More Elon Baby Mama Drama! War Explodes Between Musk and Ashley St. Clair

Summary

Bulwark Takes Episode Summary: "More Elon Baby Mama Drama! War Explodes Between Musk and Ashley St. Clair"

Release Date: April 1, 2025
Host: Tim Miller
Guest: Will Sommer, Author of the False Flag Newsletter
Duration: 10:08

---

Introduction to the Elon Musk and Ashley St. Clair Drama

In this episode of Bulwark Takes, host Tim Miller delves into the escalating drama between entrepreneur Elon Musk and Ashley St. Clair, a right-wing influencer who has publicly claimed to be Musk's fourth "baby mama." The discussion aims to unravel the complexities of their public dispute, its implications, and the broader context within which it unfolds.

Elon Musk’s Alleged Paternity and Public Claims

Tim Miller initiates the conversation by highlighting the widespread attention surrounding Elon Musk’s alleged paternity issues, stating, “There is a lot of Elon baby mama drama happening” (00:00). To gain deeper insights, Tim brings in Will Sommer, an expert in monitoring such disputes.

Will Sommer provides background on Ashley St. Clair, describing her as a "right-wing Internet personality" known for authoring a conservative children's book and being a prominent figure in certain online circles (00:54). Sommer explains that Ashley publicly declared her relationship with Elon Musk, stating, “Yes, I had a baby with Elon Musk. I will not be discussing it further” (00:54). This declaration has sparked a contentious paternity and custody battle.

Elon Musk’s Response and Legal Maneuvering

The conversation shifts to Elon Musk's response to the allegations. Will Sommer points out the peculiarity of Musk’s stance, noting, “How is it possible that he doesn't know if it's his kid or not?” (01:51). Musk’s tweet to Laura Loomer, a known conspiracy theorist and MAGA influencer, suggested uncertainty about paternity while affirming his commitment to support the child regardless (00:54).

Will Sommer further elaborates on Musk’s financial involvement, indicating that Musk has already contributed significantly to the child’s welfare by purchasing a condo and investing “hundreds of thousands of dollars” (01:57). However, Ashley alleges that Musk isn’t providing sufficient support, which adds fuel to the ongoing dispute.

Right-Wing Backlash and Public Perception

The episode explores the reaction from the right-wing community, where prominent figures like Laura Loomer have turned against Ashley St. Clair. Tim Miller references a MAGA supporter criticizing Ashley for receiving substantial financial support from Musk, saying, “he's giving her 500,000 and also a 2 and 2.5 million” (03:04). This backlash highlights a split within conservative circles about Musk’s influence and support.

Will Sommer draws attention to the disproportionate criticism Ashley faces compared to other public figures, stating, “you have this guy who is saying, you know, we need to increase the birth rate... and yet he has maybe the most baroque family life” (07:56). The discussion underscores the inconsistencies within conservative rhetoric regarding family values and personal responsibility.

Comparison to Other Family Issues Involving Elon Musk

Tim Miller transitions to discussing Elon Musk’s other family dynamics, particularly his relationship with Grimes, his third "baby mama." Despite previous tensions, such as Grimes "shitposting" Musk over personal disputes, the tone has shifted towards defense and understanding (03:23). This contrast highlights the volatile nature of Musk’s personal relationships and their public manifestations.

Will Sommer adds that Musk's interactions with his children, including his trans daughter, have been sources of public friction. Musk’s confrontation with streamer Hasan Piker over the interview with his daughter exemplifies the challenges he faces in managing his family life under the public eye (05:12).

Broader Implications on Conservatism and Family Values

The podcast delves into the broader implications of Musk’s family issues on conservative culture. Tim Miller reflects on the value placed on parenting within conservative circles, suggesting that while criticism of "deadbeat dads" is common, there seems to be a "blind spot" when it comes to high-profile figures like Musk (07:02).

Will Sommer counters by pointing out the paradox in conservative advocacy for increased birth rates versus Musk’s complicated family life, proposing that this reflects deeper contradictions within the movement (07:56). The conversation briefly touches upon the allure of ancient social structures like polygamy, indicating a possible shift towards more traditional and hierarchical family models influenced by extremist ideologies (08:54).

Conclusion and Future Outlook

As the episode wraps up, Tim Miller acknowledges the ongoing nature of the dispute and the likelihood of future developments, stating, “any moment now, another baby mama might pop up” (09:39). Will Sommer concurs, emphasizing the need to stay informed as the situation evolves (10:08). The discussion underscores the intersection of personal drama, public persona, and political ideology in shaping the narrative around Elon Musk and Ashley St. Clair.

Notable Quotes:

• Tim Miller: “There is a lot of Elon baby mama drama happening” (00:00)
• Will Sommer: “Ashley St. Clair is a sort of right wing Internet personality” (00:54)
• Will Sommer: “He’s saying we need to increase the birth rate... yet he has maybe the most baroque family life” (07:56)
• Tim Miller: “You can check the stocks” (05:12)
• Will Sommer: “This is somewhat of a predictable outcome if you followed Elon’s other family issues” (01:57)

Key Takeaways:

1. Public Paternity Battle: Elon Musk and Ashley St. Clair are embroiled in a highly publicized paternity and custody dispute, with significant financial and social implications.
2. Conservative Criticism: The right-wing community is divided, with some defending Musk while others criticize Ashley for alleged financial support.
3. Complex Family Dynamics: Musk’s interactions with his other family members, including Grimes and his trans daughter, add layers to the public’s perception of his personal life.
4. Conservatism and Family Values: The episode highlights the contradictions within conservative ideologies regarding family support and personal responsibility.

