Tim Rips Stephen Miller’s Sick Abuse of Power

Summary

Bulwark Takes: Tim Rips Stephen Miller’s Sick Abuse of Power
Release Date: May 10, 2025
Host/Author: The Bulwark
Episode Summary by ChatGPT

---

Introduction

In this compelling episode of Bulwark Takes, host Tim Miller delves deep into the alarming actions and rhetoric of Stephen Miller, a prominent figure within the current administration. The episode, released on May 10, 2025, features insightful discussions with key members of The Bulwark team, including Simone Sanders, Alicia Menendez, Eugene Daniels, Andrew Weissman, and Michael Steele. The central focus revolves around Stephen Miller’s apparent attempts to undermine fundamental constitutional rights, particularly the suspension and erosion of habeas corpus.

---

Understanding Habeas Corpus

The episode opens with a discussion on habeas corpus, a cornerstone of legal rights in the United States.

Tim Miller introduces the topic by emphasizing its significance:

“It is such a fundamental part of our freedoms.”
[02:04]

Following this, Andrew Weissman elaborates on the definition and historical importance of habeas corpus:

“It is commonly known as the Great Writ... it allows individuals to challenge unlawful detention before a court.”
[03:08]

Alicia Menendez underscores the urgency of protecting this right:

“Due process. That's in there. That is in there for a reason.”
[08:27]

This segment establishes the foundational understanding necessary to comprehend the gravity of the subsequent discussions.

---

Stephen Miller’s Threat to Constitutional Rights

The conversation shifts to Stephen Miller’s provocative stance on immigration and legal processes. Miller’s statements suggest a willingness to bypass legal norms, posing a direct threat to constitutional protections.

Alicia Menendez expresses her concern:

“We may have to suspend habeas corpus. Give us a sense of what this threat really means.”
[04:26]

Michael Steele further critiques Miller’s remarks:

“What Stephen Miller is saying is both not going to happen, but... incredibly dangerous for anyone who is a lawyer.”
[03:08]

Stephen Miller responds defensively, downplaying the threats:

“They’re just making empty threats because they’re losing in court.”
[05:56]

However, he admits the administration is closely monitoring judicial decisions:

“...we’re going to keep our eye on how the judges are ruling and then we'll decide what we're going to do.”
[10:28]

This exchange highlights the tension between maintaining constitutional integrity and executive overreach.

---

Impact on Immigration Enforcement

The discussion delves into real-world implications of Miller’s rhetoric, particularly concerning Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) practices.

Eugene Daniels cites recent incidents:

“A young woman in Georgia... was sent to some ICE detention center three hours away, shackled...”
[05:56]

He adds:

“None of this is orderly, none of this is humane. None of this is focused on criminals...”
[06:31]

Simone Sanders emphasizes the targeted impact on marginalized communities:

“They want people to start self-deporting because they know that they’re not going to be able to legally...”
[07:56]

The dialogue paints a grim picture of immigration enforcement devolving into arbitrary and inhumane practices, straying from the administration’s campaign promises.

---

Constitutional Ramifications and Legal Battles

The episode underscores the potential constitutional crisis stemming from these actions.

Andrew Weissman warns of long-term consequences:

“The Constitution is so much of a guarantee... if we allow the President... to act as though they govern the Constitution and not the other way around...”
[08:27]

Simone Sanders adds:

“Due process. That’s in there. That is in there for a reason...”
[08:47]

The panel discusses how these actions could lead to a fundamental erosion of legal protections, with Andrew Weissman cautioning:

“The Constitution is not a suggestion. It is a guarantee.”
[08:02]

This segment highlights the critical role of the judiciary and legal advocates in resisting executive overreach.

---

Calls to Action and Future Outlook

As the episode concludes, there is a unanimous call to resist and push back against unconstitutional measures.

Michael Steele categorizes Miller’s tactics as "mafia talk," underscoring the transactional nature of such threats:

“This is such a transactional use of that.”
[10:28]

Andrew Weissman stresses the importance of vigilance:

“We must put this in place... due process... constitutional crisis situation.”
[10:27]

Simone Sanders advocates for collective action:

“You have to have people stand up and say no.”
[08:59]

The team unanimously agrees that safeguarding constitutional rights requires persistent effort and unified opposition to any attempts at their erosion.

---

Conclusion

In this episode, Bulwark Takes delivers a powerful critique of Stephen Miller’s approaches to immigration and constitutional law. Through rigorous discussion and poignant quotes, Tim Miller and his co-hosts illuminate the dangers posed by executive overreach and the potential suspension of fundamental legal protections like habeas corpus. The episode serves as both a warning and a rallying cry for listeners to remain informed and actively defend the constitutional safeguards that underpin American democracy.

Notable Quotes:

• Tim Miller: “It is such a fundamental part of our freedoms.”
  [02:04]

• Alicia Menendez: “Due process. That’s in there. That is in there for a reason.”
  [08:47]

• Michael Steele: “This is such a transactional use of that.”
  [10:28]

• Simone Sanders: “You have to have people stand up and say no.”
  [08:59]

---

This detailed summary encapsulates the key discussions, insights, and conclusions presented in the episode, providing a comprehensive overview for those who have not listened to it.

