Podcast Summary: "Cómo romper con Israel" (CARNE CRUDA #1519)

Podcast: Carne Cruda
Date: 27 May 2025
Host: Javier Gallego "Carne Cruda"
Guests: Ruth Herrero, Javier Biosca, Javier Espinosa, Quique Andrés Pretel, Miquel Ayestarán, Imad Ismail Egazi

Episode Overview

In this powerful and somber episode, Carne Cruda investigates the unfolding genocide in Gaza and the shifting postures of Western governments toward Israel. The discussion delves into the effectiveness (or lack thereof) of arms embargos, the real impact of diplomatic pressure, internal fissures within Israel, and the growing momentum of citizen-led boycotts. Experts and firsthand witnesses paint a dire portrait of the humanitarian catastrophe and the political complexity of breaking ties with Israel. The episode maintains a strongly critical tone, demanding justice and tangible political action.

Key Themes & Discussion Points

1. The Unprecedented Genocide in Gaza

[00:52–04:06]

• The Gaza genocide is described as unique in history for being broadcasted live and openly acknowledged by its perpetrators (Host, [00:52]).
• High-profile statements by far-right Israeli politicians call for total conquest and colonization of Gaza, targeting even children as enemies (Moshe Feiglin, [00:02]).

  “Cada niño en Gaza es un enemigo. Hay que conquistar Gaza y colonizarla, y no dejar a un solo niño ghazatí allí.” – Moshe Feiglin ([00:02])

• Massive civilian deaths: 54,000 killed, including 16,000 children, plus starvation and mass displacement.
• International response begins shifting as images of famine among children shock the world; slow moves toward arms embargoes and reviews of agreements.

  “El genocidio en Gaza es un hecho único en la historia. [...] Gaza será la tumba del sionismo.” — Host ([00:52])

2. Shifting International Responses: Cosmetic or Substantive?

[04:06–10:28]

• 17 EU countries call for the review of the Association Agreement with Israel due to human rights abuses ([04:22]), citing Article 2 on human rights.
• Arms embargos discussed in Spain, France, Canada, UK; but actions often limited to suspension of new deals or symbolic measures ([05:09], [07:47]).

  “Estamos ante una acción cosmética que responde a la presión también de la opinión pública europea.” — Ruth Herrero ([07:47])

3. The Role of Public Pressure Versus Government Will

[10:28–12:18]

• Real change is coming from public mobilization, not governments.
• Analogy with the anti-apartheid campaign in South Africa: civic boycotts and mass protests gradually isolated the regime.

  “La acción que está cambiando es la movilización popular de la gente en todos los países.” — Javier Espinosa ([10:57])

4. Arms Embargoes: Symbolic or Effective?

[23:10–26:31]

• Spain’s direct arms trade with Israel is minimal, mostly “dual-use” and non-lethal parts. However, Spain is a significant importer of Israeli defense systems (missiles Spike, defense platform Sealam).

  “A día de hoy nuestra dependencia del material israelí es significativa. [...] el proyecto estrella del Ejército de Tierra cuenta con blindaje israelí, comunicaciones tácticas israelí...” — Quique Andrés Pretel ([24:33])

• Arms embargoes are symbolic and easily circumvented via triangulation or indirect cooperation.

  “El embargo es una medida simbólica, puede ser fácilmente sorteado. Hecha la ley, echa la trampa.” — Pretel ([26:31])

5. Economic and Military Interdependence

[23:10–25:48]

• Spain’s trade with Israel hit a record €3 billion in 2022, highlighted by mutual investments and deep military relations.
• Potential embargo would hardly dent Israel’s independent defense industry or its ability to continue military operations ([29:53]).

Notable Quotes & Segments

• Dehumanization of Palestinians:

  “Cada niño en Gaza es un enemigo.” — Moshe Feiglin ([00:02])

• On International Hypocrisy:

  “Netanyahu ya no tiene reparos en reconocer que a Hamas lo financió Israel para destruir a la Autoridad Palestina y que van a tomar y destruir Gaza.” — Host ([00:52])

• On the Impact of Popular Movements:

  “Fue la sociedad la que consiguió imponer un cambio en la estructura y en la percepción política…” — Javier Espinosa ([10:57])

