Transcript
Mark Gagnon (0:00)
Jesus Christ. To Christians, he is the Messiah. To others, he's a prophet, a guru, a spiritual master, and to some heretics, an outright imposter. Most of us grew up with one version of Jesus, maybe from church or movies or, you know, that dusty old Bible at grandma's house. But if you step outside of Christianity, the story explodes. Because almost every religion and philosophy has an explanation for who this person was. Everything from Islam, Hinduism, Judaism, Scientology, and even Gnosticism. And today, we are diving into all of the stories of Jesus. Almost every religion, philosophy and worldview has a story and an explanation about Jesus Christ and who this figure was. And today, we're diving into the many versions of Jesus, many of them we've never been told about. So sit back, relax, and welcome to Religion Camp.
Sponsor/Ad Voice (0:58)
Wayfarer's big sale is returning. Get ready for way day. For four days only, score up to 80% off all things home. With free shipping on everything. From October 26th through 29th, score Wayfair's best deals like up to 80% off area rugs, up to 60% off mattresses, up to 60% off bedroom furniture, and more exclusive doorbuster deals. So mark your calendar and shop Wayday starting October 26th at Wayfair.com Wayfair Every style, every home.
Sponsor/Ad Voice (1:30)
This episode is brought to you by Ulta Beauty. Holiday cheer is here, and Ulta Beauty has gifts for everyone on your list. Treat them to fan favorite gift sets from Charlotte Tilbury and Peach and Lily. Go all out with timeless fragrances from ysl, Ariana Grande and Carolina Herrera. And you can never go wrong with an Ulta Beauty gift card. Head to Ulta Beauty for gifts that make the holidays brighter and even more beautiful. Ulta Beauty gifting happens here.
Mark Gagnon (1:59)
What's up, people? And welcome back to Religion Camp. My name is Mark Gagnon, and thank you for joining me in my tent, where every single Sunday, we explore the most interesting, fascinating, and controversial stories from every religion from around the world, from all time, forever. Yes, this is my attempt to understand what everyone on this big planet is believing. Right? I mean, I truly believe, and I say this all the time. The best way to understand a people and a culture is to understand the God that they worship. So thank you guys for joining me. The show wouldn't be possible without y', all, and it also wouldn't be possible without my friend Christos. How are you, buddy? Doing great. All right, Christos, we don't have time because we're talking about the other Christos. We're talking about Jesus Christos. The Lord himself. The second best one. All right, come on. You're getting heretical off Rip. Okay? And this is why the comments are lambasting you every single day. Let me just say a few things up top. First off, it's cold in the studio, okay? It's freezing. We don't have heat because we're in the middle of the. The Canadian wilderness, okay? We're deep in the tundra. Not at a studio in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, okay? We are far, far away. And that's why I'm wearing my cozy coat, all right? Secondly, I want to make it clear. I. I was raised Catholic, all right? I was not raised Hindu. I was not raised Muslim. I was not raised Scientologist. So some of the information in here, it's possible I may have overlooked some things. Possible that part of it is incorrect. It's also possible my pronunciation is not perfect. So if I miss anything, please don't hesitate to correct me gently in the comments. Okay? Let me also say, if you're interested in, you know, the stuff we're doing over here at the Camp Universe, check out History Camp, where I dive into all the historical topics I'm fascinated by. And then, of course, Camp Gagnon, the main channel, where we do a lot of interviews and talk to people much smarter than I am about all the things that matter. I think that's basically everything, right? So let's dive in. This is a fascinating conversation for me because, you know, I was raised Catholic, so in my view, Jesus Christ is the Lord. He's the one and only. He's the Son of God, triune, you know, God the Father, God the Son, and God the Holy Spirit, all existing as one. And for me, that was basically just my philosophy on Jesus Christ my whole life. And then I started talking to my Muslim friends. They're like, you know, we have Jesus Christ in our tradition. I go, what? They go, yes, Isa bin Maryam. He is the prophet in Islam. Peace be upon him. And I was like, whoa, that's crazy. So I started looking into it. Almost every worldview on earth has a story about this immaculate person. Okay, was he a guru, as many Eastern philosophies will tout, Just a wise, you know, thinker that sort of reached a level of nirvana, some type of enlightenment. Was he the Messiah himself? Again, we're not going to figure all these answers out today, but