Loading summary
Blinds.com Narrator
The right window treatments change everything. Your sleep, your privacy, the way every room looks and feels. @blinds.com, we've spent 30 years making it surprisingly simple to get exactly what your home needs. We've covered over 25 million windows and have 50,000 five star reviews to prove we deliver. Whether you DIY it or want a pro to handle everything from measure to install, we have you covered. Real design professionals, free samples, zero pressure right now. Get up to 40% off site wide plus get a free professional measure@blinds.com rules and restrictions apply.
Tim Miller
Hey y'. All, Tim Miller from the Bulwark here. I woke up on the west coast to just you love it when you
Podcast Co-host
take out your phone and there's something that brings you joy in the morning that's so rare these days, that's so often that you're doom scrolling. And I like to joy scroll. And that happened for me because Slayer Pete Buttigieg was on CNBC's Squawk Box.
Tim Miller
If you don't know that show, it's
Podcast Co-host
the morning financial show.
Tim Miller
It's kind of like the Fox and Friends of cnbc. And you know, it's not, it's not
Podcast Co-host
like Fox and Friends in the sense that it's all right wingers. There is a single person that kind
Tim Miller
of reflects the doocy view on Squonk Box.
Podcast Co-host
His name is Joe Kernan. He and Pete got into it on the state of the economy, the war
Tim Miller
in Iran, and it was delicious.
Podcast Co-host
I've already on social media offered to
Tim Miller
welcome both of them to the Bulwark
Podcast Co-host
YouTube page where hopefully they could do a longer version. Like I want to see. I want to see like a Joe
Tim Miller
Rogan podcast length engagement between Kernan and Buttigieg. Give me three hours, I can host it.
Podcast Co-host
I'll just kind of just fade into the background and let them go. Just kind of direct the conversation. We'll see if they take me up on that.
Tim Miller
But if you have not had this joy yet, or even if you had
Podcast Co-host
already and just want a second helping, I figured we should go through some of the highlights of Pete showing how you do it when you know you're arguing with somebody that's trying their best to rationalize their support of Donald Trump and maga. Just really quick, before we go into it, please subscribe to the feed. Help us out here. We're trying to get up to 2 million subscribers.
Tim Miller
And also, like, part of the reason
Podcast Co-host
why I'm showing this is I've been
Tim Miller
on this like the Democrats in this moment. Donald Trump is Vulnerable.
Podcast Co-host
The arguments of people on his side
Tim Miller
are as weak as they've ever been.
Podcast Co-host
The Democrats need to be going into more challenging spaces. Something that I'm trying to do myself, but that I like, that you need actual Democratic politicians doing. And so I want to, you know, give out candy to the ones who are doing it right. And Pete is obviously, like, the prime example of this. So let's watch this together. We'll play some of the highlights from Pete and Joe Kernan.
Joe Kernan
I understand that.
Pete Buttigieg
And look, I'm saying this to somebody who knows what it's like to be sent to war by a US President. And when a president sends you to war, when you and your buddies are on that gray tail plane going into a war zone, you do it with some level of confidence, some level of assurance that your chain of command. All the president of the United States.
Joe Kernan
Doesn't even sound like this. Now that we're there, do you hope this has a successful outcome? There were 40,000 Iranians that were slaughtered by the same regime. 47 years of killing Americans, stirring trouble all around the world.
Pete Buttigieg
And how do you feel about that regime being left intact by this president?
Joe Kernan
Be the case. And I don't know what might happen.
Tim Miller
All right, so, like, right before this clip, just to give you guys the
Podcast Co-host
context, like, Pete is making the case against the war and why it's stupid. And Kernan is trying to interject and do the thing that these guys do, which is like, oh, you're rooting against
Tim Miller
the country like, you want us to. Like, our soldiers are so good. Why don't you respect the troops and the soldiers? And Pete's like, fuck you. I was a soldier. I was a trip.
Podcast Co-host
I know what it's like to go over there.
