
Donna Summer’s 1977 hit “I Feel Love” is the inspiration for the final track on Beyoncé’s new album, “Renaissance.” Summer became the queen of disco in the ’70s, but her catalog goes much further than that. You can hear her legacy in decades of electronic and R&B. “She is an architect of the pop culture we experience today,” J says. In this episode, J and Wesley revisit her 1982 album, “Donna Summer” — and explore why, out of all of her music, this self-titled album is the most distinctly Donna.
Loading summary
Narrator/Announcer
Throughout the Fort Myers area, life unfolds at your own speed. Here, connecting to loved ones and yourself is an unhurried pleasure. Whether kayaking beneath mangroves, pausing to watch birds take flight, finding seashells along the shoreline, or walking the beach, each moment invites reflection. Fort Myers is a place to experience fully at a pace that just feels. Feels right. Discover a slower, more intentional way of living@Visit fort myers.com hey, everybody.
Wesley Morris
Just wanted to say that we're about to have conversation about one of our favorite artists, Donna Summer. But there's also a little Michael Jackson in it, and we just wanted to let you know that in case it's something you don't want to deal with today.
Jay Wortham
As always, take care of yourself first, and we will see you on the other side. One of the many visceral pleasures delights of the new Beyonce album Renaissance is that it brought us, our dearly departed Donna Summer, back into the public consciousness. Yes.
Wesley Morris
Yes. Oh, yes. This is Summer Renaissance. And it is an interpolation of Donna Summer's I Feel Love.
Jay Wortham
Yes.
Wesley Morris
And it's like an express train to bliss. I mean, this is the thing about Beyonce.
Jay Wortham
I mean, she loves to give flowers, and the song and the entire album is an honoring of Donna Summer. It's like flowing, curly hair, glittering sequins, something fur, something opulent.
Wesley Morris
Yes.
Jay Wortham
Those are the visuals that accompany her music. You know, that imagery has become a backbone of contemporary culture. I mean, if you think about it, she is an architect of the pop culture we experience today.
Wesley Morris
Yeah. This one song, I Feel Love, is responsible for 50 years of electronic music in all its forms and all its permutations, all the directions it wound up going, and we are still living in it in 2022.
Jay Wortham
Yes.
Wesley Morris
And because of this song and a bunch of songs she does after this, in the 1970s, she essentially becomes the queen of disco. And how she gets to this place is. You know, it's. It's kind of an interesting story. She's born in Boston in 1948 and tries to get a part in the Broadway musical Hair. Can't get a part in. In the Broadway production. So the producers are like, well, you know, we have a spot in Germany, if you want to do that. So she goes to Germany, becomes a fluent German speaker. She's doing girl group stuff. She's doing gospel rock, and at some point hooks up with this guy, Giorgio Moroder, who, along with Pete Bilade, Donna Summer, invent what essentially becomes disco. They perfected, is what I should say.
Jay Wortham
Okay, okay.
Wesley Morris
And they did many Many songs together. But I Feel Love was a song that just was completely electronic. The only organic, real instrument on the whole thing, the only sort of like human generated sound on that song is Donna Summer's voice.
Jay Wortham
It's so good. It's so good. It's so good. It's so. Okay, Wesley, you know, I'm all about the body right now. I'm all about thinking about what it means to be in your body, to lose your body, to let go of it a little bit. And, you know, that song, I Feel Love invites you in to let the music just rip through you. And also what's happening around the same time in American history is the arrival of the study of Somatics, which is all about trying to move out of getting out of your head and back into the body. And that this song comes out pretty much in the same time that this understanding of Somatic's work is arriving in the west, to me just feels like not just a coincidence, but that Donna Summer is a soothsayer. And she knew that people needed to be feeling themselves, to heal themselves, to sort of be in relationship to themselves and other people and their bodies and the earth.
Wesley Morris
Yeah, I mean, like, it. It is a letting your body control your mind.
Jay Wortham
It's like a shot of adrenaline laced with sparkle paste. Like it just shoots you to the moon. It elevates your mood, it raises your credit score, it smooths out your wrinkles. It just fills you with serotonin.
Wesley Morris
But I would also say that there's more to her than I Feel Love. And I think one of her challenges as an artist was to try to complicate her sound. The ways in which she is always combining, recombining, rethinking, bringing in the church, bringing in rock and roll, synthesizing those things with electronic music. And my favorite Donna Summer album, the one that best shows off this interest in a diversity of sound is one that nobody paid attention to.