For listeners interested in the intricate dynamics of high-profile personal disputes and their intersection with political and social ideologies, this episode of Bulwark Takes offers a comprehensive analysis backed by expert insights.

Transcript

[Tim Miller]

Hey guys, it's Tim Miller from the Bulwark. There is a lot of Elon baby mama drama happening. I've seen this, like, in my peripheral vision on social media and with jokes people have been making to me in their text chain. But I've not been able to really understand the details and rather than waste my time going deep into the replies of Elon Musk's X account. But the better thing to do is bring in Will Sommer, author of the False Flag newsletter, who monitors this stuff for a living. So, Will, where are we at? Elon, I guess the thing that I've most seen is that is that the woman, Ashley St. Clair, who is the alleged baby mama four, who is a MAGA influencer. Elon tweeted at Laura Loomer, a conspiracy theorist, saying that he doesn't even know if that is his child, but he's going to pay for for it anyway. That's all I know. Take me from there.

[Will Sommer]

Yeah. You know, that's traditional Family court Judge Laura Loomer. Traditionally, this is how we hash out custody cases. Yeah. So Ashley St. Clair is a sort of right wing Internet personality. She wrote a conservative children's book. She's kind of like a just a figure. And so that's why a few months ago I was, I think, like a lot of people, I was surprised when she posted a thing that was like, statement, yes, I had a baby with Elon Musk. You know, no, I will not be discussing it further. And since then, it, what I think was initially people were saying, why are you like, putting this all out there? And they were saying, well, you know, we can't get in touch with Elon. We got this baby. And so this has since then become kind of a, an ugly paternity fight. You know, she claims Elon isn't giving her enough money to take care of the kid, which as we know, is one of many kids he has.

[Tim Miller]

I'm selling it because I need to make up for the 60% cut that Elon made to our son's childhood.

[Will Sommer]

And so that's sort of where we're at. But it's all playing out in this really sort of bizarre way online.

[Tim Miller]

How is it possible that he doesn't know if it's his kid or not? I guess would be the question.

[Will Sommer]

That was an odd one, right, that he's sort of implying, you know, it could be someone else's kid. We don't know. We know, obviously in the past he's had kids through ivf, which you would think would make the paternity pretty clear. I don't think we know how this baby was conceived. I mean, we want to get into it, but basically he's. He, Ashley Sinclair and him are now locked in this, this sort of child support battle. And so perhaps he's saying this to, you know, try to get out of paying the child support. He said he's already, you know, he's bought her a condo. He's paid hundreds of thousands of dollars for the kid. And so this is also creating this dynamic on the right where a lot of people, these right wing personalities you mentioned, Laura Loomer, are saying, you know, Ashley, you're a gold digger. They're turning on her.

[Tim Miller]

Yeah, I saw one MAGA guy I follow, you know, kind of saying that, oh, he's, he's giving her 500,000 and, and also a 2 and 2.5 million. Like 500,000 a year and 2.5 million up front or something. And like, that seems like kind of a lot to me, like, like siding with Elon. Like, this woman is getting too much money from the richest in the world.

[Will Sommer]

For Elon, that's 500,000 is half of one vote in Wisconsin.

[Tim Miller]

Great point.

[Will Sommer]

The Supreme Court race. So. So, yeah, I mean, she's saying she wants more and she's saying she's. He's basically ab. You know, their family, such as it is. You know, this is somewhat of a predictable outcome if you followed Elon's other family issues, but there it is.

[Tim Miller]

Speaking of his other family issues. So the previous baby mama, Grimes. We don't accept negative words about Grimes on this podcast. Personal preference. We love. We love and honor Grimes. She's been. She was kind of shitposting Elon for a little while because he wasn't like, replying to her because they had a hospital appointment with a kid or something. And there's another point where she's kind of shit posting him over his attacks on Western civilization or something. And then I guess maybe he's come to his defense now.

[Will Sommer]

So.

[Tim Miller]

So what's happening with Baby Mama three?

[Will Sommer]

Well, I mean, right. I mean, this moment, it was so bizarre. I mean, it was sort of right when Elon was taking over Doge and she's tweeting at him, you know, hey, Elon, you know, why don't you, like, our child is having a medical emergency. I'm sorry to be tweeting this on the website you own, but this is the only way to get in touch with you. And that was the same night he was doing the Thing with the chainsaw and waving it around, wearing the video game shirt.

[Tim Miller]

This is the chainsaw for bureaucracy.

