Loading summary
Transcript44 lines
- [00:02]
SpinQuest Advertiser
Forget everything you had planned for this weekend because you are sitting on your couch and winning from the comfort of your own home. I'm here with spinquest where you can play hundreds of slot games, all the table games you love, and you could even win real cash Prizes. New users 30 coin packs are on sale for 10@Spinquest.com SpinQuest is a free
- [00:24]
Tim Miller
to play social casino void where prohibited. Visit spinquest.com for more details. Hey, everybody, it's Tim Miller from the Bulwark. Earlier this week, I was over on the Piers Morgan show and you may have seen a clip going around of me talking about how I was not going to call Pastor Doug Wilson pastor, and I'm just going to call him Doug because he doesn't follow even remotely anything resembling the teachings of Jesus Christ and he is just a right wing hack, provocateur and political actor. And there's space for those people in the world, but they're not pastors. So we discussed the merits of Doug Wilson's worldview Wajahat and Ali and myself took turns taking some whacks at that. We also talked about a bunch of other stuff. And my main takeaway from this is just the case for this war in Iran is so weak that the Piers Morgan show, which is trying to get both sides on to do a food fight, it's like it's hard to even find people to defend the war. And to me, that was the most telling part of it. So anyway, Doug's arguments were so weak that initially I thought, why? Why even subject you guys to this on the YouTube page? But after popular review, the people wanted it. The people. Sometimes the people like just giving an asshole a swirly, even if it's not highbrow debate content. And so we've listened, we've learned. And so we're going to provide you some extended clips so you can see a little bit more of Doug and I stick around me on the Piers Morgan show. Subscribe to the feed. By the way, we need to get up to 2 million. We need to get to 2 million. Let's go. Subscribe to the feed. See you later.
- [02:16]
Piers Morgan
Okay. Well, Tim Miller, you're a Catholic, I believe, is that right?
- [02:20]
Tim Miller
Well, I'm a cradle Catholic, Pierce. We're all on a journey together.
- [02:29]
Piers Morgan
No, I was just curious what you feel about the row between the Pope and the President. Has what the Pope been saying crossed a line in terms of political commentary? Or is he just being consistent to what most Popes do, which is preach about peace and not war?
- [02:48]
Tim Miller
Yeah, I think that the people that think that the Pope has crossed a line, you know, have, you know, no memory or didn't start paying attention to the news or to the Pope before Donald Trump was around. Pope Leo's comments are in line with what we've heard from popes going all the way back to Pope John Paul and Pope John Paul ii opposed both Iraq wars, did so vocally. And, you know, I don't recall George H.W. bush or George W. Bush getting into a fight with the Pope. Multiple popes have criticized Democratic leaders for their stances on abortion and other issues. I don't remember Joe Biden or Nancy Pelosi telling the Pope to shut his piehole when he weighed in on the Catholic teaching on abortion. Donald Trump wants to make everything about himself. He wants to pick this fight because that's the only thing he knows how to do, is bully people and pick fights. So it's kind of a what we'd expect for Donald Trump. It's a little confusing for JD Vance, who converted to Catholicism two seconds ago and then decided to write a book about his conversion to now come out and say that the Pope needs to be careful when he speaks about theology, as if J.D. vance, who's been a Catholic for two minutes, knows more about Catholic doctrine and just war theory than the Pope. I think probably he would benefit from listening to the Pope. And, yeah, I just. I don't know who is really buying that from him, from the Vice President. It's not as if he comments about how Donald Trump should be careful with his language ever. JD man never criticizes Donald Trump, but now all of a sudden, he simultaneously went through this conversion to Maga Hood, where he's a Donald Trump acolyte, and he went through a conversion to Catholicism at the same time. It's very phony and it's very fake, and I don't think it's helping either of them politically.
- [04:40]
Doug Wilson
All the contradictory statements coming out of Iran really just reveal nothing more than the fact that nobody knows who's in charge there.