Jay Wortham
Okay.
Wesley Morris
Came out in 1982. And I feel like to understand what this woman was really all about, we should talk about that.
Jay Wortham
I'm in.
Wesley Morris
So today on this show, we're going to talk about Donna Summer, the album by Donna Summer. I'm Wesley Morris.
Jay Wortham
And I'm Jay Wortham.
Wesley Morris
We're two culture writers at the New York Times.
Jay Wortham
And this is still processing.
Wesley Morris
It's gotta be. The first time I ever heard Donna Summer was in 1982, when I was maybe 6. My mother bought a lot of 45 singles because they were cheaper than whole albums. And I distinctly remember there Being a copy of a song called State of Independence. And on the COVID was this woman. And she was just strikingly beautiful to me. And the song was just as beautiful. It had this great heavy bottom, but it kind of chugged along with the sound that I did not know, I would not have known then to describe as like some kind of African, Latin something. Right. And she sounded so sure of what she was singing.
Jay Wortham
Yes. Her voice is so beautiful too.
Wesley Morris
It's so beautiful. I played that song over and over and over and over. And my mom at some point was like, stop it.
Jay Wortham
Wow.
Wesley Morris
And at some point I got my hands on the whole album. And the album is called Donna Summer. Now, the producer of the self titled Donna Summer album was Quincy Jones. And at this point in 1982, Quincy Jones, he is one of the biggest producers in the world. They make this great song called State of Independence. There is like a 25 person choir on this, on this song. Every single person is a person you've heard of. Let's call Lionel. Lionel Richie. Is Stevie around? We'll call Stevie Wonder. You know our friend Dionne Warwick. I saw her at the Gelsons the other day. Wonder what she's up to. Just bring everybody in. And I'm a big chart person. And I was home keeping track of the charts. Guess what? Never cracked the top 40, of course, number 41. But you know what was a hit?
Jay Wortham
Wow.
Wesley Morris
The same song, basically.
Jay Wortham
I was gonna say it's like the inverse of that song.
Wesley Morris
Well, both these songs have a kind of driving like Caribbean, African. They're both drawing from diasporic sources basically. Right. To make a kind of R and B. And the thing about the Donna Summer album is that I have always thought of this self titled album as the B side to Thriller.
Jay Wortham
Okay. What?
Wesley Morris
Well, I mean, first of all, Quincy Jones produced them both.
Jay Wortham
The DNA's there.
Wesley Morris
But also because these are two artists who are really thinking about what the future should sound like and the way to take all this technology and make it sound like it's moving somewhere into the future. And Michael Jackson is on this album in what way? He's in the State of Independence choir. He's also in there. Yeah, yeah. So I just want to say that I. In my mind, I. What I see is Donna Summer down the hall from Michael Jackson.
Jay Wortham
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Wesley Morris
And Quincy's just like.
Jay Wortham
He's running back and forth.
Wesley Morris
Donna, I gotta go.
Jay Wortham
Right.
Wesley Morris
Michael. Michael's calling. He won't stop.
Jay Wortham
No surprise there. The contributions of an incredible radical black woman lost to time because some Men were too busy.
Wesley Morris
But what if this album had done what Thriller did? Even did like 10% of what thriller did. Now, I'm not about to sit here and tell you that Donna Summer is a better album than Thriller. I'm not saying that.
Jay Wortham
Okay.
Wesley Morris
That's not what you hear coming out my mouth. But Donna Summer is all about bringing 100% of her many different interests to this album that she is calling something after herself. And so one of my favorite songs in this album is called if It Hurts Just a Little.
Jay Wortham
Come on, baby.
Wesley Morris
Come on, sugar.
Jay Wortham
Come on, honey. Come on down.
Wesley Morris
Come on, baby.
Jay Wortham
Hold on a second.
Wesley Morris
This is called It Hurts if It Hurts Just a Little.
Jay Wortham
Okay?
Wesley Morris
And it just has that oomph, that char. The best part of the meat is the chard stuff that was on the grill. It's a little salty, crispy, savory, burnt ass ends right here. The thing about that song that I love so much is that you can hear what the next 10 years of American R and B is kind of going to sound like.
Jay Wortham
Okay.
