Podcast Summary: City Journal Audio – "What Happened to Law and Order in NYC?"
Date: October 17, 2025
Hosts: Liana Zagarri (A), Editor, Bigger Apple, and Nicole Jelina (B), Senior Fellow, Manhattan Institute
Duration: Approx. 1 hour
Overview
In this episode, host Liana Zagarri and senior fellow Nicole Jelina explore the reality behind perceptions of crime and disorder in New York City, analyze the effectiveness of recent public safety policies, and assess mayoral candidates’ plans in the lead-up to a pivotal election. They dissect the disconnect (or convergence) between perception and reality, dig into crime data trends post-pandemic, and debate policing, fare enforcement, mental health interventions, and criminal justice reform. The discussion concludes with a comparative evaluation of how the main mayoral candidates might shape NYC's safety future.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
1. Perceptions vs. Reality of Crime in NYC
- Context: Public debate often frames New Yorkers’ rising anxiety about safety as mere perception.
- Jelina counters: "The numbers back up people’s perceptions of greater unsafety...Felonies are still 29% higher than they were in 2019...Petty larceny is also still 21% higher than before COVID." [01:00–02:30]
- Progress: Shootings and homicides are at or near record lows (a major mayoral talking point), but overall safety has not returned to pre-pandemic norms. The feeling—and reality—of disorder is supported by data.
2. Personal Experience of Safety
- Zagarri: Reflects on feeling less safe today compared to pre-pandemic—"I think there was less disorder...certainly fewer people struggling with mental health and homelessness in the streets." [03:13]
- Increased vigilance: “I'd say I'm more wary...there will definitely be times when I have my headphones in and they're not playing anything, just because I want to know what's going on...” [03:58–04:33]
3. Violent Crime Trends and High-Profile Incidents
- Discussion of random violent attacks shocks the sense of security, underscoring how unpredictability undermines trust in the city environment.
- Jelina: “We have learned...that just being aware of your surroundings won’t always protect you. There’s just no way you can defend yourself in some of these situations.” [04:33–05:43]
4. Public Transit Safety and Its Ripple Effects
- Subway crime: Violent felonies are 16% higher than 2019, though nonviolent felonies (like theft) are down, possibly due to rider behavior changes. Assaults in transit are up 64% since 2019. [07:47]
- Rhetoric vs. reality: Officials’ reassurances are undermined by continued deployments of the National Guard and increases in violent incidents.
- Fare Evasion: Fare evasion has exploded (44% on buses compared to less than 10% pre-pandemic), eroding respect for laws and overloading police resources. [11:44–13:46]
Zagarri: "It wasn't just people that...were struggling. It seemed like perfectly middle class people walking on without paying.” [11:44]
5. Mental Health Crisis Response: Civilianization and Challenges
- Mamdani's plan: Proposes shifting police response in mental health crises to clinicians and outreach teams.
Jelina: “It would be less worrisome if this were like a five year plan. But he is basically saying he wants to do this immediately...” [21:40–22:16]
- Scaling challenges: Current programs are small-scale with limited clinicians; most involuntary transports still require police backup.
- Volume & complexity: “If you bring this up to the level of the whole city, you’re looking at hundreds of thousands of calls a year for mental distress.” [26:50]
- Safety for responders and the unpredictability of calls are major implementation barriers for expanding civilian-only response.
6. Police Staffing & Recruitment
- Candidate plans:
- Sliwa: +7,000 officers, back to force of 40,000 (90s/00s model)
- Cuomo: +5,000 officers, alongside civilian violence interrupters
- Mamdani: Maintain current levels, but shift duties [27:38–29:42]
- Recruitment/retention issues: High retirement rates, struggles to attract qualified candidates, and relaxed eligibility create risk for force quality.
“If you’re asking for trouble, yes...where you start to have systemic issues is when you relax the standards too far.” [29:59]
7. Correctional System Crisis - Rikers Island
- Mandated closure: NYC must close Rikers by 2027, but new jails’ capacity will be far too low (under 4,000 beds vs. current need closer to 8,000). [32:15–35:58]
- Candidates:
- Mamdani: Staunchly supports the four-borough jail plan (despite feasibility concerns).
- Cuomo: Suggests rebuilding modern jails at Rikers instead.
