Clues with Morgan Absher and Kaylin Moore

Episode: INFAMOUS: Gabby Petito
Date: September 17, 2025

Overview: Main Theme and Purpose

In this deeply researched episode, Morgan Absher and Kaylin Moore explore the tragic, infamous murder of Gabby Petito—a 22-year-old aspiring travel content creator whose disappearance in 2021 turned into a global news event fueled by social media sleuthing, public scrutiny, and massive digital detective work. The hosts walk listeners through the timeline from Gabby's childhood through her relationship with Brian Laundrie, the national manhunt, the investigative missteps, and the lasting impact on conversations about domestic violence and true crime culture.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

The Rise of Gabby Petito and the Van Life Dream

• Gabby Petito was described as creative and vibrant since childhood and drawn to adventure over traditional life paths.
• Reconnected with Brian Laundrie, a quiet, artistic, and very different personality, leading to a fast, intense relationship.
• Gabby's plan: embark on a months-long, content-driven cross-country van trip, aiming to grow her “Van Life” social media persona.
• Notable Quotes
  • [07:42] Kaylin Moore: “She had a deep craving for adventure and for new experiences. And what she really wanted, deep down, was to be a travel blogger.”

Relationship Dynamics & Red Flags

• Gabby’s relationship with Brian showed early red flags: family tensions (notably with Brian’s mother Roberta), lack of boundaries, and Gabby becoming more isolated.
• The couple’s relationship was described as magnetic but marked by stark personality differences and gradual escalation of controlling behavior from Brian.
• Notable Quotes
  • [13:28] Morgan Absher: “There’s a boy mom and then there’s a mom who has sons and she is a boy mom...”

The Trip and Social Media Exposure

• The couple’s trip began July 2, 2021, documented through upbeat, beautifully shot posts by Gabby, masking underlying turmoil.
• As Gabby’s posts suddenly stop and family can’t reach her, alarm builds—her usually steady communication ceases.
• Notable Quotes
  • [22:45] Kaylin Moore: “All of her posts are so positive too. Inspirational stuff, filled with so much gratitude... And to those who were watching and hearing about Gabby’s adventure online, it seemed to be a total dream come true.”

The Vanishing: Timeline of Disappearance

• August 25: Gabby’s last Instagram post; last FaceTime with her mother on Aug 24.
• Strange texts followed—including one to her mother referencing her “Gampa Stan,” which was out of character and rang alarm bells.
• [25:34] Morgan Absher: "The text reads, quote, can you help Stan? I just keep getting his voicemails and missed calls... Gabby doesn’t call her grandpa Stan."
• Silence follows, and the last message says "no service in Yosemite" [25:59].

Family Concerns and First Evidence

• The Petito family members desperately try to reach Gabby, also contacting Brian’s parents—who remain silent.
• Sept 11: Gabby is officially reported missing; her van is found at Brian’s parents’ home in Florida, but with no Gabby.
• The Laundrie family immediately gets a lawyer and refuses to cooperate. [30:09] Morgan Absher notes, "It is beyond weird and frustrating..."

Key Evidence Timeline (with Timestamps)

• Clue 1: Out-of-character texts from Gabby to her mother [25:34-26:37]
• Clue 2: Gabby’s van at the Laundrie home [29:34-30:09]
• Clue 3: Suspicious debit card transactions by Brian and staged “goodbye” Zelle payments [34:40-36:31]
• Clue 4: Whole Foods surveillance footage—Gabby last seen alive [36:31-40:15]
• Clue 5: Body cam footage of police stop in Moab after a 911 domestic dispute call [46:12-53:49]
• Clue 6: Gabby’s digital footprint—a hiking app pinpointing her last location near Spread Creek in Grand Teton NP [53:49-55:19]
• Clue 7: Dashcam footage from the Batun family showing Gabby’s van at Spread Creek [57:19-57:53]
• Clue 8: Brian’s Ford Mustang clues for his disappearance [65:19-66:12]
• Clue 9: Brian’s confession notebook found after his suicide [71:25-74:24]

Moab Police Encounter and Law Enforcement Failures

• Released police body cam footage shows Gabby emotionally distraught, taking all blame for the incident, while Brian is calm and collected.
• Moab officers miss key indicators of abuse, ultimately separating the couple for just one night.
• Notable Quotes
  • [50:04] Kaylin Moore: “In the dashcam footage...they’re kind of agreeing that women can be emotional sometimes. Yeah, we get it, man. Like, we have wives.”
  • [51:02] Morgan Absher: “That’s why we’re getting a botched here…”

The Social Media Firestorm and Citizen Sleuths

• Gabby’s case goes viral, inspiring both productive tips and overwhelming, at times obstructive flood of theories and false leads.
• Citizen sleuths help uncover key evidence (like the Batun family's dashcam video), but TikTok and Reddit also contribute conspiracy and chaos.
• [44:39-46:09] “TikTok is also treating this like a real time mystery that they can help solve… at one point [the FBI] received over 4,500 tips just in that first week alone.”

