Club Shay Shay "BEST OF NFL Week 11 Part 1: Shedeur Named QB1, A.J. Brown DRAMA, & Fields BENCHED!"

Host: Shannon Sharpe (with guest "Ocho")
Date: November 19, 2025

Episode Overview

In this episode, Shannon Sharpe and his co-host ("Ocho") break down the hottest storylines from NFL Week 11, including Shedeur Sanders’ first NFL action, the ongoing A.J. Brown situation in Philadelphia, and debates surrounding quarterback preparation and team dynamics. The hosts deliver candid, insider perspectives on coaching decisions, player development, and the reality of NFL locker rooms, with signature humor and depth.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Shedeur Sanders’ NFL Debut: QB Preparation Controversy

[03:01 - 11:24, 24:59 - 35:20]

• Debut Details: Shedeur entered the game after Dylan Gabriel's concussion, posting a rough stat line (4 of 16, 47 yards, 0 TD, 1 INT). The panel scrutinizes the coaching staff and Browns’ lack of QB2 preparation.

  • Shannon Sharpe: “For Kevin Stefanski to say the first time that Shedeur Sanders had taken a snap with the starters…was in this game is malpractice.” [03:30]
  • Both hosts question why Shedeur was thrown in without practice reps with the starting offense, calling it fundamentally unfair and setting him up for failure.

• Importance of 1st-Team Reps:

  • Ocho: “This ain’t Madden…you don't just take out one quarterback and put another in and expect success, especially when you haven’t had any reps with the ones…” [04:54]
  • They discuss how established QBs (Brady, Peyton, Brees) always consult with offensive staff to build gameplans around their strengths—a luxury Shedeur did not have.

• Chemistry and Cadence:

  • The analysts stress the necessity of QB-receiver chemistry and even offensive line familiarity with cadence, noting Wyatt Teller’s comments about Shedeur’s cadence post-game [24:59].
  • Sharpe: “For a quarterback, Ocho, not to get no reps. I’m talking about none… that makes no sense.” [09:53]

• Unfair Assessment:

  • Sharpe: “To ask Shedeur to get in a game in which he has not taken any snap from the center… and expect him to work a miracle… if I were to give him a grade, I would say incomplete.” [32:00]

• Takeaways: Both hosts agree fans should temper criticism and expect improvement next start if Shedeur gets practice time with the first team.

2. Miles Garrett: Defensive Dominance & Team Frustration

[16:53 - 24:38]

• Miles Garrett’s performance and Defensive Player of the Year candidacy are highlighted, but with concern for his talents being "wasted" on a non-contender.

  • Sharpe: “For a man his size to move like he does…he has no weakness because he can turn power to speed, speed to power…” [20:19]
  • Debate ensues over whether defensively dominant players deserve more recognition even if their team isn’t winning.

• Sharpe: “At what point in time does Miles Garrett say, man... I ain't even sniffing the playoffs. My season is already over.” [22:57]

3. Deep Dive: Quarterback-Receiver Relationships

[27:34 - 33:46]

• Audio from Shedeur Sanders and Miles Garrett gives an inside look at the mental and emotional challenges of sudden responsibility and team expectations.

  • Shedeur Sanders (clip): “I like knowing every detail about my receivers…I know, you know, we at the bottom right now, this performance, everything, it’ll never be like this, but…I’m dedicated to being able to get those opportunities with those guys…” [27:34]
  • Miles Garrett (clip): “Don’t be discouraged from no one drive or two drives. It’s a team game, so we’re all in this together.” [28:58]

• Both hosts emphasize trust and timing between QBs and receivers, and how elite QBs won’t play with unproven receivers in crucial moments.

• Sharpe: “Do you think Tom Brady would allow some receiver that he didn’t throw to during the course of the week to be out there on Sunday?...Because he wouldn’t trust you.” [30:48]

4. Eagles vs. Lions, AJ Brown Drama, and Play Calling Issues

[39:59 - 63:27]

• Quick game summary: Eagles win 16-9 in tough weather; defense shines, offense struggles, A.J. Brown limited despite 11 targets.

• Examination of the reported closed-door meeting between A.J. Brown and Eagles owner Jeffrey Lurie over Brown’s frustrations about his role:

  • Sharpe: “How many times have you ever heard of Jeffrey Lurie…meet with a player about something he was posting on social media…?” [56:44]
  • The hosts agree Brown’s social media frustrations have been simmering since last season and note this offense isn’t designed for monster receiving stats.

• Play Calling Predictability:

  • Ocho: “If I can tell you based on A.J. Brown’s alignment exactly what route he’s running…what do you think those…playing across from him are doing?” [62:16]
  • He and Sharpe both identify lack of offensive creativity and predict offense will need to evolve when the defense isn’t bailing them out.

• Dome (indoor) teams vs. weather:

  • Sharpe discusses the challenge for dome teams like the Lions playing on the road in bad weather come playoff time.

• Outlook: The Eagles win ugly, but are getting vital experience and may evolve at the right time. Lions’ dependency on conditions highlighted.

Notable Quotes

• On Shedeur’s Preparation

  • “You don’t just take out one quarterback and put another quarterback in and expect success…especially when you haven’t had any reps with the ones.” – Ocho [04:54]
  • “If I were to give him a grade, I would say incomplete. Incomplete.” – Sharpe [32:00]

• On NFL Backup QBs:

  • “Imagine showing up your first day of class and the teacher gave you a test, and you don't know what the hell is on.” – Sharpe [33:19]

• On Miles Garrett:

  • “He is so…for a man his size to move like he does…when it comes to rushing, he has no weakness.” – Sharpe [20:19]
  • “I want to see him on the all-time stage. I want to see him in an AFC or NFC championship game. I want to see him in the Super Bowl.” – Sharpe [24:17]

• On Jalen Hurts/Eagles Offense:

  • “He's not going to go out there and throw for no 400, 500 yards. That’s not the offense…But when times come and you put him in situations where he has to beat you with his arm, we’ve seen him do it.” – Ocho [58:55]

Timestamps for Important Segments

• Shedeur & Browns QB controversy: [03:01 - 11:24], [24:59 - 35:20]
• Miles Garrett DPOY Talk: [16:53 - 24:38]
• First-hand from Shedeur & Garrett (audio): [27:34 - 29:27]
• QB-Receiver Chemistry, Practice Realities: [29:27 - 33:46]
• Eagles-Lions recaps & A.J. Brown discussion: [39:59 - 63:27]
• Eagles’ offensive predictability, Brown’s alignment: [62:16 - 63:44]

Tone & Language

• Casual, humorous, and direct with plenty of insider football wisdom.
• Sharpe and Ocho use anecdotes, personal experience, and relatable metaphors.
• Several moments where they “keep it real” about locker room politics and the realities hiding behind public storylines.

Memorable Moments

• "Test without a syllabus": Sharpe's vivid metaphor for Shedeur’s unpreparedness (33:19).
• AJ Brown owner meeting: Rare public confirmation and discussion of a star WR meeting face-to-face with ownership over social media griping (56:44).
• "Route recognition": Ocho’s critical breakdown of the Eagles’ predictable play calling (62:16).

For listeners:

This episode offers deep football insight on everything from sideline relationships to why backup QBs often fail (it’s not "Madden"), and candid, behind-the-scenes discussion of NFL star frustrations. Whether you're tracking the Browns' QB drama, Eagles’ championship hopes, or just love raw NFL talk, this is a can’t-miss conversation.