Case 312: Dustin Wehde – A Detailed Summary

Podcast Information:

• Title: Casefile True Crime
• Host/Author: Casefile Presents
• Episode: Case 312: Dustin Wehde
• Release Date: March 29, 2025

Introduction

Casefile True Crime delves deep into the harrowing and complex case of Dustin Wehde's murder, exploring the intricate web of relationships, motives, and evidence that surrounded the incident. This summary encapsulates the key points, discussions, and conclusions drawn throughout the episode, providing a comprehensive understanding for those unfamiliar with the original content.

The Home Invasion and Initial Response

On the evening of Thursday, December 13, 2001, Ken Lee and Jane Showmaker, a married couple and volunteer EMTs, received a frantic page about a home invasion in their rural Iowa town of Early. The peaceful community was jolted by reports of gunshots and an injured intruder. The Showmakers rushed to the scene at the Roberts' Victorian-style home, where Tracey Roberts reported that two men had broken in. According to Tracey, she had used her husband's gun to fend off one intruder, resulting in his death, while the other fled.

Notable Quote:

• Tracey Roberts (07:07): “I think it’s Dustin Weedy.” (Timestamp adjusted as per context.)

Dustin Wehde’s Involvement

Tracey’s eldest son, Bert, identified the deceased intruder as Dustin Wehde, a 20-year-old friend of the family. Dustin had been involved with the Roberts’ computer business and was considered socially awkward with a history of mental illness. Despite allegations that Dustin sought odd jobs from Tracey before the invasion, the motive remained unclear as nothing of significant value was stolen, except an old, non-valuable computer.

Notable Quote:

• Bert Pitman (11:00): “No, I think it's Dustin Weedy.”

Suspicion and Potential Motives

The police initially considered robbery but later focused on Tracey’s ex-husband, John Pitman, due to their tumultuous history. John had been involved in a bitter custody battle over their son, Bert, with allegations of abuse that were never substantiated. Parallelly, Tracey’s current husband, Michael Roberts, was scrutinized due to his controlling nature and financial motives, especially given the life insurance policies on Tracey.

Notable Quote:

• Michael Roberts (00:00): “Did you sell that car yet?”

Inconsistencies in Tracey Roberts’ Story

As the investigation progressed, numerous inconsistencies emerged in Tracey’s accounts. She initially mentioned a third intruder, lacked clarity on how she accessed the gun safe during the struggle, and her descriptions of physical assault conflicted with forensic evidence. Additionally, Dustin’s notebook containing bizarre entries hinted at a possible orchestrated plot involving John Pitman and others, casting doubt on the initial self-defense narrative.

Notable Quote:

• Tracey Roberts (00:51): “No hassle? None. That is super convenient.”

Unraveling the Truth

Years later, Special Agent Trent Villator revisited the case and uncovered significant discrepancies. The forensic analysis revealed that Dustin was already dead when Tracey fired additional shots, contradicting her self-defense claim. Further investigations into Tracey’s personal life exposed her manipulative behavior, including a false sexual assault claim against Dr. Jonathan Spencer to extort money.

Notable Quote:

• Tracey Roberts (60:12): “I did what I had to do to protect my family.”

Trial and Conviction

In October 2011, Tracey was put on trial for the first-degree murder of Dustin Wehde. The prosecution presented compelling evidence, including forensic inconsistencies and Tracey’s manipulative actions. Despite a robust defense portraying her as a victim, the jury found her guilty after less than five hours of deliberation. Tracey was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

Notable Quote:

• Bert Pitman (95:58): “If it wasn’t for what my mum did, I wouldn’t be sitting here today.”

Aftermath and Continuing Mysteries

Tracey’s conviction did not quell the lingering questions. Her son, Bert, and supporters continued to protest her innocence, while Tracey maintained her stance of self-defense, hinting at deeper conspiracies involving Michael Roberts. The case remained a subject of intrigue and debate, highlighting the complexities of truth and deception in criminal investigations.

Notable Quote:

• Mona Weedy: “Tracey chose to take my son away. That’s just so hard.”

Conclusion

Casefile True Crime meticulously unpacks the tragic and convoluted case of Dustin Wehde, revealing the dark undercurrents of familial strife, manipulation, and the quest for justice. Through detailed examination of evidence, testimonies, and the evolving dynamics of the individuals involved, the episode underscores the challenges faced by law enforcement in unraveling the truth amidst layers of deceit.

Final Thoughts:

The Dustin Wehde case serves as a poignant reminder of the complexities inherent in true crime investigations. The interplay of personal vendettas, unreliable narratives, and forensic evidence creates a tapestry that is as intriguing as it is tragic. Casefile True Crime effectively captures these nuances, offering listeners a compelling exploration of one of Early Iowa’s most baffling crimes.