Wesley Morris
It's got that sort of up tempo kind of sideways funk where, like, the percussion is sort of driving the, you know, this. This call and response gospel element in conversation with this driving percussion. And it just is. All you want to do is move yourself to it. I think one of the things about this album that is interesting to think about, it's like Thriller does not sound like anything else. There's nothing that sounds like that album.
Jay Wortham
Yeah.
Wesley Morris
And this, to me, sounds like you can hear a template being established for other artists to try. It is in conversation with a future R and B.
Jay Wortham
If it hurts just a little bigger. Oh, and if you try, you will see.
Wesley Morris
So they could have done six more of those?
Jay Wortham
Absolutely.
Wesley Morris
But no, she's like, Quincy, I have some other feelings. My boy Bruce Springsteen, he was in Gelson's too. This is Protection. And this is Bruce on the guitar.
Jay Wortham
How unexpected.
Wesley Morris
Yes. This, by the way, to me, is the beat it of Donna Summers.
Jay Wortham
Donna Summers.
Wesley Morris
What? This is the beat of Protection.
Jay Wortham
I want to hear it again.
Wesley Morris
Now, I'm not saying that Protection and Beat it sound alike. They don't sound alike, but they're serving a similar function. And I don't know if it was Quincy's idea to have a great singer paired with a great guitarist, a great white rock guitarist. And Bruce Springsteen is not exactly Eddie Van Halen, you know, in terms of, you know, that legendary solo on Beating Legendary. But the concept is the same. Take an established rock star and put them with an established R and B pop star and see what happens. Yeah, it's true that Protection also does sound like it is responding to a moment and beat. It sounds like it just really, truly dropped from the sky from some other planet. Whereas Protection sounds like a Bruce Springsteen song that Donna Summer is singing. She's making a case for all the ways in which this music can be recombined. And that to me is enough.
Jay Wortham
Huh?
Wesley Morris
But this album didn't do so well commercially. I, I mean it was, it went gold. Not bad.
Jay Wortham
It's wild.
Wesley Morris
It's just wild.
Jay Wortham
And what does it mean that Donna Summer was someone equally talented, equally resourced, equally available, and equally in the same position as Michael at that moment in history. And yet one person makes Thriller, the other person makes a self titled album. The world remembers Thriller.
Wesley Morris
Don't nobody remember this album.
Jay Wortham
Yes, we're always curious about these alternative histories, what could have Been. And this is a really juicy one.
Wesley Morris
I just think about this all the time. Like I think Wannabe Starting Something is the single greatest opening song on any album, maybe ever. And I also think sometimes what would have happened if Quincy had given it to Donna Summer?
Jay Wortham
Absolutely.
Wesley Morris
What would Donna done with Wannabe Starting Something? Now instead we have Donna Summer, the album by Donna Summer. And she's got a great voice that, you know, the disco era didn't always allow her to use. And so I think we're gonna take a break and when we come back, I want to talk about this one song where I think Donna Summer sounds great. And simultaneously I have never heard her sound like this before.
Jay Wortham
Let's do it.
Narrator/Announcer
This episode is supported by Choiceology, an original podcast from Charles Schwab hosted by Katie Milkman, an award winning behavioral scientist and author of the best selling book how to Change. Choiceology is a show about the psychology and economics behind our decisions. Hear true stories from Nobel laureates, historians, authors, athletes and everyday people about why we do the things we do. Listen to choiceology@schwab.com podcast or wherever you listen.
Sponsor/Advertisement Voice
This message is from Saatva. Come Labor Day, the days grow shorter and we fall back into our regular routines. But for Team USA athletes training for the Olympic and Paralympic Games Milano Cortina, 2026, it's go time. Time for longer days, harder training and deeper restorative sleep that's essential to their recovery. Saatva is proud to help as official mattress and restorative sleep provider of Team USA. You can enjoy that kind of sleep too. Visit saatva.comnyt to save $625 on $1,000 or more. Don't just imagine a better future. Start investing in one with betterment, whether it's saving for today or building wealth for tomorrow. We help people in small businesses put their money to work. We automate to make savings simpler. We optimize to make investing smarter. We build innovative technology backed by financial experts. For anyone who's ever said, I think I can do better, so be invested in yourself. Be invested in your business. Be invested in better with betterment. Get started@betterment.com Investing involves risk. Performance not guaranteed.
Wesley Morris
Jay.
Jay Wortham
What?
Wesley Morris
I cannot believe we have made it this far into a conversation about Donna Summer by Donna Summer and have not talked about the opening song, Laying on Me.