we can explore what many of these traditions, both in a literal sort of dogmatic sense, but also in sort of a casual, you know, philosophical sense, what they say about Jesus Christ and it's interesting because it will give an insight as to how these different religions and philosophies sort of operate. You know, is it something very rigorous? Is it something very specific? Is it something more that's, you know, kind of just like open and, you know, free to interpretation? And we'll even explore some of like the, dare I say, fringe philosophies, you know, gnosticism, things like that. We're going to be getting into all of it. We'll also answer some of the big questions, right? Why do some religions see him as divine while others see him as a, you know, a spiritual teacher? And why do the teachings resonate with some people from different parts of the world and different backgrounds? And what does this tell us about the way humans, human beings search for meaning? So I'm hoping by the end of this discussion you'll have a deeper understanding of Jesus Christ, who he is, and how different religions and how different people around the world view this person. So we should probably start with Christianity, right? That one makes the most sense. It has Jesus in the name Jesus Christ. Deanity. So, I mean, you probably, if you've grown up Christian, you think you got it all figured out. You know, that's how I feel. And Christianity's take on Jesus is, shall I say, the most straightforward. Okay, we start with his birth. All right, this is the grand entrance. Christians believe that Jesus wasn't just born, he was divinely conceived. In Christianity, it is believed that the angel Gabriel appears to a young woman named Mary and tells her that she is going to have a baby. She says, let thy will be done. And the craziest part, she is a virgin. She is perfect. She is the perfect woman. And the Son of God will be born from her. This is a, you know, a miraculous conception. And it's not just a cool origin story. It is the proof of Jesus's divine nature. This idea that Jesus being conceived by the Holy Spirit is both fully divine, you know, from God and also fully human from Mary. And this divine birth sets the stage for everything that Christians really believe about Jesus. So, you know, Jesus is growing up and he's not your regular kid. Again, not a ton is known about Jesus's early life, you know, the, the lost years of his time before his sort of, you know, testimony and work as, you know, a spiritual leader. But Christians believe he is the long awaited Messiah that is prophesied in the Old Testament. So, you know, the Jews of this time are waiting for Messiah and here he is, Jesus. So as Jesus is beginning his Ministry. He's not only a miracle worker and not only a wise teacher. Christians believe he is God in human form. He is a part of this Holy Trinity that I've spoken about. Okay, this is the concept that has, I will say, been debated for centuries. But it is this idea that God is three in one. The Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. And they are distinct yet fully one God. And this is why this has been a debate. But we'll save, you know, triune discussion for a different time. Then, of course, you have the crucifixion and the resurrection. Now, these are not just traumatic events. They are cornerstone to what Christians believe about salvation. Christians believe that Jesus willingly died on the cross to take punishment for all of the sins of humanity. It is a profound concept, right, that God himself would incarnate and come to earth in human form and suffer and die for the sake of his creation. It's pretty beautiful. And it doesn't just end there, because three days after the death of God literally for his creation, human beings, he resurrects. And that is true. Resurrection isn't just seen as a miracle. It is viewed as proof that Jesus truly is divine and has power over death and ultimately conquers death. The greatest comeback story of all time with eternal consequences. And this belief in Jesus resurrection isn't just a footnote. It is the entirety of the ball game. I think if there is any singular moment in Christianity that can summarize what it is to be Christian, it is in the resurrection of Christ. That is why Easter is, you know, such a big holiday for Christians around the world. So Paul says in Corinthians 15:14, and if Christ has not been raised and our preaching is in vain and. And your faith is in vain, basically saying that if Christ doesn't raise from the dead, the entire Christian faith is pointless. So that is why it is such an important and integral part of Christian teaching. Now, here's where things are interesting, right, that, you know, Christians don't just believe Jesus is fully divine, they believe that, but they also believe that he is fully human. And this is a dual nature of Jesus. 