Coaching Real Leaders: Episode Summary

Episode Title: How Do I Handle It When I Disagree with My Boss’s Decisions?
Host/Author: Harvard Business Review / Muriel Wilkins
Release Date: October 21, 2024

Introduction

In this episode of Coaching Real Leaders, Muriel Wilkins delves into the complexities of handling disagreements with superior leadership decisions. The session features a coaching conversation with a high-performing executive, referred to as Adam, who grapples with maintaining his core values while navigating challenging dynamics with his boss.

Adam's Background and Career Trajectory

[01:15] Adam: "I've always had a major love for finance and... my current role, which is C-suite level."

Adam shares his career journey, highlighting his ambition and love for finance, which led him to pivot his career overseas. This move allowed him to ascend rapidly within a smaller market, ultimately securing a C-suite position. His initial optimism was fueled by his role as a change agent, focusing on cultural transformation and operational performance.

The Core Challenge: Trust and Communication with His Boss

[02:04] Adam: "...the trust part was a little bit more difficult for me to accomplish with my boss."

Upon assuming his recent role, Adam encountered unexpected challenges in building a trusting relationship with his boss. While he successfully fostered relationships with colleagues, breaking down barriers with his superior proved more elusive. This difficulty affected how he approached interactions, leading to missed opportunities to voice critical perspectives.

Recognizing the Trap: Balancing Relationships and Core Values

[04:21] Adam: "My career advancement has moved so rapidly that I am now trusted into some of these positions where I have to also make sure that my maturity level gets up to that point as well."

Adam identifies himself in a "trap" where his rapid career progression demands a higher level of maturity in handling difficult situations. He acknowledges a dissonance between his usual approach of relationship-building and the new demands of his leadership role, leading to internal conflict and regret over not asserting his viewpoints.

Defining Influence vs. Decision-Making

[18:21] Adam: "I suppose for me it's presenting your arguments, your arguments being essentially crisp, data-driven..."

Muriel and Adam dissect the difference between influencing and decision-making. Adam realizes he conflated his role as an influencer with that of a decision-maker, setting unrealistic expectations for his ability to control outcomes. This misalignment contributed to his frustration and sense of inadequacy when his efforts to influence decisions fell short.

Navigating Inner Conflict: The Smoke Alarm Analogy

[42:17] Coaching Assistant: "If that is the smoke alarm, what choices do you then have?"

Muriel introduces the smoke alarm analogy to help Adam understand and manage his inner conflict. Just as a smoke alarm signals potential danger, inner discomfort indicates the need for strategic assessment and mindful decision-making. This framework encourages Adam to prioritize his actions based on what truly matters, aligning his responses with his core values without sacrificing important relationships.

Strategic and Mindful Leadership: Aligning Actions with Priorities

[47:10] Adam: "Right."

The conversation advances to strategizing how Adam can maintain his voice in high-stakes situations without compromising relationships. Muriel emphasizes the importance of clarity in prioritizing outcomes and making conscious decisions that reflect his leadership values. Adam acknowledges the need to be more strategic and mindful, ensuring his actions align with his priorities to mitigate internal conflicts.

Key Insights and Takeaways

1. Co-Creation of Dynamics: All interpersonal dynamics are co-created, but in one-on-one coaching, the focus is on the individual's controllable actions and mindset.

2. Differentiating Influence from Decision-Making: Understanding one's role in influencing versus making decisions is crucial for setting realistic expectations and reducing self-blame.

3. Recognizing and Responding to Inner Conflict: Inner discomfort acts as a signal to assess and realign priorities. Leaders must develop frameworks to respond strategically rather than react impulsively.

4. Aligning Actions with Core Values: Maintaining integrity and staying true to core values, even in the face of challenging relationships, is essential for sustainable leadership growth.

5. Strategic Preparation: Being well-prepared and adaptable in decision-making scenarios enhances a leader's ability to influence effectively without feeling compromised.

Conclusion

By the episode's end, Adam gains clarity on managing his inner conflicts and aligning his actions with his leadership values. He commits to a more strategic and mindful approach, ensuring that his decisions reflect both his personal integrity and professional responsibilities. This transformative coaching session not only addresses Adam's immediate challenges but also equips him with tools for ongoing leadership development.

Notable Outcome: A few months post-coaching, Adam received a promotion to an even more senior role, indicating the positive impact of the coaching session on his leadership trajectory.

Quotes

• Adam on Career Progression:
  [01:23] "I was able to successfully get promoted into... my current role, which, you know, is C-suite level."

• Adam on Trust Challenges:
  [02:04] "The trust part was a little bit more difficult for me to accomplish with my boss."

• Adam on Influence vs. Decision-Making:
  [21:04] "I have plenty of examples like that."

• Muriel on Inner Conflict:
  [50:35] "...some of our house. Right. It's like when the smoke alarm goes off in our house."

• Adam on Maintaining Core Values:
  [37:49] "...I can't live with myself if I don't stick to my core values in that situation."

Final Thoughts

Adam's journey underscores the intricate balance between maintaining personal integrity and fostering professional relationships. Through strategic reflection and conscious decision-making, leaders can navigate disagreements and uphold their core values without compromising essential relationships.

For More Episodes and Insights:
Join Muriel Wilkins and other leaders in their coaching conversations by subscribing to Coaching Real Leaders on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your preferred podcast platform. Engage with the community and continue your leadership growth journey.