Bulwark Takes: "JD Vance Lies About Protester Confrontation, Hides Behind 3-Year-Old Daughter" – Detailed Summary
Release Date: March 9, 2025
In this episode of Bulwark Takes, The Bulwark team delves into Vice President Jesse Donald Vance's recent controversial account of a confrontation with protesters in Cincinnati. Hosts dissect Vance's narrative, scrutinize his political maneuvers concerning Ukraine, and expose perceived hypocrisies in his rhetoric.
1. Accusations Against JD Vance’s Protester Confrontation
Speaker A launches the discussion by condemning Vice President JD Vance for fabricating a victim narrative involving his three-year-old daughter during a protest in Cincinnati. The critique begins immediately at the episode's start:
"Our Vice president, Jesse Donald Vance is playing the pretend victim again on social media to try to torque people. And this one is one of the more abominable efforts yet." [00:00]
Speaker A challenges the veracity of Vance's statement that protesters were trailing him and his daughter, emphasizing the inappropriateness of using a child in such a scenario:
"If you're chasing a three-year-old as part of a political protest, you are a shit person." [04:00]
2. Impact of Vance’s Policies on Ukraine
The hosts shift focus to Vance's foreign policy decisions, specifically his role in halting intelligence sharing with Ukraine. Speaker A underscores the detrimental effects of this move on Ukrainian civilians, particularly children:
"JD Vance and his daddy, Donald Trump paused intelligence sharing with Ukraine because of the temper tantrum that they had in the White House. And the ramifications of this have been unbelievable." [02:00]
An interview with Kaitlyn Robertson from Kiev is cited to highlight the urgent needs in Ukraine exacerbated by the lack of intelligence support. Additionally, insights from the Institute for the Study of War are mentioned, detailing Russia’s intensified military campaigns due to insufficient Ukrainian defense capabilities.
3. Hypocrisy in Emotional Manipulation
A significant portion of the episode critiques Vance's stance on emotional manipulation. Speaker A draws parallels between Vance's accusations against Ro Khanna and his own use of his daughter to garner sympathy:
"JD called that emotional manipulation, then said that Roe was hiding behind the kids and he was committing emotional manipulation. And, like, here he is, like, just shamelessly doing the exact same fucking thing." [03:30]
The hypocrisy is further illustrated by highlighting Vance's failure to provide the necessary support to Ukraine, contrasting his private actions with his public accusations.
4. Reality Check: Debunking Vance’s Narrative
The podcast presents evidence contradicting Vance’s portrayal of the protest. Speaker A references a video clip where protester Ann Henry outright denies any pursuit of Vance and his daughter:
"One of those protesters, Ann Henry, talked to WCPO News in Cincinnati and said this is just all lies. Nobody was chasing him." [04:46]
This segment aims to expose Vance's alleged fabrication, reinforcing the argument that he is manipulating the narrative for political gain.
5. Vance’s Defensive Stance on Russia’s Aggression
Further analysis is provided on Vance's reluctance to unequivocally condemn Russia. Speaker A points out Vance's tendency to entertain alternative explanations about Russia’s actions, likely to appease certain political factions:
"JD cannot just acknowledge that Russia is the bad guy and they're consistently the bad guy and they are the ones that have been infringing on other people's territory." [05:27]
This section underscores the tension between Vance’s public statements and the reality of Russia's aggressive maneuvers in Ukraine.
6. Conclusion: Holding Vice President Vance Accountable
The episode concludes by reiterating the critical view of Vice President Vance’s actions and statements. Speaker A emphasizes the discrepancy between Vance’s portrayal of himself as a victim and his political actions undermining Ukrainian support:
"That is our vice president. That's what he did this weekend, I guess. Shit Posted." [05:36]
The hosts call for listeners to remain vigilant and critical of Vance's narratives, advocating for accountability and truthfulness in political discourse.
Notable Quotes:
- "Our Vice president, Jesse Donald Vance is playing the pretend victim again on social media..." [00:00]
- "If you're chasing a three-year-old as part of a political protest, you are a shit person." [04:00]
- "JD Vance and his daddy, Donald Trump paused intelligence sharing with Ukraine..." [02:00]
- "JD called that emotional manipulation... doing the exact same fucking thing." [03:30]
- "Nobody was chasing him." [04:46]
- "JD cannot just acknowledge that Russia is the bad guy..." [05:27]
- "That is our vice president. That's what he did this weekend, I guess. Shit Posted." [05:36]
This comprehensive analysis by Bulwark Takes provides listeners with an in-depth examination of Vice President JD Vance's recent actions and statements, highlighting inconsistencies and potential ulterior motives. By incorporating direct quotes and timestamped references, the episode ensures clarity and substantiates its critiques, offering a valuable perspective for those seeking to understand the nuances of current political narratives.