Bulwark Takes: Mitch McConnell Can’t Save Himself From His Legacy

Release Date: February 15, 2025

In this compelling episode of Bulwark Takes, hosted by Sam Stein alongside political analysts Sarah Longwell and Bill Kristol, the discussion centers on the enduring legacy of former Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell. The episode delves deep into McConnell’s recent political actions, health concerns, and the broader implications for the Republican Party and American politics.

1. McConnell’s Landmark Vote Against RFK Jr. [01:26]

The episode begins with Sam Stein highlighting a recent pivotal moment: Mitch McConnell's decision to vote against the confirmation of RFK Jr. to a high-profile position. This move positions McConnell as the sole Republican senator opposing multiple cabinet nominees, including Tulsi Gabbard and Pete Hegseth.

Sam Stein [01:26]: "Mitch McConnell voted against RFK Jr. Put out a statement noting that he is a survivor of polio and that he believes that people who question the efficacy of vaccines do not deserve the public's trust..."

This solitary vote raises critical questions about McConnell's current influence and the shifting dynamics within the Republican caucus.

2. McConnell’s Diminished Health and Its Impact [02:26]

A political analyst joins the conversation to discuss McConnell’s declining health, noting that his physical limitations—such as being in a wheelchair and experiencing falls—reflect his waning capacity to wield power as he once did.

Political Analyst [02:26]: "He's in a wheelchair. He is much diminished. He's had some falls, he's had some freezing episodes..."

This deterioration is contrasted with his earlier years as a formidable Senate leader, suggesting that his ability to lead and influence may no longer be what it once was.

3. The Legacy of Leadership and Missed Opportunities [04:23]

The discussion shifts to McConnell’s legacy, particularly his role following the January 6th events and the impeachment of former President Trump. The analyst questions whether McConnell should be viewed as a tragic figure who failed to steer the Republican Party away from destructive paths.

Political Analyst [04:23]: "Is he worthy of our sort of disgrace? Is he disgraced now? And so he just, in his moment of disgrace, is he facing that by being the lone Republican vote?"

Sam Stein acknowledges the complexity of McConnell's legacy, recognizing both his contributions and the significant missteps that have marred his reputation.

4. Institutionalism vs. Lust for Power [07:45]

A critical analysis is offered on McConnell's self-perception as an institutionalist versus the reality of his actions that may have undermined the very institutions he purportedly sought to protect. The decline of Congress and the overpowering of the presidency are cited as direct consequences of McConnell’s strategic choices.

Sam Stein [12:39]: "He leaves or will be leaving office with the institution of Congress greatly diminished. Right. Like here we have a situation where Donald Trump has basically decided he doesn't really care what Congress does..."

The conversation posits that McConnell’s pursuit of power may have led to the erosion of Senate norms and the strengthening of presidential authority to an unprecedented degree.

5. Personal Character and Political Accountability [16:00]

The dialogue turns personal as the hosts and analysts assess McConnell’s character and accountability. They argue that his decisions, particularly his reluctance to whip votes against Trump post-January 6th, have had lasting negative effects on the Republican Party and American democracy.

Political Analyst [16:00]: "He has made a series of bad choices for power that he knew were wrong for the Republican Party, that he knew were wrong for the country."

This segment underscores the sentiment that McConnell bears significant responsibility for the party’s current challenges and the broader political landscape.

6. The Erosion of Moderate Republican Influence [17:45]

The discussion critiques the diminishing role of moderate Republicans like Susan Collins and Lisa Murkowski. The hosts express disappointment in these senators for not leveraging their influence to counteract more extreme elements within the party.

Political Analyst [17:45]: "I would like to say that the moderate block in the Senate of Republicans just did not show at all. We should absolutely defeat Susan Collins..."

This point emphasizes the loss of centrist voices within the GOP and the consequent shift towards more polarized politics.

7. Conclusion: A Legacy in Question [19:00]

As the episode wraps up, the hosts reflect on whether Mitch McConnell can salvage his legacy amidst the current political turmoil. They consider whether his final actions will be viewed as attempts at moral clarity or as too little, too late in addressing the party’s trajectory.

Sam Stein [19:00]: "This just comes down to January 6th. It's like some horrible, horrible trauma happened to our body politic... And that's why we're here."

The episode concludes with a sober assessment of McConnell’s place in history, questioning if his recent votes and statements will redefine his long-term legacy or if they will be overshadowed by past decisions.

Notable Quotes

• Sam Stein [01:26]: "Mitch McConnell can't save himself from his legacy."
• Political Analyst [04:55]: "He did a lot to break down the norms of civility of the body of the Senate..."
• Sam Stein [07:55]: "If you have truth serum or if we just sort of were being honest about it, McConnell's votes probably represent where, what, a quarter to a third of the Republican Senate caucuses, for sure."
• Political Analyst [09:50]: "It's never too late to do the right thing."
• Sam Stein [16:00]: "If you're responsible for Trump, other than Trump himself and the voters who support him, it's McConnell."

Final Thoughts

This episode of Bulwark Takes offers a thorough and nuanced examination of Mitch McConnell’s political career and legacy. Through a detailed discussion of his recent actions, health issues, and the broader implications for the Republican Party, the hosts provide listeners with an insightful analysis of one of the most influential figures in contemporary American politics. Whether viewed as a tragic figure or an ignominious leader, McConnell's decisions have undeniably shaped the current political landscape, leaving a legacy that continues to be debated and scrutinized.