- [04:49]
Piers Morgan
Oh, boy. Okay, let me bring Tim Lewin. Tim. I mean, there's a lot of contradictory statements coming out of everywhere, and I'm all for the fog of war and, you know, dealing with the enemy in a way that they may understand. And, look, nobody pretends Donald Trump is a conventional politician or president. He's always used the power of incendiary rhetoric to get what he wants, and sometimes he's been successful at doing it. So, you know, you know, maybe there is method to the Madness. Maybe this is the language the Iranians will understand, and maybe in six months time, we'll look at this as a piece of strategic genius. But I've got to say right now, I'm not feeling that. I'm feeling more that Donald Trump has got sucked into something. I mean, as we came on air with this show today, he's put out a direct denunciation of the increasingly popular claim that he got bullied into this or Trump talked into it, persuaded into it by the Israelis. He said, israel never talked me into the war with Iran. The results of October 7th added to my lifelong opinion that Iran can never have a nuclear weapon. Did I watch and read the fake news pundits and polls in disbelief? 90% of what they say are lies are made up stories, blah, blah, blah. But you know, the mere fact he's felt compelled to say that when we all read a big New York Times piece last week which detailed in really quite extraordinary detail how Benjamin Netanyahu sat in the Situation Room at the White House laying out a sequence of events. If America joined this and attacked and took out the Ayatollah and the top people, then you would see the IRGC slowly lose power. You'd see the people rise up and take it over. The Strait of Hormos would be an irrelevance and so on. Only the first bits happened. And that's the cold, hard reality. And I'm, I'm of the view that Donald Trump has got into something, he wants to get out, but he is not sure how to do that. Where it doesn't look like an abject failure.
- [06:46]
Doug Wilson
The cold, hard reality is that it's been six weeks.
- [06:51]
Tim Miller
Yeah, well, and things have gotten worse. Six weeks passed.
- [06:54]
Piers Morgan
It was actually a question for Tim. So sorry, we'll come back to you.
- [06:57]
Doug Wilson
Worse for Iran, I mean, look, we
- [07:00]
Piers Morgan
were told, we were told it was going to be over in. We were told it was gonna be over in two to three weeks. Two to three weeks ago. And it's not. So, Tim.
- [07:07]
Tim Miller
Yeah, look, the Trump bleat about how Israel didn't push him into this is definitely a lady doth protest too much moment. The fact that he had to say that, I just think that we can all see reality with our eyes. This is not to say that there's like some secret cabal of Jews that are like puppet mastering and manipulating Trump. It's not to say that. It's just to say that Bibi came into our Situation Room and made the case to him for this war. And then a couple Weeks later, they got into the war. That's just what happened. I don't think that there's anyone out there who thinks that if Israel did not want this war, wasn't agitating for it, that Trump was going to go at it alone and do it on his own. There's just no reason to think that that would have happened. And a big part of why we shouldn't think that would happen is just listening to Donald Trump and J.D. vance's own words where they said that they weren't going to do this up until they changed their mind. So, look, I just think that the quote unquote pastor we've got over here saying that we're only six weeks into this. He's very incoherent in his defense of this. And I think it's probably a big challenge for you, Piers, to get people onto the show to defend this war because Trump is incoherent talking about it. Any defender of this war sounds incoherent because we haven't got anything. Like there's been no progress made and there was no case made for it. And if you just look at, if you go back seven weeks and you just said to the American people, it's like, hey, here's what things are going to look like in seven weeks from now. The Strait of Hormuz will have been closed. Energy prices are higher for everybody. Critical energy infrastructure in Arab states are taken offline. The UAE is coming to us to ask us for a loan. Now over a dozen Americans are dead. We've unknown how many Americans are wounded because they're not being honest with us. Iranian citizens have been killed, including school children that we accidentally killed. We've depleted our military material. So that is the state of affairs. And in exchange for that, what have we gotten? We've moved from one Khamenei to another. The IRGC is in more control and Iran has lost some ships and they've lost some of their missile capabilities. Like that's it. Like that's all we've gotten out of this. Who would want, who would make that deal like that, would that if you made that pitch to people eight weeks ago, 3% of the American public would have been for that. You know, the really strong Israel hawks maybe would have been for that, but no one else.
- [09:24]
Piers Morgan
So they interesting thing.
