Alex Padilla (3:09)

Sir. Sir. Hands up. Hands up. Senator Alex Padilla. I have questions for the secretary because the fact of the matter is a half a dozen violent criminals that you're rotating on your.

Unknown Speaker 4 (3:25)

I also want to.

Alex Padilla (3:28)

How many?

Sarah Longwell (3:34)

On the ground. On the ground. Hands behind your back. Hands behind your back.

Unknown Speaker 2 (3:41)

All right, cool. One hand. Lay flat. Lay flat.

Alex Padilla (3:45)

Other hand, sir.

Unknown Speaker 2 (3:46)

Other hands.

Sarah Longwell (3:54)

There's no recording allowed out here.

Unknown Speaker 2 (3:57)

I did not know. There's no recording allowed out here.

Unknown Speaker 3 (4:00)

The United States Secretary of Homeland Security, Kristi Noem, went on fox news at 3:00pm and told this lie. Quote, he didn't ID himself. Padilla did. So there's that. But he also tried to say before he was manhandled that he was there with questions for the secretary at her press conference. Here's how he described it after a few moments ago.

Alex Padilla (4:25)

Since the beginning of the year, but especially over the course of the last. Over the course of recent weeks, I. Several of my colleagues have been asking the Department of Homeland Security for more information and more answers on their increasingly extreme immigration enforcement actions. And we've gotten little to no information in response to our inquiries. And so I came to the press conference to hear what she had to say, to see if I could learn any new additional information. And at one point, I had a question, and let me emphasize, just as we emphasized, the right for people to peacefully protest and to stand up for their First Amendment rights, for our fundamental rights. I was there peacefully. At one point, I had a question, and so I began to ask a question. I was almost immediately forcibly removed from the room. I was forced to the ground, and I was handcuffed. I will say this. If this is how this administration responds to a senator with a question, if this is how the Department of Homeland Security responds to a senator with a question, you can only imagine what they're doing to farm workers, to cooks, to day laborers out in the Los Angeles community and throughout California and throughout the country, we will hold this administration accountable.

Unknown Speaker 3 (6:15)

If this is how they treat a senator with a question, imagine what they're doing to others. That's the question for all of us right now today. Joining me, Msnbc political analyst, host of the Bulwark podcast, Tim Miller's here. Also joining us, the publisher of the Bulwark and host of the focus group podcast, Sarah Longwell is here. Let me play for all of you. Senator Chris Murphy reacting on the Senate floor.

Chris Murphy (6:45)

Speaking for myself, I don't ask law enforcement to throw my constituents to the.

Unknown Speaker 2 (6:53)

Ground.

Chris Murphy (6:55)

And violently handcuff them because they have a different opinion from me. You know why I don't do that? Because we don't do that in a democracy. We don't do that against ordinary citizens. And we certainly don't allow the administration and the law enforcement that works for the administration to do that to a United States senator. This kind of violence, simply because the White House doesn't agree with people who dissent. If this is how a United States Senator can be treated, then none of us ultimately are immune. If this is how a United States Senator can be treated, none of our constituents are safe. This is a test for the country, but this is a test for the United States Senate as well.

Unknown Speaker 3 (7:50)

Sarah Longwell, your thoughts?

Sarah Longwell (7:54)

