Buffalo Plus Podcast Summary

Episode: What's RIGHT with the BILLS OFFENSE, what's WRONG with the DEFENSE and mid-season AWARDS
Date: November 8, 2024
Hosts: Mike Catalana, Jenna Cottrell, Dan Fetes

Episode Overview

This episode dives into the Buffalo Bills’ 7–2 start to the season, analyzing what’s working with the offense, the lingering concerns with the defense—especially against the run—and issuing mid-season team awards. The hosts mix serious football discussion with banter, memorable moments, and a midseason review full of superlatives.

Key Discussion Points

1. Bills’ Fast Start & Playoff Prospects

• 7–2 Record Context:
  • Dan notes that the last six times the Bills started 7–2, they’ve reached the AFC Championship Game (03:17).
  • Mike stresses the tougher playoff structure now (just one bye) and focuses on matchups for postseason success (03:49).

"They have a lot of tough games coming up... when they get to the playoffs, it’s going to all be about matchups."
— Mike (03:49)

• Winning Without Dominance:
  • Jenna points out the team’s ability to win games without always playing their best, relying on a mix of running, passing, and “Josh Allen magic” (05:09).

2. Injury Updates & Impact on Offense

• Keon Coleman (WR):

  • Did not practice; doubtful for the upcoming game. The team suggests they won’t rush him back and may look to get him ready for Kansas City instead (06:03–07:36).
  • Issue is with wrist function, not grip. Team being cautious (08:03–08:15).

• Curtis Samuel & Amari Cooper:

  • Both limited in practice; Cooper practicing in a regular jersey but not catching in team drills (07:36–08:44).

• Overall Concern:

  • Jenna voices concerns about receiver depth due to injuries (09:14).

3. What’s Working with the Offense?

• Joe Brady’s Impact (Offensive Coordinator):
  • Dan heaps praise on Brady for giving Josh Allen “easy answers” to defenses and more simple throws (09:50).
  • Passes are shorter (3.9 yards past line of scrimmage on average), showing Allen’s evolution in reading defenses and making the right play (10:17–11:45).

"It’s not about making the best play, it’s the right play. That’s what Joe Brady has been preaching to him."
— Dan (12:43)

• Yards After Catch (YAC):

  • 59% of Josh Allen's passing yards come after the catch, 13% higher than previous years (11:45–12:13).

• Receiving Corps:

  • Khalil Shakir and Keon Coleman's physicality and ability to generate YAC have been difference-makers (11:45–12:13).

4. The Run Game Resurgence

• Effective Run Scheme:
  • Mike and Dan note complementarity of the run and pass, citing offensive line improvement and the impact of Ray Davis (14:01–15:46).
  • Team adapts offense week to week, which Mike describes as having a “Chiefs-y” feel (14:28–15:10).

"They're kind of morphing their offense along with what their strengths are... all of that is really blended nicely."
— Dan (14:58)

• Josh Allen's Designed Runs:
  • Recent designed power runs for Allen have not been effective—hosts prefer his runs off scrambles, and criticize the scheme when tight ends are expected to block edge defenders (17:08–19:04).

5. Defensive Issues: Run Defense Under the Microscope

• Recurring Problem:

  • Hosts agree stopping the run has long been the team’s Achilles heel (19:15–20:59).
  • DaQuan Jones hasn’t returned to prior form after injury; defensive tackle group seen as undersized except for the newly returned Jordan Phillips, whom Mike doubts will have a major immediate impact (19:51–20:52).

• Philosophical Approach:

  • Sometimes the Bills are willing to concede rushing yards to protect against big pass plays, especially against teams like Miami (21:09–21:53).
  • Taron Johnson and defensive staff candid about “giving up the run” to limit explosive passing attacks (21:11–21:53).

6. Colts Matchup Discussion

• QB Switch:
  • Discussion on Colts’ controversial switch from rookie Anthony Richardson to veteran Joe Flacco—hosts think Flacco’s immobility makes Colts more one-dimensional and perhaps easier to defend (23:31–24:22).
  • Colts’ Jonathan Taylor is far more effective with a mobile quarterback in Richardson; hosts question the Colts’ developmental plan (24:50–26:51).