Tim Miller
And I wouldn't have wanted to be sent to a war zone for something where the leadership in charge didn't have a plan for success or didn't have a clear rationale for doing it or hadn't thought through some of the obvious contingencies, like the closing of the Strait of Hormuz. This is obvious. And so I think Pete, like, having
Podcast Co-host
credibility there is very important. I think it's pretty telling that Kernan, like, falls back on this. Like, don't you want us to succeed?
Tim Miller
Don't you want America to succeed? You know, like Pete's counter.
Podcast Co-host
That is pretty good. It was just like, well, like, we haven't succeeded. The regime is still intact.
Tim Miller
I would kind of add on on top of that.
Podcast Co-host
Like, yeah, America succeeding means not starting dumbass wars that make Us weaker economically and geopolitically alienate our foes. Like, you know, that is this is not the path to success. Like, this is the path to fucking ruin. Like, yeah, I want America to succeed. Don't you want America to succeed? If you want America to succeed, why are you on board with this stupid fucking war anyway? Let's. The conversation pivots then more to what
Tim Miller
you expect them to be talking about
Podcast Co-host
on a morning finance show, which is the state of the economy. So let's watch some of that for.
Pete Buttigieg
Is that an argument?
Joe Kernan
So you don't want this to work and it was just a bad move. You want us to pull out now?
Pete Buttigieg
Look, there's no obvious way out now, but I want to make sure that this ends in a way that, first of all, our economy can recover, that we're not paying so much for gas. I mean, right now, oil's 100 bucks. Jet fuels 200 bucks. Gas is over four bucks.
Joe Kernan
Diesel's like average 380. Under Biden for four years.
Pete Buttigieg
And. And when we left, inflation was lower than it is today.
Joe Kernan
You accounted for 21. President pricing. This president took inflation rate, inflation.
Pete Buttigieg
This president more than 3% year on year. You saw the numbers just come out. It's more than 3% year on year.
Joe Kernan
Okay, it is. The math is directly month from 2, 7 to 3%.
Pete Buttigieg
It's higher than when he got here.
Joe Kernan
It's not 9%.
Tim Miller
So Pete begins by talking about the
Podcast Co-host
impact of the war on, on gas prices and, and, you know, the impact on people domestically. And like, that is significant. I mean, gas prices are getting expensive in Louisiana, but damn, I'm here in California and it's like, I don't even know how people who are on out, like, I don't know how working people afford this. I don't know how you afford this. If you have a kind of hourly pay job or if you're on a fixed income as a senior. Like, how do you go places? The gas is already that expensive. And it's only going to get worse.
Tim Miller
I call it.
Podcast Co-host
Catherine Rampel pointed out today that gas prices rose 20% in March in the higher month. This is the single largest monthly increase in gas prices since we began measuring it. The biggest gas price increase since we've been measuring it last month, March, and it's getting worse. And Kernan's response is, well, gas was also expensive under Biden.
Tim Miller
Like, okay, bro, all right, what about now?
Podcast Co-host
What about what we're doing now, Pete? And then go kind of back and forth and they have this kind of crosstalk fight over the inflation numbers. And at the end, Andrew Roth Sorkin, who, if you don't know him, is totally, really down the middle, smart economics reporter, is just like, dude, this is just the math. Like, the math is the math. Inflation is up.
Andrew Ross Sorkin
This piece of it is basic. The president did say that he was, he wanted to be in office to bring inflation down, and he has not brought inflation down.
Pete Buttigieg
That's all.
Podcast Co-host
It's not just that, like Trump hasn't brought prices down. It's like the rate of increase now is up from where it was when Biden left. So I don't know. I mean, some of this stuff, you get into dorky econ talk and it feels like they could have been on an AEI panel hashing this out. Like, I'm not sure this is the most resonant thing with voters, most resident part of the exchange. But like, it's pretty funny that that is like the position of Kernan is so weak, the position of the Trump defenders in the economy is so weak now that like they, they really are forced to resort to.