100% God, 100% human. Which also has sparked a ton of debate. Scholars and church leaders have gone back and forth about this for a long time. Now. Christians believe that Jesus's humanity is what makes him relatable. He experiences hunger, he experiences fatigue and even doubt. In Luke 22, verse 44, he even backs up this idea and says, and being in agony, he prayed more earnestly and his sweat began, became like Great drops of blood falling to the ground. Now that's not just a divine drama. It is a human moment of fear and anguish. And at the same time, his divinity means that he has the power to save humanity from death and from sin. But here's the thing. While all of these beliefs about Jesus are central to Christianity, they are not universally accepted outside the faith. Other religions have their own perspective on who Jesus was and what he means. So obviously, Christians will see Jesus as, you know, divine, the son of God who became human to save the world. Other religions will have their own perspectives. So let's shift our perspective to Islam. Now, if you don't know Muslims, you might be surprised to know that Jesus is a big deal in Islam, that Jesus is one of the prophets. And so Jesus in Islam is known as Isa. Now, Muslims will deviate with Christians on who Jesus was because he is respected as a prophet and as all the prophets are, matter of fact. I mean, I'll even have Muslim friends be like, yes, of course, Isa. Peace be upon him. They will show a ton of reverence and respect for Jesus Christ, but they don't see him as. As divine. So let's start with his birth. For Muslims, much like Christians, Jesus was born of a virgin. Mary, or Miriam in Arabic is highly respected in Islam. It's a very common name amongst Muslims around the world. And in fact, she is the only woman mentioned by name in the Quran. And there's an entire chapter named after her. The Quran also describes how Mary was visited by an angel who told her that she would give birth to a pure son. Sounds familiar? Because it should. And it is almost exactly to the Christian account, except in the Quran, the angel is Jabril, the translation of Gabriel. Now here's where things start to diverge. While Muslims believe in Jesus's miraculous birth, they don't see it as proof of his divinity. Instead, they see it as a sign of God's power to create life in the way that he chooses. Now, there are miracles. As we've talked in Christianity briefly, Christ is a miracle worker. Now, Muslims believe that Jesus was also a miracle worker. The Quran mentions several of Jesus miracles, including healing the blind, healing lepers, raising the dead, and even creating a bird out of clay and breathing life into it. It's pretty impressive, right? And here's what's interesting. In Islam, these miracles aren't seen as proof that Jesus is divine. Rather, they are viewed as signs given to him by God to prove his prophethood. So in Muslim tradition, Jesus is portrayed as a humble servant of God always quick to attribute all of his miracles to God, to Allah. It's like he's saying like, hey, don't look at me, I'm just the messenger. I'm just a prophet for God. All credit goes to the one and only God, Allah. Now speaking of messengers, that is really how you know Islam views Jesus, that he is one of the most important prophets and messengers of God. In fact he is considered one of the five most important prophets and in Islam alongside the prophets Noah, Abraham, Moses and of course the prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him. Now in Islamic belief, Jesus was sent to guide the children of Israel back into the straight path. He came with a new scripture known as the Injil, also known as the Gospel of Issa, which Muslims believe was the original uncorrupted message of God. However, they also believe that this original message has been lost or altered over time. Now here is where we get another fork in the road between Islamic and Christian belief. While Christians see Jesus as the son of God and part of the Holy Trinity, Islam rejects these ideas. The Quran is very clear on this point, stating in no uncertain terms that God has no offspring and that there is no God but Allah. So for Muslims the concept of God having a son is seen as incompatible with God's nature. They argue that an all powerful, self sufficient God doesn't need a son or partners. Right? It's like saying like, hey, there's one singular monotheistic being that is known as Allah, that is God. So in Islam Jesus is just seen as a fully human prophet of Allah. And of course he is exceptionally important and is able to do miracles because of the power of Allah, but he is not considered divine and he is not worshiped. Muslims respect and love Jesus, but their worship is reserved for for Allah alone. Now another prominent difference amongst Muslims and Christians in their belief of Jesus is the end of his earthly ministry, specifically the crucifixion. So while Christians believe