Loading summary
A
Oh, oh, oh. O'Reilly. Check engine ABS or maintenance light on. Take the guesswork out of your warning lights with O'Reilly Veriscan. The service is free and provides a report with solutions verified by ASE Certified Master Technicians. And if you need help, we could recommend a shop for you. Ask for O'Reilly Veriscan today. Oh, oh, oh. O'Reilly Auto Parts. Hey, everybody, it's Tim Miller from the Bulwark here. Fresh off her campaign to do dick checks in the ladies restroom at the Capitol. Nancy Mace has flip flopped, and now she's against gay marriage. And she's made that announcement by robbing a talking point from, I don't know, 1991, Pat Robertson or James Thompson or something like that by tweeting Adam and Eve, not Adam and Steve. Oh, big hit there, Nancy. Big hit. Not like we never heard that one before. Oh, boy, you're really digging deep. Oh, my feelings are so hurt. Here's the thing. I try not to get too upset when people that are having a psychotic break lash out against the gays. And that's clearly what's happening here. I mean, Nancy Mace is mentally unwell. And so, you know, I don't take it personally. I don't think it says anything about my happy family that Nancy Mace is throwing stones at it from her broken home. You know, I mean, I do think this is an example of an unhappy woman that has, I believe, two divorces lashing out at people in committed relationships who are just kind of living our lives. So I don't think it means so much about my husband or my daughter. You know, I'm not, like, going to get my feelings hurt. This is a, this is a deeply sad woman just looking for attention. But I do think it merits noting, like, the, her trajectory goes just so stark, and it mirrors what is happening with the Republican Party writ large. Where you went from this moment where there was this kind of Christian cultural conservatism that was like, part and parcel with the party and there were like these factions within the party. Back when I was a Republican, you know, it was, I was kind of in the moderate, the socially moderate, fiscally conservative faction. And then you had the, you know, kind of evangelical Christian right faction. You know, back then, Nancy was in my faction. And you had this trajectory going forward where like those factions kind of mer, like Donald Trump just jumps into the party, the Kool Aid man breaking through the wall and, you know, focuses so much on immigration and this white grievance politics. And it, and it jumbles everything right where a bunch of evangelicals are on board with this, like, thrice married mushroom dicked libertine from New York City. And so things get jumbled. And, like, as part of that jumble, like, the gay issue gets kind of tamped down. Like, Rhonda Sanctimonious tried to kick it back up with the don't say gay bill in Florida. But, like, for the most part, there was, like, this relative truce on gay issues where they dialed in on going after trans folks, dialed in on immigrants, etc. And so Nancy is sort of part of this. So, like, as somebody that was a socially moderate Republican, it gets kind of swept up in maga. But then she still is pro gay marriage. You can kind of do that. But I think the fact that now she has gone, you know, full Tony Perkins with the you're not allowed to be Adam and Steve. I say with my deep voice, like, I just. I think it's telling that, like, that gay truce is sort of ending. Right? And. And as the cultural right as ascendant and as they focus on their white grievance politics and their anti immigrant politics and anti trans politics, it was only, like, a matter of time until the gays got wrapped up into that, and we've reached that moment. And so to kind of give you a tour through that trajectory, through the story of this one ill person, Nancy Mace. I wanted to go back through her history, so here she is. We went back through just her Twitter history to make it nice and clean. 2021. I strongly support LGBTQ rights. No one should be discriminated against. Oh, thanks. Religious liberty, gay rights, and transgender equality can all coexist at this point. She's even pro trans. Noting also it's 2021. So Biden is president. This is. This is not during the Romney campaign, and this is after Trump 1.0. And she is talking about how she wants dignity for everybody. Trans, gays, straights, religious people. Oh, it's nice. It was a great place to land. If only we all could have stayed there. March 2, 2021 country might be happier. Let's go forward. She pushes ahead to June, and she posts a South Carolina Pride flag. Wow. A rainbow South Carolina flag. South Carolina's got a great flag. The pandemic kept all of us from fully celebrating pride here in the low country in 2020. But hopefully we'll begin to open back up. We can all come together to celebrate the challenges our LGBTQ neighbors have overcome and the bright future ahead. That's so sweet. She missed pride in 2020 because of the pandemic. And she decided she wanted to get us all back together for a big drag celebration in the low country. Huh? But I would even been invited to that. That would have been nice. So there we go. Faster ahead to July. She just passed the Respect for Marriage Act Shout out. That protects marriages like mine. Maybe doesn't project protect marriages into the future, but it protects existing marriages. And she reads. She's a big fan of marriage, having done a few times. She shows a little self deprecating humor there. And if gay couples want to be as happy or as miserably married as straight couples, more power to them. Trust me on this. Some of her issues are starting to appear here. Miserably married. This is. We're a little bit before the time. Is this the moment? Yeah, this is the moment. This is a little bit before the period where she famously now, having had another failed marriage, is in a relationship. The boyfriend is going to a prayer breakfast. She's speaking to a prayer breakfast. And she does this. And when I woke up this morning at 7, I was getting picked up at 7:45. Patrick, my fiance, tried to pull me by my waist over this morning in bed. And I was like, no, baby, we don't got time for that this morning. I gotta get to the prayer breakfast and I gotta be on time and a little tmi. But he can wait. He's got. I'll see him later tonight. That's an ick for me. That's an ick for me. Don't know about talking about getting laid at a prayer breakfast, but. Okay, so that's Nancy kind of trajectory from equality for everybody. Mispride. Love trans people to go ahead and get married if you want gays. It's miserable. She's sucking down a glass of wine or maybe doing a shot and kissing a lady next to her. Let's look at that. That's not. That's interesting. Hey, I like to party. So no judgment there, but it's an interesting video to remember as we push forward here.
