Damn His Soul To Hell

Summary

Cold Case Files: "Damn His Soul To Hell" – Detailed Summary

Introduction

In the gripping episode titled "Damn His Soul To Hell," Paula Barros delves deep into one of Hazleton, Pennsylvania's most haunting unsolved mysteries. This episode chronicles the tragic murder of nine-year-old Maurice Ciavarella in 1964, a case that baffled investigators for decades before finally seeing resolution through advancements in forensic technology and unwavering investigative persistence.

The Disappearance of Maurice Ciavarella

The story begins on a cold, late winter morning in Hazleton. At [02:34], Marissa Pinson sets the scene:

"It's March 18, 1964, in Hazleton, Pennsylvania. Nine-year-old Maurice Ciavarella grabs her gloves and leaves for school, never to return." [02:34]

Maurice, a bright and loving child, typically walked to St. Joseph's Academy with her siblings. On that fateful day, she left a few minutes early to bring canned goods to her classroom in preparation for the feast day of St. Joseph.

Community Shock and Immediate Aftermath

Maurice's absence was quickly noticed. At [04:02], Devin Brutoski, a lieutenant with the Pennsylvania State Police, explains:

"They speak to the instructor that would be her homeroom teacher. That instructor says, I haven't seen Maurice either and I have her marked absent through the morning classes. That's when they realized something went terribly wrong." [04:02]

The community was thrust into chaos. Ronald Ciavarella shares the family's anguish:

"What's happening to my family's life? Why have we been inflicted with such a horrible injury?... Could the perpetrator have been someone within our own family?" [01:05]

The local priest was notified, and the family was informed that Maurice had not returned home. The initial investigation was swift, with law enforcement questioning everyone close to Maurice.

Discovery of Maurice's Body

Three days after her disappearance, Maurice's lifeless body was discovered near a coal stripping pit by Arthur Robinson and his nephew. At [05:15], Devin Brutoski recounts:

"He notices something approximately 25 feet down a slope from the top of the garbage dump area... At first, he thought it was a doll, but as he got closer, he realized it was a little girl." [05:15]

The autopsy revealed a horrifying truth: Maurice had been brutally assaulted, strangled, and beaten. Lieutenant Devin Brutoski details the grim findings:

"She was sexually assaulted. She was strangled and beaten... The cause of death was listed as homicide." [08:59]

Initial Investigation and Early Suspects

The investigation initially focused on individuals within the community. At [16:44], investigators mention Bruce Hildebrand, a known local troublemaker:

"Bruce Hildebrand had a lot of problems with alcohol... He confessed but later recanted his confession, attributing it to a state of depression." [16:44]

Another suspect, Harold Nichols, emerged but met a tragic end before providing any meaningful leads:

"Harold Nichols... committed suicide prior to coming in for the polygraph examination." [20:44]

Despite these leads, the case stalled, and Maurice's murder remained unsolved, leaving the community in fear and the Ciavarella family devastated.

Decades of Silence: The Cold Case

For over fifty years, Maurice Ciavarella's murder case lingered unsolved. The Ciavarella family endured immense pain, with Ronald Ciavarella expressing enduring frustration:

"I never gave up on Maurice's case." [21:33]

By 2007, advancements in DNA technology offered a glimmer of hope. Investigators re-examined Maurice's clothing and extracted seminal fluid, creating a DNA profile. However, initial database checks yielded no matches.

The Breakthrough: Genetic Genealogy

In 2017, a new investigator took the helm, bringing fresh perspective and technology to the table. At [25:48], Marissa Pinson highlights the pivotal moment:

"That forward movement comes in an email to Lt. Brutoski from an unlikely source. Eric Schubert is a forensic genetic genealogist." [25:48]

Eric Schubert's expertise in genetic genealogy proved instrumental. By analyzing Maurice's DNA and building extensive family trees, Schubert traced potential suspects to the Palmeno family, specifically focusing on James Paul Fort.

Confirming the Suspect: James Paul Fort

After meticulous research and DNA matching, the team zeroed in on James Paul Fort, a man with a troubling past. At [37:42], the Lieutenant reveals:

"We were 99% sure that James Fort was gonna be our suspect in this homicide." [37:42]

Despite Fort's passing in 1980, investigators obtained DNA from his exhumed remains. A dramatic moment occurred during exhumation when a crucifix inexplicably appeared through a narrow slit in the coffin, symbolizing what many saw as divine confirmation.

On February 3, 2022, nearly 58 years after the murder, DNA evidence conclusively linked James Paul Fort to Maurice's death:

"We received the results from our DNA lab, and James Paul Fort matched the DNA profile from the semen stain on Maurice Ciavarella's jacket." [39:26]

Family and Community Closure

The Ciavarella family finally received closure. Ronald Ciavarella expressed profound gratitude:

"I'll never stop praising the Pennsylvania State Police for the work they've done on Maurice's case for the last 58 years. Amazing." [40:06]

Carmen Marie Radke, Maurice's sister, emphasized the family's resilience and love:

"I want people to know how wonderful my parents were, showing us that hate was not the way to go. Hate to them would have just destroyed us, and we just had love for each other and that helped us get through all those years." [40:30]

Conclusion

"Damn His Soul To Hell" serves as a testament to the relentless pursuit of justice and the transformative power of modern forensic science. Maurice Ciavarella's case, once a source of fear and sorrow, finally saw resolution, providing solace to a grieving family and a community that never forgot.

