Cold Case Files: Dead West - Murder In The City of Saints

Podcast Information:

• Title: Cold Case Files
• Host: Paula Barros
• Episode: Dead West: Murder In The City of Saints
• Release Date: May 27, 2025

Introduction

In the gripping episode titled "Dead West: Murder In The City of Saints," Paula Barros delves into the harrowing cold case of Sherry Black, a beloved bookstore owner whose brutal murder shook the serene community of South Salt Lake City, Utah. This detailed investigation not only uncovers the relentless pursuit of justice by dedicated law enforcement but also highlights the profound impact on Sherry's family and community.

The Crime: Sherry Black's Murder

On a chilly afternoon, [04:34] Earl Black recounts the tragic discovery:

"I walked in the shop and hollered Sherry. And she didn't appear... She had a pair of scissors sticking out of her belly."

Sherry Black, a passionate book lover and respected member of her community, was found brutally murdered in her family-run bookstore. The scene was gruesome, with extensive blood evidence indicating a violent struggle.

Initial Investigation

Detective Duane Ruth, then deputy chief of the South Salt Lake City Police Department, responded to the emergency call [08:51]:

"As you walk in, it's a little bit of a labyrinth. Books everywhere... The human in me cried. It was a horrific sight to see."

The initial response focused on securing the scene and collecting vital evidence, including a large pair of bloody shears, broken glass, and partial fingerprints. The absence of a clear motive complicated the early stages of the investigation.

Suspicion Falls on the Husband

Earl Black, Sherry's husband, became the primary suspect due to the immediate assumption that a spouse is often the first to be considered in such cases [10:14]:

"The husband's always number one suspect... I'd seen enough movies and read enough books."

However, surveillance footage corroborated Earl's alibi, eliminating him from suspicion [10:27] and shifting the focus of the investigation.

Family and Community Impact

Sherry's family, including her daughter Heidi Miller and granddaughter Courtney Hawkes, grappled with the loss and the ensuing investigation. Heidi reflects on her mother's quiet strength and her untimely death [08:31]:

"She was strong and courageous. I wish she would have been more fearful and a little more careful to protect herself."

The Miller family's connection to the prominent local business community, particularly through Larry H. Miller's legacy, amplified public interest and media attention around the case [11:04].

Case Goes Cold

Despite extensive efforts, including DNA and fingerprint analysis, the case stalled after three years [22:34]. Detective Duane Ruth expressed frustration over the lack of viable leads:

"We spent a lot of time trying to figure out if anything was taken from that store. There wasn't any money missing... You wonder, who, why?"

As tips dwindled and investigative avenues closed, the case felt increasingly stagnant, leaving Sherry's family desperate for answers.

Breakthrough with Investigative Genetic Genealogy

Seven and a half years later, in March 2018, the investigation took a pivotal turn with the introduction of investigative genetic genealogy. Detective Ben Pender spearheaded this innovative approach, leveraging DNA databases to trace potential relatives of the perpetrator [23:49].

"We know that there are multiple different databases people will submit their DNA to... we can trace back to our suspect."

This method led to the identification of Adam Antonio Spencer Durbrough, whose DNA matched evidence from the crime scene [26:30]. Extensive surveillance and forensic analysis connected Adam to the murder, culminating in his arrest.

Confession and Arrest

In a tense interrogation, Adam Durbo (later identified as Adam Durbrough) confessed to the murder [29:55]:

"I was so angry, and I just lashed out... I hit her in the back of the head."

His admission provided closure to the Black family and the community, revealing that personal frustrations and unaddressed emotional turmoil led to the tragic act [32:11].

Sentencing and Aftermath

Adam Durbo was swiftly sentenced to life without the possibility of parole [34:10]. The Black family expressed a mix of relief and lingering pain, with Heidi Miller emphasizing the importance of advocacy and remembrance [35:11]:

"It was a huge relief to know he's done... that gives me comfort."

Detective Ruth reflected on the significance of the case, acknowledging the collective effort that led to justice [34:58]:

"I do believe justice was served... it's a privilege to have been part of witnessing people that come together for a greater good."

Sherry Black's Legacy

In the wake of the case, Sherry Black's family championed legislation to support the use of investigative genetic genealogy, ensuring that her story would aid in solving future cold cases [35:36].

"I want people to remember my mom and my mom's story because I want them to know that they can have an impact on unsolved crimes... they can be genetic witnesses."

Through advocacy and community engagement, Sherry's legacy continues to inspire and facilitate breakthroughs in criminal investigations.

Conclusion

"Dead West: Murder In The City of Saints" masterfully intertwines a tragic personal loss with the relentless pursuit of justice, showcasing the transformative power of advanced forensic techniques and the enduring strength of a grieving family. Sherry Black's story serves as a poignant reminder of the impact one life can have on a community and the importance of never giving up on finding the truth.

Notable Quotes:

• Earl Black [05:27]: "Knocked over. You're not thinking straight... I’ll never forget it."

• Heidi Miller [08:31]: "I wish she would have been more fearful and a little more careful to protect herself."

• Detective Duane Ruth [17:29]: "We have suspect DNA... but there was no match in the database."

• Heidi Miller [35:11]: "It was a huge relief to know he's done, he's put away, and he won't ever hurt another person."

This comprehensive summary encapsulates the emotional journey, investigative challenges, and ultimate resolution of Sherry Black's murder, highlighting key moments and insights shared throughout the episode.