Cardiac Cowboys: "The Starting Gun"

Podcast: Cardiac Cowboys
Host: Chris Pine (for iHeartPodcasts)
Episode: The Starting Gun
Date: September 29, 2025

Overview

“The Starting Gun” launches the Cardiac Cowboys podcast by plunging listeners into the high-risk, high-reward birth of open heart surgery. Centered on the maverick surgeons of the American Midwest and Texas in the 1950s, it tells the gripping story of deadly childhood heart defects, medical prohibitions, and the wild innovation that defied them — with the fate of a real boy named Gregory Glidden and his father at its heart (literally). The episode showcases the courage, resourcefulness, and setbacks of these largely uncelebrated pioneers, setting up the broader saga of rivalry, radical ideas, and the revolution that shaped cardiac medicine.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. The Forbidden Frontier of Heart Surgery

• Context: In the early 1950s, the heart was a no-go zone for surgeons—considered certain death for the patient. Even the bravest only diagnosed, never treated.
  • “All a cardiologist could do was take a picture and diagnose. They couldn't treat anything.”
    (Dr. Gerald Imber, 02:45)
• Need: Millions of children, post-baby boom, suffered from congenital heart defects. Hospitals were full of doomed kids like Gregory Glidden (03:12).
• Setting the scene: The first open heart surgeries one day would mean the difference between life and death — but in the early 1950s, the field did not yet exist (03:26).

2. Introducing the Mavericks: Lillehei and Lewis

• Background: Not the Ivy League, but the Midwest — specifically the University of Minnesota under Dr. Owen Wangensteen — became the cradle of open heart surgery (11:30).
• Personalities & Contrasts:
  • John Lewis: Tall, witty, poetic, the “Butch Cassidy” of the pair — focused, intellectual, gentle.
  • Walt Lillehei: Stocky, intense, an outsider who rebuilt motorcycles as a teen, “chillingly” driven, with blue eyes that could “stop people in their tracks.”
    • “He absolutely was fascinated about how things fit together and how things actually worked.”
      (Sia Bowman, nurse, 10:24)

3. War Experience and a New Era in Surgery

• WWII aftershocks: Surgeries, blood transfusions, and anesthesia all advanced rapidly because of wartime necessity (09:09).
• University of Minnesota under Wangensteen: A hub for “tinkerers, outside-the-box thinkers and rule breakers” — determined to make the impossible routine (12:29).

4. The First Success: Hypothermia and John Lewis’ Breakthrough

• The Hypothermia Method: By cooling the body to slow metabolism, surgeons could buy precious minutes to work inside the heart.
  • “The heart is pumping blood at five liters a minute, and you open it up and it is still working. It’s a bloodbath.”
    (Dr. Gerald Imber, 07:23)
• The First Case: 1952, John Lewis repairs 5-year-old Jacqueline Johnson’s atrial septal defect, using hypothermia.
  • "I remember looking up at the clock. It was about 10 minutes to 10 when the heart took over. I said, this is it, John. We're into the heart to stay.”
    (Walt Lillehei, 16:34)
• Limitation: Effective only for simple heart defects; more complex cases were impossible.
  • “You could do surgery inside the heart, closing relatively simple defects. But any more complex procedure really was not doable. Reproducibly.”
    (Dr. Eric Rose, 17:13)

5. Lillehei’s Personal Tragedy and Drive

• Cancer Diagnosis: In 1950, Walt Lillehei is diagnosed with non-Hodgkin lymphoma and survives a harrowing 10+ hour surgery, leaving him disfigured and feeling mortal (21:25–23:47).
  • “He really believed that he was living on borrowed time… Life was a gift.”
    (Dr. Craig Lillehei, 23:32)
• New urgency: His own illness fuels a relentless drive to go beyond Lewis’ successes — to cure ever more complex defects (24:08).

6. The Leap: Inventing Cross Circulation

• Eureka Moment: Over drinks, the team wonders if a parent’s (or other donor’s) circulatory system could temporarily serve as a heart-lung machine for the child.
  • “Why don’t we use another animal’s circulation to bypass the heart so that oxygenated blood would go to the brain and you would have time to do what you needed to do?”
    (Dr. Gerald Imber, paraphrasing Lillehei, 26:00)
• DIY Innovation: Assembling equipment from beer tubing, dairy pumps, and anything at hand—true “garage science.”
  • "People of Lillehei's generation, especially the cold weather states in the Midwest, made do with what they had. And if they didn't have something, they made it themselves."
    (Roberta Beach, 27:10)

7. The Glidden Family’s Ordeal and Tragedy

• Case study: Lyman and Frances Glidden have multiple children with fatal heart defects; their daughter dies as a child (18:41–19:36). Their son Gregory is selected as the first candidate for the experimental cross-circulation surgery.
• Consent and Risk: The Glidden parents consent, knowing both Gregory and his father could die (28:18–28:45).