Notable Quotes:

• Ronald Ciavarella at [00:48]: "What's happening to my family's life? Why have we been inflicted with such a horrible injury?"

• Mark Barron at [01:23]: "It was a question the community was asking for over half a century."

• Devin Brutoski at [08:59]: "The cause of death was listed as homicide."

• Marissa Pinson at [25:48]: "Eric Schubert is a forensic genetic genealogist... I would love to do it."

• Devin Brutoski at [39:26]: "James Paul Fort matched the DNA profile from the semen stain on Maurice Ciavarella's jacket."

• Ronald Ciavarella at [40:06]: "I'll never stop praising the Pennsylvania State Police for the work they've done on Maurice's case for the last 58 years."

This comprehensive summary encapsulates the emotional journey, investigative challenges, and eventual triumph in uncovering the truth behind Maurice Ciavarella's tragic demise.

Transcript

[Marissa Pinson]

Get the Angel Reese Special at McDonald's. Now, let's break it down. My favorite barbecue sauce, American cheese, crispy bacon, pickles, onions and a sesame seed bun, of course. And don't forget the fries and a drink. Sound good?

[Devin Brutoski]

I participate in restaurants for a limited time.

[Marissa Pinson]

Hi cold case listeners. I'm Marissa Pinson, and before we get into this week's episode, I just wanted to remind you that episodes of Cold Case Files as well as the A and E classic podcasts, I Survived American justice and and City Confidential are all available ad free on the new A and E Crime and Investigation channel on Apple Podcasts and Apple plus for just $4.99 a month or 39.99 a year. And now onto the show. The following episode contains disturbing accounts of physical and sexual violence. Listener discretion is advised.

[Ronald Ciavarella]

The route to school was about five to six blocks. So on that day, Maurice left alone and she disappeared.

[Mark Barron]

This was indeed one of the more unimaginable things that happened to this community back then.

[Ronald Ciavarella]

What's happening to my family's life? Why have we been inflicted with such a horrible injury? People crying, people jumping up and down trying to deal with the horror. Could it be someone that my parents knew? Someone that Maurice knew? Could the perpetrator have been someone within our own family?

[Mark Barron]

It was a question the community was asking for over half a century.

[Marissa Pinson]

There are over 100,000 cold cases in America. Only about 1% are ever solved. This is one of those rare stories. Amanda Christman is a reporter with the Hazleton Standard.

[Mark Barron]

Speaker Hazleton is roughly two hours away from New York City and Philadelphia. It's in northeastern Pennsylvania. Our roots stem from the coal mining industry. Folks here have always been blue collar, hard working, tough people. But that said, Hazleton has some of the biggest hearts. I always wanted to be a storyteller. And as I got older, I found out that I could tell other people's stories through the newspaper while shining the light on truth. It was quite often that folks in the newsroom would talk about the Marie Chiavarella case. The big question was always who did it? It was a question the community was asking for over half a century.

[Marissa Pinson]

It's March 18, 1964 in Hazleton, Pennsylvania. It's a cold, late winter's morning when nine year old Maurice Schiverella grabs her gloves and leaves for school. Carmen Marie Radke is Maryse's sister.

[Carmen Marie Radke]

On the morning of March 18, it was a normal morning. We all got up, got ready for school. The feast day of St. Joseph was March 19. So on March 18, Maurice was bringing canned goods in celebration of the sisters feast day.

[Marissa Pinson]

Ronald Ciavarella is Maurice's brother.

[Ronald Ciavarella]

I was the firstborn. Ronald Ciavarella followed by Carmen Marie. Middle brother was Barry. The fourth individual born was Maurice and the youngest, David. Maurice, who typically walked to school with Carmen Marie and Barry on that particular day. She left a few minutes early because she needed to get those canned goods into her classroom. Hurry up and get over to Catholic Mass by 8 o'clock or she would be late. The route to school was about five to six blocks.

[Marissa Pinson]

Maurice, however, would never make it to St. Joseph's Academy.

[Carmen Marie Radke]

We usually would come home for lunchtime. Barry and I came home and Maurice didn't. At first we thought maybe she just stayed at school because there was something at school she wanted for lunch that the cafeteria was having.

[Ronald Ciavarella]

My father said no, she didn't have any plans to do that. Go back to school and find her. So that's what they did.

[Marissa Pinson]

Devin Brutoski is a lieutenant with the Pennsylvania State Police.

[Lieutenant]

Carmen notified her teacher, who in turn notified the priest who was the head of the Catholic school.

[Marissa Pinson]

Mark Barron is a corporal with the Pennsylvania State Police.

[Devin Brutoski]

They speak to the instructor that would be her homeroom teacher. That instructor says, I haven't seen Maurice either and I have her marked absent through the morning classes. That's when they realized something went terribly wrong.

