Buffalo Plus Podcast Episode Summary

Episode: WHY the Bills 'SHOULD' DOMINATE the 'FLAILING' 'Fish' and JOSH ALLEN's 'new' NOSE

Date: September 17, 2025
Hosts: Mike Catalana, Jenna Cottrell, Dan Fetes

Episode Overview

In this episode, the Buffalo Plus team delivers an in-depth preview of the upcoming Buffalo Bills vs. Miami Dolphins Thursday Night Football clash. The hosts discuss the stark contrast in organizational cultures, why the Bills are poised to dominate, the turmoil in Miami, and share insights about Josh Allen’s well-publicized nose injury. The group also dives into specific matchups, their player-of-the-week picks, and wraps up with memorable moments from inside and outside the NFL.

Key Discussion Points and Insights

1. Why the Bills Should Dominate the Dolphins

• State of the Dolphins:
  • All three hosts are adamant that Miami is in disarray, both on and off the field.
  • Repeated references to their lack of fight, accountability, and disorganization.
  • “They're a mess, and they know they're a mess. They have internal and external problems.” — Mike (03:16)
  • “The Dolphins are more name than game and they have no chance in this game.” — Dan (04:01, 18:56)
  • Specific mention of recent in-game blunders, e.g. delay of game and too many men on the field after long reviews (05:06).
• Trap Game Framing:
  • Hosts dismiss concerns about a Bills letdown despite the short week and emotional win over the Jets.
  • Jenna cautions, "You have to respect that there are players that could make a huge impact if you don't respect that." (00:00, 18:27, 18:56)
  • Mike: “Bad teams don’t know they’re bad yet. I do believe this team thinks they’re bad.” (22:03)
• Buffalo’s Approach:
  • Home field advantage, maturity of Bills veterans, and turnover margin cited as reasons for confidence.
  • “The Bills don’t give teams really anything. They don’t turn the ball over. That’s the biggest thing.” — Jenna (24:13)
  • "24 straight games, the Bills have won the turnover battle." — Dan (24:30)

2. Dissecting Miami’s Collapse: Culture and Coaching Issues

• Mike McDaniel’s Tenure:
  • Debate about his authenticity and effectiveness — consensus is he lacks necessary authoritative leadership.
  • "He tried to be the parent that's friends with the child...there was times when you needed accountability for this team" — Jenna (06:11)
  • “Some people are just better coordinators than head coaches. That may be Mike McDaniel.” — Dan (07:34)
• Talent vs. Results:
  • Dolphins regularly cited as a “team with names, but not the game.”
  • Even so, warning not to ignore playmakers like Tyreek Hill or Achane.

3. Josh Allen’s ‘New’ Nose: Injury Updates and Locker Room Reactions

• Nose Injury (28:16):
  • Allen’s bloody nose discussed as comic relief; potential visor return considered.
  • “He looks like a Bosa now,” — Spencer Brown (28:30).
  • Joking about who has the biggest nose and camaraderie in the Bills’ locker room (29:02–29:53).

4. Player Matchups and Game Expectations

Matchups to Watch

• Bills' Corners vs Dolphins Receivers:
  • Dan keys in on Christian Benford to be a shutdown presence: “If you can disrupt that [first read], it changes everything.” (32:12)
• Greg Rousseau’s Homecoming:
  • Jenna: “This is his spot… I could see him making a couple big plays for the Bills in this one.” (33:47)

Respect for Miami’s Talent (With Caveats):

• Jenna and Mike repeat the potential for big plays if Miami gets rolling, but none of the hosts ultimately view this as a legitimate threat.

5. Memorable Quotes & Moments

• “The Dolphins are more name than game and they have no chance in this game.” — Dan (04:01, 18:56)
• “You have to at least respect that there are players that could make a huge impact if you don't respect that.” — Jenna (00:00, 18:27)
• “Bad teams don’t know they’re bad yet. I do believe this team thinks they’re bad.” — Mike (22:03)
• “I think the Dolphins have trapped themselves in just a bad team in a bad environment.” — Dan (04:22)

Timestamps for Important Segments

• [04:01, 18:56] — Dan’s repeated “more name than game” T-shirt moment
• [06:11] — Jenna on Miami’s lack of accountability and McDaniel’s failed leadership
• [07:34] — Coaching transitions: coordinators vs. head coaches
• [24:13–24:34] — Turnover margin as Bills' winning DNA
• [28:16–29:53] — Josh Allen’s nose injury, visor talk, and locker room humor
• [32:12] — Picasso Player of the Week: Christian Benford (Dan’s analysis)
• [33:47] — Jenna’s pick: Gregory Rousseau
• [38:13–39:46] — Game predictions (Bills 40–17, 33–10, 37–20)
• [41:31–43:48] — Chiefs hot takes, culture breakdown after Super Bowl loss

Notable Quotes & On-Brand Banter

• On the Dolphins’ Culture:
  • Mike: “They’re bad because they got bad. Two bad teams when you have good players…that culture is bad.” (10:14)
  • “He tried finding the players, I tried doing this. How absurd is that?” — Mike on McDaniel (11:31)
• On Preparation and Respect:
  • Jenna: “You still have to prepare if you’re the Bills… because stuff can happen that you are just not expecting.” (21:02, 24:04)
• On Bills' Locker Room:
  • “It is fun to hear other players poke fun at the quarterback… it looks like I saw his dad. I know where he gets his nose.” (29:06)
• On the NFL’s Weirdness:
  • “The NFL is freaking weird, man. It’s freaking weird.” — Jenna (24:04)
• On the Chiefs’ Struggles:
  • “That is crazy for me… a champion… some guy trying to talk trash to a guy who's taken a knee.” — Mike on Chris Jones (40:18)
  • “I think they just seem like they're… tired, which I know sounds silly. They're just coming off the off season…” — Jenna (42:47)

Game Predictions

• Dan: Bills 40, Dolphins 17 (38:39)
• Jenna: Bills 33, Dolphins 10 (38:42)
• Mike: Bills 37, Dolphins 20 ("some garbage points by the Dolphins," predicts McDaniel could be fired after the game) (39:15)

Player(s) to Watch (Picasso's Player of the Week)

• Jenna: Khalil Shakir—“I think this is a moment for him to really have a big game.” (31:29)
• Dan: Christian Benford—looking for him to stop Tua’s first read and disrupt the Dolphins passing rhythm (32:12)
• Mike: Gregory Rousseau—points to his matchup, Miami connection, and playmaking potential (33:47)

Fun Features and Personal Stories

• Emmy Nominations: Jenna discusses attending the Emmy Awards and losing out to a Bills/Oishei Children’s Hospital story; team reflects on making meaning of big career moments (44:07–47:31)
• Studio Banter: Playful rundown of studio setup, shoes, hair, and how the new room may or may not cut down on interruptions

Final Thoughts

The Buffalo Plus team is confident the Bills will cruise past the floundering Dolphins, attributing their certainty to the Bills’ discipline, depth, and leadership, in stark contrast to Miami’s turmoil. There’s unanimous respect, but not fear, for Miami’s individual playmakers. The episode is rich in insider banter, statistical context (especially on turnovers and Josh Allen vs. Miami), picks for breakout players, and concludes with heartfelt camaraderie around their Emmy-worthy work.

For more Bills content and exclusive coverage, subscribe to Buffalo Plus on YouTube and check out their live events as mentioned at episode’s close.