Memorable Quote:

"It was a leap of faith."
(Jamie Napoli, 28:18)

8. Professional Rivalries and Institutional Tensions

• John Lewis’ Failed VSD Attempts: More complex heart defects defeat hypothermia; children die, and Lewis’ career rapidly collapses (30:04–30:53).

  • “It is difficult to tolerate the success of a friend.”
    (John Lewis, as quoted, 30:53)

• Backlash and Resistance: Cross-circulation is seen as dangerous, heretical, even “carnival sideshow” medicine (32:24–32:58). The night before surgery, hospital administrators nearly shut it down.

  • “Congratulations, you’re about to be the first surgeon to have a 200% mortality.”
    (Willis Potts, as quoted about the risks, 32:24)

9. Gregory’s Surgery: Triumph and Heartbreak

• Surgical Sequence: Gregory, at 13 months, undergoes surgery using his father’s blood as life support; Lillehei manually finds and repairs the heart defect (35:55–37:39).

  • “Pump on.”
    (Command in the OR as circulation is established, 36:11)
  • “It's remarkable that he was able to get them closed with relatively primitive needles and primitive suture material that now we take for granted entirely.”
    (Dr. Eric Rose, 37:43)

• Short-lived Victory: Despite a technically perfect operation, Gregory dies days later from pneumonia—a post-operative infection.

  • “He looked and he saw that his repair, his VSD repair, had completely healed. He didn’t know whether to laugh or cry because there was a dead baby on the table. But he knew he had cured his problem and the child had died from pneumonia.”
    (Dr. Gerald Imber, 42:40)

10. The Aftermath: Setback and Persistence

• Institutional Fallout: The hospital views the outcome as justifying their fears.
  • “They thought this was a terrible idea.”
    (Dr. Gerald Imber, 41:52)
• Lillehei’s Relentlessness: Undeterred, he investigates exactly what went wrong, confirming the repair worked, then quietly schedules two more surgeries while administrators are away (45:02).
  • “When something's got to be done, it's got to be done.”
    (Dr. Gerald Imber, 45:13)
• Legacy: Despite initial failure, the innovation works, opening the door to a worldwide revolution in heart surgery.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• “Before 1950, surgeons considered the living heart off limits. Less than 20 years later, doctors weren’t just transplanting hearts, they were building artificial ones.”
  (Chris Pine, 03:00)

• “If he was intensely focused on his work before, now, post op, Lillehei’s drive was preternatural.”
  (Jamie Napoli, 23:47)

• “He had to break the news to the family.”
  (Jamie Napoli, 40:01)

• “Very, very easy to criticize an effort that results in a dead child. But part of Walt’s genius was his persistence.”
  (Dr. Eric Rose, 45:32)

• “His little heart changed the world.”

  • Epitaph on Gregory Glidden’s grave—used to underscore Gregory's sacrifice and its impact (44:28).

• “The door to open heart surgery had just been blown wide open. But no one outside of Walt Lillehei knew it.”
  (Jamie Napoli, 43:02)

Important Timestamps

• [03:26] – The life-or-death stakes in 1954 and the unknown of open heart surgery.
• [07:23] – The technical impossibility and taboo of operating on a beating heart.
• [16:34] – The first successful open heart surgery (John Lewis’ procedure).
• [23:32] – Lillehei’s cancer and “living on borrowed time.”
• [26:00] – The cross-circulation breakthrough discussed over drinks.
• [32:24] – Institutional opposition and the risk of "200% mortality."
• [36:11 – “Pump on”: The first cross-circulation operation on Gregory.
• [37:21] – The moment Lillehei finds and repairs the defect in the heart.
• [42:40] – The revelation: Surgery succeeded; infection killed Gregory.
• [43:28] – Modern beneficiaries, like Dr. Pamela Evans, reflect on Gregory’s legacy.
• [44:28] – The epitaph: “His little heart changed the world.”
• [45:02] – Lillehei’s defiance: scheduling further secret surgeries.

Tone & Style

• The storytelling is cinematic, mixing taut narration with candid archival clips and personal remembrances.
• Language is both medically precise and evocatively emotional: “makeshift laboratories,” “motley crew,” “chillingly intense,” and “living on borrowed time.”
• Speakers’ quotes are left in context, preserving their frankness and immediacy.

Conclusion: Setting the Stage

“The Starting Gun” ends by cementing Lillehei’s cross-circulation as the radical breakthrough that “fired the starting gun” for modern open heart surgery. Though shadowed by tragedy, this episode presents the courageous gamble and perseverance that ignited a revolution, setting up the coming feuds, rivalries, and triumphs in subsequent episodes—where the “rise and fall of the heart surgeon as God” will be explored in greater depth.

For Next Time:

Teaser: The next episode will follow the fierce rivalry that made Houston, Texas the new “cardiovascular capital of the world” — and the competitive, sometimes bitter, dynamic that shaped the field.

(Advertisements, sponsorships, and non-content sections have been omitted from this summary.)