Ben Shapiro | Club Random with Bill Maher

Summary

Podcast Summary: Club Random with Bill Maher Featuring Ben Shapiro

Episode Title: Ben Shapiro | Club Random with Bill Maher
Release Date: November 3, 2024
Host: Bill Maher
Guest: Ben Shapiro
Location: Club Random (Undisclosed)

---

1. Introduction to the Conversation (06:13 - 24:47)

Bill Maher (A) welcomes Ben Shapiro (B) to Club Random, commending him for stepping into a venue that seemingly contrasts his usual ideological stance. They briefly reminisce about past experiences, including Ben's involvement with the punk rock band Molly Hatchet, which he humorously downplays, emphasizing his longstanding straight-laced and religious nature.

---

2. Religion and Personal Philosophy (02:27 - 04:23)

Ben Shapiro delves into his perspective on religion, describing it as both a blessing and a curse. He articulates the inherent risk in religious belief systems—if correct, everything aligns; if incorrect, the consequences are dire, echoing Pascal's Wager. Shapiro emphasizes his stringent adherence to his beliefs, stating:

“I'm as straight laced as it is possible to be. So, you know, that's my blessing, my curse.” (02:27)

Bill Maher challenges the notion that the primary reason for religiosity is the fear of damnation, to which Shapiro counters by discussing the practical implications of religious control over moral behavior.

---

3. Experiences with Crime and Relocation (04:31 - 07:50)

Shapiro recounts a harrowing experience of nearly being robbed in Los Angeles, detailing the aggressive nature of the perpetrators and the emotional impact it had on him and his family. This incident reinforces his decision to relocate to Florida for safety reasons. He shares:

“I almost got robbed last night... And I remembered why I moved to Florida so.” (04:32 - 05:21)

Bill Maher offers light-hearted advice on avoiding third street restaurants, blending humor with a subtle critique of urban safety.

---

4. Political Divergences: Trump vs. Biden/Kamala (07:50 - 19:53)

A significant portion of the discussion centers on the political landscape, particularly the contrasting figures of Donald Trump and Kamala Harris. Maher expresses concerns about the Democratic Party's direction, fearing a departure from traditional liberalism towards what he terms an "aggressively anti common sense agenda." He states:

“And we agree on the aggressively anti common sense agenda.” (07:30)

Shapiro critiques the Democratic fixation on demonizing Trump, comparing the constant vilification to authoritarian tactics. He argues that Trump's actions, though controversial, are balanced against the potential pitfalls of Democratic leadership under figures like Harris. Shapiro asserts:

“I think there's a better chance of the latter [Kamala Harris being a 'stealth woke nut'] than the former [Trump becoming a tyrannical dictator].” (19:31)

The conversation explores themes of media influence, voter priorities, and the integrity of democratic processes, with both hosts emphasizing the importance of common sense and pragmatic governance over ideological extremes.

---

5. Foreign Policy and International Relations (38:11 - 93:06)

Shapiro and Maher engage in a robust debate on foreign policy, focusing on U.S. involvement in the Middle East. Shapiro advocates for decisive military action to ensure national security, referencing the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the effectiveness of the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF). He highlights the complexities of war, the limitations of treaties like the Geneva Convention, and the necessity of exerting military strength to achieve peace.

“Peace is an outgrowth of one side kicking the shit out of the other side so hard that they decide not to do war anymore.” (76:31)

Maher counters by emphasizing the moral and ethical dilemmas inherent in international interventions, questioning the long-term effectiveness and humanitarian implications of U.S. military actions. The dialogue touches upon historical precedents, such as the British Empire's tactics and the U.S. Revolutionary War, to illustrate the enduring brutality of warfare and the challenges in imposing enduring peace through military might.

---

6. Social Issues: Drug Legalization and Youth (38:10 - 43:35)

The hosts discuss the societal impacts of drug legalization, particularly marijuana. Shapiro shares his personal experience with drug use and asserts that marijuana is non-addictive compared to substances like cocaine and cigarettes. He argues for local control over dispensaries to balance personal freedom with community standards.

“Pot never does that to me. Pot never says, ooh, do me.” (40:37)

Maher acknowledges the nuanced debate, agreeing that public policy must consider both personal freedoms and societal externalities. They discuss the balance between individual rights and community safety, addressing concerns about youth addiction and neighborhood regulations.

---

7. Youth, Education, and Parenting (57:09 - 59:26)

Shapiro and Maher explore themes related to youth behavior, education, and the role of parenting. Shapiro advocates for discipline and personal responsibility, critiquing modern parenting styles that, in his view, fail to instill accountability in children. He emphasizes the importance of structure and the long-term benefits of fostering resilience in youth.

“Discipline is love. It's not on the surface, it's below the surface, but it translates to love. It really does.” (59:22)

Maher concurs, highlighting the challenges parents face in balancing authority and empathy, and the societal repercussions of inadequate parenting. They discuss the psychological impacts of bullying and the importance of nurturing responsible, independent-minded individuals.

---

8. Cultural Critiques and Media Influence (62:07 - 74:21)

The conversation shifts to cultural critiques, focusing on media narratives and their influence on public perception. Shapiro criticizes the media's tendency to amplify fringe opinions, leading to polarized and often misleading narratives. He accuses both sides of the political spectrum of engaging in "nut picking," where isolated incidents are portrayed as widespread trends.

“It's very easy to try and mistake an anecdote for a trend.” (62:20)

Maher echoes these sentiments, lamenting the superficial treatment of complex issues and the media's role in perpetuating divisive rhetoric. They discuss the repercussions of oversimplified narratives on societal cohesion and the importance of nuanced discourse.

---

9. Historical Perspectives and Modern Parallels (76:00 - 93:06)

Drawing parallels between historical events and current affairs, Shapiro references significant moments like the British Empire's tactics, the U.S. Revolutionary War, and modern conflicts to illustrate recurring patterns in human behavior and governance. Maher and Shapiro debate the efficacy of different foreign policy strategies, the role of military intervention, and the complexities of nation-building.

Shapiro emphasizes the necessity of understanding historical contexts to inform present-day policies, arguing that without decisive action, peace remains elusive. Maher challenges this view by questioning the moral underpinnings and long-term sustainability of such approaches.

---

10. Concluding Thoughts and Reflections (93:06 - End)

The episode wraps up with the hosts reflecting on the overarching themes discussed, reiterating their commitment to pragmatic solutions over ideological rigidity. They emphasize the importance of personal responsibility, informed decision-making, and the need for balanced governance that respects both individual freedoms and societal well-being.

---

Notable Quotes:

• Ben Shapiro:
  “I'm as straight laced as it is possible to be. So, you know, that's my blessing, my curse.” (02:27)
  “Peace is an outgrowth of one side kicking the shit out of the other side so hard that they decide not to do war anymore.” (76:31)
  “It's very easy to try and mistake an anecdote for a trend.” (62:20)

• Bill Maher:
  “Discipline is love. It's not on the surface, it's below the surface, but it translates to love. It really does.” (59:22)
  “If you make all the right decisions and then you fail, then maybe you can blame external factors.” (29:49)

---

Key Takeaways:

• Religious Integrity: Shapiro maintains a stringent adherence to his religious beliefs, viewing them as both guiding and limiting factors.

• Personal Safety and Relocation: Experiences of urban crime influence personal decisions, highlighting the intersection of personal experience and broader social issues.

• Political Polarization: The debate underscores the deep divides in current American politics, particularly concerning leadership qualities and party directions.

• Foreign Policy Realism: A pragmatic approach to international relations and military intervention is advocated, stressing the complexities and moral dilemmas involved.

• Social Responsibility: Emphasis on discipline, personal responsibility, and the role of parenting in shaping future generations.

• Media Critique: The media's role in shaping and sometimes distorting public perception is critically examined.

• Historical Context: Understanding historical events is deemed crucial for informing present-day policies and avoiding past mistakes.

• Cultural Sensitivity: Discussions on cultural practices, drug legalization, and societal norms reflect ongoing debates about freedom and regulation.

---

This episode of Club Random offers a candid and unfiltered dialogue between Bill Maher and Ben Shapiro, traversing a wide array of topics from personal experiences to intricate political and social issues. Their exchange provides listeners with diverse perspectives, encouraging critical thought and informed discourse on contemporary challenges.

Transcript

[A]

Okay, here's the deal. Listen up. Rocket Money is a personal finance app that helps find and cancel your unwanted subscriptions, monitors your spending, and helps lower your bills so you can grow your savings. Stop wasting money on things you don't use. Cancel your unwanted subscriptions by going to rocketmoney.com/ that's rocketmoney.com/rocketmoney.com/.

[B]

This episode is brought to you by Skinny Pop Popcorn. Perfectly popped, endlessly delicious. Oh, so light and crunchy. Skinny Pop Original Popcorn is the snack you've been searching for. Made with just three simple popcorn kernels, sunflower oil and salt. Snacking never felt or tasted so good. Perfectly popped, endlessly delicious. Give yourself permission to snack and pick up Skinny Pop Original Popcorn today.

[A]

Hey, my old pal Shane Smith from Vice, who just did this show, has a new podcast. Shane talks to everybody about the biggest trending topics that hit your feed every week. It's called Shane Smith Has Questions. And it's on the Vice News YouTube channel and on audio, too. Anywhere you listen to your podcast, I recommend it highly.

[B]

You know, as somebody who has a bit of a dog in the Hitler fight. Right.

[A]

I was gonna say, you know, like.

[B]

The funny hat, you know, says something about it. Like on a practical level, again, that's.

[A]

Adorable that you think that.

[B]

Then he wants to stick around after that club Randall.

[A]

Ben, are you back there?

[B]

I am. I'm hidden back here in the Richard Bradley's chair.

[A]

I just came to this place.

[B]

Yeah, exactly.

[A]

I gotta give it up because I bet you you've never done anything like this.

[B]

The last time I did something like this was probably when I was in studio with. Was it Molly Hatchett? Randomly Molly Hatchet? Who was that again? It was like a punk rock band.

[A]

When was this?

[B]

This is like years and years ago. 15 years ago. I don't know.

[A]

Yeah.

[B]

Yeah, it's pretty wild.

[A]

Well, I appreciate you coming to a place that seems antithetical to everything you stand for and believe in, but I bet, I bet you you had your day when you were like a wild, like. No, not high school.

[B]

Not even a moment. No, really, not.

[A]

Not even a moment.

[B]

Not even a moment. I'm as straight laced as it is possible to be. So, you know, that's my blessing, my curse. Right? That's the thing about being religious. Like, if we're right, then it works out great. And if we're wrong, boy, do we F up. Right? I mean, that's the. That's. That's sort of the Pascal's wager of it.

[A]

So, well, but come on, that's not even why you really should want to be religious.

[B]

No, of course not.

[A]

It's not. But I mean, certainly people do that. I mean, I always say. Because I think I'm fair about religion. Yes. I'm anti religious, of course. But I do admit it does some good. I mean, it's not a hundred to zero. Proposition Charities, Catholic Charities. And one of the things it does is it does keep some people in line.