Timeline of the Discussion

• 00:02–00:29: Clip of Moshe Feiglin outlining genocidal rhetoric.
• 00:52–04:06: Host/narrator unpacks the scale of destruction, Israel's impunity, and beginnings of international policy shifts.
• 07:47–10:28: Ruth Herrero and Javier Biosca analyze EU policy changes as largely symbolic, driven by public pressure.
• 10:28–12:18: Javier Espinosa discusses parallels with South Africa: only social movements force real change.
• 16:49–18:45: Extended analysis of the limitations of economic and diplomatic sanctions, emphasizing boicots and their historical precedents.
• 19:06–22:25: Parliamentary pressures within Spain, moral lines being drawn, internal polarizations.
• 23:10–28:40: In-depth technical assessment of military/economic dependencies by Quique Andrés Pretel.
• 31:34–34:45: South Africa’s genocide accusation in the International Court of Justice, ICC warrants, and the European Union’s wavering adherence to international law.
• 37:29–40:16: Analysis of Israel’s ongoing impunity at a state level compared to more concrete legal efforts to hold individuals accountable.
• 40:32–44:56: Miquel Ayestarán on Israeli society: internal dissent exists but is overwhelmed by support for the government’s strategy.
• 46:34–51:24: Grim conclusions: experts see little hope for a viable Palestinian state; the dominant logic is one of ethnic cleansing and societal fragmentation.
• 51:33–57:23: Testimony from Imad Ismail Egazi: personal account of survival, family evacuation from Gaza, and the everyday reality of genocide.

The Situation Inside Israel: Dissent and Dominance

[40:32–46:02]

• Despite some protests and stark critiques from figures like ex-PM Ehud Olmert and Yair Golán, most of Israeli society continues to support the Gaza war effort.
• Dissent is present but politically marginalized; the far-right and religious blocs have unprecedented power ([43:04]).

  “La coalición que tenemos actualmente de gobierno es una coalición fuerte y una coalición sólida. [...] Netanyahu no está ahí por casualidad.” — Miquel Ayestarán ([43:04])

The Limits of Legal and Diplomatic Action

[31:34–36:48]

• The ICJ’s and ICC’s proceedings against Israel have little traction, especially as EU states, Hungary, and the US refuse to recognize or act on arrest warrants ([34:45], [36:48]).

  “Puede ser un detonante de implosión en el marco europeo de manera clarísima [...] solo se respeta el derecho internacional en la medida en que no colisiona con los intereses.” — Ruth Herrero ([32:32])

Pessimism and Pragmatic Hope

[46:34–51:14]

• Hope now lies mostly in the cumulative effect of grassroots pressure, not in governments or international institutions.
• The prospect for a Palestinian state—or for meaningful justice—is extremely bleak by expert assessments.

  "El Estado palestino ya no va a existir nunca jamás, porque es inviable..." — Javier Espinosa ([50:41])

Firsthand Testimony: Life Under Siege

[51:33–57:23]

• Imad Ismail Egazi gives a harrowing, personal update—his family only partially escapes Gaza; his daughter remains as the sole Spanish-language journalist on the ground ([51:33]).

  “Hay mucha gente como mi hija, mucha gente que no querrán salir, aunque prefieren morirse ahí, porque no es tan fácil salir…” — Imad Ismail Egazi ([55:46])

• He echoes the call for meaningful actions—sanctions, justice first, before any peace.

Concluding Reflections & Memorable Moments

• Experts agree: real pressure must come “desde abajo”—from public boycotts, street protests, grassroots legal action—rather than rhetorical government outrage.
• Both panelists and witnesses describe a grievous “bath of cold reality,” with few immediate prospects for justice but a clear imperative for ongoing civil resistance and solidarity.
• The episode closes with Palestinian voices and the reminder that “menos palabras y más hechos” (“less talk and more action”) is the only path forward.

Notable Quotes

• “El genocidio en Gaza es un hecho único en la historia. [...] Gaza será la tumba del sionismo.” — Host ([00:52])
• “Estamos ante una acción cosmética que responde a la presión también de la opinión pública europea.” — Ruth Herrero ([07:47])
• “La acción que está cambiando es la movilización popular de la gente en todos los países.” — Javier Espinosa ([10:57])
• “El embargo es una medida simbólica, puede ser fácilmente sorteado. Hecha la ley, echa la trampa.” — Quique Andrés Pretel ([26:31])
• “El Estado palestino ya no va a existir nunca jamás, porque es inviable...” — Javier Espinosa ([50:41])
• “La esperanza es lo último que se pierde, porque hay mucha gente que no querrán salir, aunque prefieren morirse ahí…” — Imad Ismail Egazi ([55:46])

Additional Resources and Context

• Continued public actions (BDS, boycotts, protests) are cited as the most promising source of pressure.
• Ongoing legal cases by South Africa, individual lawyers, and activist groups seek to document and prosecute Israeli military personnel for war crimes.

Overall Tone:
The episode delivers a sobering, unsparing critique of the West's complicity, the limitations of diplomacy and legalism, and the moral urgency of civil mobilization. The speakers combine rigorous analysis with emotional testimony, resulting in a call for increased grassroots activism and uncompromising moral clarity.

Listen and full details: carnecruda.es
Support the program: http://bit.ly/HazteproductorCC