Okay, so first of all, I want to pick apart something that's happening in the room, which is at the second he said, I'm Alex Padilla, I'm a United States Senator. The fact that Kristi Noem didn't call people off, right? I mean, you just think about all the times in this country. I just most recently take Joe Biden's State of the Union when Lauren Boebert and Marjorie Taylor Greene started screaming at him during his speech. Nobody came in and dragged them out and threw them to the ground. This is not, it is not uncommon for elected officials to sort of confront each other in this way at a moment when people are paying attention. I mean, Linda McMahon from the Education Secretary, when the Democrats were out in front of the Department of Education, they invited her to the podium. She came out to sort of, you know, get into it with them, and they invited her to the podium and let her talk. There is a way in which Kristi Noem should have immediately identified him as a colleague, not as an enemy. Right. And that's an important distinction. It's a way that it is something deep we're losing in politics that she should not have intervened or that other people shouldn't have stood up and said, this is not how we treat a US Senator. We can't do this. I mean, that is her responsibility. And so the fact that she let it happen, and I'll tell you something, it's telling. She had this sort of 15 minute conversation with him afterwards. It's because once they realized that it was on tape, that somebody had it right, they knew this was bad because this doesn't happen. I've never seen anything like it. You see plenty of interactions with elected officials getting into it with each other. You do not see the FBI or Secret Service dragging their colleagues to the floor and cuffing them. It is not something that happens. And so the fact that she wasn't there to say don't do this, that's sort of the scary part that they're just letting it happen. And it's because it is the ethos of, of this administration to treat people not as colleagues but as enemies.

Unknown Speaker 3 (9:57)

Tim Miller, your thoughts?

Unknown Speaker 2 (10:00)

Just one thing going off what Sarah was just saying about press conferences. This is one area where, Nicole, maybe you and I both have some expertise on this. I've only me especially because I've both been a press flack who has been trying to manage a press conference when other people have disrupted it. And I've been a disruptor of press conferences, believe it or not. And in none of those occasions were anybody touched. You know, nobody was certainly nobody is thrown to the ground. Like this is just the nature of how politics work. And I do think that's an important thing to say because some folks who are watching this might, you know, whatever, think that he was acting inappropriately or whatever, you know, like this happens in politics. And particularly at a moment like this, you know, where there's all these extreme things that are happening in California targeting Senator Padilla's constituents, it is almost called for and makes sense for him to take this opportunity. She and Kristi Noemi's in his state, you know, the MAGA folks like to a big talking point right now is that people voted for this. Well, the people of California didn't vote for this. They voted for Alex Padilla. And so he has a right to represent his constituents just as much as Donald Trump has a right to try to enact the policies that he thinks that he was elected on. So I just think that's one element about the press conference side of this. The other thing about dhs, and you played that from Chris Murphy. It was about a month ago that Chris Murphy was asking Kristi Noem in a hearing about dhs and he was listing about how this agency is out of control and how it's a lawless agency. And he listed a handful of things among them, the fact that they're spending way more money than they have been allotted by Congress. She is illegally spending money that they don't have on immigration enforcement and on ICE officials. That's one element talked about the way that they're doing immigration enforcement. I mean, we've talked a lot about the Venezuelans that they snatched off the street and then kidnapped and sent to El Salvador or what we've seen seen with Mahmoud Khalil or other ways where they've been going around the law to do immigration enforcement. And that is happening right now in LA too, as we speak. They are racially targeting to Ben Rhodes point, companies where a lot of Hispanic folks work. They're going in there without deportation notices. They're just doing random sweeps, racially targeted. They're harassing people that are legal residents that don't have their papers or whatever. Maybe in some cases they do have their papers. They don't believe them because they're speaking because their English is not good enough for the officers like across all these things. So the DHS is acting lawlessly. This is not a one off thing where there are three random cops who roughed up Padilla and maybe they were acting inappropriately. This is DHS's MO.

Unknown Speaker 3 (12:38)

Sarah, let me ask you to pick up on the point you were making before the break about Kristi Noem. She rose like a firework, if you will, and VP stakes and then seemed to sabotage her own chances when she wrote in her own words, her own telling of her experience murdering her own dog by shooting, her own description of frisky puppy in the face. This is someone for whom sadistic conduct toward animals at least was part of her brand. How do you think she's writing this out in terms of the manner in which she went on Fox News seeming confident that no one would check her facts.