[Lieutenant]

At that time the priest made his way to the Chiverella house and. And they informed the family at which time they started calling the police departments and notifying them that Maurice had not shown up for school that day.

[Ronald Ciavarella]

My father realized that something went awry with the situation.

[Carmen Marie Radke]

And that's when my father started looking. One of the neighborhood women yelled over to my dad and asked who and what he was looking for. And she said if you're looking for the little girl, they found her.

[Marissa Pinson]

About three miles away from the Chiverella's home, a man makes a grim discovery.

[Lieutenant]

Arthur Robinson and his nephew were driving in what would normally be called the stripping area, which is a coal mine area out in Hazel Township.

[Devin Brutoski]

And while he is there, he notices something. Approximately 25ft down a slope from the top of the garbage dump area, he.

[Mark Barron]

Sees what he thinks is a doll. And as he got closer, he realized that it was a little girl.

[Lieutenant]

He immediately left the refuse pit and called the state police.

[Mark Barron]

This blindsided people. This was not expected.

[Lieutenant]

When the troopers found the dead girl, they did make some phone calls. Back in 1964, churches were big in the hazleton area, especially the Catholic Church. The priests who were attached to the school that Maurice went to, they made their way out to the scene to administer last rites, which was common back in the day.

[Devin Brutoski]

And one of those priests actually knows the victim and positively identifies her as Marie Sanchevarella.

[Marissa Pinson]

News of the gruesome discovery reaches the family.

[Carmen Marie Radke]

I remember the priests coming to the home. Family members were coming to the house.

[Ronald Ciavarella]

My father's family had a lot of connections. A lot of brothers and sisters and uncles and aunts and so forth. There was nowhere to sit. People jumping up and down because their adrenaline was pumping, Trying to deal with the horror that they were digesting. People crying. So I went downstairs with my dad and tried to emotionally cope with what had happened to Maurice and what was happening to my family. My father owned a grocery store. My mother, she was a seamstress, sewing machine operator. I was the firstborn, followed by Carmen, Marie, Barry, Maurice, and David.

[Carmen Marie Radke]

Maurice was a quiet, loving little girl.

[Ronald Ciavarella]

When Maurice was in first grade, she had a speech impediment that became more noticeable. My mother got the services of a speech therapist, helped work with Maurice over several months. And she turned into an entirely different young little girl. She would clown around a lot. Her teasing and kidding was great.

[Carmen Marie Radke]

Maurice and all of us would go to daily mass at church. Maurice loved the music of the organ. We'd always ask our parents about getting one. So that Christmas of 62, my parents prized Maurice with the organ. She was ecstatic.

[Ronald Ciavarella]

She wanted to be like Sister Josephine. She wanted to be a Catholic nun.

[Lieutenant]

She was down an embankment, and her hands were bound. Her feet were bound. She appeared to have ligature marks around her neck. Her stockings were pulled down just below thigh level. Along with her underwear were pulled down along her legs. Also, she had a scarf stuffed into her mouth, which they called a babushka at the time. However, her clothing, which consisted of a blue jacket, wasn't dirty. It appeared that she had been placed there at the bottom of the pit.

[Devin Brutoski]

And it was a very cold day. It was like 26 degrees. The original investigators were looking for any type of tangible, physical evidence that they could have. They found a piece of insulation that had a footprint in it that was near the body. They collected that in the hopes that, hey, that could be something tangible. We could maybe compare that to a shoe of a potential suspect.

[Lieutenant]

They realized that there was a tire track down in the refuse pit. And they actually casted that, which they'll pour a casting in, and then they'll raise the tire track out. And we Kept that. At the time, in 1964, DNA evidence didn't exist. So what they were looking for would be any type of blood evidence that may have been left by the perpetrator on the victim.

[Devin Brutoski]

They also gathered all of the clothing that Maurice was wearing.

[Lieutenant]

So the coroner did an autopsy, and they determined that Maurice was sexually assaulted. She was strangled and beaten. They also made a determination of a bruise on her abdomen, as if somebody had struck her very hard and it caused some damage to her intestines on the inside. So they listed the cause of death as homicide.

[Mark Barron]

She was the Chiverella's child, but she could have been anybody's child.

[Lieutenant]

It was a very dark time for the city. The day after this crime was reported, a lot of the kids were not allowed to go out in the yard by themselves anymore. Everybody was scared that their child would be next. Anybody that's going to sexually assault a small girl and then strangle her and leave her in a stripping pit in the cold, in the snow is just a monster.

[Mark Barron]

There was never a crime as heinous before in people's memory as the one that happened to Marie Chiavarella.

[Ronald Ciavarella]

The day after Maurice was murdered, the family went to Catholic mass because it was a day of obligation at the church. And then we went back home, and I remember we were nurturing each other, crying, embracing each other, because that was the only dynamic we felt was helping each other.

[Marissa Pinson]

Police questioned Maurice's family, determined to find out all they can about the little girl.

[Lieutenant]

They interviewed the father, they interviewed the mother of Maurice, they interviewed the brothers and sisters.