Tim Miller
But what about 2022?
Podcast Co-host
It's like, well, we'll see how that works.
Pete Buttigieg
And his central campaign promise was he was going to take inflation and drive it down. And instead he's not.
Joe Kernan
I thought in the, it was three
Pete Buttigieg
when he got here and now it's more, it could not be simpler than that.
Joe Kernan
It's around three and we're involved in a war.
Pete Buttigieg
Said on day one it would go down. He came in on day one and now it's up.
Joe Kernan
It's up to 3%. It was 21 and a half percent priced. It would go down four years. Over four years. It was 21 and a half. Democrats own the affordability.
Pete Buttigieg
Listen to me, period. Why did the president fail?
Joe Kernan
You don't think Democrats own the affordability crisis?
Pete Buttigieg
Why did the president fail, fail to keep his promise to lower prices, in your opinion?
Andrew Ross Sorkin
I'm laughing because this is, this, this piece of it is basic. The president did say that he was, he wanted to be in office to bring inflation down, and he has not brought inflation down.
Pete Buttigieg
That's all. He drove it up. He not only failed, he drove it up. Mr. Secretary, let's talk.
Joe Kernan
Have had a minimal. A minimal.
Pete Buttigieg
You tell a family where I live that $1,000 per household is minimal from
Joe Kernan
the 21 1/2% increase that you're the Democrats.
Pete Buttigieg
We can, we can argue all day about just how bad Covid was and how bad it got and what.
Joe Kernan
Okay.
Pete Buttigieg
And all that you call, unless where I live, a thousand bucks per household isn't minimal.
Joe Kernan
Now you found. Now Democrats found religion on inflation after presiding over the worst inflation in 40 years. Now you found it's 2026.
Pete Buttigieg
They're in charge. You guys are in charge. I'm aware you're going to do differently, all right?
Podcast Co-host
I mean, Pete does the job here.
Tim Miller
But like, the funniest part is, the
Podcast Co-host
funniest part is just like the desperate, angry Kernan with like caked on makeup
Tim Miller
on his face being like, democrats own the affordability crisis. Democrats own it. It's just like, man, like a year ago I would have been annoyed by that. Six months ago I might have been
Podcast Co-host
kind of mad about it. And we have to fight on this. We gotta argue. She's like, nobody believes this. Who believes this anymore? Like, only people that are full in the cult and have. And that the Democrats have no chance of ever winning over. Right? Like there's some percentage of Americans that Democrats will never win over. And so those people might be able to soothe themselves and suck on their thumb by being like, the Democrats own this because of what happened after Covid four years ago. But that just isn't how politics works.
Tim Miller
Like, in order to, to win over
Podcast Co-host
people who aren't in your cult, you have to have a explanation for them or a message or a plan. And so just like the Democrats did this all in 2022, it's like, sorry, bro, that's not, that's not going to work.
Sponsor Narrator
Bulwer takes a sponsored by Soul. Now. If you've been listening to our show for a while, you already know how much I love Seoul's out of office THC gummies as well as their sparkling beverages perfect for the summertime. Now they're launching something new. Mood Gummies. Now lately, I've been more mindful about how I want to feel when socializing, winding down or just living my life. Instead of defaulting to a drink and hoping for the best, I've chosen to Sol's new Mood Gummies. Whether I need a little spark to go out or something to settle down at night, they've got the perfect options to make me feel just right. SOL is a wellness brand that makes delicious hemp derived CBD and THC products designed to make feeling good simple. Sol's new Mood Gummies have precise dosing, clean ingredients and formulations designed for predictable effects so you can choose how you want to feel when while staying in control. If you're looking for a bright, social and energizing buzz and who isn't? Go with the uplift gummies. That's 3 milligrams of Sativa THC plus CBG. It's perfect for daytime plans or just beating the afternoon slump. And when it's time to wind down, lamello gummies deliver 3 milligrams of indica, THC and CBN. It's ideal for cozy nights and fully unplugging. Make today a good day. Get yourself some soul gummies. Right now, Seoul is offering our audience 30% off their entire order. 30% off. Go to getsold.com and use the code bulwarktakes. That's getsoul.com promo code bulwarktix for 30% off.