Transcript

[Advertiser]

Here in America, work is in trouble. We've offshored our manufacturing, sent away good jobs and lost so much ability to make things. American Giant is a company that's pushing back against this tide. They make high quality clothing, sweatshirts, jeans, dresses, jackets and so much more right here in the USA. Visit american-giant.com and get 20% off your first order when you use code STAPLE20 at checkout. That's 20% off your first order at american-giant.com promo code STAPLE20. Here in America, work is in trouble. We've offshored our manufacturing, sent away good jobs and lost so much ability to make things. American Giant is a company that's pushing back against this tide. They make high quality clothing, sweatshirts, jeans, dresses, jackets and so much more right here in the USA. Visit american-giant.com and get 20% off your first order when you use code STAPLE20 at checkout. That's 20% off your first order at american-giant.com promo code STAPLE20.

[Tim Miller]

Hey, guys, it's Tim Miller here. I had the opportunity to be in studio with my man Michael Steele and my girls, Simone Sanders and Alicia Menendez, who have a new PrimeTime show on MSNBC. So I went up there to be with them Week one. We got into this insane news week to cap it off for everybody. Wanted to show you a couple of the clips from it. So check it out here. And I'll be back with you on the Borg podcast on Monday. We'll see you all then.

[Simone Sanders]

Peace.

[Eugene Daniels]

We are back staying on that breaking news out of Newark, New Jersey. The city's mayor arrested at a protest outside an ICE detention center. Joining the conversation, MSNBC political analyst and writer at large for the Bulwark, Tim Miller and MSNBC senior Washington correspondent and co host of the weekend, Eugene Daniels. And back with us, Andrew Weissman.

[Andrew Weissman]

I just know we've been talking about habeas corpus and I think it's important folks have the definition. So it is a. Actually, Andrew Weissman, you are the guru here. Tell us what habeas corpus is. I could get my dictionary, but you're better.

[Michael Steele]

So, I mean, it is commonly known as the Great Writ. But don't worry, I'm not going to get too in the weeds. It is something that even before this country was founded, it was incredibly important in England and then in the United States to have this ability to go to court to, say, produce the body that if you have been improperly charged, improperly seized, that you had ability to go to court and say under a writ of habeas corpus. A judge has to determine that it was valid for the state to do this to you. It is such a fundamental part of our freedoms. That is why what Stephen Miller is saying is both not going to happen, but to Michael's point, is incredibly dangerous for anyone who is a lawyer. This is, it has to be the most fundamental right in terms of freedom in any country that thinks of itself as a rule of law country.

[Alicia Menendez]

Tim. And just picking up on that point, I have been moved by your passion on the conversations over the last few days around what's happening to individuals, persons under our Constitution. And now you've got Tim Miller, excuse me, Stephen Miller, standing on the White House. Yeah, I know, right? Dude, I'm sorry. Standing on the White House lawn. Just cavalierly. Yes, we're looking at the fact that we may have to suspend habeas corpus. Give us a sense of what this threat really means. Because I think a lot of folks, you know, can get, you know, lost with me and Andrew as lawyers kind of talking about this stuff. This is fundamental, as Andrew said. And I think folks need to understand with a level of passion how significant what Tim Miller. I keep saying, Tim, Steve Miller is saying in this moment that we should be very afraid but ready to lean in and block, stop tackle any way we can.

[Stephen Miller]

Yeah, not my cousin, Stephen Miller. No relation. Look, I was sent to Andrew in the last segment. So the good news about this is he's making these empty threats because they're losing in the court. So that's the good news. But the danger is really the fact that this is where their head is going, Right. Which is that we are going to take away people's right to due process and we are going to deport them. Maybe we'll deport them to their home country. Maybe we'll put them in the jail four hours north of me in Louisiana and make them sit there for a month. There was a young woman in Georgia the other day who was brought here when she was 4, was stopped at a traffic stop. She got sent to some ICE detention center three hours away, shackled, you know, put into a prison. Right. Like, who knows they're floating, sending people to Libya. We already know that they're putting people in the El Salvador prison. Like, this is absolutely fundamental and this is a threat to every American. Obviously, people that are here on a green card or on a visa or on an over, you know, they're at more threat if you're not a U.S. citizen. But if these guys on the White House law are going to Say we're going to continue this like this is our objective. We are going to take people and we don't care what the court says, we don't care what the law says. And we're going to throw them in a foreign prison or throw, throw them in a war torn African country or throw them in a jail across the country. That is a deep, scary, fundamental threat and it must be rejected and it must be pushed back against aggressively. And that's why I appreciate what the mayor and others are doing in New Jersey.

[Eugene Daniels]

Eugene, let's take a look at some of the headlines we saw just in the last few days. Tim referenced two of them. One, the fact that you had that young woman out of Georgia who was stopped during a traffic violation. You also have a judge blocking the deportation flights of Asians and Mexican migrants. That happens on Wednesday. And then you had ICE agents detaining one, two others arrested during a chaotic scene out of Worcester, Massachusetts. None of this is orderly, none of this is humane. None of this is focused on criminals, which is what this administration campaigned on.