- [09:27]
Doug Wilson
So then, last thing, I've been a quote unquote pastor for just shy of 50 years. And so I'd like to know how much longer I have to go before I become a real pastor.
- [09:39]
Tim Miller
Well, you have to follow the teachings of Jesus Christ, probably. You wanna be a real pastor. I mean, you can call yourself how you want, Doug. I'm just gonna call you Doug. I'm kind of tired of you being called pastor, but, you know, I think
- [09:51]
Piers Morgan
we can afford him.
- [09:51]
Tim Miller
Doug, you're out there.
- [09:52]
Piers Morgan
We can afford him.
- [09:53]
Tim Miller
You hate everybody. You attack black people, gay people, immigrants. All you do is spread hate. Your you've got behind there is talking about how much you love bad words. Look, if you want to teach this kind of fake Christianity, that's fine.
- [10:11]
Piers Morgan
Have you read it?
- [10:13]
Tim Miller
No, I've not read your book. Very happy to have not read your book. But if you want to do this kind of signaling, you should probably stop
- [10:19]
Doug Wilson
commenting on what it's about.
- [10:21]
Tim Miller
Well, I've seen enough of your material on social media that it doesn't really require anymore. I mean, it's not like there's a ton of deep thought that's going behind it that requires further study.
- [10:36]
Doug Wilson
As the show started out, I thought we were supposed to refrain from attacking religious leaders.
- [10:45]
Piers Morgan
You attacked the Pope.
- [10:47]
Unidentified Guest (possibly a critic of Doug Wilson)
Well, I have no problem. Listen real quick, Pastor. I have no problem attacking wolves and sheep's clothing. I have no problem attacking a man who wrote that American slavery was mutually harmonious between the. The slave master and the slave. That's you. I have no problem attacking a man who proudly says he wants to do away with the 19th Amendment, which gave women the right to vote. I have no problem attacking a man like yourself who sits here incoherently supporting an incoherent, unwinnable, illegal war in Iran. I have no problem attacking you, a man who is the religious leader of Pete Hegseth. A man who's a cosplay crusader who's leading some type of crusade. Probably you put him on as a Secretary of Defense, getting Americans and innocent civilians killed. I wish you would be a better Christian. I wish you would open up the Bible. I wish you would meet the Jesus that I met when I went to an all boys Jesuit Catholic high school. The Jesus that took care of the sick, that took care of the poor, that welcomed the immigrant, that welcomed the marginalized, that helped them. But instead you've used Jesus as a mascot for, I don't know, your white Christian supremacy, your cruelty, your misogyny. And I'm so glad that people are finally waking up to your cruelty and to the idiocy of your star disciple, Pete Hexseth, who keeps messing up and literally does not read the Bible and quotes Pulp Fiction. Just sit with them. Maybe both of you can read the Constitution, read the Bible and just take a break, Pastor. Just take a break.
- [12:06]
Piers Morgan
Yeah. Who lasts past your response?
- [12:10]
Doug Wilson
Just incidentally, we know that Jesus was not a socialist because he could actually feed people.
- [12:19]
Unidentified Guest (possibly a critic of Doug Wilson)
Wonderful. Great response.
- [12:21]
Tim Miller
That's what you got, man.
- [12:24]
Piers Morgan
Doug, to be fair to the pastor, he probably, the pastor would have probably got a bit of support from Michael Knowles, but unfortunately we can't find Michael Knowles, which is why he has to find.
- [12:34]
Tim Miller
It's hard to find. It's tough for you. It's a really tough job. It's supposed to be a debate show. But the war is so stupid that literally the only person who seems to be forward is Mark Levin, you know, and you can't have him on three times a week, you know, life, Liberty, Levin, micropenis, Mark. But nobody else can offer a coherent case for this war. And so obviously Michael Knowles doesn't want to come on. And you have Doug over here who's already basically saying he's going to be against it if it goes on much longer. So it's challenging because the war is so stupid. That's why it's challenging.