that Jesus was crucified and then resurrected, the Islamic narrative takes a different approach. According to the Quran, Jesus wasn't crucified at all. Instead it states that it was made to appear to them that Jesus was crucified. Now what exactly this means is still up for debate and it has been discussed by Muslim scholars for centuries. Some interpret this to mean that someone else was made to look like Jesus and was crucified in his place. While others suggest that Jesus was put on the cross but he didn't die there. They believe that he was taken away and actually ended up surviving. But of course this is disputed amongst Muslim scholars. Regardless of the specific interpretation, the core belief remains this, that Jesus was not necessarily killed by crucifixion. So what happened to Jesus? In the Quran, it states that God raised him to himself, so he raised up Jesus to himself. And many Muslims interpret this to mean that Jesus was taken to heaven, you know, bodily or spiritually without experiencing death. And this belief has a lot of interesting points. For one, it means that in Islamic tradition, Jesus didn't die for anyone's sins. The whole concept that Jesus died for humanity is central to Christianity, but it doesn't exist in Islam. Instead, Muslims believe that each person is responsible for their own actions, and they must seek forgiveness for what they do directly from Allah. But the story of Jesus in Islam doesn't end with his ascension. Many Muslims believe that Issa will return to earth near the end of times. And in Islamic end time theology, or eschatology as it's called, Isa plays a critical role in the events that lead up to the Judgment Day. He's expected to return to defeat the Antichrist, also known as the Dajjal in Islamic traditions. You know, we call it the Antichrist in Christianity, but it is ultimately the end time person that will come and sort of unite the world in an evil way against the will of Allah. And Isa will come down to destroy the dajjal, and then basically justice on earth will be established and lead people to true faith in Allah. It's worth noting that while Jesus is highly revered in Islam, he is not the final messenger of God. And that role is purely the Prophet Muhammad. Now, Muslims see Muhammad as the seal of the prophets, the final messenger sent to all of humanity, not just a specific group. In the Quran, it mentions that Jesus prophesied the coming of Muhammad. And this is based on the interpretation of a verse where Jesus speaks of a messenger that will come looking for him, named Ahmad, which is another name for Muhammad. So you might be wondering, if Muslims have such a high regard for Jesus, why don't we hear more about Jesus in Islam? And that's partially because it's just a different, different emphasis. While, you know, Jesus is so central to Christianity, in Islam, the focus is on the message more than the messenger. So the core of Islam is the belief in one God and the teachings of the Quran, which Muslims believe is the direct word of God. So that said, Jesus plays a significant role in Islamic thought and spirituality. And many Muslim scholars and mystics have written extensively about Jesus and praised his miracles and his asceticism and his teachings. As a matter of Fact, in Sufi tradition, which is sort of a mystical subset of Islam, Jesus is often portrayed as the perfect example of spiritual poverty and trust in Allah. And there are beautiful stories in Islamic tradition about Jesus and his compassion and humility and his wisdom. One famous hadith states, both in this world and in the hereafter, I am the nearest of all people to Jesus, the son of Mary. The prophets are paternal brothers. Their mothers are different, but their religion is one. And this hadith really encapsulates the Islamic view of Jesus. He is a beloved brother in the faith and part of the same prophetic tradition that culminates in the Prophet Muhammad. And it's a perspective that sees continuity where others might see some contradiction. So that is basically Jesus in Islam. You know, it's clear that while there are significant differences in the Christian view, there's still a deep respect and a love for Issa Ben Mariam. He is the mighty prophet, a performer of miracles, a bringer of divine guidance, and really a key figure even in the end times of Islam. So we've talked about Christianity. Obviously, Jesus is the Messiah. Islam, Jesus is a prophet. But what about Jesus's own people, the people of Judaism, the Jews themselves? This was the religion of Jesus. Some would say, well, they have a different perspective. In Judaism, Jesus isn't seen as the divine figure that Christians worship. Instead, he is viewed primarily as a historical figure. This is a man who lived and taught and died as a Jew in ancient Judea. Now, let's start with the basics. Jesus was born and raised Jewish. He lived his entire life as a Jew. He was