Jay Wortham
What are you waiting for?
Wesley Morris
You ain't ready.
Jay Wortham
Oh, yes.
Wesley Morris
A little like percussion. Like hard percussion. The bass sound, it's got that funk synth. And she's having a great time singing this song like that. The way she sounds where she just. There's been a change inside my life.
Jay Wortham
Wow.
Wesley Morris
It's just. She sounds. She never sounded like that before.
Jay Wortham
Maybe one of the reasons she's never sounded like this before is because she hasn't ever felt like this before.
Wesley Morris
Okay.
Jay Wortham
She's back in the States after having lived abroad for nearly a decade. It sounded like she found a lot of freedom living abroad the way many black Americans do. And she's coming back home. She's coming back into a country that can only see a black woman who dares to mention or play around with sex and sexuality as being this vixen, to put it politely.
Wesley Morris
Well, not only that, but just to want to be taken seriously. Absolutely.
Jay Wortham
As a. Right. As a human.
Wesley Morris
There's an interview that she gave where she basically is saying, listen, one of the hardships for me is that people don't take me seriously.
Jay Wortham
Right.
Wesley Morris
And what they couldn't take seriously was that in the minds of a lot of people, Donna Summer was the queen of disco.
Jay Wortham
Hmm.
Wesley Morris
It can feel like a limitation child.
Jay Wortham
Yes. I'm tired just listening to you. The world wouldn't let this woman reinvent herself. Surprise, surprise, Keep going.
Wesley Morris
That's basically it. And by the way, yes. This was a music that ate the country.
Jay Wortham
That's right.
Wesley Morris
This is not some little mini genre. This wasn't something that happened or where nobody. Donald Duck. Has a mock disco song. Everybody did a disco song. The biggest movie of 1977 is Saturday Night Fever, where a white man goes to dance at a disco.
Jay Wortham
Are you as good in bed as you on that dance floor?
Wesley Morris
Disco is everywhere. In the late 1970s, and people are sick of it.
Jay Wortham
Yeah.
Wesley Morris
And it all comes to a head in 1979 at a white Sox game where the field is essentially piled high with disco records and then set on fire. This was a white male energy. White male rock energy. This is now officially the world's largest anti disco rally. But there's something about that moment where they have the disco demolition, basically, is what. What it wound up being called, where, you know, these white guys are basically laying waste to music made by black people. Yeah, black women.
Jay Wortham
A lot of black women.
Wesley Morris
Queer people.
Jay Wortham
It's upsetting because what's being burned is ideas and freedom and play.
Wesley Morris
Yes.
Jay Wortham
It's just such an antidote to the heaviness of the economy, the political environment, everything. And for a bunch of people to say, y' all have had your fun and we don't want to see any more of it is really scary.
Wesley Morris
The images are upsetting.
Jay Wortham
Yeah. The history of white people using fire to keep us from ourselves. You look at those images and they are familiar.
Wesley Morris
Oh, yeah. I mean, we can just say it. It was a lynching by other means.
Jay Wortham
I mean, imagine being Donna Summer and trying to still make music after something like that. But Donna Summer, she's no stranger to this kind of hate. She says, you know what? I receive this, I see it, and this will not put out my flame. And Donna Summer joins a long legacy of people who have a different experience of identity and self while being abroad, where they find a type of support and feel a freedom of categorization in some ways, right?
Wesley Morris
Yes.
Jay Wortham
The way that Europe shows up in the 60s and 70s for a lot of people is a place of respite. It is a place of reprieve from everything that's happening here in the civil rights and post civil rights era. And it seems like she finds a home in Germany that other scholars and black feminist thinkers, including our own Audre Lorde, have found. Audre Lorde starts spending a ton of time in Berlin while she's recovering from cancer. She finds all these Afro Germans who are there. And so there is this incredible black radical feminist consciousness in parts of Germany. And, you know, it's hard to know, but to what extent was Donna Summer engaging or feeling any of that?
Wesley Morris
And I think that there's something about experiencing that in Europe and then coming back to the United States and hooking up with. I mean, the first black producer she works with is Quincy is Quincy Jones. Right. And the sound that they arrive at together. There are nine songs on this album, not a One sounds like the other, except there's an element in all of them to gospel and that is really striking to me. Except. Except. Except the last song, which is called Lush Life. And it's a cover of the classic, you know, jazz standard Lush Life by the one and only Billy Strayhorn.