Tim Miller
All right, and then we circle back
Podcast Co-host
to kind of the public opinion part of this. And, and, and whether Kernan's arguments are working. Let's listen to that.
Joe Kernan
We gotta get through this war. And you've heard people get through this war.
Pete Buttigieg
We didn't have to be fighting this war. What are we doing?
Joe Kernan
That's a matter of opinion. You can't say that.
Pete Buttigieg
It's a matter of opinion that I share with most of the Americans and a large number of Republicans and a whole bunch of MAGA people who bought into this president because they actually believe
Joe Kernan
75% Republican approval for the war.
Pete Buttigieg
You don't start with the approval you have within your own party. But the point is, the magical Democrats
Joe Kernan
aren't going to approve anything.
Pete Buttigieg
I'm talking about Americans. Americans disapprove of the president and their right to do so.
Joe Kernan
He's got the same approval rating other presidents have had at this point in the term for a little bit above 42% right now.
Pete Buttigieg
Is unpopular for very good reasons, one of which is no more than Obama
Joe Kernan
was or Biden was at the same term at the same point of his presidency.
Pete Buttigieg
That depends on which polls you're looking at. But by and large, no. I'm sorry, but like, I've been out on the trail. I was in Marjorie Taylor Greene's district. Marjorie Taylor Greene. This is a Trump +38 district. Or it was.
Joe Kernan
I've seen 500 people. You'll get a chance to prove that in November this year.
Pete Buttigieg
We had a chance to prove it last week.
Joe Kernan
The Senate might go. I understand.
Pete Buttigieg
Yeah. Because people are presidents.
Tim Miller
My favorite part about that clip is Pete just going back at him with, we didn't have to be fighting this war. And Joe's like, we got to get through this war. He's like, we didn't have to be fighting it. You can't. You can't do that. Like that. Like, this doesn't work now. Like, this. This shit worked in the first Bush
Podcast Co-host
term with the Iraq war. Like, it stopped working in the second Bush term. This idea that, like, we've got to stand with our men and women in uniform and we got to get through the war and win.
Tim Miller
It's like, nobody knows how we're fighting the war. There was no 9, 11. There was no imminent threat. There was no case made by the president. It's like you started a war that nobody knows why. It was a stupid war. It hasn't been a success. And everybody's feeling pain now. And your message is, well, we got
Podcast Co-host
to get through the war.
Tim Miller
You got to deal with the pain. You got to suck it up. I just. The body language between Pete and Curtin in this section is just so telling. Like, Pete is, like, a little bit
Podcast Co-host
exacerbated, but also laughing and. And. And like always, just very sharp on his points. And Kernan is just huffing and puffing and. And, you know, getting redder. And his body.
Tim Miller
You can feel.
Podcast Co-host
See him tensing. He's tensing. And.
Tim Miller
And it's just because they're.
Podcast Co-host
They don't have it.
Tim Miller
Like, the points are weak.
Podcast Co-host
They got no case to make.
Tim Miller
So, long story short, this isn't your moment to go pick a fight with your MAGA friend.
Podcast Co-host
That's never going to come around.
Tim Miller
Okay, I'm not saying that, but it is a point for Democrats, for commentators like myself, and for you and your life. If you have people that you think are gettable, you think are reasonable, kindly,
Podcast Co-host
softly beginning to engage them in these conversations may be useful.
Tim Miller
Might be a transition period.
Podcast Co-host
We're in.
Tim Miller
You know, I went on a barstool podcast earlier this week, and there's one
Podcast Co-host
Republican guy on there and then one, like, really left guy, and then another guy.
Tim Miller
I don't know if.