[B]

Yeah, that's what Voltaire said.

[A]

So it makes other people fly planes into buildings. So we'll call that one a push, right? Am I right?

[B]

I mean, I won't say that all religions are exactly equal in their effect.

[A]

No. But it does keep the idea that. And this is not so much in Judaism, because Judaism is the least about the afterlife. That's true. And how much the devil is gonna poke you in the ass with a pitchfork if you fuck up on Earth. Right.

[B]

Yes.

[A]

What is the review for our students? What is the Judaic version of the post life? What's their post life?

[B]

A big debate about it, just like everything else in Judaism. But there's not one kind of clear picture. I mean, the picture that I always.

[A]

Got, is it heaven?

[B]

Yes, but heaven can be construed as sort of reunification with God more than sort of like you're hanging out just like you're a human being, but you're hanging out with all your friends up there. And hell is less of like you're burning an everlasting fire, and more like there's a cleansing process that your soul goes through because of all the sins that you've done. And that process has to continue in order for your soul to be cleansed. So it can rejoin God, essentially.

[A]

But Judaism has a concept of hell, of Hades, of. No, not really. Right. And that's hugely different.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

Than the other two big ones, for sure.

[B]

No, hell is Los Angeles. I almost got robbed last night, by the way.

[A]

What?

[B]

Oh, yeah. We were here for family and to be on this and went out with some friends last night on 3rd street for dinner. And it's, you know, not a bad area.

[A]

No.

[B]

Like 10:30 at night. We get out of the restaurant. I have security, obviously, so we start heading one way. My friends head the other as a husband and wife. They go like, you know, three cars down, they get in their car. As soon as they get in their car, a white Hyundai pulls up and three black gentlemen. I mentioned the race because they are still at large, jump out of the car. They immediately grab my friend Pull him out of his car, steal his wallet, steal his watch, pull his keys out of his pocket, his phone. They run around to his wife, they grab her, start trying to rip the jewelry off of her. She screams. And at this point their time has elapsed. They jump back in the car and they take off. And I remembered why I moved to Florida so.

[A]

Well, it's not like that couldn't happen in Florida.

[B]

Well, I mean we'd shoot you if we. Why are you strapped in Florida?

[A]

Sure you are.

[B]

So is my wife. Everybody's strapped in Florida. Come on man, I've been there.

[A]

Okay, well what I take from this is don't eat on third street anymore. There's some fine restaurants on third Street. I mean Berry's, I love Berry's. It's late night. It's a very strange restaurant because it's nice, nobody's ever in it. If you wanna like be sure to get a table at 9:00. I'm just walking off the street. I recommend it Eiley. I think there must be laundering money or something. Jones is an old. Isn't the little door on third? These are all like place I will never go again.

[B]

Yeah, no, listen, I grew up here, man. I mean I spent my entire childhood here. I was here for of the 36 years before we moved to Florida. I was here for 33 of them here and then there came a point where we were out.

[A]

Well, I mean you're not unique. Certainly there's lots of people who have knew the places people move are Florida, Nashville and Austin.

[B]

Yep, right.

[A]

Those are the three sort of like havens for people who have had wokeness up to here. And when I say wokeness, you know, I mean it's a triggering word because some people think of it in the original meaning which is as I always say, noble, alert to injustice. Certainly with our despicable racial history that was necessary to be super alert and vigilant. Then it migrated because words do. That's just the nature of language. You can't control it. Words just become something else. And it became a sort of catch all for what I have called the aggressively anti common sense agenda. I mean that's where we share a belief. Then there's lots of stuff where we don't, you know, we don't even have to talk about Trump. But you know, it is like 10 days before an election and we're about.

[B]

To elect like as a moral obligation.

[A]

The worst person ever who's a dictator. Change America for the worst forever. But you know what between friends, little things like that can go. But we agree on the aggressively anti common sense agenda. And common sense certainly is job one. Make the citizens feel safe.

[B]

Well, that's the thing. I turned to my friend after he got robbed and we were calling the cops and waiting 15 minutes for the cops to arrive. And I said to him, well, at least you've done your part to alleviate systemic racism in the United States. And that's the mentality. And he's been thinking about moving out of here for a while. And again, he and his family live here. Bad governance is a thing that ought not be countenanced, regardless of your politics. I mean, people would like to live in a place where you can walk down the street at 10:30 at night and not be robbed by roving gangs. And that doesn't seem particularly controversial, but the fact that it is, I think, you know, again, we don't have to get into the Trump of it. But I think one of the reasons why people are less concerned about things that people like Trump say is because, like, okay, the issues that matter to me are things like, is my grocery bill twice what it was three years ago? Am I getting robbed on the street? And so the disconnect between the legacy media, which is very concerned about things like systemic racism, and the normal person who's like, I would just like to not get robbed today, that drives an enormous amount of distrust in legacy media. So when they start warning about, you know, Donald Trump saying X, Y or Z, it's like, okay, well, he's saying that, you know, what I really care about is who's going to fix my life and make it better. And I think that really is a big divide right now.

[A]

Yeah. The piece I'm doing at the end of the show Friday, and I guess this will air after that, so I don't have to worry that I'm cheating myself. But it's, you know, it ends with saying that the Democrats, when they ran against Trump, certainly in 2020 and this year, really their big argument is let's get back to normal. Certainly that was Biden's and what I'm saying to them, and of course I'm voting for her and I want them to win, is. And, you know, I don't have to love everything. And I don't. But certainly it's not a hard choice for me. But if you're, what you're selling is, let's get back to normal, be normal. We know Trump isn't normal, but you're, you're, if you lose this election, it's because a sizable number, perhaps a majority, think you're not normal in fundamental ways either. And, you know, I know the left, the far left, hates me for always noticing this, but I'm going to continue to notice it because it's true. And it's not traditional old school liberalism. It's something very different. And you can't have that word, you are woke or whatever the word is, but it's different. And you can't merge them when they're very often opposite.

[B]

I think the Democratic Party has also done something where they've been intoxicated by the wonderful high of being able to just say Trump over and over and over, and Trump is Hitler over and over. And that's excuse them to basically believe they can do whatever it is that they want, say what it is they want. The weird thing about this election cycle is that positionally, Trump is the most moderate candidate in Republican history. Right. He took abortion basically out of the platform.

[A]

Right.

[B]

I mean, like at the rnc, he basically sidelined abortion, which is a huge issue, obviously, for the pro life community. That's a big part of the Republican Party.

[A]

He appointed the judges who got rid of it.

[B]

That's true. I mean, he will not. They got rid of Roe. But the point is that his position has been that he will veto, for example, a national abortion ban. No other Republican could have gotten away with that. Correct. When it comes to things like when it comes to same sex marriage, that's completely out of the platform. Because it's not.

[A]

Right. The great part of being a cult leader is that you. No, seriously, is that when it's about personality and this is true, and, you know, it's funny you bring up Hitler, it's like he's the one talking about Hitler now. I think it's hysterical that for years now, you guys don't seem to care at all that he. The only, the only human who he has ever not shit on is Putin. Like everybody else gets it. Friends, enemies, people back in the fold. Everybody gets shit on except. And a couple of other dictators he likes. But now he's sort of like thrown that mask away and just like, you know, I like all these people who are Hitlerian. Let's just say I like Hitler too. Well, I mean, it's kind of funny.

[B]

Well, here's the thing about the whole Hitler thing. So, you know, as somebody who has a bit of a dog in the Hitler fight, Right. I was gonna say, you know, like the funny hat, you know, says something about it. As somebody who actually cares about this sort of thing? I was with Trump like two weeks ago at the grave of the Labavitzer Rebbe with the hostage family where one of the kids is being held right now in captivity by Hamas American kid. And I'll tell you something, Hitler didn't do that. So for all of the jibber jabber about the stuff he says, the thing I've always said about Trump is that on his gravestone it's going to be written 45th, maybe 47th president of the United States. He said a lot of shit. And that's true. He does say an enormous amount of shit. And the way that I look at Trump is. And then what does he actually do? And I've noticed many of the people who are, who are calling him Hilarion seem to be perfectly okay with the pro Hamas protesters on campus or with slow walking aid to Israel in the middle of a war with actual people who agree with actual Hitler. I mean, in Gaza they used to have like an actual store called Hitler 2 that was like an actual shop. It was a clothing shop in the Gaza Strip. It was reported on by the Jerusalem Post in 2015. And like, I'm more concerned about that, frankly.

[A]

Nazi uniforms were sharp. There's just no way around it. Listen, it's just, you go, boss.

[B]

Hitler did do one amazing thing. He did kill Hitler.

[A]

Yeah, yeah, but the uniforms were just on point.

[B]

Hugo Boss man.

[A]

I mean, among other. Yes, but I mean just the way that the cut on those legs, especially the general's uniform with the red stripe on the leg and also those leather full length, snazzy just with the, the lapels, everything was just. Now, there are things I don't like.

[B]

About the turbine.

[A]

But I can answer your question there about like the. Well, he just says stuff. I mean, this is. You're so sanguine about this. It just amuses me. And it won't in the future because, yeah, he didn't do a lot of the stuff he said the first time, but he tried, you know, Hillary, lock her up. Yeah, he tried. He tried to get Sessions to do that.

[B]

Not really.

[A]

Yeah, he did.

[B]

No, he didn't.

[A]

And he certainly tried to not honor the election and as I said from the beginning, didn't concede. And he tried everything. He did not have in place enough lackeys and stooges to pull it off the first time. That may not be the case the second time. That's my worry about Trump. The whistling past the graveyard. He says a lot of things about the enemies within and all these words and phrases that we heard from places where they did conduct pogroms about people. That's exactly what they said in Rwanda.

[B]

Okay. I mean, I think that if you're believing that Donald Trump is a figure who's about to massacre the Houthis, I don't know.

[A]

If they were here, we would.

[B]

I highly.

[A]

The Houthis, they're eating the pet. The Houthis, The Haitians ate all the dogs and the cats. The Houthis go for the hamsters.

[B]

But here's the thing. I keep asking people, what's the practical path for Trump to do this? I've actually said to people, if you actually want Trump not to deny the next election, then probably he should win, because he ain't sticking around for a third term. All he wants is to win. Once he wins, he frankly, I mean, really, again, like, on a practical level.

[A]

Again, that's adorable that you think that.

[B]

And he wants to stick around after that. The only reason he stuck around this time is because he lost last time. That's the only reason he's there.

[A]

I mean, he's not even unique in this. Once you get to be president, once you have the plane and wherever you want to go in the world, you can get there faster than any other human being because they will clear the countryside, the streets, they will clear everything. Once you have all those kind of perks, you never want to give up. Look at Biden. He must have known that he was a shell of his former self, but you cannot. It's like flying private.

[B]

Yeah, he's eligible. Trump's not eligible after.

[A]

Once you fly private, once they can't.