- [13:07]
Piers Morgan
Well, I would say, I would say, I would say, I would say Michael Knowles. Michael, hang on. Pastor Michael Knowles doesn't duck debates. I don't. I think we've had a breakdown of communication. We'll find out what happened. But it's a shame because I think he would have probably. The pastor does feel a bit on his own at the moment. So, Tim Miller, I mean, it's a very interesting split that is occurring here. I'm just again slightly baffled by Trump's strategy of just dumping all over all these periods. He did the same to Riley Gaines last week when she quite rightly said she didn't like the imagery of Jesus and so on. No, no Christian should like the president United States doing that. But he started lashing out people who have been very supportive of him historically. Recent. Historically. What does that tell you about what is going on here and what does it mean for say, the midterm elections and the 2028 election?
- [13:55]
Tim Miller
Yeah, well, I think I can explain what's going on here pretty simply, and that is that Donald Trump has done a series of things as president that have caused backlash among his own voters and are starting now with the Iran war to negatively impact their lives. I think folks were upset about the Epstein files cover up. Of course, that didn't really affect them personally, but they cared about that issue. And when he did it, that caused, that kind of started the backlash. Among the megabase. But now with this war, look, he didn't make the case for this war to anybody, including his own voters. And a lot of people went and voted for him because they were under the impression that he was gonna be opposed to this, that he was the candidate that was not gonna get us into dumb Middle east wars. Cause that's what he told them. And so you just have to put your head and put yourself in the mind of one of these voters who one day woke up, went to the gas station, and all of a sudden it cost 10 more bucks to fill up their tank. And they're like, why? I can't afford this. I'm gonna have to tighten my belt in other places. And the answer that's being provided is, well, we had to do this war in Iran because we have to degrade the number of ships that they have. It's just like nobod. It is nonsensical. And so they're starting to get upset. And so in the past, Donald Trump has been able to bully media members or members of the Republican Party who step out of line because the voters are with him. You just look at any in the past of any of the Republicans who have tried to criticize Trump, and then Trump goes back at them harder, and then they back off. Like, we've seen this a bunch. Why has that worked every time? Well, it's worked because the voters have been with Trump every time. Like the MAGA base was with Trump in these arguments. The MAGA base isn't with him in the arguments anymore. So the bullying doesn't work. Right. You know, if this was a case where, you know, if Trump attacked Tucker Carlson and Megyn Kelly, their ratings went down. I don't. You know, who knows? My guess is maybe they would modulate. Maybe they'd start talking about something else. Or if he started going after the Republicans on the Hill who criticized him and their voters had a backlash against them, then they would back down. We've seen that a million times. That's not happening this time because people are pissed, because the war is stupid. He didn't make a case for it. And, and, and they're being harmed.
- [16:05]
Unidentified Guest (possibly a critic of Doug Wilson)
Even they knew. Even George W. Bush knew a war in Iran would be disastrous. It would be a quagmire. We're about eight weeks in. He cannot get out. Pierce. He is stuck. But his ego makes him doubling double down on this failed war. Everything's getting worse. His base is finally fed up.
- [16:23]
Doug Wilson
I just like,
- [16:26]
Unidentified Guest (possibly a critic of Doug Wilson)
Sure.
- [16:26]
Doug Wilson
I just like how you guys are now appealing to. To authorities like Fuentes and Candace and Alex Jones.
- [16:35]
Tim Miller
The war is so stupid that me and Candace finally agree on something. I mean, you're correct. She is a big liar. I don't think that the first lady of France has a dick, but we do agree that the war is that dumb. Yeah, that's. That's. Or on the same page on that one thing.
- [16:49]
Piers Morgan
There's certainly been. No. Well, there's certainly an interesting fusion of people that I would never have thought would ever agree about anything going on. Guys, thank you all very much indeed. I'm sorry that Michael didn't join us. That was, I think, some kind of communication breakdown. But we'll get him back next time. Thank you all very much. See you, Paris. Thank you.
- [17:09]
SpinQuest Advertiser
Forget everything you had planned for this weekend because you are sitting on your couch and winning from the comfort of your own home. I'm here with spinquest where you can play hundreds of slot games, all the table games you love, and you could even win real cash Prizes. New users, $30 coin packs are on sale for 10@Spinquest.com Spin Quest is a
- [17:31]
Tim Miller
free to play social casino void where prohibited. Visit spin quest.com for more details.