Podcast Co-host
I don't know if he actually says
Tim Miller
those politics are, but seems like, like, pretty Democrat.
Podcast Co-host
And.
Tim Miller
And the Republican guy, I was just kind of.
Podcast Co-host
I didn't go at him like, I'm on the Piers Morgan show, like, screaming at these, like, hack pundits.
Tim Miller
Like, you know, he's a sports guy
Podcast Co-host
and he's just a Republican.
Tim Miller
And Sidis was, like, softly, like, asking
Podcast Co-host
some questions, like, what do you.
Tim Miller
What.
Podcast Co-host
What do you like about what's happening?
Tim Miller
Like, what do you think would have been worse from Kamala?
Podcast Co-host
Like, isn't the impact.
Tim Miller
Isn't economic impact?
Podcast Co-host
Like, not worth what we're getting out of the Actions of the Middle east,
Tim Miller
just that kind of stuff.
Podcast Co-host
It's a good time to engage with people because they're. They're out of. They're running out of ammo. And.
Tim Miller
And that's a delicious treat.
Podcast Co-host
All right, one more. Last one. Pete ends with a really strong message on affordability and corruption. That is something that I've been desperate for, for Democrats to really pound. So let's watch that.
Joe Kernan
Presidents make difficult decisions, obviously.
Pete Buttigieg
Yeah. But usually they make difficult decisions to try to make other people better off. This president's made decisions to make himself better off. That's definitely happened. If you're the kind of person who can pay a million bucks for the entry fee to Mar A Lago, then you're doing great. But everybody else is hurting right now, and that's it.
Tim Miller
Like, on top of the fact that people's lives are worse, you know who's still making money? Trump his family. You know, people that can pay the Mar A Lago dues, they're making bank. Well, everybody else is fucking paying $6
Podcast Co-host
gas out in Fresno.
Tim Miller
All right?
Podcast Co-host
So
Tim Miller
that is compelling.
Podcast Co-host
It's something that the people understand. And as usual, Slayer Pete is nailing it. So I hope you enjoyed it. My colleagues will be all around this weekend. We have that big election in Hungary coming up on Sunday, which will be coming. Covering. I'm on a brief vacation. I'll be back on the feed on Tuesday. So we'll see you all then.
Tim Miller
Like I said, subscribe. Heck of a job, Mayor Pete.
Podcast Co-host
See ya.
Tim Miller
Bye.
This episode of Bulwark Takes features host Tim Miller breaking down Pete Buttigieg’s standout appearance on CNBC’s Squawk Box, where Buttigieg went head-to-head with co-host Joe Kernan over the Trump administration’s handling of the economy and the ongoing war in Iran. The episode dissects the exchange, highlighting Buttigieg’s arguments, the weaknesses in the Trump defense, and the broader implications for Democrats entering more adversarial media spaces.
(05:01–10:40)
On Military Service as Credibility:
"Fuck you. I was a soldier. I was a trip. I know what it’s like to go over there." (03:44, Tim Miller paraphrasing Buttigieg)
On Gas Prices and Economic Pain:
"I want to make sure that this ends in a way that, first of all, our economy can recover, that we're not paying so much for gas." (05:07, Pete Buttigieg)
On Affordability and Corruption:
"This president's made decisions to make himself better off...If you’re the kind of person who can pay a million bucks for the entry fee to Mar A Lago, then you’re doing great. But everybody else is hurting right now, and that’s it." (16:15, Pete Buttigieg)
On Political Messaging:
"In order to win over people who aren't in your cult, you have to have a explanation for them or a message or a plan." (10:25, Tim Miller)
"Slayer Pete" demonstrates how to counter weak Trump-era economic and foreign policy arguments in adversarial forums, persistently redirecting the conversation to kitchen-table concerns and the corrupt enrichment of the powerful. Tim Miller urges Democrats to follow Buttigieg’s example, to confidently enter tough spaces, and to offer relatable, credible messages as the vulnerabilities of the Trump camp become increasingly obvious.