The Search, Discovery, and Aftermath

• Jen Batun’s YouTube footage locates Gabby's van at Spread Creek, leading to the discovery of her body nearby.
• Autopsy confirms Gabby died by blunt force injuries and manual strangulation [61:00].
• Immediately after, Brian disappears and becomes the subject of a nationwide manhunt.
• [67:17-67:44] The search is chaotic, with police, searchers, and online figures all involved.

Brian Laundrie's Disappearance and Death

• Brian’s parents claim he left home for a hike and never returned, but their cooperation is highly suspect.
• His remains are found in October, cause of death self-inflicted gunshot wound, after his parents lead authorities straight to the site suspiciously quickly.
• Notable Quotes
  • [70:41] Morgan Absher: “People were really weirded out by the fact his parents seemingly just walked in the park and found him...”

The Confession Notebook and Family Involvement

• Brian leaves behind a notebook attempting to portray Gabby’s death as a mercy killing—widely dismissed as a self-serving fabrication.
• Evidence suggests premeditation, extensive cover-up, and family involvement, especially through the infamous "burn after reading" letter from Roberta.
• [78:57] Direct excerpt: “If you need to dispose of a body, I will show up with a shovel and garbage bags. If you fly to the moon, I will be watching the skies for your re entry. If you say you hate my guts, I'll get new guts.”

Lessons About Domestic Abuse and the Cycle of Violence

• The hosts discuss the cycle of violence in abusive relationships, drawing from both expert insights and Gabby’s behavioral patterns.
• Introduce the idea of "reactive abuse" or "self-defense," explaining why victims might blame themselves or be mistaken for aggressors.
• [88:56] Kaylin Moore shares: "I remember her describing it as being a frog in a boiling pot of water. You just don’t feel it at first.”

White Woman Syndrome and Missing Persons Inequity

• Gabby's father channels the visibility of her case into advocacy for missing persons of color, acknowledging that media attention is often biased.
• Promotes the Gabby Petito Foundation and its partnerships to improve outcomes for other missing persons cases.
• The episode ends with a spotlight on the still-active missing person case of Daniel Robinson [91:27-93:59].

Memorable Moments & Notable Quotes

• [09:13] Morgan Absher: “She’s so cute. You watch these videos and you can just tell she's someone you want to be friends with.”
• [15:53] Kaylin Moore (on how Gabby’s parents learned of her engagement): "That’s really hurtful for Gabby’s mom."
• [46:52] Kaylin Moore: “You hear these horror stories...really good on this guy for seeing a guy slap a girl on the sidewalk and call it in...”
• [73:51] Kaylin Moore: "Just such cowardice."
• [79:40] Kaylin Moore (quoting the Bible verse from Roberta’s letter): "For I am convinced that neither death nor life… will be able to separate us..."

Important Timestamps

• [04:25] Kaylin and Morgan outline approach: timeline, step-by-step investigation
• [13:28] Discussion of family dynamics and “boy mom” trope
• [22:45] Start of road trip, early van life posts
• [25:34-27:20] Gabby's last contact and the red flag “Stan” text
• [29:34] Authorities find Gabby’s van at Laundrie house
• [34:40] Digital evidence: debit card transactions and Zelle payment
• [36:31-40:15] Last footage of Gabby from Whole Foods and eyewitness accounts
• [46:12-53:49] Moab police stop: body cam breakdown
• [55:19-57:53] Social media sleuthing leads to crucial footage from the Batun family
• [65:19-66:12] Brian’s Mustang clue and misidentification by police
• [71:25-74:24] Brian’s notebook confession and lies
• [83:24-87:08] Discussion of warning signs, abusive patterns, and the Walker cycle of violence
• [89:55-91:27] The digitization and public sleuthing effect, Gabby’s legacy turns to advocacy

Concluding Reflections

Clues’ hosts highlight the intersection of new media, public engagement, and law enforcement in modern investigations. They also underscore the heartbreaking patterns of intimate partner violence—and the need for societal vigilance, empathy, and resources for victims.

If you or someone you know is in an abusive relationship, the hosts recommend resources like loveisrespect.org, encouraging all listeners to check in on their relationship health.

Case Advocacy: Missing Person of the Week

• Daniel Robinson: Missing since June 23, 2021, in Buckeye, Arizona.
  • Description: 5'8", African American male, 165 lbs, black hair, brown eyes, missing part of his right forearm.
  • Tip Line: 623-349-6411

Final Thoughts

This episode is both an in-depth case analysis and advocacy for awareness of domestic violence warning signs. Morgan and Kaylin urge their listeners to stay vigilant, support other missing persons cases, and see beyond sensational headlines to deeper issues of interpersonal danger and media inequity.

For Photos and More

See @CluesPodcast on Instagram for episode visuals and further content.

This summary is provided to give you a comprehensive understanding of the "Clues: INFAMOUS: Gabby Petito" episode—a must-listen for true crime followers and anyone seeking insight into the entwined power and peril of modern-day digital sleuthing.