Tim Miller, Sarah Longwell and Jon Lovett Demand Andry Be Freed Now At Supreme Court

Summary

Podcast Summary: Bulwark Takes – "Tim Miller, Sarah Longwell and Jon Lovett Demand Andre Be Freed Now At Supreme Court"

Release Date: June 7, 2025
Host: The Bulwark
Participants: Jon Lovett, Tim Muller, Sarah Longwell
Topic: Advocacy for the release of Andre following his detention by authorities, with a focus on constitutional rights and opposition to current immigration policies.

---

1. Introduction and Rally Overview

Jon Lovett opens the episode by sharing his recent experience at a Supreme Court rally advocating for Andre's freedom. He reflects on the turnout and the collaborative effort with organizations like the Human Rights Campaign.

• Jon Lovett (00:00): "Hey, everybody. Just got back from the Supreme Court. We had a Free Andre rally. It was very cool. Bunch of people showed out."

He briefly mentions delivering his first rally speech and encourages listeners to engage and share the cause.

• Jon Lovett (00:31): "Free Andre."

2. Tim Muller's Inspirational Speech

Tim Muller takes the stage with a passionate address emphasizing the importance of resilience and collective action against perceived political adversaries.

• Tim Muller (00:37): "Donald Trump thrives on weakness. He thrives on people who are afraid to fight."

Muller articulates the struggle against forces he views as attempts to redefine American identity and undermine constitutional values. He highlights the personal nature of the fight, connecting it to Andre's situation.

• Tim Muller (02:10): "What we're seeing right now is Donald Trump and Stephen Miller and all these people trying to see who we are, trying to decide who we are."

He underscores the significance of persistence and community effort in combating these challenges, urging listeners to remain engaged and proactive.

• Tim Muller (06:50): "Always give more than what's expected of you, because 80% of success is simply persistence. So do not be afraid of failure. Be afraid of not trying."

3. Jon Lovett's Further Reflections

Jon Lovett returns to reinforce the urgency of the situation and the moral imperative to act, reiterating the government's role in Andre's predicament.

• Jon Lovett (04:22): "We did this to Andre. I mean, not literally us. None of us here voted for this. But we, the United States government, did this to Andre and not some crooked cop or some corporation or some foreign country."

Lovett emphasizes the constitutional rights at stake, advocating for due process and equitable treatment for all individuals, regardless of their background.

• Jon Lovett (05:15): "Everybody gets due process under the law, and it's up to us to fight for it."

He calls on the audience to utilize platforms like social media and to support organizations dedicated to defending immigrant rights, personalizing the issue by highlighting Andre's humanity.

• Jon Lovett (06:05): "Andre is a human. He's a person with a soul."

4. Sarah Longwell's Perspective

Sarah Longwell addresses the alignment of conservative values with the advocacy for immigrant rights, challenging the current Republican stance on these issues.

• Sarah Longwell (07:40): "What I want from us, and one of the things we do try and do at the Bulwark, is to remind Republicans that they're Americans first and that the values that this country was founded on, they still have to abide by."

She reflects on the historical Republican appreciation for immigrants, citing Ronald Reagan's inclusive vision of America, and criticizes the party's deviation from these foundational values.

• Sarah Longwell (08:20): "Ronald Reagan used to say he had this great line. He would say, you could move to Japan, but you'd never be Japanese."

Longwell calls for a return to constitutional fidelity, rule of law, and equal treatment, urging former Republicans to recognize and uphold these enduring American principles.

• Sarah Longwell (09:10): "We should never let them forget what they're doing. Because if they want to say they're pro life, we're going to make them prove it."

5. Concluding Remarks

The episode concludes with a unified call to action from all speakers, emphasizing the collective responsibility to defend constitutional rights and advocate for Andre's release. They encourage listeners to remain steadfast, engaged, and proactive in their efforts to effect change.

• All Speakers (Throughout): "Let's free Andre."

---

Key Takeaways:

• Advocacy for Andre: The primary focus is on the urgent need to free Andre, highlighting his humanity and the constitutional violations involved in his detention.

• Constitutional Fidelity: Emphasis on upholding the Constitution, due process, and equal treatment for all individuals, regardless of their immigration status or background.

• Political Commentary: Critique of current Republican leadership and policies, advocating for a return to foundational American values that embrace and protect immigrants.