Jay Wortham
I definitely heard this song. Delilah played this song at some point in my childhood when I was driving home somewhere in the backseat of my dad's car. I feel I like, I deeply resonate with this saxophone.
Wesley Morris
I don't know if you know anything about Billy Strayhorn.
Jay Wortham
I don't.
Wesley Morris
He was Duke Ellington's right hand man.
Jay Wortham
Okay.
Wesley Morris
Negro gay person, huh? One of us, you know, in the 1930s and 40s. And the idea that this person in Ladonna Adrian Gaines Summer wanted to end the album is Billy Strayhorn's classic American staple, Lush Life. It's just really deep to me. But I heard a story that I know is true that Donna didn't want to sing it.
Jay Wortham
Oh.
Wesley Morris
Because she was a little concerned about, you know, Billy Strayhorn being openly gay. And Donna Summer, you know, has these struggles about, you know, her Christianity and it's sort of anti gay values. And Quincy Jones is like, hey, Donna, you can do it. This song is great. Everybody has sung this song. I think you can do it and I think you could do a great job singing it. So why don't you give it a try.
Jay Wortham
Again?
Wesley Morris
But the biggest hit she had during this period in the 1980s was not on this album. And it's the song, the mega hit. She works hard for the money. And there's something about the you better treat her right part. It's always stuck with me.
Jay Wortham
Yeah, cuz it's a song. I mean, she famously writes this song after noticing a very fatigued bathroom attendant on a night out. And she's like, she works hard for her money. And also I think writes a song for women like this bathroom attendant and herself and I'm sure mother, aunts, cousins, sibling, just recognizing how hard women work to be recognized to whatever degree. Donna Summer's aware that the world cannot appreciate some of her genuine talents and her real intellectual labor. I mean, she talks about having these hit songs and everyone around the world knowing her name and knowing her music and being so sick she can't eat, she can't sleep. And the compression that she feels because of this fame, because of this compression into a sex icon, and it culminates in a deep depression and a suicide attempt. And when you think about it, she works hard for the money. Is also about Donna Summer. We should also luxuriate a bit in. In the credit that Beyonce gave to Donna Summer. Right? It is a type of care. It is a type of archival practice. It is a type of stewardship that black women must do for each other. And this is a very long and rich practice. It's everywhere from Twitter with Cite Black Women. It's work that Alice Walker did when she wrote a piece about going to find where Zora Neale Hurston was buried and finding an unmarked grave and reminding the world of the work that she did and brought her out of a type of obscurity and obsolescence to remind people of her contribution. And I think this is work that Beyonce's doing right now. Like, let me remind you, let's enjoy this album. Let's enjoy this sound, but let's talk about where it came from and one of the shapers of this cultural movement. But I do think there is something incredibly profound and generous in the reminder that the world is not always going to remember us for our contributions, but we can do it for each other.
Wesley Morris
That's our show.
Jay Wortham
Still Processing is produced by Elissa Dudley with Christina Josa and Hans Buto. We are edited by Sarah Saracen and Sasha Weiss.
Wesley Morris
The show is mixed by Marianne Lozano and recorded by Maddie Masiello.
Jay Wortham
Digital production by Mahima Chablani.
Wesley Morris
Our photo editor is Esla Attar. Our theme music's by Kindness. It's called World Restart from the album Otherness. And yo, we're gonna be back next week.
Jay Wortham
Yes, you were gonna do that.
Host: The New York Times
Episode Title: Summer Renaissance
Date: November 8, 2022
In this episode, Wesley Morris and Jay Wortham dive deeply into the influence and legacy of the iconic Donna Summer, examining her pivotal impact on pop and electronic music—particularly through the lens of Beyonce’s album "Renaissance," which revives Donna Summer’s spirit and sound for modern audiences. Through personal reminiscences, critical analysis, and cultural context, they explore Donna’s innovation, the struggles of Black women in music, and the significance of honoring artistic foremothers.
"Summer Renaissance" provides a rich, nuanced reflection on Donna Summer’s significance as more than just the "Queen of Disco": she emerges as a bold musical innovator, a Black feminist figure navigating structural and cultural barriers, and a continuous inspiration for icons like Beyonce. Through personal storytelling, historical context, and critical thinking, Wesley Morris and Jay Wortham illuminate the necessity of memory, attribution, and celebration among Black women artists—reminding us that their contributions are foundational to pop culture as we know it.