Sarah Longwell (13:20)

Yeah. Well, what's interesting is her accusing somebody else of performative theater because nobody has done more cosplaying. You know, she's constantly dressing herself up like federal agents. She's constantly putting detainees behind her for photo ops, which is some of the grossest behavior behavior I've ever seen out of a public official. But Nicole, I also want to pick up on something that you're talking about, which is the lies that Republicans are telling. So one thing that has been interesting, you saw a lot of people, you know, in the tech community and conservatives talk about how you needed Trump to be a free speech president. He was going to be a free speech president. We have to have free speech in this country. Well, a sitting senator should be able to ask a question of the head of Department of Homeland Security. And in fact, I find it odd that Kristi Noem was. Wouldn't recognize Senator Alex Padilla. I mean, he is the ranking member, I believe, on one of the immigration committees. So the idea that she absolutely doesn't know who he is is absurd. But, you know, you've got Donald Trump saying if people show up to protest his tanks in the streets, that they're going to be met with incredible force. Well, he's not talking about violence. He's not talking about riots. He's talking about people who show up to protest the tanks in the streets that they will be met with force. I mean, this is what this administration is doing. This is not singular. This is not one. This is about how this entire administration is approaching people who dissent. And so nobody better come here and try to tell me this is a free speech president or a free speech administration. Her reasoning for the treatment of Senator Alex Padilla is that he was disrespectful. Being disrespectful is not a reason to handcuff somebody on the ground. It's just not. Not even a U.S. senator. Right. It's not. And I gotta say, my last thing is Republican senators should be very careful on this right now. If they do not come out and defend Senator Padilla's right to ask questions of this administration, of his colleagues, they are setting an extraordinarily dangerous precedent for how senators are going to be treated in this country. They should protect their own institution. They should have an interest in their office being protected from this kind of behavior because they're all going to want to ask questions at some point, accountability questions of their leadership. And that is right, and it's American.

Unknown Speaker 3 (15:47)

We have an answer already to Sarah's question about Republicans, at least on the House side. I'm actually not going to play this, but Tim Miller, Speaker Johnson, I've been asked to play it. Let me play this.

Mike Johnson (16:02)

It's not my decision to make. I'm not in that chamber. But I do think that it merits immediate attention by their colleagues over there and that they. I think that that behavior, at a minimum, is it rises to the level of a censure. I think there needs to be a message sent by the body as a whole that that is not what we are going to do. That's not how we're going to act. We're not going to have branches fighting physically and having senators charging Cabinet secretaries. We got to do better.

Unknown Speaker 3 (16:28)

So Tim Miller, the victim, is who Speaker Johnson would like to see censured?

Unknown Speaker 2 (16:36)

Yeah. I mean, you can't even see Kristi Noem in the video. It's like, hard to tell. Like this notion that he was some physical threat to her is just absurd. And he's manhandled and bullied and thrown to the ground. It's sick. And it's hard to even dignify what Mike Johnson said with a response. It's related to what you said right before the break, Nicole, about how they're not interested in de escalating. They actually want to escalate. There's an article in Real Clear Politics, a conservative website. This morning they interviewed a bunch of Republican strategists and folks in the Hill. Mike Johnson might even been quoted in the story, if I recall, about how they want this fight. They think that a fight over disorder in the streets of California is a winner for them politically and is gonna be their path to have a better midterm. And they're not hiding it. It's not like a conspiracy theory of the anti Trump crowd that are saying that Trump wants escalation and that Republican MAGA Republicans want escalation in the streets of la. They're saying it like they are. Their explicit policy efforts is they want to turn the heat up. They want it to seem like things are out of control because they think that's a political winner for them. And that goes back to what you and Ben were talking about about propaganda earlier and why they're replaying the same videos over and over again of some legitimately bad things that some folks are doing, but they're trying to blow it out of proportion and they're trying to instigate it because they think it's a political winner, because that's part of the playbook that they have put forth for seizing more power. And so I think that ties directly to the Speaker's response there.

Unknown Speaker 4 (18:14)

We interrupt this program to bring you an important Wayfair message. Wayfair's got style tips for every home. This is Stiles MacKenzie helping you make those rooms sing. Today's style tip when it comes to making a statement, treat bold patterns like neutrals go wild. Like an untamed animal Print area rug under a rustic farmhouse table. From wayfair.com, fierce, this has been your Wayfair style tip to keep those interiors superior. Wayfair every style, every home.