Summary of "KIDNAPPED: Denise Huskins" – Clues with Morgan Absher and Kaelyn Moore
Podcast Information:
- Title: Clues with Morgan Absher and Kaelyn Moore
- Host/Authors: Morgan Absher and Kaelyn Moore
- Episode: KIDNAPPED: Denise Huskins
- Release Date: June 11, 2025
- Description: Delving into the harrowing true crime case of Denise Huskins and Aaron Quinn, this episode explores the complexities, investigative failures, and eventual justice surrounding their kidnapping ordeal.
Introduction
The episode begins with the hosts setting the tone for an intense exploration of a notorious crime case.
- Morgan Absher [00:00]: Opens with vivid imagery of the crime scene, mentioning items like a black ski mask, duct tape, and NyQuil.
- Kaelyn Moore [00:18]: Highlights the lack of visible signs of disturbance in Denise and Aaron’s home, emphasizing the unusual nature of the case.
Key Quote:
- Denise Huskins [02:35]: “They went on national news to say that this was all a hoax and we were liars. So I didn't trust anything that was given to me.”
The Kidnapping Incident
On March 22, 2015, Denise Huskins and her boyfriend, Aaron Quinn, experience a terrifying home invasion.
- Aaron's 911 Call [02:14]: Aaron reports that they were awakened by intruders who tied them up, drugged them, and took Denise hostage.
- Intruders’ Behavior [07:00]: The assailant uses pre-recorded messages, administers sedatives (NyQuil and Diazepam), and demands $17,000 for Denise’s release.
- Denise’s Abduction [08:43 – 10:49]: Denise is moved to another location, faces threats of sexual assault, and is eventually dropped off near her childhood home in Huntington Beach.
Key Quotes:
- Morgan Absher [08:10]: “These aren’t just headphones playing music. They’re playing pre-recorded messages with instructions.”
- Denise Huskins [10:27]: “You’re staring up at a camera in a corner, seemingly watching me. I just got told if I do anything, it’s not going to end well.”
Initial Police Response
The Vallejo Police Department (VPD) initially mishandles the investigation, casting doubt on Denise and Aaron's credibility.
- Skeptical Police [12:29 – 13:35]: Officers question Aaron’s sobriety and suggest he might be lying about the kidnapping.
- Detective Matt Mustard [17:13]: Exhibits blatant bias, suggesting Denise might be recreating past trauma and painting Aaron as a suspect.
Key Quotes:
- Detective Mustard [17:24]: “I’m going to tell them that I’m not looking for a live Denise. I’m looking for a dead Denise.”
- Morgan Absher [17:35]: “He’s trying to make you look like a monster.”
Public Misinformation and Press Conference
As Denise reappears, the public narrative shifts unfavorably against her and Aaron.
- Denise’s Release [21:34 – 30:46]: Denise contacts authorities, confirms her kidnapping via a phone call, but VPD label it as a hoax.
- Media Influence [32:31]: The release coincides with the popularity of "Gone Girl," skewing public perception further.
- Death Threats and Public Scrutiny [33:02 – 37:50]: Denise and Aaron receive death threats as media portrays them as liars, leading to severe PTSD.
Key Quotes:
- Morgan Absher [33:03]: “They say Aaron and Denise owe the community an apology.”
- Kaelyn Moore [37:50]: “We’re stopping this.”
Discovery of the Real Perpetrator
A critical breakthrough comes three months later, linking Denise’s kidnapping to a similar home invasion in Dublin.
- Dublin Home Invasion [42:07 – 43:54]: A similar pattern emerges, leading police to Matthew Mueller through evidence found at the scene.
- Detective Misty Karasu [43:54 – 46:26]: Connects the dots between Mueller’s discarded items and Denise’s case, leading to Mueller’s arrest.
Key Quotes:
- Detective Karasu [46:26]: “Denise is not a liar. She’s not Gone Girl in real life.”
- Morgan Absher [43:38]: “He’s leaving behind his cell phone, which is the most important thing.”
Legal Proceedings and Arrest
Matthew Mueller is formally charged and convicted, but the path to justice is fraught with systemic failures.
- FBI Involvement [47:52 – 55:20]: FBI steps in after recognizing patterns, ultimately charging Mueller with multiple crimes.
- Conviction and Sentencing [55:20 – 57:00]: Mueller receives a 40-year sentence for kidnapping and life terms for other home invasions.