[Ronald Ciavarella]

The Pennsylvania State Police had asked if they could speak with my father in private, and he said, fine. So I accompanied my father. And it was at that point that the state police started getting into more detail.

[Devin Brutoski]

In any investigation, you want to go ahead and create a timeline. You want to establish a timeline to try to nail down when the crime occurred. When was the last time that you saw Maurice alive?

[Lieutenant]

After interviewing them, they realized the timeline for Maurice leaving the residence was shortly after 8am so the police were going.

[Devin Brutoski]

Ahead and contacting all the neighbors and people that lived within. I believe it was about a five city block area. To try to establish what route she took to school that day.

[Lieutenant]

They spoke with Helen Slattery, who was a cut to the Ciavarella family, and that's when they were able to pinpoint more or less the 8:15 time frame of when she was last seen heading eastbound on fourth Street.

[Marissa Pinson]

Everyone in Hazleton seems to have a.

[Mark Barron]

Theory about the murder in the absence of an answer. There were a number of rumors going around town as to who could have done something like that. Some people believed it had been someone local because of the intimate knowledge of our geography and finding that coal stripping pit which would be only known to somebody locally.

[Carmen Marie Radke]

I remember people wondering, was it one of our neighbors? That's what the scariest part was, not knowing who and what they might do next.

[Marissa Pinson]

Who Doesn't Love the good Things in Life? Even though I enjoy a little luxury, it doesn't mean I can always afford it. Until I discovered Quince. Quince is my go to for luxury essentials at affordable prices. I recently treated myself to their Mongolian cashmere crewneck sweater and I am absolutely in love. At just $50, it's a fraction of what I'd pay for similar quality elsewhere. The softness and warmth are incredible and I've been wearing it everywhere. From cozy nights in to dressy dinners out. Quince offers a range of high quality items at prices within reach like washable silk tops and dresses, organic cotton sweaters and 14 karat gold jewelry. The best part? All Quince Items are priced 50 to 80% less than similar brands. By partnering directly with top factories, Quince cuts out the cost of the middleman and passes the savings on to us. And Quince only works with factories that use safe, ethical and responsible manufacturing practices and premium fabrics and finishes. I love that. I also picked up their washable silk slip dress and it's become a staple in my wardrobe. The quality rivals luxury brands I've owned and at $80 it's a steal. Plus it's machine washable which is incredible for silk. With Quince I can indulge in luxury without the guilt. It's changed the way I shop for essentials and my wardrobe has never looked better. Give yourself the luxury you deserve with quince. Go to quince.comcoldcase for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. That's Q U I-n c e.com cold case to get free shipping and 365 day returns quint.com cold case cold case Files is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Do you ever find yourself playing the budgeting game, shifting a little money here, a little there and hoping it all works out well? With the name your price tool from Progressive, you can be a better budgeter and potentially lower your insurance bill too. You tell Progressive what you want to pay for car insurance and they'll help you find options within your budget. Try [e-mail] Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates Price and coverage match limited by state law. Not available in all states. Three days after Maurice is murdered, on a cloudy gray morning, the town of Hazleton unites to support the chiverellas and say goodbye to Maurice.

[Carmen Marie Radke]

I remember the church being packed with people, the viewings, the lines were out to funeral doors home.

[Marissa Pinson]

Can you describe for us what the funeral was like? Yes.

[Ronald Ciavarella]

We had some private time with Maurice as she laid in her white casket and wearing her first holy communion dress. And that was very traumatic. That was horrifying.

[Mark Barron]

We see a headline where it says farewell kiss from mother as coffin closed. That right there really hits home that a mother is giving her nine year old child a farewell kiss. Parents aren't supposed to outlive their children.

[Carmen Marie Radke]

The day of the funeral was a long, sad day. It was hard to see her parents grieving like that. The biggest question is why? Why would somebody do this terrible thing to Maurice?

[Marissa Pinson]

Investigators look for similar cases in nearby jurisdictions. One case immediately stands out.

[Devin Brutoski]

There was a cold case that had occurred in October of 1962 in Bristol involving Carol Ann Docherty. She was a nine year old girl who was found beaten and sexually assaulted and strangled to death in a upstairs balcony of St. Mark's Church in Bristol.

[Lieutenant]

The Bristol high school basketball team played a basketball game the night of 17th March 1964.

[Devin Brutoski]

There was that possibility that maybe somebody who had been at that basketball game could have been responsible for the Carol Ann Docherty homicide. And now struck again in Hazelton. All of the students from Bristol who were absent the following day and who would have been of age to have committed such a crime, they were questioned, their whereabouts were confirmed. The fans that had attended the game who drove separately from the buses that were taking fans to and from Bristol, they were contacted, they were checked, they were cleared.

[Marissa Pinson]

The Docherty case is unsolved and police can't link it to the murder in Hazelton. Police then look at the people closest to Maurice.

[Devin Brutoski]

Her father had owned a little grocery store called the Little Market. Somewhere in the customer group could have been a person of interest.

