Podcast Title: Classical Stuff You Should Know
Host/Authors: A.J. Hanenburg, Graeme Donaldson, and Thomas Magbee
Episode: 263: The Ballad of the White Horse and Some Dudes Who Sing
Release Date: July 30, 2024

Introduction

In Episode 263 of Classical Stuff You Should Know, hosts A.J. Hanenberg, Graeme Donaldson, and Thomas Magbee delve deep into G.K. Chesterton's classic work, The Ballad of the White Horse. This episode explores Chesterton's poetic retelling of Alfred the Great's battles against the Danes, intertwining historical narrative with profound philosophical critiques of early 20th-century romanticism and nihilism.

Historical Context of "The Ballad of the White Horse"

Thomas Magbee opens the discussion by introducing Chesterton's work, emphasizing its setting in late 19th to early 20th-century England. He explains how Chesterton uses the legend of Alfred the Great, the sole English monarch to bear the title, to critique contemporary philosophical movements:

"Chesterton was looking at the philosophers of his day and saying if you follow these things to their logical conclusion, it is just going to bring you to sadness and misery and violence and madness." (Thomas, [00:36])

The trio underscores Chesterton's staunch Catholicism and his critical stance against the prevailing romantic and nihilistic philosophies, noting his sharp exchanges with contemporaries like H.G. Wells.

Chesterton’s Philosophical Critique

Thomas elaborates on Chesterton's main thesis: the modern world's flirtation with romanticism and Nietzschean "will to power" leads inevitably to nihilism—a belief in the world's inherent meaninglessness:

"If you embrace that sadness, you think, 'Oh, isn't the world tragic? Aren't I a noble thing?'" (Thomas, [25:17])

Graeme connects this to modern cultural phenomena, referencing Carl Truman's Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self and its assertions about the triumph of romanticism in popular culture.

Character Analysis: The Danes and Their Philosophies

Chesterton personifies various philosophical stances through the Danish chiefs Harald, Elf, Ogier, and King Guthrum. The hosts break down each character's embodiment of specific worldviews:

1. Harald: The Embodiment of Hedonism

Thomas reads Harald's mocking song, highlighting his hedonistic and conquering spirit:

"But we shall enjoy the world, the whole huge world. A toy great wine like blood from Burgundy cloaks..." ([16:42])

A.J. interprets Harald as representing hedonism, comparing his ethos to:

"We could really tie one on." ([10:11])

Quote:

"He wants to experience everything, but in that sort of vulgar way." – Thomas ([17:00])

2. Elf: The Lover of Melancholy

Thomas presents Elf’s somber melodies, noting his romanticized sadness:

"There is always a thing forgotten when all the world goes well..." ([21:35])

Graeme describes Elf as embodying melancholic romanticism, a longing for meaning in inherent sadness.

Quote:

"The soul is like a babe buried alive." – Elf ([26:23])

3. Ogier: The Wrathful Nihilist

Thomas reads Ogier’s fervent and destructive verses, illustrating his descent into anger and nihilism:

"Hate alone is true." ([30:07])

A.J. connects Ogier to modern manifestations of senseless violence, portraying him as a nihilist who seeks to destroy order to assert meaning:

"He's the Joker. Some people just want to see the world burn." ([32:26])

Quote:

"I want to destroy the thing and that there's something beautiful in the ability to destroy." – Ogier ([32:27])

4. Guthrum: The Final Nihilist King

Thomas analyzes Guthrum’s philosophy, which culminates the nihilistic trajectory:

"The soul is a lost bird, the body a broken shell." ([39:08])

A.J. summarizes Guthrum as embodying the acceptance of death’s inevitability and responding with hatred:

"Death is coming for us all. Might as well enjoy the little things while we can." ([39:35])

Quote:

"He is realizing that the only thing coming for you is death." – Guthrum ([40:38])

Counterbalancing Characters: Eldred, Mark, and Colon

To juxtapose the destructive philosophies of the Danes, Chesterton introduces three English lords—Eldred, Mark, and Colon—who represent growth, civic responsibility, and redeemed passion.