B
Bulwark Takes is sponsored by Soul struggling to switch off at night. Soul's out of office. Gummies help me relax, quiet my thoughts, and help me fall asleep naturally. Just the right balance of CBD and THC to ease me into a restful night. And it doesn't get much more restful or cozy than these fall nights. You need to wake up every day at your best. You know how much my parenting skills have improved because I am sleeping deeply and I'm waking up locked and ready the next day. Sol is a wellness brand that believes feeling good should be fun and easy. Sol specializes in delicious hemp derived THC and CBD products designed to boost your mood and help you unwind. Their best selling out of office Gummies were designed to provide a mild relaxing buzz, boost your mood, enhance your creativity and relaxation. With five different strengths, you can tailor the dose to fit your vibe from a gentle 1.5mg microdose, which is, you know, pretty good for the parenting, to their newest 15 milligram gummy for a more elevated experience, the Tim Miller Experience. Seoul has a variety of products specifically designed to help you get a better night's rest, including their top selling Sleepy Gummies, a fan favorite for deep restorative sleep. Bring on the good vibes and treat yourself to Seoul today. Right now, Seoul is offering our audience 30% off your entire order. What is steal? Go to getsoul.com and use the code bulwarktakes. That's getsoul.com promo code bulwarktakes for 30% off.
A
Then at the end of the year, once again she is talking about how she's happy to protect the status of marriage regardless of your skin color or sexual orientation. And then once again, she's doing an interview for CBS News and talks about how miserable her life is and how gays can be miserable with her. And then we go ahead to 2024. Here is where Nancy starts to turn. No longer is she an advocate for gay, lesbian, trans equality, but she is radicalized against trans women. Trans women are not women. She's pissed about this. Now she's going after them. The campaign that sort of culminates when I discussed earlier about how she wants to like be a dick monitor in the women's bathrooms. She's so scared of having trans men in the bathroom. So she wants to really do cup checks herself. And I notice that she never wants to be on the receiving end of a cup check, but I wouldn't want to suggest that. I'm just, just saying it's the jury's still out. She's going to throw around accusations. You never know. So she's mad. She's mad at Sarah McBride, she's mad at trans women. She's just, she goes from like kind of tweeting pride flags to like being a one person bulldog going after trans women. But during this process, she gets chastised by this guy. Brad Palumbo is like a right wing gay saying about how he's disappointed in her. And Nancy replies to Brad, Brad, you're barking at the wrong tree. You're 100 wrong. I voted for gay marriage twice, in fact. And I would do it again, but that doesn't mean your balls have the right to be in my bathroom. Fair enough, I guess. And I don't quite get it. I mean, there are like gender neutral bathrooms everywhere. I mean, I've been to gender a lot of gender neutral bathrooms, so it's like, not that, you know, again, it feels like a deep obsession with balls in the bathroom that I don't quite get. And it also doesn't really seem like she'd be that cool with like a trans man as a vagina being in her bathroom. But anyway, so she doubles down. No pro gay marriage. Just no balls in the ladies room. Then Funny, this person, Boots, shout out to Boots, replies to her, you're gonna be against gay rights as soon as it becomes socially advantageous. Shout out, Boots. Bam. Bing. And Nancy Mace says, nope. Voted for gay marriage twice, in fact. So that was there November 2024. So not quite a year ago in December, she echoed that. She voted for gay marriage twice. People can dress however they want. Just don't do it to kids. Don't make the government pay for it. Also don't force women to undress in front of men. We have rights. Okay, April 19th, she goes forward once again. I voted for gay marriage twice. This is kind of in a shouting match she has with a gay in a grocery store. Things are unraveling even more. And then we sort of see where this is headed. June 1st. No longer is there the gay South Carolina flag being posted, but it's a gay. It's a American flag. Excuse me, this is my pride flag. America, America, America. I don't like gay pride flags anymore. So I don't like trans people anymore. I don't like gay pride flags anymore. And yesterday this culminates with Adam and Eve, not Adam and Steve. So I think we learned a couple things. Again, Nancy Mace is unhappy and unwell and I don't know, she's running for governor. I'd recommend the people of South Carolina look somewhere else. Even if they're going to put a MAGA person in that I don't like, they should probably put somebody in that is a little bit more, you know, even in the head right now, somebody's a little more balanced because you just never know. And all of this stuff that I just went through, this is all in the last four years. If you elect her governor, who