- Structural/cultural issues: "By just moving to new jails, you’re not changing the underlying problems...” [36:00–39:01]
- Public experience: Poor visitor treatment, logistics, and culture—not just location—are core correctional system failings.
8. Juvenile Crime & Systemic Reform
- Raise the Age: Law moving most 16–18-year-olds out of adult criminal system. Consequence: “If you’re caught with a gun six times...you don’t really rise to the level of attention until you’ve shot someone...” [40:22]
- Increase in underage involvement in serious crime—even as overall violent crime is down.
9. Mayoral Candidates and Public Safety Philosophies
-
Broad spectrum:
- Mamdani: Focused on shifting policing burden, less attention on “quality of life” enforcement.
Zagarri: “My concern...is that there may be less focus on the quality of life issues that have been proven effective at reducing bigger crimes.” [42:50]
- Cuomo: Moderate, hybrid approach; experience in executing large-scale projects, but past reform decisions under scrutiny.
“Cuomo is a person who has already made most of his mistakes. Is that good or bad?” [44:49]
- Sliwa: Hardline, “back to basics” approach—more cops, visible enforcement, clear priorities for crime deterrence.
“You have the least to be concerned about from Sliwa because you know what you’re getting.” [44:37]
- Mamdani: Focused on shifting policing burden, less attention on “quality of life” enforcement.
-
Political strategy: Excessive focus on national politics (anti-Trump positioning) distracts from pressing urban concerns.
Jelina: “To focus on that and not the bread and butter of the city would be a bad idea.” [53:20]
10. Reporting & Data Limitations
- Many “small” crimes go unreported due to barriers, undercounting actual disorder. [47:36–48:39]
Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments
- On crime perception:
"People feel less safe and they perceive more disorder because there is, in fact, less safety and less order." – Nicole Jelina [00:59]
- On resilience of disorder:
"We have learned through watching these videos...there’s just no way you can defend yourself in some of these situations." – Jelina [04:33]
- On fare evasion trends:
"It wasn’t just...people that were struggling...it seemed like perfectly middle class people walking on without paying." – Zagarri [11:44]
- On mental health response proposals:
"Taking this away from the police without proven that you have the competence to make this work is a real risk for public safety." – Jelina [21:40]
- On policing and recruitment:
"If you’re asking for trouble...you start to have serious systemic issues when you relax the standards." – Jelina [29:59]
- On the four-borough jail plan:
"This idea that you can immediately cut the jail population in half without affecting public safety...if you could do that, we would have done it already." – Jelina [35:58]
- On quality-of-life enforcement:
"If we do not take action against misdemeanors, it just means we are at risk of much bigger crimes.” – Zagarri [42:50]
- On candidate competence:
"Mamdani is a person who hasn't made his mistakes yet, and Cuomo is a person who has already made most of his mistakes. Is that good or bad?" – Jelina [44:49]
- Closing optimism:
“I genuinely think that all of them want to make the city better...adopting some of Mr. Mamdani's ideas would make the city more compassionate...broken windows has proven to work...competence is a weaker element for Mr. Mamdani as opposed to the other two.” – Zagarri [54:40]
Segment Timestamps
- Intro & Episode Framing – 00:00–00:41
- Statistical Trends: Perception vs. Reality – 00:59–03:13
- Personal Safety, Subway Discussion – 03:13–05:55
- Viral Violent Attacks & System Trust – 05:43–07:47
- Transit Crime, Fare Evasion, Law Disregard – 07:47–16:52
- Mayoral Election, Policing & Safety Platforms – 16:52–29:57
- Riker’s, Jails, Correction Reform – 32:15–39:40
- Raise the Age, Youth Crime – 39:54–42:46
- Candidates’ Strengths, Weaknesses, Public Safety Stakes – 42:49–49:30
- Federal Interventions, National Guard, Immigration Policy – 51:04–54:27
- Final Reflections and End – 54:27–61:15
Conclusion
This episode provides a rigorous, data-rich, and candid assessment of New York City’s safety environment, scrutinizing the ongoing challenges and trade-offs faced by residents, city officials, and political hopefuls. The hosts argue convincingly that perceptions of increased disorder are rooted in reality, and they stress the urgent need for both competence and compassion in crafting solutions—regardless of who wins the mayoral race.
Recommended Action:
For listeners interested in the future of public safety, urban management, and criminal justice reform, this episode is essential for understanding both the challenges and the nuanced policy debates that will shape New York for years to come.