CMO Confidential Episode Summary: Scott Griffiths | Primer on the Marketing CFO - Why it Might Be Right for You

Release Date: October 8, 2024

Introduction

In this engaging episode of CMO Confidential, host Mike Linton delves into the intricate relationship between marketing and finance with his guest, Scott Griffiths, the Chief Financial Officer (CFO) of the Affiliate Network. Scott shares his unique perspective as the first-ever Marketing CFO at Farmers Insurance, shedding light on the challenges and strategies involved in aligning marketing initiatives with financial objectives.

Guest Background

Scott Griffiths brings a wealth of experience, having started his career at KPMG in England as an auditor before moving into various roles at Countrywide and Farmers Insurance. Notably, he was the inaugural Marketing CFO at Farmers, a role that required him to bridge the gap between marketing aspirations and financial accountability. Mike mentions, “Scott was the first pick of the marketing team to become the first ever marketing CFO at Farmers and we worked together for many years” ([00:31]).

Marketing and Finance Intersection

Scott begins by addressing common perceptions about marketing and finance. He acknowledges the stereotype that marketing often presents a “biased version of the truth” ([02:19]), but emphasizes that responsible marketers aim to showcase the positive aspects of a product without misleading customers. He criticizes internal reporting practices that favor marketing’s success narratives over objective performance metrics.

Establishing Alignment and Measuring Success

One of the primary challenges Scott faced was aligning marketing activities with the company’s strategic goals. He explains, “we had to look at every marketing activity spend through a strategic standpoint” ([05:07]). Scott and his team assessed each marketing initiative’s contribution to moving the company from point A to point B, eliminating activities that didn’t align strategically.

A notable example Scott shares involves Farmers Insurance’s sponsorship of NASCAR. He points out the misalignment between NASCAR’s audience and Farmers’ target customers, leading to inefficient spending despite the high visibility: “when you looked at who the target customer was for Farmers and who the target viewer was for NASCAR, they were completely misaligned” ([05:44]).

Challenges in Team Alignment

Scott discusses the complexities of managing a diverse marketing department with various sub-functions like search, brand, events, PR, and internal communications. He highlights the importance of creating a KPI scorecard that ties marketing activities directly to corporate goals, facilitating objective decision-making ([07:05]).

Why Most People Aren’t Good at Their Jobs

Scott introduces a thought-provoking segment on workforce performance, citing the normal distribution to explain that only a small percentage of employees are exceptional or poor performers, with the majority falling into the average category ([10:14]). He emphasizes that average performers do their job satisfactorily but lack the drive to generate outstanding results. Scott asserts, “most people aren't good at their job” ([09:50]), underscoring the need for organizations to cultivate and retain top talent to achieve excellence.

Managing Conflict Between Marketing and Finance

Scott elaborates on the inherent conflicts between marketing and finance departments, often rooted in differing priorities and biases. He stresses the necessity of collaboration, data-backed decisions, and mutual understanding to bridge these gaps. Scott advises leaving egos aside and focusing on shared objectives: “everyone in the room needs to leave their ego at the door” ([22:35]).

He provides practical tips for facilitating productive conflict:

• Avoid Managing by Consensus: Majority rule can lead to mediocre outcomes if most team members are average performers ([24:01]).
• Empower Top Performers: Delegate strategic decisions to high-performing individuals to drive progress ([24:02]).
• Focus on Shared Goals: Align discussions around overarching company objectives rather than departmental wins ([25:49]).

Saying No Effectively

A critical aspect of Scott’s role involved making tough decisions to allocate resources efficiently. He advises maintaining objectivity and credibility by basing decisions on measurable data: “Be objective, right. And be seen as being objective” ([26:53]). Scott also recommends using constructive language when declining proposals, such as suggesting alternatives or testing new ideas: “No, but how about we test the theory?” ([28:12]).

Advice for Finance Professionals Aspiring to be Marketing CFOs

Scott shares two key traits essential for finance professionals considering a transition to a Marketing CFO role:

1. Comfort with Ambiguity: Marketing outcomes are often less tangible and require navigating uncertain results. Scott mentions, “Marketing by its nature is very ambiguous” ([30:17]).
2. Strong Communication Skills: The ability to articulate complex, ambiguous data succinctly to stakeholders is crucial ([30:15]).

He emphasizes that success in this role hinges on blending financial acumen with an understanding of marketing dynamics.

A Humorous Anecdote

Towards the end of the episode, Scott entertains listeners with a funny story about underestimating a prominent golfer's appearance at a Farmers-sponsored event. He recounts mistaking professional golfer Rickie Fowler for an average teenager, highlighting his own fallibility: “I was not good at my job” ([34:10]).

Conclusion

This episode of CMO Confidential offers invaluable insights into the role of a Marketing CFO, highlighting the delicate balance between strategic alignment, objective measurement, and effective communication. Scott Griffiths provides actionable advice for both marketing and finance professionals aiming to enhance collaboration and drive business success. His candid discussions underscore the complexities of integrating financial discipline with creative marketing strategies, making this episode a must-listen for executives navigating similar challenges.

Notable Quotes:

• Scott Griffiths ([02:19]): “The real question as CFO of marketing was to cut through the BS and give an objective and measurable view of the performance of marketing.”
• Scott Griffiths ([10:14]): “Most people aren't good at their job. They do their job satisfactorily, but they lack the drive to generate outstanding results.”
• Scott Griffiths ([22:35]): “Everyone in the room needs to leave their ego at the door. It’s about agreeing on the end goal.”
• Scott Griffiths ([26:53]): “Be objective, right. And be seen as being objective.”
• Scott Griffiths ([28:12]): “No, but how about we test the theory?”
• Scott Griffiths ([34:10]): “I was not good at my job.”

Listen to More Episodes:

• Marketing, the Battle Between Believers and Non-Believers. Parts 1, 2, and 3
• Secrets from a CFO, Scott Lindquist. Parts 1, 2, and 3
• A Marketer Turned Tech Exec Talks About Big Data, Mainframes, and AI

Stay connected with CMO Confidential on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, and the I Hear Everything network.