[Simone Sanders]

It is the point. The chaos is the point. The fear that folks are feeling that are looking at this. That is the point when you have, you're watching black and brown people getting snatched up and taking places. That's the point when you have people being removed from the country and not just sent to their home countries, right. Without due process, possibly being sent to another country that is not their home country without due process. Right. All of this is how they want people to feel because they want folks to feel. From every conversation I've had with folks in the administration and everyone around them is they want people to start self deporting. They want people to start taking themselves out of the country because they know that they're not going to be able to legally in the way that we all know that folks, how this process happens, how long it takes, they won't be able to do that in the next four years with all of the promises that they made. And I will say they talked about the criminals, but when you actually talk to them, right, as all of us have, when you actually sit down and talk with them, whether it's the Stephen Millers or even Caroline Levitt, the White House press secretary, and you ask what does a criminal mean? Are you just talking about someone who is here undocumented? And they say yes, Right. So that means everybody's in that category. It's not just someone who came here at some point 10 years ago and broke the law last week. It could be Anyone who is here undocumented in this country, and I think that's something for folks to really pay attention to.

[Stephen Miller]

That includes people that are brought here. And there are four, by the way. Does not include people that chose to come here, you know, illegally.

[Andrew Weissman]

Yes. This is the. I wrote. I want to stay on what Eugene just said, because I wrote about this for msnbc. I'm a turn to talk to you. I know it's kind of awkward, but I just. I wrote about this for MSNBC daily this week because the Constitution is actually not a suggestion. It is a guarantee. And if we allow the President of the United States and his staff. Because that's what Stephen Miller is. He is a staffer, baby.

[Simone Sanders]

Mm.

[Andrew Weissman]

And his staff to act as though they govern the Constitution and not the other way around, there is actually no coming back from that. The Constitution is so much of a guarantee that, you know, people. You know, we talk about the Emancipation Proclamation. Oftentimes our children are still learning it in school. It is the Emancipation. The Emancipation Proclamation did not end slavery. The 13th amendment did.

[Simone Sanders]

Correct.

[Andrew Weissman]

The 13th and 14th and 15th amendments were so important. What they contained was so critical that the elected officials at the time during Reconstruction said, we must put this in.

[Simone Sanders]

The Constitution, because at the end of the day, it's all we have. Right. Like, it is the document that we're supposed to go to. And the Founding Fathers missed a lot of things, right. When they were creating these documents. That's the point of amendments. But at the end of the day, due process. That's in there, right? That is in there. It's in there for a reason. And at the end of the day, when you're watching, whether it's President Trump or his team kind of trying to skirt around that because they made some promises to his base during the election, they cannot do that. The problem is you have to have people stand up and say no. Right. So the courts are starting to do their jobs, but the courts don't have armies. And so we're still hurtling toward this. When is it a constitutional crisis situation? Right. Because what Stephen Miller is saying is that at the end of the day, they want to do what they want to do. And looking at. They can be looking at whatever they want. But I will say one of the things I kind of always have to remind myself with dealing with Stephen Miller is like, he says, we're looking at a lot of things, but what are they actually doing? Is he trying to distract. Are they throwing something out there because they want us to look at that and not something else. Not saying that they don't want to do it, but it is like you have to really look at the whole conversation that they're trying to have. What does Stephen Miller actually want to do when he's saying they're looking at this and who is he kind of signaling to that they're looking at this? Right. Is that to the doj? Is that to dhs? Who are they talking to when they're saying that?

[Alicia Menendez]

You've got the.

[Michael Steele]

I was going to say one of the things, just to answer your question, is that Stephen Miller, not Tim, actually answers that question. Because when he says, you know, we're thinking about this, he said, but one of the reasons we may not do it is we're going to keep our eye on how the judges are ruling and let's see how they do and then we'll decide what we're going to do. So it's just such mafia talk, which is, you know, let's see if you actually, you know, rule in our favor and if you actually start pulling back from these rulings against us, maybe we won't go down this road. I mean, this is such a transactional use of that. But again, going back to Michael's point, the idea that you would float something that is so blatantly unconstitutional and violates just deep seated fundamental rights is really the sort of the shocking part of that.

[Stephen Miller]

And a lot of times they float stuff just to see if they can get away with it, you know, and if there isn't pushback, then they'll go and do it.

[Andrew Weissman]

Such an important conversation. Andrew Wiseman, Tim Miller and Eugene Daniels, thank you all for being with us tonight.

[Ryan Seacrest]

It is Ryan Seacrest here. There was a recent social media trend which consisted of flying on a plane with no music, no movies, no entertainment. But a better trend would be going to chumbacasino.com it's like having a mini social casino in your pocket. Casino has over 100 online casino style games, all absolutely free. It's the most fun you can have online and on a plane. So grab your free welcome bonus now at chumbacasino. Com sponsored by Chumba Casino.

[Advertiser]

No purchase necessary vgw group void where prohibited by law 21 + terms and conditions apply.