[Will Sommer]

Chainsaw. I think this is, needless to say, a guy with kind of a complicated paternity history. The other thing I should say is the reason that Ashley Sinclair stuff is back in the news originally is because she sold her Tesla. So, you know, for Elon, that's like the ultimate. She sold her Tesla to Carvana and she had, I think a very clearly staged.

[Tim Miller]

As a protest.

[Will Sommer]

Yes. Well, she's saying, look how poor I am. Elon has, has immiserated me. I have to sell my Tesla. And so the Daily Mail was there to see the Tesla towed off. So, I mean, the idea. Clearly she tipped them off to get some publicity here for her child custody case or her paternity case. But I mean, it is, you know, she was saying, well, you know, who knows how much money I could get from him? Obviously his stock is in the dumps.

[Tim Miller]

You can check the stocks. I am, I'm not the only one. His oldest child is trans and has been speaking out against him again a little bit more recently. So I don't, I don't know if that's attached to any of this, but it does seem to be something that he is that. That impacts him.

[Will Sommer]

Yeah, we've had to learn a lot about Elon's kids, maybe more than I would have expected a few years ago. I mean, of course there's also the one he takes the White House and, and who sometimes hangs out with Trump sans Elon, you know, and obviously he's gotten very mad about this trans daughter of his. He got really mad at the streamer Hasan Piker, who I believe interviewed the trans daughter. And so he really has this habit and I don't know if it's deliberate or not. It's sort of playing out this family drama online.

[Tim Miller]

Yeah, I was going to say just test this out for me. Maybe call your daughter. I don't know, just throwing that one out there. Just an idea for viewers who are watching who maybe have an estranged family member. Sometimes it's not fixable. I understand that, but certainly I would say on the kind of hierarchy of options, shitposting about them on your social media platform seems suboptimal as compared to like, I don't know, calling her, calling a couple of the baby mamas, checking in, seeing if the kids have any doctor's appointments, seeing if they need any money. And that seems to be, you know, preferable. But that's not really his style.

[Will Sommer]

Yeah, you really don't want the, you know, for example, in the Grimes case to be in a position where, you know, the mother of one of your children has to tweet at you like, hey, our kid is going to the hospital for an emergency, maybe cut it out with. And, you know, there's also a guy who is video gaming, we're to believe, you know, two thirds of the day. So maybe a little less Diablo, maybe a little more parenting.

[Tim Miller]

Yeah, you'd almost, you know, for me, Will, you know, your backstory is a little different than mine, but, you know, my people attacking deadbeat dads, it's a pretty common thing, you know, in conservative culture growing up. And there's something to that. I guess at certain times there was maybe some, you know, racist undertones to it. But as a general principle, attacking people that don't parent their own child, maybe not attacking them, but criticizing people that don't parent their own child for selfish reasons, I think is probably a noble position in society, that we should honor people that actually parent their child, children, rather than those that abandon them. And that kind of element, that strain of conservatism, is that completely lost, or do you see that in critiques of Elon coming from the right?

[Will Sommer]

No, I mean, to be frank. I mean, it is interesting. You have this guy who is saying, you know, we need to. Well, he's certainly increasing the birth rate. He's saying we need to increase the birth rate. You know, America, Western. Western values has to have to. You know, we have to shore these up. And yet he has maybe the most baroque family life of, like, any public figure in America. And so, you know, you have this situation. If anything, I've seen, you know, a lot more people on the right going after Ashley Sinclair, who is a relatively blameless figure here. You know, they dug up these old messages where she was saying to her friends, like, oh, my gosh, Elon's messaging me, you know, I want to have his baby, or, you know, what have you. Which strikes me as kind of just girl talk. But they're. These are being treated as, like, the. The smoking gun that, you know, she entrapped innocent Elon, who, you know, incidentally, does have kids all over the place anyway.

[Tim Miller]

Yeah. The reject modernity, embrace tradition trad Catholic crowd that does seem to have a little bit of a blind spot.

[Will Sommer]

Well, to that end, it's funny you bring that up. I mean, I think perhaps this is more of a, like, really trad, like, going back to, like, ancient Greece.

[Tim Miller]

Polygamy.

[Will Sommer]

Or polygamy, yes. We're going to have more of a, like a warlord type system. Chieftain.

[Tim Miller]

That's interesting. Well, that's something I considered. It's, it's uber traditional. Like, you know, we're going to go back. We're going to go way back, you know, and not back to the 50s, maybe, or, you know, the, the 1550s.

[Will Sommer]

The 550s.

[Tim Miller]

The 550s.

[Will Sommer]

I mean, you know, like, there's that guy, Bronze Age pervert who's like a very, you know. Yeah. And he's like a very, you know, influential figure in the, you know, in terms of the kind of the young, who the young Trump administration figures read. And I mean. Yeah, that's a guy who's talking about, you know, going back to the Bronze Age.

[Tim Miller]

All right. Well, it's, you know, we all wish that we didn't have to care about this. We all wish that we didn't have to care about this. But as long as he's the shadow president, I do think it speaks a little bit to, into the mindset of the right and what is happening on where the right is going. So I appreciate that you're following it for us. And who knows, any moment now, another baby mama might pop up. And so we'll make sure to keep people posted.

[Will Sommer]

Absolutely.