• Collective Action: A strong call for community engagement, persistence, and proactive measures such as contacting representatives, donating to relevant organizations, and raising awareness through social platforms.

• Human Rights Focus: Collaboration with organizations like the Human Rights Campaign to underscore the broader human rights implications of immigration policies.

Notable Quotes:

• Tim Muller (02:10): "What we're seeing right now is Donald Trump and Stephen Miller and all these people trying to see who we are, trying to decide who we are."

• Jon Lovett (05:15): "Everybody gets due process under the law, and it's up to us to fight for it."

• Sarah Longwell (07:40): "What I want from us, and one of the things we do try and do at the Bulwark, is to remind Republicans that they're Americans first and that the values that this country was founded on, they still have to abide by."

• Sarah Longwell (09:10): "We should never let them forget what they're doing. Because if they want to say they're pro life, we're going to make them prove it."

---

This episode of Bulwark Takes serves as a passionate plea for justice and constitutional integrity, urging listeners to actively participate in the fight to free Andre and to uphold the fundamental American values of due process and equal treatment for all.

Transcript

[Jon Lovett]

Hey, everybody. Just got back from the Supreme Court. We had a Free Andree rally. It was very cool. Bunch of people showed out. I gave a rally speech for the first time. I hope you guys think I did well. Let us know in the comments. Sarah talked.

[Sarah Longwell]

Mine was good.

[Jon Lovett]

You don't have to let me know. She was great. Love it. Talked a bunch of other folks. Human Rights Campaign was working with us on it. It was very moving. We were so appreciated. Folks came out and looking forward to the big show tonight. So enjoy the rally. Share it with your friends. Free Andrew.

[Tim Muller]

Bring him home.

[Jon Lovett]

Free Andre.

[Tim Muller]

Bring him home.

[Sarah Longwell]

Pride and say.

[Jon Lovett]

Protest.

[Sarah Longwell]

Pride and say.

[Tim Muller]

It is now my honor to introduce Jon Lovett from Boat Save America and Cricket Media. Hey, everybody. Thank you for coming out. I'll be brief. I've never done that before, but I'll try. I don't. We all heard what Lindsey had to say. There's not much more to say about this. We are all here because we understand what's at stake. You know, we hear this all the time. It's like a cliche, like, this is not who we are. I find it a very annoying thing when people say that, because it is if we let it. What we're seeing right now is Donald Trump and Stephen Miller and all these people trying to see who we are, trying to decide who we are. And the question is, will it be defined by what they tell us or will it be defined by what we tell them? I think we were all on our heels for a while, felt like that. It felt like they were on the ascent, and it felt like Democrats were caught flat footed. Felt like our country was caught flat footed. But I feel more inspired by what I've seen every day since as we've picked ourselves up and figured out how to fight back. Donald Trump thrives on weakness. He thrives on people who are afraid to fight. He makes. He's a bully. He takes advantage of people. And when people give, he takes more. And what we have to remember over the next couple years is Donald Trump's going to win some fights and he's going to lose some fights, but every inch we lose is an inch we won't get back. Earlier today, we found out that they are sending Kilmar Abrego Garcia back to the United States. And they're going to try to say it proves whatever bullshit they've been saying. But what that tells us is two things. One, it means the pressure matters. They can pretend they're immune to politics and democracy. They are not. That's 1 and 2. They can send people back anytime they want. They can bring Andre back anytime they fucking want. Kristi Noem. A mother is asked to give proof of life. That's it. Proof of life. That Andre, this innocent person who only touched the immigration system because he followed the rules, is alive and she wouldn't do it. That's their cruelty. That's their callousness. They think that's who we are. I don't agree. And it's up to us now, day by day, week after week. Donald Trump is relentless. We have to be just as relentless. We are going to decide what America is, not them. So thank you all for coming out. Thank you for being part of this. Thank you for staying engaged. Thank you for not giving up. Because they want us to throw in the towel. They want us to think what we do doesn't matter. It's not true. We can fight and we can win. So thank you all so much. And I'll turn it back over. Thank you. Look at this. I love the. Oops.

[Jon Lovett]

Sorry.

[Tim Muller]

I love this eagle shirt. Look at this thing. It's beautiful. I love it. I love it. These colors don't run. What colors are colors? Okay, there we go. Can everyone say these colors don't run?

[Jon Lovett]

These colors don't run.

[Tim Muller]

Next, I have the privilege of introducing Tim Muller from the Bulwark.