1. Eldred: The Guardian of Domestic Life

Thomas discusses Eldred as the embodiment of domestic cultivation and the joy of a well-maintained home:

"He is the opposite of Harald, who wants to conquer and consume." ([46:14])

Quote:

"He wants to watch his plums ripen and the predictable things of growing." – Eldred ([47:02])

2. Mark: The Champion of Institutions

Thomas portrays Mark as a stalwart believer in law, order, and structured society, drawing from his Roman heritage:

"He remembers Rome and believes in strong institutions." ([47:15])

A.J. relates Mark to the importance of organized society and hierarchy:

"Mark represents the belief in man's ability to institutionalize and have hierarchy." ([47:22])

Quote:

"I will be buried in a Roman grave for all the world is Rome." – Mark ([59:28])

3. Colon: The Mystical Christian Warrior

Thomas introduces Colon as a bridge between Christian mysticism and pagan spirituality, embodying redeemed passion:

"He is the embodiment of the mystics, the aesthetics of Christendom." ([54:24])

A.J. expresses affinity for Colon, highlighting his synthesis of wildness and Christian authority:

"Colon is redeemed passion, the spiritual side of the creative world under divine authority." ([55:18])

Quote:

"There is a spiritual side to nature that is still under God's authority." – Colon ([58:17])

Climactic Battle and Conclusions

In the battle scenes, all characters—both Danes and English lords—meet noble fates, symbolizing the clash between destructive and constructive philosophies. Thomas emphasizes that despite their noble intentions, the characters' deaths reflect their inherent philosophies:

"They all die in ways that embody what they stand for." ([59:07])

A.J. expresses enthusiasm for Chesterton’s storytelling:

"I love that book. I think I've read it twice." ([59:28])

Graeme and Thomas conclude that Chesterton advocates for a Christian society balanced with growth, civility, and redeemed passion as antidotes to nihilism and romantic excess.

Final Quote:

"Building your home, building your family, having your home and hearth... is the antidote to nihilism." – Thomas ([60:47])

Takeaways and Reflections

The hosts reflect on the enduring relevance of Chesterton's message, drawing parallels to modern societal issues like alienation and identity politics. They argue that Chesterton's vision of a balanced Christian society—embracing growth, strong institutions, and spiritual mystery—offers a counterbalance to the destructive philosophies that lead to nihilism.

Thomas suggests practical takeaways:

"Growth, civility, and passion are the antidotes to nihilism." ([60:44])

A.J. envisions a society where organized passion and spiritual depth foster a meaningful life, contrasting sharply with the nihilistic and hedonistic tendencies critiqued in the episode.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• "Chesterton was looking at the philosophers of his day and saying if you follow these things to their logical conclusion, it is just going to bring you to sadness and misery and violence and madness." – Thomas ([00:36])

• "The soul is like a babe buried alive." – Elf ([26:23])

• "I want to destroy the thing and that there's something beautiful in the ability to destroy." – Ogier ([32:27])

• "He will be buried in a Roman grave for all the world is Rome." – Mark ([59:28])

• "There is a spiritual side to nature that is still under God's authority." – Colon ([58:17])

Conclusion

Episode 263 of Classical Stuff You Should Know offers a comprehensive exploration of Chesterton's The Ballad of the White Horse, highlighting its critique of nihilism and romanticism through vivid character embodiments. The hosts effectively connect historical narrative with modern philosophical debates, emphasizing the timeless relevance of Chesterton's insights.

For listeners unfamiliar with the episode, this summary provides a detailed understanding of the key discussions, character analyses, and philosophical reflections presented by A.J., Graeme, and Thomas.

Connect with Classical Stuff You Should Know:

• Website: classicalstuff.net
• Patreon: patreon.com/classicalstuff
• Twitter: @ClassicalStuff
• Email: theguys@classicalstuff.net

Note: Stay tuned for future episodes and interactions on Patreon!