Is “China” as we understand it today really a continuous civilization — or a modern political construction?

In this episode of The China Desk, host Steve Yates sits down with Bill Hayton, journalist and author of The Invention of China, to unpack one of the most provocative ideas in China studies: that many core concepts of modern China — including its identity, history, and territorial claims — are far more recent than commonly believed.

Drawing on his research, Hayton explains how ideas like Chinese nationalism, sovereignty, and even the concept of “China” itself were shaped in the late 19th and early 20th centuries — often influenced by foreign thinkers, political pressures, and the collapse of the imperial system.

A major focus of the conversation is how these constructed narratives continue to shape modern Chinese policy, propaganda, and global strategy.

The discussion covers:
• Why the term “China” was not historically used by Chinese rulers
• How modern Chinese identity emerged in the late imperial and early republican periods
• The origins of the “5,000 years of history” narrative
• How nationalism was constructed to unify diverse populations
• The invention and political use of Han ethnic identity
• Why historical narratives are used to legitimize CCP authority
• The concept of “national humiliation” and its political function
• How myths about history influence modern Chinese foreign policy
• The South China Sea and the origins of China’s maritime claims
• Why many widely accepted historical claims lack solid evidence
• Taiwan’s complex historical relationship with mainland China
• Why Taiwan has only been governed alongside China for brief periods
• How WWII decisions shaped modern territorial claims
• Xi Jinping’s consolidation of power and rise of hardline nationalism
• The role of ideology in shaping CCP domestic and foreign policy
• Reciprocity and how the U.S. should approach China strategically

Hayton also explains how these narratives are actively reinforced today — from education campaigns to political messaging — to create cohesion, justify policy, and shape how both Chinese citizens and the outside world understand China.

The conversation highlights a critical takeaway: without questioning these foundational assumptions, policymakers risk misunderstanding China’s intentions, overestimating historical inevitabilities, and limiting strategic flexibility.

00:00 — Intro + Bill Hayton joins the China Desk
00:33 — Background and journalism career
05:04 — How The Invention of China came together
06:06 — South China Sea research and historical gaps
07:09 — Questioning accepted historical narratives
08:20 — The invention of “China” as a concept
10:59 — Why “China” wasn’t historically a unified nation
12:16 — Dynasties vs modern nation-state thinking
14:01 — Foreign influence on Chinese nationalism
16:23 — The “5,000 years of history” narrative explained
17:18 — Race, identity, and the Yellow Emperor myth
19:25 — National humiliation as a unifying tool
21:28 — Why historical narratives bind populations
24:19 — The invention of Han ethnicity
26:39 — Political motivations behind ethnic identity
28:55 — Reception and backlash to the book
32:34 — Taiwan: history vs modern claims
34:17 — Why Taiwan wasn’t central to China historically
36:37 — WWII and shifting territorial narratives
37:50 — Modern CCP narratives on Taiwan
39:34 — Xi Jinping and rising nationalism
41:17 — Ideology, control, and state power
42:10 — Reciprocity and U.S.–China strategy
45:43 — Final thoughts + where to follow Bill

Watch Full-Length Interviews: https://www.youtube.com/@ChinaDeskFNW