[Jon Lovett]

Hey, babe. Thanks so much. Nice cutoff. Following up, John Lovett and John Lovitz is tough, but I'm going to do my best. Appreciate y' all coming out here tonight. You could be pre gaming, but this stuff is really important and I want to talk about why it's important. There's so much horrible shit going on in the world. There's genocides, there's bombings, there's scams. Why should you care about this with all those things that are out there? And I want to tell you why. It's because we did this to Andre. I mean, not literally us. None of us here voted for this. But we, the United States government, did this to Andre and not some crooked cop or some corporation or some foreign country. We did it. And so it is up to us to get him back. It is up to us to free him. Because the US is a government still for this moment of, by and for the people. And so it is up to us to do everything we can to bring him back. And it's up to these folks in the rows behind me to defend the Constitution where all persons, all persons get due process. All persons, not just some persons. We don't get to Take away due process from persons that the little gerbils in the White House doesn't like because they're brown or because they got tattoos or because they're gay or whatever. Everybody gets due process under the law, and it's up to us to fight for it. I want to. I want to just talk about Andre for a second, because Andre is a human. He's a person with a soul. I don't know if any of you have been to his Instagram page. You can scroll through that page and see it. You can look at his smile. You can see that he's a real person. Donald Trump wants to dehumanize these folks. He wants to say that they are vermin, that they are gangsters, that they're gang bangers, that they're thugs, that they're bringing fentanyl into the country. And he wants people to not care about them. And he's making a bet that the American people won't care about them because that he will convince them that they are less than human. But he's wrong about that. He's wrong about that. We cannot be made to be afraid. The people, the makeup artists for Venezuelans from Venezuela are not the ones coming for us, okay? They are not. It's the fucking jackbooted thugs taking people off the streets because they're tattoos and sending them to a foreign concentration camp. So we have to stand up to them and say no. And so I want you to go back to Andre's Instagram page. I scrolled through it. It's a fucking tough scroll, to be honest, thinking about this nightmare that we put him through. But there's one caption that he wrote on one story, and he said this. Always give more than what's expected of you, because 80% of success is simply persistence. So do not be afraid of failure. Be afraid of not trying. It's our time to give more than what's expected of us in this case. We should call our representatives. We should march in the street. We should tell these folks behind him that they have to give him his rights, that they have to free Andre. Donate to Immigrant Defenders, and we have to do everything we can to free him. We cannot be afraid of trying. I appreciate y' all coming out here today. Let's free Andre. Thank you so much.

[Tim Muller]

Next up, we have Sarah Longwell from the Bulwark.

[Sarah Longwell]

What's up, my lesbians? Some of you, please, can I hold this? It's fine.

[Tim Muller]

Whatever.

[Sarah Longwell]

I'll stand like this. Hey, look, I don't know if you guys Know, the bulwark or if, like, it's a thing that's familiar to you. Oh, yeah. Great, Great, great, great. Okay, so we've been the Never Trumpers now for, like, almost 10 years, because this has been. This national nightmare has been going on for quite some time. And people have been asking us because the bulwark has been very focused on what is happening with these disappearing of immigrants and deportations that look more like kidnappings. They're like, I'm surprised you former Republicans are all over this the way that you are. But I actually want you to understand something that the Republican Party that we grew up in understood that immigrants added tremendous value to our country. Ronald Reagan used to say he had this great line. He would say, you could move to Japan, but you'd never be Japanese. You could move to France and you'd never be French. But if you had freedom in your heart and you wanted to follow our laws, anybody can come to America from anywhere and become an American. And they took that as a sign of America's greatness that people wanted to come here. That was what made us great. And so, look, obviously the Republican Party has abandoned that. But the other thing we were raised on as young conservatives was fidelity to the Constitution was a belief in the rule of law and due process and equal treatment. Those things mattered to Republicans and conservatives at one point, not because they're strictly conservative values, but because they were always taken on faith that they were American values that we all agreed on. And so what I want from us, and one of the things we do try and do at the Bulwark, is to remind Republicans that they're Americans first and that the values that this country was founded on, they still have to abide by. And so our job is to remind them every day of what those values are so that they can't forget. And that's what. When we do that, it's by not forgetting about people like Andre, it's about reminding them every day. Because deep down inside of them, they know it's wrong. They know it's wrong. And we should never let them forget what they're doing. Because if they want to say they're pro life, we're going to make them prove it. Thank you.