[B]

Even list him on a ballot. I mean, once his second term is over, it's over. And as far as the people he's going to appoint to his Cabinet, they have to go through Senate confirmation. I mean, like, here's the thing about Trump. And again, we don't have to talk about Trump the whole time, but the systems of government, the checks and balances, were built to stop stupid, blundering attempts to overrun those boundaries. They really were. I mean, that's why you can say that Donald Trump tried all this stuff and it failed, because the system was basically built for that. What the system was not really built for was the takeover of institutions from the inside and then the gradual weakening of those institutions. So, you know, for example, the use of the Occupational Safety and Health Administration to try and cram down vaccines on 80 million Americans, or the. Or the attempt to ram down, you know, alleviation of Student loans, single handedly. And then after the Supreme Court says, don't do that, the attempt to continue to do that, or the activation of the Department of Justice to continue investigating Trump, apparently, for everything under the sun, these sorts of things, they can be abused that way. And those abuses are pretty serious.

[A]

I'm not gonna follow all those trails because we're here at Club Random, but, I mean, I could. I mean, some of what you say I agree with, some I don't. My. I'll just. Let's end this section of our conversation with just this one question. If he does do these things that I fear, will you admit it?

[B]

Sure.

[A]

Yes, of course. I think he will. I think you're an honorable guy. I mean, I do.

[B]

I posed him when he was doing this between November and January last time around.

[A]

Okay, but he did it, so how could you possibly forgive it?

[B]

I mean, I don't forgive what he did between November and January. And now I'm faced with a binary choice between two candidates. And who do I think is going to be?

[A]

You really think the hellscape that would be America would be worse under Kamala? I mean, again, all the woke stuff, I mean, this is last week's editorial that I did, and this week they both kind of have the same theme, which is that, Kamala, you need to convince the undecided voter that you're not a stealth woke nut. Yes, that's it.

[B]

Are you convinced?

[A]

No, but I would take that even over as much baggage comes with that, it's still better than the guy who doesn't concede elections, loves Putin, loves autocracy, fundamentally doesn't understand that that's the linchpin to America, the peaceful transference of power. No, I don't think he would ever give it up. I don't think he would ever say, I lost.

[B]

Can I ask you the countervailing question?

[A]

And he will probably try to pass it on to Uday and Hussein.

[B]

So you've said, you've asked me, you know, if Trump does all these things, will you admit it and say. And I said, okay, so if Kamala turns out, if she wins and she turns out to be just as stealthily woke as I fear she will be, and if she pursues bad kind of foreign policy that I think she will, I assume that you'll also come forward.

[A]

And say that what I will admit is that she was a stealth woke nut. I will not admit, because I haven't said it now and never have and never would, that that is yet worse than not conceding an election. Understood that to me is the absolute bottom.

[B]

So I think that if you're going to make a bet to be fair, just to, you know, if we're going to put it in people's lap, then the bet is basically, do you think there's a better chance that Donald Trump ends up being a Hitlerian tyrannical dictator who overruns all the boundaries of power, or do you think that there's a better chance that Kamala Harris is going to be a stealth woke nut who runs America into a ditch? And I think there's a way better chance of the latter than the former.

[A]

But yes, maybe so. Hmm. Don't know. But a good question at least. What is not a question in my mind is if the worst outcome of each happened, which is the worst of the two. Not fair.

[B]

That's part of the calculus.

[A]

Can you agree with it? Well, I mean, it would be worse.

[B]

If Donald Trump turns into Hitler. I think that that is worse than Kamala Harris being bad, not Hitler.

[A]

He's not going to kill all the Jews. He likes the Jews.

[B]

He does.

[A]

And so do I. I have to tell you, I have a substack now, because it's a rule, every media person must have a substack. We have exclusive content from Club Random, some great extras, and me talking directly to you about whatever the fuck I feel like. But it's mostly about the goings on here at Club Random. Find it at billmar.substack.com I'll see you there. The marketing gurus from Radioactive Media are back and bringing you another episode of Club Random. Thanks gurus, business owners and CMOs. How do you plan on growing your business in 2025? With this crazy election season, there are going to be a lot of uncertainties. But one thing is certain. Things will be different in 2025. Why not utilize something reliable and stable for your marketing efforts and tap into the power of podcasts and radio? In the U.S. audio reaches more than 271 million people weekly. That's more than social media and digital combined. My friends at Radioactive Media know the recipe to launch. Optimize and scale performance by building compelling audio campaigns that work for advertisers who want to reach the right audience. Text them. Just text random to 511-511. They believe in the power of audio so much, they even use it themselves. Right here, right now. You can utilize the strength of text messaging, which can generate an ROI as high as 7 to 1. Start planning for 2025 now. Go to RadioactiveMedia.com or text the word random to 511-511 Discover how audio marketing can surpass your current strategies with new and innovative ways. Innovative ways to sound better. Go to RadioactiveMedia.com or text random to 511511 text random to 511511 today. Message and Data rates may apply. I hate paying for things twice like subscriptions. I mean, can you name every single subscription you have? I can't. And I'm not alone. 74% of people have subscriptions they've forgotten about. With Rocket Money. I don't have to remember every subscription or worry about forgetting any because I can see the them all laid out right in front of me. So you can get rid of phones and apps and just shit you don't want, you don't want or signed up for or when you're high that you may be paying for for years. Rocket Money just helped me cancel my Columbia Record Club subscription from 1972. Damn, I wanted to keep that one. Although I do still have that Cream album. Okay, here's the deal. Listen up. Rocket Money is a personal finance app that helps find and cancel your unwanted subscriptions, monitors your spending, and helps lower your bills so you can grow your savings. Rocket Money has over 5 million users and has saved a total of $500 million in canceled subscriptions, saving members up to $740 a year when using all of the app's premium Stop wasting money on things you don't use. Cancel your unwanted subscriptions by going to rocketmoney.com/ that's rocketmoney.com/rocketmoney.com random when you think about businesses that are selling through the roof, like Aloe or Allbirds or Skims. Sure, you think about a great product, a cool brand, and brilliant marketing. But an offer often overlooked. Secret is actually the businesses behind the business making selling and buying simple for millions of businesses. That business is Shopify, and we use Shopify ourselves at our own merch store and it's fantastic. Nobody does selling better than Shopify. Shop in the name people Home of the number one checkout on the planet and the not so secret Secret with Shop Pay that boosts conversions up to 50%. So if you're into growing your business, your commerce platform better be ready to sell whatever your customers are scrolling or strolling on the web, in your store, in their feed, and everywhere in between. Businesses that sell more sell on Shopify. Upgrade your business and get the same checkout that Skims uses. Sign up for your $1 per month trial period at shopify.com/all lowercase. Go to shopify.com/random to upgrade your selling today. Shopify.com/random and I appreciate your reaching out about my chapel roan editorial a few months ago.

[B]

Yeah, it was great. It was great.

[A]

But it means a lot. But it means a lot to me.

[B]

Because am I allowed to shit on like the other guests you've had on the show or not?

[A]

Of course.

[B]

Okay. So Bill Burr was a fucking asshole on this show.

[A]

My show?

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

That was so long ago.

[B]

I know, but it pissed me off. Really. It was quite terrible.

[A]

That's the last time you saw my show?

[B]

No, I watched the show consistently, but that one's been in my craw for a while.

[A]

Okay. I don't even remember it. And I don't think he was an asshole. I think I remember that he had a great. Maybe he was like. He was here. Oh, this show, yes. Oh, I thought you meant real time.

[B]

No, no, no. This show.

[A]

Oh, this show, yes. Well, you know what? Bill and I have a great relationship. It's not what I call a loving relationship, but. But we have a grudging respect for the other one. And when he is funniest is when I purposely goad him cause he's like Mr. Regular Guy. And I'm not really a pompous professor, but I can play one because I know a lot of words he doesn't and things he doesn't which he finds to be elitist. You know, Ben, listen, I think he's.

[B]

Super funny and I think he was an asshole on the show.

[A]

That's very possible. But I happen to love that episode because I would say things like, you know, just to provoke him. Bill, do you find it entirely elemacenary that this. And I was just. I love playing the straight man and it just gave him the chance to be the Boston guy who's like whatever the fuck that means. And it's funny. Comedians love just to do that.

[B]

Yeah. Now the thing that ticked me off was where he started essentially getting high handed about. Well, you don't know anything about the Middle east and you can't speak about this, but I love the protesters and the protesters are great.

[A]

Were you funny in school? I was not the class clown. That was too beneath me. I was a snob even as a kid. But I was kind of the class wit. I would try to make the teacher laugh. Were you anything like that in school?

[B]

I mean, a little bit, but I was pretty biting. I mean, like I was. I was two years younger than everybody.

[A]

Right.

[B]

So when you were advanced Yeah, I skipped third grade and ninth grade, so.

[A]

That makes so much sense. Because really, I mean, your capacity. I mean, I feel like I have skills that you don't have, but you have definite, like. And you're not the only one. But people who can write, write and read, like long thousand word tomes. Very. I mean, your mastery of the detail of the law and every issue and how fast you speak, you know, it's like I can't aspire to these things and frankly, I don't want them. But they are impressive and they're rare.

[B]

So, I mean, I'll say that when I was in school. So that results when you skip a couple grades and you don't hit your growth spurt until, you know, senior year, when that happens, that's likely to result in you basically being, you know, the class punching bag.

[A]

Were you stuffed in a locker, that kind of stuff?

[B]

Oh, yeah, much worse than stuffed in a locker, but yes.

[A]

Really? Like what?

[B]

Like, physically abused? Like, hit like that kind of stuff? Like that.

[A]

Physically, but not sexually.

[B]

Not sexually. Not sexually. Like hit with belts, that kind of stuff.

[A]

And to get fucked in a locker?

[B]

No, that would be bad. That would be bad. I don't think my life would have gone quite as bad.

[A]

The ultimate humiliation.

[B]

Yeah, that would have been terrible. But no, it was bad. So you carry a chip on your shoulder around.

[A]

I mean, I also was a huge loser in high school and super shy and again, growth spurt. Not that I ever read, really. A big one, but at least I got to normal. But I think at like 14, I was still very short for. And you know, kids are feral. Kids are awful.

[B]

They are.

[A]

Kids are the real Nazis. You have to civilize them. And before you do, their instinct is to be awful. And they are.

[B]

I agree with you.

[A]

All four of them I went to.

[B]

I mean, people, they're wonderful and terrible. Yes.

[A]

Yeah.

[B]

I mean, they're innocent but not good. Kids are innocent, but not good.

[A]

That's a great way to put it. Yeah. I mean, it's funny, whenever I go to my doctor for a checkup, she always says, like, you know, and stress. I'm like, life is stress. I said, you know, when I was stressed when I was a kid, adulthood is not stressful at all. Even though I've had many stressful episodes about various things. But compared to the knot in my stomach that was every day, because it wasn't like I was ostracized every day, but some days. So, like, which. Which days it can end?

[B]

Exactly. Exactly.

[A]

Which of these Nazi children who Somehow, somehow they got to be the Gestapo. What are they? Kids?

[B]

Also, especially in high school, they have an innate ability to spot the chink in your armor and just go right for it. The weak, the weakness, the weakness.

