Bulwark Takes: Elon is Destroying his Tesla Empire!
Released on March 18, 2025, "Bulwark Takes" delves into the rapid decline of Tesla's market dominance, attributing much of the fallout to Elon Musk's controversial leadership and strategic missteps. Hosts Tim Miller and guest JVL provide a comprehensive analysis of Tesla's current predicament, backed by recent financial reports, market trends, and competitive pressures.
1. JP Morgan's Alarming Report on Tesla's Decline
The episode kicks off with Tim Miller highlighting a significant analyst report from JP Morgan that paints a dire picture for Tesla. According to Tim, JP Morgan stated:
"We struggle to think of anything analogous in the history of the automotive industry in which a brand has lost so much value so quickly." ([01:43])
This report forecasts an unprecedented drop in Tesla's sales, projecting first-quarter deliveries to plummet by nearly 20%, from an estimated 444,000 new vehicles to 355,000. Tim emphasizes the speed and severity of this decline:
"Just like think about how quick that that dip is." ([04:30])
2. Elon Musk's Polarizing Influence on the Tesla Brand
JVL delves into the reasons behind Tesla's spiraling fortunes, pinpointing Elon Musk's contentious public persona and political engagements as major factors. He notes:
"Elon Musk is basically gone on a tear where he is told at least half of America that he hates them." ([02:37])
This antagonistic stance has alienated a significant portion of Tesla's customer base, particularly in Europe. JVL cites a staggering poll from Germany where:
"94% of Germans said that they are not interested in buying a Tesla." ([03:40])
His comments underscore the erosion of Tesla’s brand loyalty, especially in its largest markets like California, where sales have reportedly dropped by 40% over the past three months.
3. The Plummet of Tesla's Stock and Secondary Market Value
The conversation shifts to Tesla's financial struggles, with both hosts expressing concern over the drastic fall in stock prices. JVL remarks:
"Tesla's down almost half. Half. I'm thinking about the old Eddie Murphy routine..." ([05:23])
The stock has plummeted from a high of $488 to approximately $228, signaling a loss of investor confidence. Additionally, the secondary market for Tesla vehicles is suffering:
"Depreciation reveals all. ... The prices on the secondary market ... are in the toilet." ([03:38])
This depreciation not only affects Tesla’s reputation but also leaves current owners grappling with significant losses should they attempt to sell their vehicles.
4. Rising Competition in the Electric Vehicle (EV) Market
Tim introduces the escalating competition within the EV sector, particularly from Chinese manufacturers like BYD, which claims to have developed technology allowing EVs to charge in about five minutes—a stark contrast to Tesla’s longer charging times. He states:
"China's BYD ... is trying to jump onto this right now." ([12:08])
JVL adds that:
"EV startups can go from zero to one pretty fast. ... The moat for Tesla in the EV space is nothing like the moat that Ford, GM, and Toyota enjoyed in the ICE space." ([09:26])
This surge in competition is not just limited to China but also includes established brands like Hyundai, Cadillac, and Polestar, all vying to erode Tesla’s market share with innovative models and aggressive marketing strategies.
5. The Burden on Tesla Owners Amid Declining Value
The hosts empathetically discuss the plight of Tesla owners who are now facing the brunt of the company's decline. Tim shares a personal anecdote:
"My buddy ... bought a Tesla about five years ago. ... he's stuck with this thing. ... it's a burden for poor Tesla owners." ([10:47])
JVL echoes these sentiments, highlighting the frustration among owners who find their vehicles depreciating rapidly and associating Tesla cars with negative cultural stigmas:
"They don't want to be driving a Nazi mobile ... people, you know, throwing up sea guy's at them." ([09:26])
6. Future Prospects and Potential Solutions for Tesla
Despite the grim outlook, the discussion touches on potential avenues for Tesla's survival. JVL suggests that government contracts might offer a lifeline, given Elon Musk's connections. However, Tim counters with:
"At some point isn't he going to be forced to like go to work maybe?" ([07:14])
They ponder whether internal pressures, such as shareholder revolts, could compel Musk to refocus on Tesla's core business. Yet, JVL remains skeptical about Musk's ability to steer the company back to stability:
"I'm not convinced that Elon showing up to Tesla is going to make Tesla's cars better." ([07:33])
7. Conclusion: A Brand in Free Fall
The episode wraps up with a consensus that Tesla’s brand is in free fall, exacerbated by Elon Musk’s divisive leadership and the mounting competitive threats in the EV market. Tim concludes with a sharp critique of Musk:
"Elon. Suck on an egg." ([12:19])
The hosts reaffirm their commitment to monitoring Tesla’s trajectory, emphasizing the broader implications for the automotive industry and consumer trust.
Key Takeaways:
- Rapid Sales Decline: Tesla is experiencing an unprecedented drop in sales, with projections showing a 20% decrease in quarterly deliveries.
- Brand Damage: Elon Musk's polarizing actions and political affiliations have significantly tarnished Tesla's brand, especially in key markets like Europe and California.
- Financial Struggles: Tesla's stock has halved from its peak, and vehicle depreciation in the secondary market is severely impacting owners.
- Intensifying Competition: The EV market is becoming increasingly crowded with aggressive entrants from China and established automakers innovating rapidly.
- Owner Frustration: Current Tesla owners face financial losses and social stigmas, adding to the company's woes.
- Uncertain Future: Potential solutions like government contracts are overshadowed by internal challenges and fierce competition, leaving Tesla's future in doubt.
Notable Quotes:
- "Tesla's down almost half. Half." — JVL ([05:23])
- "94% of Germans said that they are not interested in buying a Tesla." — Tim Miller ([03:40])
- "Elon. Suck on an egg." — Tim Miller ([12:19])
For More Information: Subscribe to "Bulwark Takes" and stay updated on in-depth analyses of current events and industry trends. Visit The Bulwark for additional resources and discussions.