Key Quotes:
- Kayla Moore [57:15]: “He needs his badge revoked.”
- Morgan Absher [55:20]: “Matthew has been charged and convicted appropriately.”
Aftermath and Apology
Denise and Aaron pursue justice beyond the courtroom, leading to a successful defamation lawsuit against VPD.
- Federal Complaint [63:31 – 64:32]: They sue Vallejo PD for defamation, highlighting wrongful accusations and resource wastage.
- Settlement and Apology [64:32 – 65:04]: Awarded $2.5 million and receive a partial apology from VPD, acknowledging harsh and offensive comments.
Key Quotes:
- Kaelyn Moore [64:32]: “They proved to be unnecessarily harsh and offensive.”
- Denise Huskins [64:32]: “We know that something worked eventually.”
Detectives’ Roles: Good vs. Bad
The episode contrasts the negative actions of Detective Mustard with the commendable efforts of Detective Karasu.
- Detective Matt Mustard [56:28 – 58:14]: Accused of misconduct, bias, and obstructing justice throughout his career.
- Detective Misty Karasu [58:14 – 60:00]: Praised for her diligent work in connecting cases and bringing Mueller to justice.
Key Quotes:
- Morgan Absher [56:28]: “This man is a menace to society.”
- Kaelyn Moore [58:44]: “Detective Karasu cared deeply and was willing to work with the evidence.”
Interview with Denise Huskins
Denise shares her journey post-kidnapping, advocating for better policing techniques and trauma-informed practices.
- Advocacy and Book Release [65:04 – 74:32]: Denise and Aaron publish “Victim F,” emphasizing the victim's perspective and the psychological impact of trauma.
- Science-Based Interviewing [75:23 – 85:32]: Denise discusses the importance of respectful, trauma-informed interviewing methods and critiques traditional, coercive police interrogation techniques.
- Personal Life and Healing [85:32 – 97:33]: Denise and Aaron marry, welcome two daughters, and continue advocacy work, focusing on supporting other victims and influencing law enforcement training.
Key Quotes:
- Denise Huskins [66:34]: “We wanted to show the victim’s experience because most people go through some kind of trauma and it impacts every aspect of their life.”
- Morgan Absher [79:43]: “It feels like a type of training that it would be useful to do every few years as a good reminder.”
Conclusion
The episode wraps up by highlighting the resilience of Denise and Aaron, the systemic issues within law enforcement, and the ongoing need for advocacy and reform.
- Final Reflections [98:25 – End]: Denise emphasizes the role of respectful treatment in victim recovery and the importance of continuous education for law enforcement.
- Hope and Change [97:30 – End]: The couple remains dedicated to making a positive impact, inspiring others, and fostering better relationships between victims and police.
Key Quotes:
- Denise Huskins [99:03]: “Everyone plays a pivotal role in the victim's experience and what you do and say matters.”
- Kaelyn Moore [100:09]: “Thank you so much for jumping on with us.”
Notable Quotes with Timestamps:
- Denise Huskins [02:35]: “They went on national news to say that this was all a hoax and we were liars. So I didn't trust anything that was given to me.”
- Morgan Absher [08:10]: “These aren’t just headphones playing music. They’re playing pre-recorded messages with instructions.”
- Detective Mustard [17:24]: “I’m going to tell them that I’m not looking for a live Denise. I’m looking for a dead Denise.”
- Detective Karasu [46:26]: “Denise is not a liar. She’s not Gone Girl in real life.”
- Denise Huskins [66:34]: “We wanted to show the victim’s experience because most people go through some kind of trauma and it impacts every aspect of their life.”
- Denise Huskins [99:03]: “Everyone plays a pivotal role in the victim's experience and what you do and say matters.”
Final Thoughts:
"KIDNAPPED: Denise Huskins" is a compelling exploration of a tragic case marred by investigative shortcomings and public misjudgment. Through Denise and Aaron’s harrowing experience, the podcast underscores the critical need for empathy, proper training, and systemic reform within law enforcement to prevent future miscarriages of justice. The hosts, Morgan Absher and Kaelyn Moore, adeptly navigate the complexities of the case, providing listeners with a thorough understanding of both the human and procedural elements involved.
For those interested in delving deeper, Denise and Aaron’s book, "Victim F," offers an intimate recounting of their ordeal and ongoing advocacy efforts.
Follow Clues Podcast on Instagram @CluesPodcast and YouTube @CluesPod for more engaging true crime stories.