[A]

I don't know if that's like a Darwinian thing.

[B]

Probably right?

[A]

Like, let's kill the weak.

[B]

And so, you know, I have a sort of counterintuitive view of bullying, which is it's really, really bad. And also, I'm not sure that it's necessarily bad for everyone who was bullied because, you know, as somebody who was pretty viciously bullied in high school, I think it was kind of good. Not that I was bullied, but like, you grow some thick skin, you get some skill sets, you think you wouldn't.

[A]

Be the success you are if you hadn't been.

[B]

I was always pretty determined. But when you learn young to take shit and to kind of walk back at it, that's not bad.

[A]

When the Washington Post writes an editorial about you.

[B]

Exactly, exactly.

[A]

It's not as bad.

[B]

Whatever. Okay. I mean, especially because, you know, I haven't. I will say my life is a very boring and predictable life because I've made a bunch of good decisions. And one of my. One of my, you know, kind of pet peeves about people's life stories is that the ones that are really interesting are very often ones where it's people making their own obstacles and then overcoming the obstacles they make for themselves. And I'm pretty proud of the fact that I haven't had tons of obstacles that are at least self created. I mean, like, I grew up in Burbank, California. Over here, I had great parents. We had a small house, like 1,100 square feet. And it was six of us in a small house with one bathroom. And that's not an obstacle. That's just called life.

[A]

Right?

[B]

And then, you know, we got a little older. My parents got a little wealthier. They moved into a 2,400 square foot home and still wasn't that big. And, you know, then I went to college, and then I paid my way through law school, and then I got married and now I have four kids. And it's a series of good decisions. And it sounds super boring because it turns out that life being good is kind of boring.

[A]

It sounds like boring and predictable, which is what you just said is, you're good with that. See that?

[B]

It's great. It's solid.

[A]

Oh, see, that's what would make me want to put a bullet past my tongue. Like, no, really, I Mean, yeah. Boring and predictable is what I've like, tried and sacrificed many things to maintain. Not.

[B]

I think that it depends on sort of the definition. Obviously, when you're saying you don't want boring and predictable, you don't mean that you'd like to be revived from an overdose. Right? Like, that's not today. I'm a little down, you know, but.

[A]

I'm going to shoot this in my.

[B]

Arm and like, see how this goes.

[A]

Where are my manners? Ben, can I get you a joint?

[B]

Absolutely not. You know, people say. People say I'm too mellow already, Bill. If I have more, I'm just going to be.

[A]

But it's cool that you'll sit with me and do it. Yeah, that's, that's, that's good libertarianism, right? That's a good kind.

[B]

Listen, I don't want a pot shop on my street. I'm for zoning laws. But, you know, you're an adult.

[A]

And it's really not that harmful. Did you see that The Democrats are finally. What did they. They did something. They had a big thing with Willie Nelson. Or is that tomorrow? Maybe that's tomorrow. Maybe.

[B]

I mean, they're dragging all of them out. They dragged out Eminem, Willie Nelson. Really going for it.

[A]

No, but this is like a last minute, like, pot initiative. I think it's just full legalization. And I mean, here's an interesting question.

[B]

Evolution. Kamala Harris from like locking up everybody for Pod two.

[A]

I mentioned that in our meeting.

[B]

Smoking up to.

[A]

That's when she kind of lost me. I mean, I remember I donated to her. This is back when I used to give money to some politicians. I've learned my lesson. But I think she was very against pot. And I thought, oh, wow. I mean, like, unnecessarily, especially for the Democrat, it looked to me like, oh, you're picking on poor little pot because they can't fight back and it makes you look tough. And that pissed me off because, you know, pot is one of my, you know, one of the independent voters. Call it issues that matter to me. You know, it's all about issues that matter to me.

[B]

I gotta say, I do think that for young people, the strains of pot have gotten a lot more intense than when I was a kid.

[A]

Thank you, Jesus.

[B]

Again, I mean, but for young people, I don't think it's a wonderful thing. Like 20 year olds who are regularly talking, I don't think that's a great thing for them.

[A]

Well, 20, you're okay, 20, you're grown up and that's when you really want to be smoking. Listen to Uncle Bill, kids.

[B]

But it's one of those areas of disagreement that we're gonna have.

[A]

But I'm very glad that I did not start until I was 19. I was. It was after the first year of college, the summer after. That's good. I feel like. Good for my body and good for my mind. You have to learn what reality is before you start fucking with it, you know? But, you know, as far as libertarian principles go, to me, the most private place that you should not try to interfere with is inside my mind. Don't tell me what I can do inside my mind. That's worse than coming into my house, even. That's my mind. And if I want to open the doors of Perception. You know the group the Doors?

[B]

Yeah, of course.

[A]

You know that. That's where that name comes from.

[B]

I did not know that.

[A]

Aldous Huxley, I believe it was, wrote a book called the Doors of Perception about drugs, and that's where they took that name from. Okay, look, I.

[B]

You taught me something. I did not know that.

[A]

I can't believe there's one thing in this world you didn't know.

[B]

To be fair, this is an area of expertise.

[A]

I know, but I feel like. I feel very good that I knew one thing you didn't know.

[B]

You know, when it. When it comes to this sort of stuff, I also am a big fan of localism on this. So, again, I don't want to pot shop in my neighborhood where my kids are. And if you want to live in libertarian land in LA with all the adults with no kids around, like, that's your prerogative.

[A]

I must tell you, as someone who probably has not been to a pot shop, or as we call them, dispensaries.

[B]

Thank you. Again, not my area of expertise.

[A]

I know. That's why I'm filling it up.

[B]

Yeah, no, I appreciate it, but I.

[A]

Promise, you learn things. It's not like I know you don't want it in your neighborhood, but I think you're picturing a crack den and a pot chop. It's just people like me who can afford it, going in and having a very elegant experience with budtenders and people selling a product, giving you advice. You know, the marketing gurus from Radioactive Media are back and bringing you another episode of Club Random. Thanks, gurus. Just because the election is over and we've been promised that desks will be made of chocolate and. And gold will flow in the streets. That may not happen. So as a business owner, you need to Kick some ass on your own. And you can do that with Radioactive Media. Why not tap into the power of podcast and radio? My friends at Radioactive Media know the recipe to launch, optimize and scale performance by building compelling audio campaigns at work. For advertisers who want to reach the right audience, text them. Just text random to 511511 start planning for 2025 now. Go to RadioactiveMedia.com or text the word random to 511-511. Discover how audio marketing can surpass your current strategies with new and innovative ways that sound better. Go to RadioactiveMedia.com or text random to 511511 text random to 511-511 today message and data rates may apply. One of the greatest character builders that is Things that suck is struggling with money. Sheesh. No one wants to think about debt, but the cold hard truth of it is many people will get deeper in debt during the holidays because they buy stupid shit. Last year, half of American consumers took on debt to pay for the holidays. That is stupid. This year it could be you. It's never too early to start planning to get out. And the people at PDS Debt can help with a personalized solution just for you. If you're making payments every month on your debt and your balances aren't going down, PDS has solutions for you. Everyone with $10,000 or more in eligible debt qualifies and there is no no minimum credit score required, bad and fair credit accepted. Save more while paying off your debt in a fraction of the time. Debt sucks. I remember. I do. So start planning today. Get a free debt analysis right now@pds debt.com random it only takes 30 seconds. That's PDS. D E B T pdsdebt.com random Sleep or my friend has joint pain or my friend has Parkinson's. And what would help? And I do have a question for.

[B]

You on this, actually, and I want to get your opinion on it.

[A]

Yes.

[B]

So you look at Denver, right? Denver has a huge problem with people in the streets who are clearly high. It's actually made a quality of life difference in terms of homelessness, in terms. And that has been linked to legalization of pot in places like Denmark.

[A]

Pot in the streets? Is that what you're saying?

[B]

I'm saying high levels of drug use in the streets.

[A]

Drug use is way too broad, my friend.

[B]

Okay, so pot legalization, do you think that's been a boon for Seattle, San Francisco, Denver?

[A]

I think anything.

[B]

What limits do you think should be.

[A]

Anything that involves great numbers of people? There's going to be some downside. I remember talking to Bezos about this. I don't know, just come up at dinner with a bunch of people and they were mentioning something that Amazon they were going after them for and he said, Well, I have 1.9 million. I think that was number. Is that about right for Amazon employees, which is like the size of the city of whatever it was San Antonio. Would you expect the city of San Antonio to like have no sexual harassment? You know?

[B]

Right.

[A]

You're talking about 1.9 million people. I think it's kind of like that with it's the right thing to legalize pot. We should certainly have what we want, the pursuit of happiness, blah, blah, blah. But yes, some number of people are gonna fuck up and we should also have immigration and some number of people who come as migrants will comm crimes to try to pretend that that's the whole issue of immigration. Yes, it's one thing you factor in when you go, what's the right answer on this? And certainly that answer isn't no immigrants. You want to have no immigrant crime, have no immigrants. That's not the right answer. Anything in the middle would you concede is some mixture of both.

[B]

Of course there are always trade offs when it comes to public policy. Of course, the real question I'm asking, I suppose is about externalities, level of addictiveness. Because again, as pot has gotten significantly more powerful. I mean, it's not the same pot as when I was growing up and kids in school were smoking and passing it around.

[A]

Okay, well, if someone has been smoking steadily for 50 years, I can attest it is not addictive. But I know that was a joke, but let me tell you why it's actually the truth.

[B]

Okay?

[A]

I know what addiction is. I did cigarettes for 20 years. That was stupid. I also did cocaine for a few years. That was really stupid because I didn't ever really like it. And just shows if you take a drug long enough casually, eventually it will grab you by the nuts and make you want it every day. That happened with coke and it happened with cigarettes. That has never happened with pot. That is the difference. These drugs said to me, do me now. I'm demanding you do me now. Pot never does that to me. Pot never says, ooh, do me. I tell pot, oh, okay, this would be a good time to smoke. That's a difference. I could and I do.

[B]

If there were data that showed the opposite, would you shift your opinion on it? Like maybe you're an exception?

[A]

I'm sure data does for Some other person. I'm a different person. We all react to drugs very differently. Most people reacted to cocaine. They got chatty. The last thing I could ever do on coke was talking. Most people couldn't fuck. I love to fuck on coke, okay? People are different and our chemistry is different. And how drugs affect us. Pot. About a third of the people get paranoid. About a third get sleepy. And about a third, and these are the people who should be doing it, get high. It makes us, like, better in a certain way. Things move faster in our brain and we just enjoy life. Everything would be better. But again, because I'm not addicted, I don't do pot for stupid things. And it would never, like, watch a movie high. Like, I don't need to be in a different realm for a movie. It's too passive. I'll do this when I'm rewriting something. Stand up. Sex, good conversation. The things I really like in life, that I want to heighten the experience. But that's not addictive. Other people, it does get addictive. I'm sure there are drooling idiots with Cheeto dust on their shirt who sit home all day and smoke pot all day. And by the way, their heroes are people like. And I love them. But Willie Nelson, Snoop Dogg, people who. Woody people have this reputation for smoking pot all day long because they do. That's so far from me. So I'm just saying that's the spectrum when we're talking about pot. Don't judge me by the worst people who do it.

