Catalyst with Shayle Kann: Explaining the ‘Watt-Bit Spread’

Release Date: August 7, 2025

Introduction

In this illuminating episode of Catalyst with Shayle Kann, Shayle revisits a compelling conversation with Brian Janis, co-founder of Cloverleaf Infrastructure and former VP of Energy at Microsoft. The focus of their discussion centers on the “Watt-Bit Spread,” a concept Brian coined to elucidate the intricate relationship between data centers and the electricity market. Despite being a rerun from December, Shayle emphasizes the enduring relevance of this dialogue, especially given the persistent misconceptions surrounding the economic dynamics between data centers and energy consumption.

Understanding the Watt-Bit Spread

At the heart of the conversation is the "Watt-Bit Spread," a term Brian Janis introduced to describe the economic disparity between the value derived from converting electrical power (watts) into digital information (bits) and the actual cost of the electricity consumed in this process.

Brian Janis [01:25]: "I don't know that there's any energy conversion that creates a greater return than turning an electron back into a bit."

Brian explains that this conversion process is exceptionally profitable, especially in the realm of artificial intelligence (AI) and large-scale data centers. However, the current pricing of electricity does not adequately reflect its true value in facilitating this conversion. This mispricing creates a significant incentive gap, where the high demand for power by data centers is not matched by corresponding investments in energy infrastructure.

Current Market Dynamics

Shayle draws parallels between the rapid expansion of data centers today and the rise of natural gas for power generation in the U.S. over the past two decades. He highlights that while natural gas experienced a 2.3x growth in market share from 2000 to 2020, the current surge in data center growth is occurring at an even more accelerated pace, driven by advancements in AI and cloud computing.

Sheil Khan [03:09]: "I'm Sheil Khan. I invest in revolutionary climate technologies at Energy Impact Partners. Welcome."

Brian underscores that the demand for data center capacity remains exceptionally high, but this surge is coupled with unprecedented challenges in energy procurement. Unlike the 2010s, where colocation providers with expertise in real estate and fiber filled the infrastructure gap, today's scenario demands deep energy expertise—something that many existing colocation firms lack.

Challenges in Energy Procurement

A significant portion of the discussion delves into the complexities of demand planning in the current energy landscape. Data center operators face uncertainty in predicting their exact energy needs, making large-scale infrastructure investments risky without assured receipts of demand.

Brian Janis [09:04]: "It's really hard. And what happened during the 2010s is you had the colocation market sort of fill the gap because every company underinvested in their infrastructure..."

Brian points out that the traditional model of simply acquiring land and leasing data center space is no longer viable. The escalating requirements for power capacity—often in the gigawatt range—necessitate substantial investments in energy infrastructure, including generation, transmission, and substations. This shift has transformed the economics of data center development, making it a more capital-intensive endeavor.

The Economic Disconnect

The core issue Brian identifies is the "Watt-Bit Spread"—the value data centers place on electricity versus the utility's pricing structures. Electricity rates have not kept pace with the increased value that data centers derive from power, leading to a misalignment that discourages utilities from expanding necessary infrastructure.

Brian Janis [20:50]: "The more electrons that you can get a hold of, especially in the AI world, the more value you can create..."

This disparity means that while data centers are willing to pay a premium for reliable and abundant power, the utilities are not incentivized to meet this demand due to the inadequate price signals. Consequently, there is a bottleneck in scaling up energy infrastructure to support the burgeoning data center industry.

Innovative Solutions: Advanced Grid Tariffs

To bridge this economic gap, Brian proposes the implementation of "Advanced Grid Tariffs." These tariffs would allow utilities to charge data center operators a premium for accelerated power delivery, ensuring that utilities can recover their investments while data centers receive the power they need promptly.

Brian Janis [35:46]: "...this is the innovation that we haven't quite seen yet. And this is what I describe in that watts bit spread piece is the advanced grid tariff."

Advanced Grid Tariffs would enable utilities to tailor their pricing models to reward timely infrastructure developments, aligning the incentives of both data center operators and energy providers. This approach ensures that investments in energy infrastructure are not only feasible but also economically viable for utilities.

Future Outlook and Sustainability

Looking ahead, Brian remains optimistic that the demand for computing power, particularly driven by AI, will continue to outstrip available power through at least 2030. He emphasizes the critical need for strategic investments in energy infrastructure to keep pace with data center growth.

Brian Janis [24:25]: "I suspect that given my fundamental belief is that the demand for compute... will remain quite high for some time because there will be a shortage of power available to plug in GPUs over that period."

However, Shayle raises a pertinent concern regarding the long timelines associated with energy infrastructure projects versus the rapid pace of data center development. Brian responds by reiterating the importance of viewing energy capacity as a value that is highest in the near term, thereby emphasizing the need for immediate investment strategies that can secure power quickly without overextending into the future.

Aligning Interests for Mutual Benefit

A pivotal theme in their discussion is the necessity for utility companies and data center operators to collaborate closely to ensure that the benefits of expanded energy infrastructure are shared beyond just the immediate customers. This mutual alignment is essential to prevent price hikes for residential consumers and to ensure that the broader grid benefits from increased reliability and lower costs.

Brian Janis [36:52]: "...we don't want rates going up for average consumers just because utilities are trying to serve data centers."

By designing tariffs that appropriately allocate costs and benefits, utilities can foster a symbiotic relationship where data centers receive the power they need swiftly, and the broader community enjoys the resultant efficiencies and reliability enhancements.

Conclusion

The episode offers a deep dive into the economic and infrastructural challenges at the intersection of data centers and energy markets. Brian Janis’s concept of the “Watt-Bit Spread” serves as a critical framework for understanding the current dynamics and for devising strategies to align the incentives of utilities and data center operators. As the demand for computing power continues to surge, addressing the Watt-Bit Spread through innovative tariff structures and strategic investments will be paramount in ensuring sustainable growth and mutual benefit for all stakeholders involved.

Notable Quotes

• Brian Janis [01:25]: "I don't know that there's any energy conversion that creates a greater return than turning an electron back into a bit."

• Sheil Khan [03:09]: "I'm Sheil Khan. I invest in revolutionary climate technologies at Energy Impact Partners. Welcome."

• Brian Janis [20:50]: "The more electrons that you can get a hold of, especially in the AI world, the more value you can create..."

• Brian Janis [24:25]: "I suspect that given my fundamental belief is that the demand for compute... will remain quite high for some time because there will be a shortage of power available to plug in GPUs over that period."

• Brian Janis [35:46]: "...this is the innovation that we haven't quite seen yet. And this is what I describe in that watts bit spread piece is the advanced grid tariff."

• Brian Janis [36:52]: "...we don't want rates going up for average consumers just because utilities are trying to serve data centers."

About the Hosts

Shayle Kann, the host of Catalyst with Shayle Kann, is an investor focused on revolutionary climate technologies. Brian Janis, co-founder of Cloverleaf Infrastructure, brings over a decade of experience in energy strategy, having previously served as VP of Energy at Microsoft.

Produced by Latitude Media

For more insights into the energy transition and climate technologies, visit Latitude Media. Supported by Prelude Ventures, Latitude Media partners with mission-driven organizations to amplify their climate stories.