Podcast Summary: Choice Classic Radio Detectives | Old Time Radio Episode: Sherlock Holmes: The Adventure of the Resident Patient (Hobbes & Shelley) Release Date: December 20, 2024

Introduction

Choice Classic Radio Detectives presents a captivating episode featuring one of Sherlock Holmes' intriguing cases, "The Adventure of the Resident Patient." Hosted by Norman Shelley and featuring Carlton Hobbes as Sherlock Holmes and Norman Shelley reprising the role of Dr. Watson, this dramatization delves deep into a perplexing mystery that tests Holmes' legendary deductive skills. The episode, scripted by Michael Hardwick for this BBC production from London, offers old-time radio fans a rich narrative filled with suspense, clever dialogues, and classic Holmesian detective work.

Plot Overview

The story revolves around Dr. Percy Trevelyan, a distinguished London University graduate and recipient of the Bruce Pinkerton Prize, who encounters a series of unsettling events at his Brook Street practice. Seeking to establish his medical career, Dr. Trevelyan accepts a lucrative offer from Mr. Blessington, an investor who becomes a "resident patient." Blessington's proposal includes furnishing a house, managing domestic affairs, and handling the financial aspects of the practice in exchange for a significant investment. This arrangement initially proves successful, boosting Dr. Trevelyan's reputation and wealth.

However, the tranquility is disrupted when Blessington becomes increasingly paranoid about potential burglaries, leading to erratic behavior and a mysterious letter from a Russian nobleman seeking Dr. Trevelyan's expertise in treating cataleptic attacks. The situation escalates when Blessington is found dead by apparent suicide, but Holmes suspects foul play, unraveling a complex web of deceit involving former associates of the Worthington bank gang.

Key Events and Developments

1. Initial Success and Investment:

   • Dr. Trevelyan accepts Mr. Blessington's proposal, leading to a prosperous period for his medical practice.
   • Blessington becomes a prosperous investor, turning the first-floor rooms into his personal space but remains largely solitary.

2. Suspicious Behavior and Mysterious Letter:

   • Blessington's sudden agitation over potential burglaries and his subsequent withdrawal from evening strolls raise concerns.
   • A letter from a Russian nobleman, Count Egrovich, requesting Dr. Trevelyan's medical assistance in treating cataleptic attacks, adds intrigue.

3. Unraveling the Catalepsy Case:

   • The consultation with Count Egrovich and his son, Iban, is abruptly interrupted by mysterious circumstances, leading to their sudden disappearance.
   • Holmes recognizes discrepancies in the case, particularly focusing on footmarks and the suspicious behavior of Blessington.

4. Suspicion of Fraud and Deception:

   • Holmes deduces that the cataleptic attacks are fraudulent, designed to facilitate the theft of Blessington's investments.
   • The involvement of former members of the Worthington bank gang, recently released from prison, points towards a meticulously planned scheme.

5. Confrontation and Resolution:

   • Inspector Lammer’s involvement confirms Holmes' suspicions about the gang's return.
   • The gang members, including Sutton, the notorious leader, orchestrated the events to manipulate and ultimately murder Blessington.
   • The episode concludes with the implication that justice will prevail, as the moral integrity of British law stands unshaken.

Notable Discussions and Insights

• Holmes' Deductive Reasoning:

  • Holmes meticulously examines the crime scene, noting minute details such as the type of cigars smoked and the distinct footmark impressions, leading him to identify the culprits.
  • His ability to distinguish genuine symptoms from feigned ones in catalepsy showcases his deep understanding of human behavior and medical conditions.

• Character Interactions:

  • The dynamic between Holmes and Dr. Watson highlights their complementary skills, with Watson providing practical observations while Holmes connects the dots.
  • The portrayal of Dr. Trevelyan’s desperation and Blessington's increasing paranoia adds emotional depth to the narrative.

• Themes of Trust and Deception:

  • The case underscores the themes of trust, as Dr. Trevelyan places his faith in Blessington, only to uncover a web of deceit.
  • The use of medical expertise as a facade for criminal intent illustrates how trust can be exploited.

Notable Quotes

• Sherlock Holmes:
  "It's quite easy to imitate the complaint. I've done it myself."
  [Timestamp: 42:30]

• Dr. Trevelyan:
  "This is a singular business. The sooner we get to Brook Street to look into it the better."
  [Timestamp: 47:15]

• Sherlock Holmes:
  "Although the shield of British law may fail to guard, the sword of justice is still there to avenge."
  [Timestamp: 1:30:45]

• Inspector Lammer:
  "This is no suicide, Inspector. It's a very deeply planned and cold-blooded murder."
  [Timestamp: 1:10:20]

• Dr. Watson:
  "I'd certainly do it differently but your approach yields results."
  [Timestamp: 58:50]

Conclusion

"The Adventure of the Resident Patient" masterfully encapsulates the essence of Sherlock Holmes' investigative prowess amidst a backdrop of suspense and betrayal. Through detailed character development and intricate plotting, the episode keeps listeners engaged from start to finish. Norman Shelley and Carlton Hobbes deliver stellar performances, embodying their characters with authenticity and depth. Michael Hardwick's script ensures a faithful adaptation of Conan Doyle's timeless narrative, making this episode a must-listen for old-time radio enthusiasts and Sherlock Holmes aficionados alike.

The episode concludes with the affirmation of justice prevailing, reinforcing the enduring legacy of Sherlock Holmes as the quintessential detective. Listeners are left with a satisfying resolution, coupled with the anticipation of more thrilling adventures in future episodes.

Additional Information

• Hosts:

  • Sherlock Holmes: Carlton Hobbes
  • Dr. Watson: Norman Shelley

• Scriptwriter: Michael Hardwick

• Production: BBC London

• Call to Action:
  "The Resident Patient was one of the Sherlock Holmes stories by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. My real name is Norman Shelley. My friend Carlton Hobbes played Sherlock Holmes and I was Dr. Watson. Michael Hardwick wrote our script for this BBC production from London. And of course I look forward to the pleasure of your company again soon for more of the adventures of Sherlock Holmes."
  [Timestamp: 1:35:00]

Enjoyed this summary? Subscribe to Choice Classic Radio on YouTube, follow us on Facebook, and consider donating at donate@ChoiceClassicRadio.com to support more thrilling old-time radio detective stories.