[Lieutenant]

They asked him if he had any trouble with anybody at their grocery store on alter Street. And Mr. Ciavarella stated that there was a person that owed him some money and that he hadn't seen him in a while. And they had an issue where he had to remove him from the store.

[Marissa Pinson]

At one point, six days after Maurice is laid to rest, police speak to the man mentioned by Maurice's father.

[Lieutenant]

Bruce Hildebrand, had a lot of problems with alcohol.

[Devin Brutoski]

Supposedly he had passed some bad checks to the father. And investigators wanted him to submit to a polygraph. And on March 30th of 1964, Mr. Hildebrand called up the state police barracks and said, I don't want to give a polygraph. I want to make a confession and tell you what I did. Bruce Hildebrand was a person characterized as having a bad temper. He liked to drink. He lived close by to where the chiverellas had resided.

[Marissa Pinson]

29 year old Hildebrand has already told police he has something to say about the nine year old's murder.

[Devin Brutoski]

The police send a car over to his house. He voluntarily gets into the car, voluntarily, says, take me to the barracks. And it's there that he gives a confession of sorts to the police.

[Lieutenant]

He was reciting what he did and what happened during the crime. The report states that he's crying, he's sobbing, he's very remorseful.

[Devin Brutoski]

He talks about having stolen his sister's car and coming across Maurice as she's walking to school. And him offering her a ride and her accepting the ride. He provides a detail that says she was going to mass that day. However, he didn't take her to school, didn't take her to mass. He takes her to this abandoned dump.

[Marissa Pinson]

It's clear to investigators, however, that Hildebrand has been drinking. And that's not the only problem.

[Devin Brutoski]

He said that he strangled her to death utilizing her scarf. But it turned out that she had been strangled utilizing her own shoelaces.

[Lieutenant]

Typically, you don't release all the information to the newspaper. So that people have the intricate details of the case. Therefore, the only thing he was providing was the general information that was released to the public.

[Marissa Pinson]

Hildebrand ultimately recants his confession.

[Devin Brutoski]

And he chalked it up to being in a state of depression at the time. And that he figured what better way to be done away with than to admitting to this crime. And that would be the end of him. The original investigators in this case did a fantastic job of trying to leave no stone unturned. They were tracking down known sex offenders in the area.

[Marissa Pinson]

In the middle of their investigation, one person stands out.

[Devin Brutoski]

Harold Nicholas was one of those gentlemen who could have had immoral traits in the past.

[Lieutenant]

The troopers at the time were given the information that Harold Nichols lived near the Chiverella residence and had a sexual deviant past. And that he may have frequented the areas of the stripping where Maurice was found. They interviewed him about some of his indiscretions in the past. They interviewed him about if he had any contact with the Chiverella family.

[Devin Brutoski]

He provided a story that had some inconsistencies, and Police had asked Mr. Nicholas to come voluntarily down to the state police headquarters in Hazleton and submit to a polygraph examination. Mr. Nicholas said that he would, and I believe he was supposed to appear on May 12, 1964, at about 9am however, come 9am on May 12, he doesn't show up.

[Lieutenant]

And we got a report of a vehicle with a dead male in it near the stripping area where Maurice was found. Upon arrival to the scene, troopers identified the person as Harold Nichols, and it appeared that he had committed suicide.

[Devin Brutoski]

And the cause of death was determined to be carbon monoxide poisoning.

[Lieutenant]

The belief was that Harold Nichols could have been the killer because why would he commit suicide prior to coming in for the polygraph? And a lot of troopers believed that it was because he didn't want to have to confess to the crime.

[Devin Brutoski]

Upon the death of Harold Nicholas, the state police collected several hair samples from his person, and they were entered into evidence for further potential use down the road.

[Marissa Pinson]

By the end of 1964, leads in the case have dried up, and. And the case of the girl who left for school and never came home goes cold.

[Ronald Ciavarella]

I know that there was frustration in me. I know there was frustration in my parents, siblings. Well, we want it to be solved.

[Carmen Marie Radke]

My mother and father were both very faithful to their religion. We prayed that we'd find whoever did this.

[Ronald Ciavarella]

I never gave up on Maurice's case.

[Mark Barron]

They didn't know if whoever killed Maurice was still around and waiting to strike again. So four years, that was in the back of their heads. Parents became more protective of their children, so their worlds changed quite a bit. That's how this story became intergenerational.

[Marissa Pinson]

The Ciavarella family suffers another tragedy when Maurice's father dies in 2006.

[Ronald Ciavarella]

Marie when my father passed, it started me thinking of Maurice's case and questions that I've had, like, why am I spending time on the person that murdered Maurice? He's already robbed so much of my conscious life.

[Marissa Pinson]

Then, 43 years after the murder, the investigation was reignited with a major breakthrough.

[Devin Brutoski]

With the advancement of technology. In 2007, our department went ahead and yet again sent out Maurice Ciavarella's clothing. And it was finally in 2007 that they were able to locate seminal fluid on her blouse that she was wearing. From that stain, they were able to obtain a DNA profile for a potential suspect.