7. Micah Hyde’s Future

• Status:
  • No expectation that Hyde will rejoin the roster this year barring injury—he seems content in quasi-retirement with family (29:37–32:23).
  • Even if he wanted to, returning and learning the new scheme would require a significant ramp-up (35:28–35:57).

"There is a lot that would go into bringing back Micah Hyde than just simply he walks in the door and he's better than Demar Hamlin."
— Dan (35:28)

Mid-Season Awards (Superlatives)

Most Surprising Player

• Dan: Ray Davis, for bringing a physical running style not seen since Fred Jackson (36:25).
• Mike: Dorian Williams, for high physicality at linebacker (37:13).
• Jenna: James Cook, for elevated play as a more physical, reliable RB (38:04).

Offensive MVP (Not Josh Allen)

• Jenna: Khalil Shakir—“the straw that stirs the drink,” dependable, explosive (39:00).
• Mike: Connor McGovern (center)—stabilizing interior O-line, strong run blocking (39:46).
• Dan: Tyrel Dodson or Terrel Bernard (LB)—defensive heartbeat, crucial with Milano out (40:32).

Most Disappointing

• Mike: Curtis Samuel, expected big things but has been ineffective; injuries may partly explain it (41:57–42:01).
• Dan: Dalton Kincaid, failing to become more than an average tight end or focal point in the offense (43:56–44:18).
• Jenna: Ed Oliver, flashes but hasn’t provided consistent interior disruption (45:14).

Best & Worst Moments

• Worst Moment: Consensus—failed trick play against Baltimore, “Killed momentum and almost got Josh Allen hurt” (47:13–48:21).
• Best Moment:
  • Jenna: Tyler Bass’s 61-yard game-winning FG (48:48).
  • Dan: Josh Allen’s swagger vs. Dolphins LB—epitome of team confidence (49:34).
  • Mike: Allen’s hurdle in Arizona; honorable mention—Aaron Rodgers’ interception sealing Jets game (50:46).

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Joe Brady’s effect on Allen:

  “I need you to make the right play. Sometimes that right play may be a special play.”
  — Dan (12:43)

• On run-game resurgence:

  "Name me a good offense in the NFL that isn't very effective running the football. There isn't one."
  — Mike (14:01)

• Hiccup Incident:
  Jenna’s on-camera hiccup led to extended, light-hearted ribbing by her co-hosts—a rare, viral podcast moment (15:46–16:30).

• On defensive run issues:

  “I don’t think the average football fan understands all that goes into a game plan defensively…”
  — Dan (21:15)

Timestamps for Major Segments

• Bills at 7-2, Playoff Outlook – 03:17
• Injury Checkup – 06:03
• Joe Brady’s Influence & Offensive Evolution – 09:50
• Yards After Catch Stat – 11:45
• Run Game & O-Line Praise – 13:39
• Debate Over QB Run Schemes – 17:08
• Bills’ Run Defense Weakness – 19:15
• Colts QB Switch Impact – 23:31
• Micah Hyde Future Discussion – 29:37
• Mid-Season Superlatives – 36:25
• Best/Worst Moments – 47:13, 48:48

Fun/Community Highlights

• Live Appearance:
  Hosts announce a live show at Whelen Brewing in Orchard Park, Nov. 13 at 7pm. (01:32–02:21)
• Gift Reveal:
  Listener Mike Silva sends Dan a custom T-shirt reading “Synchrosy: when hot takes come to fruition”—a cherished, show-related gift (52:30–54:45).
• Playful Banter:
  Numerous running jokes about hot takes, Pilates “gun show,” and failed sports equipment demos (55:20, 58:00).

Conclusion

The episode delivers a thorough mid-season Bills review: highlighting adaptability and efficiency on offense, ongoing run defense struggles, and the importance of complementary football. The hosts break down player development, roster needs, and crucial moments with expertise and a distinctive WNY flavor—with all the laughter, passion, and candor that have become the show’s hallmark.

For Further News and Analysis

Visit BuffaloPlus.com and YouTube for more content and exclusive coverage.