the hell knows what could look like four Years from now, I mean, who the hell know? I mean, she might be gay or totally deranged. Going to execute people. Like, it could be anything. That's not really a place that you want your governor to be. I don't think kind of that level of instability and unpredictability. But I think the other thing that does tell, as Boots pointed out, is that, like, if there's room to go after a group politically, people end up going after them. I saw a poll the other day that had gay marriage approval rating down at like, 54%. It's just one poll. It had been much higher. You know, you can read some of the tea leaves here that there's a little bit more of an open door. There's a handful of people, I think, that were always anti gay and that had, in a way, closeted their anti gay views because it wasn't politically advantageous for a while. And so some of those people, I think, will probably kind of let their freak flag fly again. And then you'll have, you know, political opportunists like Nancy Mace, who knows what is in their heart, but, like, see the way things are going, see if they can get attention for this, you know, see that they can get street cred with the cultural right and, you know, the far right, zoomers and MAGA who are looking for culture warriors, you know, who want to bring us back to the 1950s and. And they might jump on that. And so it's a noteworthy trajectory. It's also just. It also just reveals how insane Nancy Mace is. So, you know, if you're a gay out there, don't get too. Don't get. Don't get too upset over old Nancy Mace. It's a sad person, and I wish, I think for her sake, we could just roll back the clock to that beautiful day and June of 2021 when she wanted to celebrate overcoming challenges with her friends in the LGBTQ community and get together and be merry and gay and have a low country boil and enjoy life. But I don't think she's going to get that. So good luck in your future endeavors, Nancy Mace. Everybody else, subscribe to the feed. We'll be keeping you posted on entertaining and depressing and enlightening and informative things that are happening in our political life, as always, right here at the Bulwark. See y.
Podcast: Bulwark Takes
Episode: A Breakdown of Nancy Mace’s Years-Long CRASH OUT
Date: October 30, 2025
Host: Tim Miller
This episode of Bulwark Takes—hosted by Tim Miller—dives deep into the erratic trajectory of Republican Congresswoman Nancy Mace, focusing particularly on her shifting positions on LGBTQ rights over the past several years. Miller explores how Mace's changing stances mirror broader trends within the Republican Party’s cultural politics, highlighting her move from public LGBTQ allyship to adopting culture war rhetoric targeting the very same community she once supported.
Introduction to Nancy Mace’s Flip:
“Fresh off her campaign to do dick checks in the ladies restroom at the Capitol, Nancy Mace has flip flopped, and now she’s against gay marriage ... Oh boy, you’re really digging deep. Oh, my feelings are so hurt.”
(00:22)
Personal Reflection:
“Nancy Mace is mentally unwell ... I don’t think it says anything about my happy family that Nancy Mace is throwing stones at it from her broken home.”
(01:14)
“There was, like, this relative truce on gay issues where they dialed in on going after trans folks, dialed in on immigrants, etc. ... that gay truce is sort of ending.”
(03:51)
2021: Allyship
Mace’s pro-LGBTQ statements on Twitter, support for Pride, and her support of the Respect for Marriage Act.
Quote:
“2021. I strongly support LGBTQ rights. No one should be discriminated against ... Religious liberty, gay rights, and transgender equality can all coexist at this point.”
(04:31)
Mace posts a rainbow Pride version of the South Carolina flag, celebrates missing Pride only because of the pandemic, and jokes about marriage equality.
Quote:
“If gay couples want to be as happy or as miserably married as straight couples, more power to them. Trust me on this.”
(05:59)
Memorable/awkward public overshare at a prayer breakfast regarding her fiancé:
2022–2023: Gradual Shift
2024: Anti-Trans Pivot & Hostility
Mace pivots aggressively to anti-trans rhetoric, particularly targeting trans women and bathroom access.
Quote:
“Trans women are not women. She’s pissed about this. Now she’s going after them ... she wants to really do cup checks herself.”
(09:34)
Noteworthy Twitter exchange with Brad Palumbo, a right-wing gay commentator:
Predictive response from a Twitter user (“Boots”):
2025: Open Hostility & Pandering to the Far Right
Warning to South Carolina Voters:
“If you elect her governor, who the hell knows what could look like four years from now ... that’s not really a place you want your governor to be.”
(15:00)
Shifting Polls & Social Acceptance:
Cyclical GOP Strategy:
“If there’s room to go after a group politically, people end up going after them.”
(16:05)
This summary captures Miller’s sardonic, irreverent tone and the episode’s sharp critique of both Mace and broader GOP culture war strategies, marking it as both an analysis of a political figure and a cautionary tale for political and cultural observers.