[Mark Barron]

We knew about Maurice. We knew all these little details that made her who. Who she was. Decades had Passed. And in Hazelton, the community doesn't give up. We don't forget, we protect our kids.

[Marissa Pinson]

Investigators finally, armed with DNA evidence, entered the sample into a national database.

[Devin Brutoski]

In 2007, the suspect profile was checked against CODIS and there was no match. Since there was no match in codis, either the individual had been deceased for quite some time, or they were never mandated to submit to a DNA sample as required by law.

[Marissa Pinson]

Once again, the investigation grinds to a halt. In 2014, Ronald and Carmen lose their mother, Mary.

[Ronald Ciavarella]

My mother shared something with us that astounded us by way of, I don't understand this. I don't know why it happened. I've lost Maurice. I only had her for nine years, but, you know, I'm so happy and so blessed to have had her for nine years. That mindset of a blessing. And looking at the positive aspects of Maurice's life versus all the horror that.

[Marissa Pinson]

Occurred three years later, there's a new investigator and new hope.

[Devin Brutoski]

I was assigned the case in the fall of 2017 about upon the retirement of the then lead investigator, Corporal McAndrew. And when you see the massive size that this case file is, there's over 6,000 pages. Corporal McAndrew had been working potentially on acquiring this new technology where we could take a DNA sample, send it to a company and they would be able to provide us with a snapshot, if you would, of. Of an individual's ethnicity. The DNA wasn't sent out until May of 2018, and the report that we received back wasn't received until October of 2018.

[Marissa Pinson]

Just after the 55th anniversary of Marisa's murder. Police released the phenotype sketches to the media.

[Lieutenant]

We had it posted as a 25 year old, a 40 year old and a 60 year old.

[Devin Brutoski]

The potential suspect was of Caucasian heritage, had either brown or black hair, with a high probability, had green or hazel eyes.

[Lieutenant]

Therefore, we could present that to the public and maybe jog anybody's memory of what this person looked like and what they may look like now as compared to at the time of the murder.

[Devin Brutoski]

There were several tips that were received, I would say probably in upwards of around 30 that our department received.

[Lieutenant]

Corporal Barron ran down every tip that we received. However, none of those tips panned out and we were unable to identify any new suspect from that profile. And the disappointment was there, but we continued to move forward.

[Marissa Pinson]

That forward movement comes in an email to Lt. Brutoski from an unlikely source. Eric Schubert is a forensic genetic genealogist.

[Eric Schubert]

It was February of 2020 and I was reading up on cold cases in Pennsylvania. And being that Hazleton is only about 80 miles from where I go to school, it was one of the first cases that came up online. When I was looking after reading the Maurice Chevrolet article, I just could not get this article off my mind. So I immediately said, okay, what if I just send them an email saying, hey, I've read that you were trying this. I'm not trying to step on anyone's toes, but here's who I am. Here's what I've been doing. If you think there's a chance I can help out with your case, I would love to do it. I was selling myself as a volunteer who wanted to help.

[Devin Brutoski]

We met with Eric Schubert down at his college campus at a coffee shop, and he came prepared like it was a job interview. He had a resume. He had printouts of all of his accolades detailing the successes that he had had through his very short career. After the meeting, Lt. Brutawski made some phone calls, and the police departments that he reached out to said, eric Schubert's the real deal. Our sample, our DNA profile, had been uploaded by this company to a publicly available genealogical database, and we provided that information to Mr. Shubert, who then started trying to put together family trees.

[Eric Schubert]

When I first got the DNA results, what really struck me was the top match was very distant.

[Lieutenant]

And with that information, we were a bit worried that we would never get a relationship to the Hazleton area.

[Marissa Pinson]

Eric Schubert, though, is just getting started.

[Eric Schubert]

I basically made a very calculated genealogical decision to focus on one side of the family that I thought could be promising as opposed to the other. And I was just digging into that family, digging into records. And as I did that, what happened was I actually ran into this large family that had Italian lineage.

[Devin Brutoski]

Eric contacted me and said, hey, I found a pretty close relationship to the Hazleton area with this name of Paul Meno. To know that we're potentially getting close, it feels real good.

[Eric Schubert]

I really enjoy finding. Finding the answer to a mystery, finding all those little pieces of evidence where in the end, you sort of have that aha moment where all your work comes together into an answer.

[Lieutenant]

When Mr. Shubert provided us with the Palmeno name, we knew that they were from the Weatherly area, which was just outside of Hazleton. We became very excited in thinking this could be our break in the case.

[Marissa Pinson]

Discovering the name Palmeno is just the first step for Barron and Schubert.

[Eric Schubert]

Once we started narrowing in on this very large Italian family that had Hazelton connections, what we really had to do was Just make sure that we had everyone, you know, documented genealogically.

[Devin Brutoski]

I went ahead and I did some research on the Palmeno family, and I located a family member who had informed me that he had a detailed family tree for the Palmeno family and it's off branches, and he was willing to provide that to me.

[Eric Schubert]

And that allowed us to say, okay, we have this family, we have all these people. Now it's time to get some DNA samples and see if we're on the right track.