circumcised on the eighth day. He celebrated Jewish holidays. He taught in synagogues. In fact, many Jews today see Jesus as a rabbi who was deeply rooted in the Jewish traditions of the time. Now, many of Jesus's teachings align closely with a lot of Jewish principles. So take for example, you know, love your neighbor as yourself. This isn't necessarily a new Christian idea. It's straight out of the Hebrew Bible, Leviticus 19:18. When Jesus was asked about the greatest commandment, he responded with the Shema. This is a central prayer in Judaism. Hear, O Israel, the Lord our God, the Lord is one. So it's interesting to see how his teachings fit into the broader Jewish context. But don't think that this means that Judaism accepts Jesus as the Messiah or divine. That's where Judaism and Christianity will split. In Jewish belief, the Messiah is expected to fulfill specific prophecies, bring world peace, gather all the Jews back to the land of Israel and rebuild the Temple in Jerusalem. From a Jewish perspective, Jesus didn't do any of this. And also the very idea of a divine Messiah or a God in human form kind of goes against the core principles of Judaism, which is the absolute unity and non materialism of God. So for Jews, worshiping a human as God would be considered idolatry, which is one of the gravest sins in Judaism. And it just doesn't really fit into the Jewish worldview. So if Jews don't see Jesus as the Messiah or as divine, how do they see him? Well, the opinions on this will vary depending on who you ask. Some will see him as a teacher who has some good ideas but ultimately led people away from traditional Judaism. Others view him as a failed messianic claimant, you know, not the first or the last in Jewish history. And some modern Jewish scholars even try to, in a way, like, reclaim Jesus as like an important Jewish teacher separate from later Christian theology. And one thing that stands out about Jesus in his time was his independence in interpreting Jewish law, which is pretty controversial. Back then, you see, in traditional Judaism, interpretations of the law were based on a chain of transmission going back all the way to Moses. But Jesus often prefaced his teachings with, you have heard it said, but I say to you. So you know, you can see that this would be pretty controversial amongst the Jewish elite and the rabbis of the time. This approach would, you know, make him fairly unpopular. So take for example, Jesus's teaching on the Sabbath. He was criticized for healing on the Sabbath, which was seen as a violation of the law that prohibited work on the Sabbath. But Jesus argued that saving a life takes precedence over Sabbath restrictions. And this is a principle that with mainstream Jewish thought, like, if you're a Jewish doctor and someone's dying, you can save them on the Sabbath. So it's, you know, he was pushing the boundaries of interpretation, but still within a Jewish framework. It's also worth noting that Jesus had many conflicts with many other Jewish leaders at his time. And that wasn't really unique. The first century was a period of intense debate and division within Judaism. You had the Pharisees, the Sadducees, the essay, and various other Messianic movements all arguing about the correct interpretation of Jewish law and tradition. And Jesus was a part of this vibrant Jewish discourse. What's up, people? We're going to take a break because we got new merch. That's right, it is the holiday season and the good folks over at Camp R and D have been cooking up in the lab. We got the Christmas sweaters with the Aliens. We got the Christmas sweaters with the conspiracy vibes you already know. I mean, this one might be my favorite one. A Christmas tree full of aliens. Full Christmas sweater energy. And then, of course, if you just want something simple, you know, you bust out the camp logo tee with the little Christmas lights on it. Come on, bro. Get cute for Christmas, okay? It is a holiday season, all right? We're celebrating the birth of the savior, okay? And what better way to do it than to cop a couple threads for the person in your life that you know that loves a campsite that loves hanging with us every single week. And right now, we're running a promo through the holidays. That's right. Use the promo code. Christmascamp for 15 off. I just made that up on the spot. But I think we could do it right. I'll call some people. Christmas camp for 20, for 15% off. Sure, 16% off. Whatever you say, Mark. Should we give them more? One more. 17% off, people, we don't. I think this is going to work. I'm not positive we're going to see if we can do it, but I'll. Yeah. Check it out, guys. We got all the camp stuff going until the end of the year. Check it out. Thank you guys so much for supporting the show. I love you all. God bless and merry Christmas. Close your eyes. Exhale. Feel your body relax, and let go of whatever you're carrying today.