[B]

No, I'm not trying to take away your thoughts.

[A]

I made very clear you agree with that principle.

[B]

I mean, I think that obviously that's true. I mean, that doesn't necessarily dispense with the public policy considerations. Right? I mean, you have to look at. Then you have to look at the data. What are the percentages of people, what are the ages, where it's most likely to be addictive?

[A]

Okay, rubber meets the road. Should it be legal or not?

[B]

Pot, I mean, where I live. No, where you live. Sure. I'm a big fan of localism. I'm a big fan of localism.

[A]

What a dodge. Localism. Same thing.

[B]

Why is localism with Dodge?

[A]

Well, the same thing with abortion. You know, as if that very fundamental issue of life and death was somehow different between, you know, Kansas and Vermont.

[B]

Oh, it isn't. But I think that this is actually a really important political point, which is that, you know, on a principled level, were I the dictator, then all the rules would, you know, be dictated by me. But I'm not. The question is pragmatic politics. Do we wish to share a republic together? Do we wish to share the same country? If that's true, that's why the system was constructed in favor of localism, specifically for that, so that you and I can disagree on stuff and still get along. So I think that actually it's a pretty good position.

[A]

But certainly you would concede that federalism does trump localism many times, and rightly so. We do need a federal government. I mean, you're not anti.

[B]

For very few things. For a very few things. It's a government of specified power.

[A]

So you believe Alexander Hamilton went too far?

[B]

I don't think we needed a national bank. Yes, yes.

[A]

Really?

[B]

Yes, yes.

[A]

I love it that my jokes are your truth. We don't need a national bank.

[B]

Seems like banks have done pretty well at that national bank. Where here.

[A]

A central bank is not.

[B]

That wasn't a central bank. Alexander Hamilton's national bank was not like the Federal Reserve or something.

[A]

But what we have now is a.

[B]

Central bank, the Federal Reserve.

[A]

And like every big boy country does.

[B]

It didn't until the mid 20th century, until 1920s, effectively.

[A]

Okay, but isn't it something you.

[B]

I like the gold standard.

[A]

Holy fuck. That is conservative. The gold standard, yeah.

[B]

Gold standard is good stuff because it means that there isn't a cadre of wise men deciding how much my money's worth.

[A]

Do you think it would create if we did that? Like a new generation of 49ers gold prospectors. But now they have super high technology. So it wasn't like in the river with the pan and you're looking.

[B]

They could try it. But let's put it this way, the amount of gold they're going to generate by doing that's a hell of a lot less inflationary than the amount of money that's being generated by the federal government every single day.

[A]

You know what broke hearts in the old West? One whores. Because you know, you'd go into the.

[B]

Saloon and I feel like I could see that one coming.

[A]

Okay, well, I just thought of it. But I was going to say apropos of the gold thing. Pyrite.

[B]

It must have been real bad.

[A]

Pyrite looks like gold. Because I know when I was a kid I had a little pyrite.

[B]

Exactly. Not as malleable. That's how you could tell, right? It's like a hammer.

[A]

You're like, oh, is that how you tell?

[B]

That's how you tell, yeah.

[A]

And what about diamonds? Well, I mean, there was a Time when they were considered inappropriate to support as a business because they were mined by, you know, gangs basically, in Western Africa who, you know, chopped off the arms of the children to assert their sovereignty over the village. Stuff like that. They were called.

[B]

I feel like there's a joke on the other end.

[A]

No, no, no. They were called conflict. Well, I did, actually. Why don't you say that?

[B]

I feel like if you're going all the way down, it's the morass. There's going to be a joke when you come on the other side.

[A]

Because it's a true story. Well, they're called conflict diamonds, right?

[B]

Yes.

[A]

This is a true story, though. I put it in my 2003 special that I did on Broadway. But it's an absolutely true story. This girl I was dating at the time, and I was telling her about this, where in Africa, the diamonds. To assert control over the area where they need to mine, they would sometimes cut off the arms of the little children in the village. And she looked at me with sad eyes and said, both arms, because it was just one. Diamonds are just so sparkly. But both gave her pause. I just could not have been a sweeter person. But I think it just illustrated the hold that the diamonds have. Do you ever see that? You ever see Marathon Man?

[B]

Of course.

[A]

Where Laurence Olivier in the Diamond District as Zell. He's the. What was he? Was he.

[B]

He's a Nazi doctor.

[A]

Yeah.

[B]

He's supposed to be Mengele, right?

[A]

That's what I was gonna ask you. He's supposed to be Mengele, Right. Oh, what a great movie that was.

[B]

Yeah. The great Roy Scheider. Who's the best thing in the film?

[A]

Roy Scheider.

[B]

Roy Scheider's fantastic.

[A]

That's right. Dustin Hoffman. Roy Scheider.

[B]

Olivier and Dustin Hoffman, and Roy Scheider blows them both off the screen. He's.

[A]

And supposedly the scuttlebutt from the set was, you know, you had these two generations of actors. Olivier, old school. Hit your bark, hit your mark. And bark, as they used to say. Dustin Hoffman, new school, method acting. And apparently this famous scene where he's. He's a dentist, so he's got him in the chair and he's torturing him with the thing with the instruments to get. Which is just like normal dentistry. He wasn't even doing anything. The dentist hasn't done for me. And I don't know where the diamonds are, but Dustin Hoffman, supposedly, to have the correct amount of angst in the scene, stayed up for two days without sleep and Apparently Olivier said to him, dear boy, why don't you just try acting? What do you think of our affair? Business. You say you grew up out here. Were you touched by show business?

[B]

So my dad came out. Yeah, my parents came out here in 79. My dad wanted to write for film and TV. He's a musician. Oh, so you know Michelli's.

[A]

You know what?

[B]

You know, they said, you know the restaurant Michelle's over here on Ventura? Of course. My dad played piano there for 20 years, Monday and Tuesday nights.

[A]

What years? I bet you I heard him.

[B]

I'm sure he did. It would have been like early 90s through mid 2000s.

[A]

Yeah, I was still inappropriately going out to bars. Bars and clubs in the.

[B]

That's where they had all the waiters singing and stuff. So I grew up in that restaurant. Like my. I grew up.

[A]

Holy fuck.

[B]

I grew up sitting there.

[A]

And see, this is.

[B]

Bring out the food and this is.

[A]

What we need to know. Get under the yarmulke.

[B]

Yeah, exactly. Beneath the yarmulke. Yeah, exactly. The worst name for a podcast ever. Beneath the yarmulke.

[A]

Actually, it's not, but the answer is.

[B]

It'S a bald spot. But in any case, isn't today.

[A]

No, you have to leave because it's a Jewish something today.

[B]

Yet another Jewish holiday. Yeah, this is the tail end.

[A]

What is this one?

[B]

So this one is the end of Sukot. Right. So that's the festival, the festival of booths. Right. That's where we sit in the huts.

[A]

Sukkot spell it, because I've seen it.

[B]

S, U, K, K, O, T. Yeah, the kk. Yeah, exactly.

[A]

I never knew what that one was.

[B]

Yeah, this one is supposed to commemorate the Jews in the desert in. I mean, spiritually. It's supposed to commemorate basically the idea that you are living in a. In a non permanent world, in a non permanent body. And to get comfortable with the idea that you are supposed to perform a mission in life, despite the fact that life has a bunch of variables. And so you go and live outdoor in a hut for like a week, basically.

[A]

That's what they used to do.

[B]

Yeah, I mean, that's.

[A]

They don't do it.

[B]

So the story goes. I mean, no, we still. We still go and eat the meals there and some people actually sleep in it. It's like, you'll see. Yeah, you'll see them around town a little bit.

[A]

How many people do this? Like, what percentage of Jews do this?

[B]

There are like 15 million Jews on Earth. I'd say probably 2 million, maybe.

[A]

Yeah, yeah.

[B]

A couple million, if you're including, like, Orthodox in Israel. Orthodox, yeah. Two, two and a half million.

[A]

They're real super Jews.

[B]

Exactly, exactly. That's what we call ourselves. We control the weather on Friday nights, and we. And we build huts and control the.

[A]

Monetary supply and I may say, have a lot of the Nobel Prizes.

[B]

We do. We do. That is a true thing.

[A]

I'm not. Maybe it's who you know, but I'm just saying Team Hebrew has done very well at the metal account.

[B]

Listen, we're perfectly happy that.

[A]

And that's part of, I think, the reason why there's antisemitism in the world. I mean, you know, a small group of people who are outsizedly successful at certain things, especially things that are very sort of public. You know, show business, the arts, money, you know, banking, you know, medicine. Medicine. I mean, they're going to have some haters.

[B]

That's why I think that the most dangerous thing that's happening across the west is, in fact. And this, you know, the story of Canaan, Abel. You don't have to believe in God to understand the message of the story in Canaan, Abel, which is a really simple message.

[A]

Well, it's not that simple because one represented agriculture and one represented herding. You know, like.

[B]

Yeah, animal. Animal husbandry.

[A]

Animal husbandry, right. And that was in that era, obviously. The story tells us what that meant in that era, which was very important because there was a time in history when those two things were in conflict, for sure. You know, the way we argue about things that are, you know, to us, you know, should we do this or should we tax more? Should we tax less? They were like, should we go with raising the food?

[B]

Yes.

[A]

I'm a conservative. I say we should just hunt it down. What is this, raising food?

[B]

Well, in the biblical text, anyway, the basic idea is that Cain and Abel, actually, Cain is the first one who says, let's bring sacrifices. So they bring sacrifices. It doesn't really explain why God accepts Abel's sacrifice. But then God gives Cain a big speech. He says, sin crouches at your door, but you can avoid it, basically, if you do the right thing. If you read east of Eden, John Steinbeck talks about this in east of Eden. Great book. And then, of course, Cain, instead of trying to learn from Abel what he did right, or trying to correct his own ways so as to bring a better sacrifice, decides he's gonna kill Abel because he's jealous of him and angry that his sacrifice was accepted.

[A]

And he's a farmer.

[B]

Well, that too. But It's. But if he's a farmer and his sacrifice is not accepted, then presumably it doesn't kill him.

[A]

Wait, does the shepherd kill the farmer or did the farmer kill the shepherd? So what was Cain? This is so important and I'm too.

[B]

Stoned to remember which Cain is agriculture and Abel is animal Hunchman.

[A]

Right.

[B]

So they.

[A]

It's the triumph of the new thing.

[B]

I'll get fact checked if that's not true, but I think it's right.

[A]

But this new farming.

[B]

But the basic idea which I think is still relevant today beyond the debate between agriculture and animal husbandry, is the basic idea that if you are successful in society it must be because you've exploited somebody. And if you're a failure in society, it must be because you were exploited. And that is the ugliest thing that I think is happening.

[A]

Boy, is that relevant today.

[B]

Yes, that's. That, that's the thing.