[Devin Brutoski]

The more DNA we have, the better off we're going to be. And we could fine tune our direction that we have to take this investigation.

[Marissa Pinson]

Barron asks officers to help him speed up DNA collection. James Quiroz is a trooper with the Pennsylvania State Police.

[James Quiroz]

I just remember Corporal Barron coming up to my desk and asking me if I'd be willing to assist him with the Chiverilla investigation. Corporal Barron and I were going out collecting DNA samples to include or exclude people. When we would get the results from those DNA samples, we would send them to the wiz kid and. And he would tell us which way we needed to go.

[Eric Schubert]

After that, there were times where I would say, okay, we have 30 people, and for us to move forward, here's what we need to do. So that would be an occasion where we might pause for two weeks and regroup and think about what the best plan is and then come back to it and say, okay, we're gonna ask for this sample.

[Devin Brutoski]

I think we worked very well together. I think we all knew each other's limitations at times, but at the end of the day, it was a good combination of good old fashioned police work, of us going knocking on doors, building rapports with people, and having them being willing to offer cooperation.

[Marissa Pinson]

Are you tired of yo yo dieting and endless weight loss struggles? Imagine a solution that actually works, tailored just for you. That's where weight loss by hers comes in. Revolutionizing women's health care with personalized, affordable treatment plans delivered right to your door. Hers offers a holistic approach, combining cutting edge medication with comprehensive support. Their program includes access to compounded GLP1 weekly injections featuring the same active ingredients as Ozempic and Wegovy, or oral medication kits, all designed to help you achieve your goals. Getting started is simple. Just complete an online intake form and a licensed medical provider will determine the best plan for you. If prescribed, your program includes medication, ongoing care, and online support, all at one surprisingly low cost. Here's the best part. Weight loss plans through hers are incredibly affordable. Compounded GLP1 injections. Start at just $165 per month with a 12 month plan paid up front for new subscribers. No hidden fees, no membership costs, just straightforward effective care. So if you've been struggling on your weight loss journey, it's time to discover an option that truly works for you. Start your initial free online Visit [e-mail] Coldcase that's F O R H E-R S.com Coldcase for your personalized weight loss treatment options. Fourhers.com Coldcase hers weight loss is not available everywhere. Compounded products are not FDA approved or verified for safety, effectiveness or quality. Prescription required restrictions apply. Wegovia and Ozempic are not compounded. Actual price depends on product and plan purchased. I don't know about you, but I like keeping my money where I can see it. Unfortunately, traditional big wireless carriers also seem to like keeping my money too. After years of overpaying for wireless, I finally got fed up with crazy high bills, bogus fees and free perks that actually cost more in the long run and switched to Mint Mobile. My husband and I can get annual unlimited data for $50 a month, just $25 per line. Say goodbye to those jaw dropping monthly bills and unexpected overages. Mint Mobile offers premium wireless plans starting at just $15 a month with high speed data and unlimited talk and text on the nation's largest 5G network. Plus you can use your own phone and bring your number along with all your contacts. Right now Mint Mobile is offering an Incredible deal. Get three months of premium wireless service for just $15 a month. That's right, you can ditch overpriced wireless and start saving today. Make the switch to Mint Mobile and keep your hard earned cash where it belongs in your pocket. If you like your money, Mint Mobile is for you. Shop [e-mail] coldcase that's mintmobile.com cold case upfront payment of $45 for 3 month 5 gigabyte plan required equivalent to $15 a month new customer offer for first 3 months only then full price plan options available, taxes and fees extra. See Mitt Mobile for details. After more than a year of collecting data and narrowing their search in the summer of 2021, investigators get a break.

[Devin Brutoski]

Eric was very confident that we were moving down the right path to solving this case.

[Eric Schubert]

We got a break in the case in the form of some publicly uploaded DNA samples in these few families that we had narrowed it down to. And we narrowed it down to sets.

[Devin Brutoski]

Of brothers, four potential individuals who were all related. Three individuals were deceased, one individual was.

[James Quiroz]

Still alive Talking with the district attorney that was assisting us with the investigation, we had to get a DNA sample from the one remaining brother that was alive. Had we not gotten a DNA sample from that brother, it was believed that we did not have enough probable cause to exhumed the body of the other brothers that were deceased. So, in essence, all our chips were in the middle of the table. When we went after the last DNA sample.

[Devin Brutoski]

Trooper Kiros and I went down and met with the living individual, spoke with him. He was willing to provide a DNA sample. We obtained that DNA sample and sent that sample off to our DNA lab for processing. The results of that DNA test did not match the suspect profile that had been established in 2007.

[James Quiroz]

So at this time, Corporal Barron and I and Shubert were ecstatic. We had it narrowed down to two people.

[Devin Brutoski]

One brother had died several years ago. The other brother had died back in 1980. The brother that had died in 1980 had no known children, had no widow, nothing of that sort.

[Marissa Pinson]

One of the brothers emerges as a suspect.

[James Quiroz]

Corporal Barron and I did criminal history checks on both brothers, Found that one of the brothers had an extensive criminal history to include a sexual assault that occurred in 1974 that was similar to the sexual assault and homicide which had occurred in 1964.

