Plus on YouTube.