[A]

That's, that's the whole fallacy of the anti Israel coalition of useful idiots is that, you know, I mean, that was what you were writing me about what I did a couple of weeks ago, trying to explain to the kids through the chapel roan thing that, you know, they're not colonizers because they were there originally. I mean, this is indisputable, you know, so much of the buzzword information, I would hesitate to even call it information. And it's just buzzwords from TikTok, from social justice warriors who want to somehow have their version of decolonization and getting rid of apartheid. I mean, those were things that other generations did get rid of. And you know, colonization, it's kind of gone.

[B]

But it's not just that. The reason they're angry at Israel is what you said, which is that because Israel is successful, that is why everyone keeps wondering what is the, and you mention it, this sort of queers for Palestine stuff, which is chickens for kfc, right? Like what is that? And the answer is people who believe that they have been marginalized by society and therefore society has to pay the price for that. And so what you get is a bunch of really spoiled rich Western kids who believe that they are somehow victims of the society around them because they have not made success of themselves or wish not to. And so they are in alliance with people who also have actually run an entire area of the world not only into the ground, but into the worst situation in modern history. And it must be that none of those people made bad decisions. It must be that they were victimized, that society victimized them. And so Tear down the system, eat the rich, destroy private property, wreck any developing country that actually wishes to develop. That's the part that's dangerous. And I don't think that has to be a right left divide. Because I think that frankly, if you're on the left, you should, if you're a liberal. I always make the distinction left and liberal, because I don't think it's quite the same thing. But if you're a liberal, you should believe that human beings have the capacity for success. If you make good decisions, then you benefit from those good decisions. And maybe we have disagreements over redistributive mechanisms, which is why you can have a normal conversation. But if you believe that every evidence of success, group or individual, is actual evidence of exploitation by that group, that's how you end up with anti Semitic conspiracy theories. And by the way, also anti Asian conspiracy theories. It's how you end up with like, don't let the Asian kids into Harvard because they're too successful.

[A]

And you know, for the folks who are listening to this and say, oh, you know, you're always picking on the fringe. That's not the fringe. I mean, I wouldn't say it's the majority of the left, but it's the places that have been ideologically captured. It's the New York Times, it's Harvard, it's the aclu, and that is where left leaning thought comes through. So these kind of ideas, which I agree with you, are crazy. And this is again what I mean by aggressively anti common sense. It's really uncommonsensical. And they're aggressive about it, almost like, like you have to like it. You have to like penises in the women's shelters. It's not just that.

[B]

Well, but you do, because I think that the threat level perception is actually correct from their perspective because their entire definition of what you are is what you feel on the inside. And so if there's any imposition on what I feel, even if it's at war with objective reality. So if I'm a failure, and I don't feel like I'm a failure because I've made bad decisions, it's because society was mean to me. If I say to you, well, maybe the reason you're failing is because you made a bunch of dumb decisions, then I've actually threatened your identity. I'm a threat to you at that point, and that's a danger. So I do have to agree with them because otherwise I'm basically saying it's your own fault. And that's something People can't abide. People cannot abide the idea that failure is their own fault. And guess what? In a mostly free society, in a mostly free country, that's the most prosperous place in human history. A lot of failure, not all failure. An enormous amount of failure is luck. An enormous amount of failure is bad health. But an enormous amount of failure is, in fact, people making bad decisions. That gets back to my boring life again. Like, it's like, make better decisions. Like, and if you make all the right decisions and then you fail, then maybe you can blame external factors.

[A]

This sounds to me what you probably tell your kids 100% is what I tell my kids. Like, this is your big theme with your team?

[B]

This is my theme. This is my theme. By the way, this is also the theme of every successful company.

[A]

And how are the kids taking to this theme?

[B]

They like it because it turns out, you know, kids actually, like you mentioned before, that they're actually bad people. Kids, they like duty and responsibility, and they're like, no. Kids actually like those things. If you do not provide structure for kids, it is the worst mistake you can make.

[A]

Discipline is love. It's not on the surface, it's below the surface, but it translates to love. It really does.

[B]

Especially. It's the hardest thing for a parent.

[A]

Because kids know disciplining.

[B]

Your kids have pain in the ass.

[A]

Kids know on a certain level when they're being an asshole. And so when the parent, like, straightens them out, they're like, okay, it may not be conscious, but the unconscious matters too. And it gets in there. And, you know, I think the root of all the problems from the left stem from bad parenting and just giving up on the idea that you do. Kids are kids, you know, they don't deserve to be treated like just shorter adults who have just as valid a thought. They're idiots.

[B]

Yes. They're like dogs.

[A]

They don't know anything. They're stupid. I mean, even when I was 20, you said 20. I mean, oh, my God, I've said this many times on this show. Like, would it be great physically to be 20 again? But I wouldn't trade it. And I'm almost 70 for 70. If I had to go back with that brain. Because when I think about what that brain was doing and getting me to do, it's so painful.

[B]

It's true for everybody. I mean, I was writing syndicated column when I was 17, which means that all the dumb stuff or most of the dumb stuff I ever wrote was between the ages of like 17 and 24. Right? Because you get older, you get better at this stuff, and you think better thoughts.

[A]

Nobody should ever be held accountable for almost anything they did in that age, unless it's murder or something.

[B]

I mean, I agree, which is why, you know, when people have asked me before, who are the kids in school who bullied me? I'm like, I would never name them. They were like, 16. Why would I name them? That's ridiculous. They're different people now.

[A]

They dug up something I think Bernie Sanders wrote, like, when he was 19, he tried his hand. It was some kind of semi pornographic.

[B]

Story that's mostly just funny.

[A]

What.

[B]

What he wrote.

[A]

You remember it? You remember the story?

[B]

Yeah, yeah. It was like a weird. It was a weird semi pornographic piece with a rape fantasy in it or something.

[A]

So you didn't make any hay out of it.

[B]

I mean, I laughed at it because.

[A]

It was funny, but on your show.

[B]

No, not really.

[A]

Because that's what I hate about today's fucking media is that so little of it really stands the test of not bad faith, bad faith being. We know better, but we know the audience doesn't know better, so we can put this over on them. And so much of it is just some sort of cultivating these stories, and they are rampant of somebody on the left, and it's a big country, there's gonna be a lot of people who do goofy things and then make it, you know, like, making it all about that. I feel like that's what Tucker Carlson does, ignoring the bigger story. And I feel like you less than me.

[B]

I try not to, and I won't say I'm immune to it, but. No, no, I think we call it nut picking. Right. Like, find a nut picking.

[A]

Nut picking.

[B]

Right.

[A]

Perfect. I mean, yes.

[B]

Right? Like, it's very easy to try and mistake an anecdote for a trend.

[A]

You know what I said in my writer's meeting today? They were starting in on Arnold Palmer's cock.

[B]

Who gives a shit?

[A]

And I said, guys, this is Trump derangement syndrome. I said, yes. Is it gonna be in the monologue? Yes, of course. I'm a comedian, and this is ridiculous. And he's a preposterous figure and he shouldn't be president, but, like, you're actually agitated about it. And I watched the video of it, and the people, the people who get him and the people who hate him, they're just in different universes. I feel like I'm a person who hates him, but I also get him because I saw the video and the people behind him are laughing as A comedian. I see something working on a comedic level. And he's a guy who says, I'm not really a politician. And he sure is an interesting one who's gonna be part comedian and part this.

[B]

He's half stand up for sure.

[A]

He's half stand up when it bleeds over into the enemies of the people. And Hitler, you know, again, we don't have to go back there. I think you're wrong and you're gonna be proved wrong that you whistled past that graveyard. But the part about Arnold Palmer's cock, if you're agitated about that on the left, you're just looking to be agitated. He's been doing this for a long time, and it has nothing to do with anything that's going to affect your life. How big Arnold Palmer's cock is. First of all, of all, the things that I never in the world thought I'd be talking about.

[B]

Many English sentences have been constructed in the Trump era that never would have been thought. It is an amazing thing.

[A]

And, you know, if Kamala Harris said it, the race would be over tomorrow. That's what's so unfair about this. But, you know, it's an unfair sport. But what I want to know is, okay, he said the other guys after the golf matches in the shower thought it was unbelievable. Golfers shower together.

[B]

Yeah, I didn't know that either, actually. That was a new one to me. That was a new one. You know, I'll tell you this. This whole race, everybody's getting very despondent about this race on both sides. And the one thing that I'll say, and I said this earlier to some actually relatively famous world figures, is when Biden was still in the race before they threw him off the back of the train because he's dead. But before that, it was after the debate, and all my Democrat friends were despondent and upset. Well, then what's he doing?

[A]

I'm gonna defend Joe Biden. He's not dead.

[B]

You're right. He's a better candidate than Kamala Harris. But what's amazing. So it was right after the debate, and everybody was despondent on one side and ecstatic on the other side. And I said, listen, here's the good news about America. I was talking to a foreign leader at the time. And let me tell you something about America. America. Here's how much ass we kick, okay? Here's how great this country is. This country is so powerful and so awesome that we can run two 80 year olds against each other. Whichever one golfs better will make president. We'll have Hulk Hogan introduce that guy at the RNC. He'll babble for 93 minutes and you'll fucking love it. Cuz this is America.

[A]

I love America.

[B]

America's great.

[A]

America's fucking great. I was in this and. And my friends know how I feel about America. I'm not a rah rah idiot about it. I understand its flaws. But I also am someone who's read the New York Times every day since I was like 14 years old, including the part about the rest of the world. So I have it in perspective, which is what the kids today lack completely. They don't know. They think they live in the worst time ever, in the worst country ever. So they know. I feel like this. I was at the dinner the other night and I don't know, I don't know what somebody said. Maybe it was the waiter. How's everything? And we're looking. We're at this beautiful restaurant in la, all the beautiful people. And I said, terrible. That's how things are. It's America. It's terrible. There's no food, there's no meat left. We're all dying. Because some of this is what Trump says, but also some of this is what the TikTok people say. Roth. The women are ugly, everyone's miserable. Look at this restaurant. Racism is everywhere. There was a black couple having a wonderful time. I can't take it. America's just a shithole. It's a flaming pile of dog poop. And it's just hysterical on both sides. I mean, Trump gets away with characterizing America as ridiculously worse than it is. You know that. So let's not even have the argument. But also, the other side, the kids, they really think America. I mean, I've seen tons of tiktoks. I've shown some of them in editorials where, like, anywhere else.

[B]

Yeah, exactly. No, that's right, that's right.

[A]

I mean, and that's the same people who's like, Hamas is coming. Woo.

[B]

Right, Exactly.

[A]

Hey, the Houthis, they're cool.

[B]

What I've said before to people is like, you know, you think everything is so terrible now. If you had a time machine and you went back like 100 years, the first thing that you'd notice when you got out of the time machine was how everything smelled. It would smell like. It would smell awful.

[A]

I think I saw that on your show. People don't. People didn't shower 100 years ago.

[B]

They didn't have indoor plumbing in most places. And by the way, A shower was.