[Devin Brutoski]

The team that we had assembled around us, we would have our conversations and. And I think in our heart of hearts, we knew that there was one individual that was gonna be our suspect.

[Marissa Pinson]

That man's name is James Paul fort.

[Lieutenant]

We were 99% sure that James Fort was gonna be our suspect in this homicide. When we got to the point where we had the two brothers left, we had the chiverellas come into the office, and we spoke to them about where we were, and they were elated.

[Marissa Pinson]

The problem for investigators now is that both men on the list, Frank and James Fort, are deceased.

[James Quiroz]

We get down to the two Fort brothers, One of whom was cremated. The other was buried. Corporal Barron and I focused on the brother that was cremated and went to that individual's widowed wife and requested any material she may have had that was left over from his demise. She provided us two hairbrushes and a razor that we were able to extract DNA from. Sent that to the lab, and his DNA sample excluded him as a suspect. For the known sample matched.

[Eric Schubert]

So after about a year and a half of work, and after all those results, we came down to the one brother, one person, James Paul Fort.

[Devin Brutoski]

To those who knew James Fort on a personal level, the way that they explained him was that he was a very nice person and that they would never have thought him to be capable of committing this type of crime. He was an army veteran that served during the Cold War. He was a bartender.

[Marissa Pinson]

Police discovered that James Fort, who died of a heart attack more than 40 years earlier, had a dark side.

[Lieutenant]

The more we researched in the James Fort, we actually discovered a report from the 1970s where he was involved in a sexual assault of a woman.

[James Quiroz]

There are a lot of similarities to the sexual assault in 1974 to the homicide that occurred in 1964. Both victims had been abducted on Alter street, taken out to the strippings. They had been struck about their head and face area.

[Marissa Pinson]

Still, one hurdle remains for investigators.

[Eric Schubert]

Okay, we have enough evidence here to show that it is probably him. However, he's been dead since 1980 and he does not have children. So how can we get his DNA?

[Lieutenant]

We met with the district attorney's office. We obtained a search Warrant to exhume Mr. Fort's body in order to extract DNA from his body and prove once and for all that he was the person responsible for for Maurice's death. At the exhumation, we removed the tomb, brought it into a garage area, and the cemetery workers were having a hard time with the steel case that entombed the actual coffin itself. At one point, they were able to break open the metal tomb. They only broke it open about 2 inches. And we heard a loud metal clank. Everybody was looking around to see what had happened. And we looked down and there was about a 6 to 8 inch by 4 inch crucifix that somehow made itself out of the 2 inch slit in the metal casing that surrounded the coffin. And we all looked at each other and thought to ourselves, that's a sign that we have this guy and this is going to be him.

[Marissa Pinson]

On February 3, 2022, nearly 58 years after Maurice Ciarrella's murder, investigators get the answer they've been searching for.

[Lieutenant]

We received the results from our DNA lab, and James Paul Fort matched the DNA profile from the semen stain on Maurice Ciavarella's jacket.

[Devin Brutoski]

We're always told not to get attached to a case, but you can't help it. And it's a vivid memory for everybody who lived through this. And it's a vivid memory for everybody who grew up in this area.

[Carmen Marie Radke]

I was numb because I knew all this was going on. I knew why we were there and didn't want to look at this person's face.

[Devin Brutoski]

There was a sense of, I think, pride in that room.

[Ronald Ciavarella]

I'll never stop praising the Pennsylvania State Police for the work they've done on Maurice's case for the last 58 years. Amazing. I don't hate the individual person did what he did, and it's up to a higher power than me to decide where it goes from there. I feel sorrow for his family for what they're enduring right now. I wouldn't wish that on anyone.

[Carmen Marie Radke]

I want people to know how wonderful my parents were, showing us that hate was not the way to go. Hate to them would have just destroyed us, and we just had love for each other and that helped us get through all those years.

[Devin Brutoski]

At Pluto tv, we're celebrating Black History Month with our curated collection of black content all streaming for free. Find groundbreaking films including Selma, Django, Unchained.

[Marissa Pinson]

Ali and Coach Carter.

[Ronald Ciavarella]

You have an incredible gift up here.

[Devin Brutoski]

Gripping series like Power and the Game, Next level comedies, music video channels and more. Brilliant black entertainment is intentionally curated and all free this month and always on Pluto tv.

[James Quiroz]

Stream now pay Never get the Angel.

[Marissa Pinson]

Reese Special at McDonald's. Now let's break it down. My favorite barbecue sauce, American cheese, crispy bacon, pickles, onions and a sesame seed bun, of course. And don't forget the fries and the drinks. Sound good? Ba da ba ba ba.

[Devin Brutoski]

I participate in restaurants for a limited time.

[Marissa Pinson]

Get the Angel Reese Special at McDonald's. Now let's break it down. My favorite barbecue sauce, American cheese, crispy bacon, pickles, onions and a sesame seed bun of course. And don't forget the fries and a drink. Sound good.

[Devin Brutoski]

I participate in restaurants for a limited time.