[A]

Not like, as we see a shower.

[B]

Yeah. A couple hundred years ago. Definitely was not. And it was like some dude with a bucket pouring it into a canteen or whatever it was with holes in. And they.

[A]

I mean, that's. If you had a bucket guy.

[B]

Yeah, exactly. And. But the thing is that I've said on the show I had a bucket intern. The thing that I've said on the show is we have a time machine. It's called an airplane.

[A]

Right.

[B]

And it goes all over to different times. You can go to places in the world and they are living a living standard that is 15, 20.

[A]

Right.

[B]

You can go there right now and you can visit and you can see if that time is better than the time that you live in.

[A]

I remember I taught school, believe it or not, in Geneva, Switzerland, in the summer of 1978. It was right after I graduated from Cornell and my girlfriend Mike finally got a college girlfriend, and she was a linguistics genius, and her summer job was teaching at College de Le Mans, which was in Geneva.

[B]

An Ingmar Bergman film here.

[A]

Yeah, kind of. Not really. Oh, I wish. But so I followed her there, and she got me a job when we were in love, right after college ended. So I spent the summer in Geneva. Fucking hated it. But that's me. Partly my fault. But it was a very rich school in Geneva where kids from all over the world. There were kids from Japan and Italy, but a lot of them at the time were either from Iran or Saudi Arabia. And the kids from Iran, this is 1978. And by the way, the revolution happened while I think the session was the summer session. So I remember them all running to the phones because I think Ayatollah Khamenei, I forget what he did, but he was on the march. But the Iranian kids really were, like, at that point in the 1950s, you know, leather jackets and kind of.

[B]

But.

[A]

But not unsophisticated. The Saudi kids. Yeah, it was like a different time. I mean, it was.

[B]

And by the way, countries can go backwards because those Iranian kids from the 1950s, now the Iranian kids live in the 1750s because of what the ayatollahs have done to the country.

[A]

Not the people.

[B]

Not the people.

[A]

Not the people.

[B]

No, no. I don't mean that the people want to live there. The people of Iran, by the way, can. They're great. The government sucks. The government's awful.

[A]

We're both big supporters of Israel. We made differ on the Iranian nuclear deal thing. And let's not get into it, because it's just so wonky. And we're here having a good time. We're smoking a joint, so we don't have to get into that. But my reason for always thinking it was a pretty good idea to try to open up Iran is because as opposed to a lot of these places like North Korea, which you could never open, they're gone. They're like a child that was abused and kept in a cellar. That's not Iran. They have a very sophisticated populace, at least in the capital. I feel like that makes a difference. The Iranian people could be. It could be a European country.

[B]

So I agree with you. I think that the distinction on the Iranian nuclear deal is a pragmatic one. Meaning do you think that's more likely to empower the people to then change the regime, or do you think it's significantly less likely by re enshrining the power of the regime by funding them, giving them billions of dollars they can use for funding terrorism around the region and all the rest. But I think that the goal is the same, which is the Iranian people should be able to live in a semblance of freedom that they actually used to have before the Ayatollahs took over in the first place. And the proof's in the pudding. The Iranian government has been spreading terror all over the region and killing thousands of people, tens of thousands of people, because you have to include the Palestinians among that, since none of this would have happened if the Iranians weren't sponsoring it.

[A]

Aside from that, and among the things that people probably hate, again, the Jews for being good at is being badass. I mean, Munich. Munich.

[B]

That beeper operation. The beeper operation.

[A]

I was going to say, like. And then Munich type stuff, like on a scale, like, okay, first we take you out with the beepers. You know, I mean, in the last couple of years, they rolled up first Soleimani and the Gaza dude went to Sinwar.

[B]

They killed Nia, they killed Nasrallah.

[A]

Right, Nasrallah.

[B]

I mean, like, no, the beeper thing. The beeper thing is the greatest thing. I love the beeper thing. I love it. It's like, so my. We have Jewish Halloween is Purim. So my family this year is going as Avi's Beeper Emporium Explosive Sales. Like, that's the. All my kids, you don't care. Like, that's it.

[A]

I mean, I'm sorry.

[B]

Most targeted anti terror operation in literally human history.

[A]

I'm sorry young men anywhere have to have their nuts blown off. But, you know, we have to be realistic about the larger Parameters here. What does a nation do when it is being attacked? You know, I keep saying this is all very simple. Stop attacking Israel. Stop attacking Israel. And then we won't be having these fights about when should we have a ceasefire, which is always the day after Israel attacks.

[B]

Right? That's right.

[A]

There's never a better time for a ceasefire in an Israeli war than the day after.

[B]

Listen, props to the IDF for this time saying, you know what? No, we're not stopping until Hamas is extirpated, until people can go back to the north, until the Iranian threat is done with. Listen, my family was there. We were there October 6th. We left October 6th. My in laws were staying with us. They stayed into October 7th. Yeah, exactly.

[A]

And super Jews get the super Jews out.

[B]

And I mean, I think one of the things that people also don't understand about, you know, the involved Jewish community is that it's very small. So, like, I know multiple hostage families. I know families of people who have been killed in on October 7th. Families of people of IDF soldiers. IDF soldiers who are currently serving. Like, I know tons of those people. And the amount of care that Israel is taking by going house to house and street to street in the Gaza Strip to avoid civilian casualties, only to be told they're committing a genocide is just. It is sickening.

[A]

It's always been that. It's always been that. Played by completely different rules. Who was it who said Israel's the only country in the world that is supposed to act like Christians? Brilliant. But I did read, I mean, the New York Times, which is astounding to me because it's a traditionally Jewish owned newspaper that's very, very pro Palestinian.

[B]

They've been wildly anti Israel my entire life.

[A]

Your entire life?

[B]

My entire life. My entire life, truly. Oh, this is like the LA Times too. These are publications that a lot of pro Israel people started. I remember unsubscribing from the 90s.

[A]

They printed an article which you could tell on the front page they thought was like a big scandal that said Israelis are using captured Hamas fighters basically to go into an area first and possibly get blown up by their. What do you call it?

[B]

Compatriot? IEDs.

[A]

IEDs. Well, that's war. I would do the same thing if I was in war. Why should I get blown up if, you know, maybe as they're approaching it and they planted it, they'll say, you might say something. You know what, guys, you're right. There is a bomb planted in this. And I mean, it's just amazing. Like, once war Starts, it's kind of all bets are off. I know we have the Geneva Convention, and that's kind of a crazy concept in itself. It's worthy.

[B]

The Geneva convention was also designed specifically to keep people from meshing with civilian populations. The protocols of the Geneva convention apply to people in uniform. If you're out of uniform, the Geneva conventions don't apply the same way to you because it's an attempt to force people not to merge with civilian populations so as to protect the civilian population. This is like one of the purposes of the Geneva Convention in the first place, which is why if you turn a civilian site into a military site, it now becomes a military site. So if you take a UNRWA school and you put rockets in it, it's no longer a school. It is now a military site.

[A]

I mean, for most of history, wars have just de rigueur involved the civilian population. I mean, Sherman burned Atlanta and Julius Caesar, they made no distinction. The one exceptional time is sort of like Revolutionary war times, when armies, especially in Europe, marched in red uniforms, like in a line they didn't even attempt to run or h. That era of fighting when it was very gentlemanly, you know what I'm talking?

[B]

Yeah. Of course, during the medieval period, you'd have a king with some of his lords, and they would go out and they'd fight like the other king and his lords, and it would be on a field somewhere because it was very difficult to actually have mass population integration. That really begins to change around the turn of the Napoleonic era. The French revolutionary era actually is the time we have this big merger happen.

[A]

But in medieval times, they totally involved the pop. The civilian population. That's who were the fighters were. But they would burn villages and stuff.

[B]

They'd go out of the rails.

[A]

I was saying there was this brief period where people turned into gentlemen, and they were like, war is a gentlemanly operation, and we will march. I mean, to march like in these lines in red uniforms is so counterintuitive to survival, is it not? And the guy would get shot next to you, and you would just keep going.

[B]

Like to be fair to the military strategists at the time, the reason that they were walking in straight lines is because the accuracy of the rifles they were using, because they were using musket balls, is very, very bad. So if you line everybody up in a straight line, then the basic idea is you've created a massive field of fire. Whereas if you don't line them up in a straight line, it's very difficult to snipe.

[A]

No matter how bad the guns were, you don't think it would be probably better for your own survival to, like, crawl or scatter, not be all, like, lined up together, hide behind trees?

[B]

Maybe just in the name of military history, to be fair to the British Empire, they did kick the shit out of Everybody for about 200 years using these sorts of tactics, and then the tactics change. But the integration of the civilian population, the general point you're making, which is that war is brutal and it is hell, and it has never not been brutal and never not been hell. And it turns out the way you stop war is by winning it. It's only in the last half century that the west has decided that the way you stop war is by jabbering about it. That's not the way you actually stop war. I mean, there's a great book called the Causes of War by Jeffrey Blaine where he actually analyzes every war between 1700 and 1980. And what he finds is peace is an outgrowth of one side giving up. It turns out that peace is an outgrowth of one side kicking the shit out of the other side so hard that they decide not to do war anymore. And so, you know, everybody in the west for a century has been trying to figure out, what was it about the Versailles Treaty, Was it too onerous? Was it not onerous enough? And the answer. And the answer that Jeffrey Blaine gives, he says, well, you know what I noticed Germany was still standing after World War I, and then they weren't after World War II. After World War II, Germany gets completely divvied up. They could get demilitarized. They get owned by the Americans and by the Russians. They split the entire country. And guess what? Ain't no more wars from Germany. Because it turns out that when you kick the shit out of somebody really, really, really hard, they don't want to do war anymore. And so every time you have these sort of premature, what if we did a ceasefire? What if we just, like, what if we just calm down? War is a process of exhausting one side or the other. And if people remain unexhausted five minutes from now, they're back at it, as it turns out. And so it turns out the best thing the west can do is fight if they're hit. Anybody in the West? The United States, anybody? Fight a brutal, vicious war in as short a fashion as possible, trying to preserve as many civilian lives as you can and win. And then you get peace. And if you don't win, you don't get peace.

[A]

Yeah, that's true. It's the way of the world. But I will contest you on this one thing. You said the British kicked ass for a couple of hundred years using those tactics. Well, you know whose ass they didn't kick? Mr. George Washington.

[B]

That's true.

[A]

Comrade Murica. Comrade. And you know that Washington only fought nine battles and only won three. Did you know that?

[B]

I did know that, actually. Because, I mean, again, I don't wish to be like the British apologist here. There's a case we made, the British kind of gave up. And the British basically said, this is not worth the cost.

[A]

Well, because they tried every which way to defeat us. First they came down from Canada, then they went in the middle states. That's like Delaware and all those battles. And then they went through the South. They tried every which way, and then they lost. Now, of course, it also pinned hinged rather on the fact that we got the French fleet, which was on vacay, because they were. I think they were just in Haiti or something. They were probably doing something heinous and colonizing. I'm sure they were. Because all people were bad back then, including people of color in other parts of the world. All humans are the same, basically. To not think that is actually what is racist. Okay, but they were doing something horrible, I'm sure, in our hemisphere. But like, then they had like, it was like, you know, a timeshare. They had an opening and they were somehow. And we texted them and said, could. Would you bottle up the British with your fleet? As long as they're not working. I mean, we'll make it worth your while.

[B]

And listen, the other point you can make is that the Brits in the Revolutionary War are basically fighting other Brits, meaning that the Americans were a British offshoot. I mean, they were. Everybody's grandfather had been from Britain. So, you know, it was British people kind of fighting other British people.

[A]

What's amazing that probably maybe people don't realize is that 10 years before we declared independence, nobody was thinking about it in America. They were proudly British colonists 100%. But 1765, you get the Stamp Act. And that's the beginning of, oh, taxation without representation. And we're paying for. Because Britain was fighting a war with the French overseas. Other than that which became. Which was the French and Indian war here in America. But it was a global war and it cost a lot of money. And they were asking us to chip in. And this is what is the breaking point for a lot of people. People like money.

[B]

It's true. And people also The Brits recognized that because the population of the United States was growing so fast and the United States territory was, was so vast and, and lucrative that eventually, if they allowed proper representation in Parliament, eventually America would run. Britain. That was, that was one of their major concerns is that in Parliament, as the population of the United States grew, that Britain would, eventually it would. It would be a reverse colony of America as opposed to the other way around. And America was like, well, yeah, I mean, that's true. So what's the problem? And so you see, obviously, decolonization from Britain among former British citizens in Australia, you see it in the United States, you see it in Canada, you see in a wide variety of places around the globe. But, yeah, I mean, listen, the British Empire was the greatest empire of its day for two centuries through freedom of the seas. Now we're the greatest empire of our day through freedom of the seas. And this is one of the quarrels I have with some of my compatriots on the right who are more isolationist about foreign policy, and that is if all people everywhere are kind of the same. As you mentioned, it turns out that if we just abandon the world scene, then somebody else going to fill it.

[A]

And we're not really an empire. We had an empire. We had the Philippines and we had lots of places. We have a few. If we're an empire, we're a pretty lame one.

[B]

No. Well, we're an empire only in the sense that we are the ones who are guaranteeing the security of our allies. Allies. Like in the end, we are. And that doesn't mean that we have to own our allies.

[A]

Right.

[B]

They're not colonies.

[A]

It's a very loose empire.

[B]

Yeah, I mean, it's. But, but the historian Neil Ferguson, right.

[A]

We'Re not lording it over Belgium, but we would come to the. I mean, they're in NATO.

[B]

So everybody sort of understands that in the end, for example, all the shipping lanes are reliant on the power of the US Navy. That's just the reality of the world. And you know what? All right, I mean, that's the burden of greatness. And America, it's funny to think of it this way. America was an empire domestically on the continent. And we start off on one end of this giant continent, we take over the entire continent. That is a process of building an empire. So whether you call us an empire or whether you don't, bottom line is world security, economic freedom, all over the world that relies on us. Ain't nobody else filling that gap.

[A]

Somebody sent me this video I thought it was very moving of some veteran and you could tell it was heartfelt and true. And he's talking about, you fought in the Iraq war. And he said, you know, there's one night where I broke into this family's home, which is something he did a lot over there. And the guy reached for a gun, so I shot him. And then I thought, well, why did I shoot him? Because he reached for a gun. But if he was coming into my bedroom, what would I do? I'd reach for a gun. He said, what if I met this guy at a cafe somewhere and he was funny and we had coffee and maybe he wasn't, but I just did this because a politician told me to do it. I mean, that's true. And it's also true that sometimes politicians have to do. Now, not the Iraq War, I don't agree with that thing. But they just have to do things that. Yeah, there's going to be horrible things that make no sense within the macro.

[B]

I mean, the truth about even the Iraq War is that the only one who ever told the truth about the Iraq war was the much maligned John McCain who said, if you want to win the Iraq war, you're going to have to put boots on the ground there for 100 years. People read that as he wants to do that. That's it. That's how trade offs work.

[A]

So true.

[B]

That's how trade offs work. Or Afghanistan.

[A]

You know, you don't change a culture that much. I mean, you can. Ataturk did it in Turkey, but he killed a lot of people. I mean, he made mandatory laws, cut off your beard, which I'm sure didn't go well in a lot of barbershops. You know, it just wasn't. But I guess, you know, and if you didn't, we'd execute you. Yeah, you can change, but no one wants to do it that way. Otherwise you do need 100 years.

[B]

I mean, the truth is that again, because people don't know their history, they assume that, for example, after the Korean War, South Korea immediately became a beacon of democracy. And that's not true. It was a dictatorship for several decades after the Korean War. Yes, Taiwan only started having good elections in the last couple of decades. It takes a very long time for institutions to actually take root in these places. And that's why this sort of quickie foreign policy where it's like, okay, well, we'll get in there and then we'll just fix it. Or alternatively, we'll never get involved anywhere and then the world will Be a beautiful place. None of that is. None of that is real.

[A]

Now, if there's one thing I feel like the left lacks that makes them look bad. When I'm talking about the far left, when they comment on foreign policy, I'm talking about hippies and so forth, is they don't factor in this one little thing, which is that there are bad people in the world. It just seems like everything bad that America does in their mind is just sort of self generated, just for shits and giggles.

[B]

And it's totally right.

[A]

We have done bad things. I mean, the CIA has engineered coups in places and I'm sure it wasn't cool in a lot of ways, but what was the least bad?

[B]

This is the thing. There's never an amazing option in foreign policy. It's not like here's an incredible option.

[A]

Never.

[B]

It's so good. And it's like, here are a couple shitty options now pick one. Right, Right. And that is the nature of decision making. And you're exactly right that when people sort of suggest that this sort of hippy, dippy nonsense where the only people with agency on planet Earth are Americans. Right? This shit pisses me off. It really does. There was a comedian on SNL who did this the other day, he was coming back at the whole like, why are there no gays in Gaza? Thing, and he said, well, if you stop bombing them, there will be gays in Gaza. And the answer is no, actually, there will not.

[A]

He didn't.

[B]

He did.

[A]

Really? Yes. Oh my God.

[B]

It's just. It was an awful. It's like, it's. It's so idiotic because it turns out that people all over the world have belief systems and ideologies and ideas that are different than yours. And it turns out that they may have a value system that is completely different from yours. Now, all human beings have very similar biology.

[A]

It's.

[B]

But their cultures are not even remotely the same.

[A]

It's so narcissistic in its way. Like really, we're the progenitor of everything. Everything happens because what we do. You know. Get over yourself. I mean. Yes. Is colonization part of country's history. That still matters in their life today? Of course. You know, it's just like your past is the past that influences and makes you the person you are now. But it doesn't have to be determined forever.

[B]

Exactly. At a certain point, this is the case that I make all the time and people get upset. I'll be like, okay, well, the choice. Forget history for a second. The choice in front of you. You can make a good one or you can make a bad one. Which one do you want to make? And people get angry because what they actually want to do is avoid making the choice. And so they prefer talking about the history. So you get this on everything from crime policy to the Middle east, where the question I always ask about Israel and the Palestinians is, okay, so one of those states is a flourishing democracy with a flourishing economy, where Arabs and Jews live in freedom. And one of these places is a terrible place to live, where if you're a Jew and you drive in there by accident, they kill you. So which one of them has a quote, which one is the world better for existing? Which one is the world better? And that's a question nobody ever answers. Instead, they just start talking about the Balfour Declaration and various fights between the Peel Commission and the Peel.

[A]

Well, to be fair, as I always try to be, Arabs don't live in complete freedom. They have way more rights than if they're Israeli citizens. They have full rights. But certainly some of the people in the west bank and so forth who work in Israel and have to go through the checks.

[B]

Well, yeah, they live under the Palestinian Authority. Sure, right.

[A]

I mean, but.

[B]

And I'm talking about Israeli Arabs. I'm talking about Israeli Arabs. I'm not talking about the Palestinian Authority, which was delegated authority under the Oslo Accords. Right. Where you have giant. I mean, you've seen them. I'm sure they have the giant red signs outside of Palestinian Authority governed areas. They'll say in English, Arabic and Hebrew, if you are not a citizen of Palestinian Authority, if you drive in this area, we cannot guarantee your safety. And you'll be.

[A]

So when you were there, you go. Just because you want to take your kids and have them see it.

[B]

Yeah, I mean, for real, we go for religious holidays.

[A]

So you go.

[B]

My wife has family. Yeah, we go a lot.

[A]

And you fly to Tel Aviv.

[B]

Yeah, yeah.

[A]

I mean, I made the movie Religious. We spent a week there. It was one of the greatest weeks of my life. I didn't love every minute, but I'm a bad traveler. We've established that. But, I mean, Tel Aviv is New York.

[B]

Yes.

[A]

I'm the Mediterranean. I mean, and this is, you know, one of the arguments I always make with the, you know, Hamas is coming people. It's like, you're such hypocrites because you wouldn't last a day. You would go running and screaming to live in Tel Aviv, which is a lifestyle you are familiar with that you just take for granted. And it didn't just happen. That kind of lifestyle where you have freedom and prosperity and go where you want and do what you want and dress what you want, it just doesn't happen.

[B]

I think everybody in society now wants to skim the cream off the top of history without recognizing that history is a dirty, messy place with a lot of decisions that have to get made between various bad options. And this is the same thing that drives me up a wall. I was doing an event recently where I had to debate. It's some Internet thing where I'm debating a bunch of people who are voting for Kamala or whatever, and somebody comes up and the first thing they say is, before we start, I want to do a land acknowledgement and do a land acknowledgement. And I said, we are sitting on Native American tribal land. And I said, so give it back. Back. So give it back like new. Who's stopping you? Give it back.

[A]

I know I get to it, my friend. Either give it back or shut the fuck up. And it's always like, we're opening this strip mall. It's like, but you're going to. It's so performative.

[B]

Guess what? I'm fucking ecstatic that America exists. And you know what? A lot of bad shit had to happen in order to make that happen.

[A]

As if all the people.

[B]

That doesn't mean the bad shit was bad.

[A]

Yes, the proud Chumash people. This really is theirs. If you'd really rather have a teepee there than your Starbucks. I mean, just don't be stupid. Like, people ask me all the time when come on the show, like they're nervous, like, what? Oh, what should I do? How could. Just don't lie to him. Just don't lie to him and he'll love you. It's fine. Just don't lie. Whatever you believe. But once you start with the proud Jamash, people like you say you didn't give it back. Well, look, I know you turn into a vampire at 5:30.

[B]

That's right.

[A]

I could go on.

[B]

I've got my protocols of the elders meeting, man.

[A]

But what would happen if you were out there when darkness fell? Would it?

[B]

I mean, I melt. I mean, nothing happens. I do a bad Jewish thing. That's what happened.

[A]

The cognitive dissonance of talking to someone as brilliant as you and then having to let you go because it's getting dark, but I love it.