← Cold Case Files
Loading summary
Transcript82 lines
- [00:00]
Narrator/Advertiser
If your dog could talk, they'd warn you about what's lurking in their bowl. Mass produced kibble isn't just unappetizing, it could be a crime against canine health. Mysterious byproducts, unpronounceable preservatives, and who knows what fillers. Sounds more like evidence from a crime scene than dinner. Ollie is here to crack the case on pet nutrition with fresh human grade meals made with the highest quality ingredients. No mystery meats, no artificial junk, just real minimally processed food made in US Kitchens. It's the kind of clean eating that keeps tails wagging and noses sniff for more. With five fresh protein first recipes like Beef with Sweet Potatoes and Turkey with Blueberries, your pup won't have to wonder what's in their food ever again. Because when it comes to their health, the only mystery should be where you hide the treats. Dogs deserve the best and that means fresh, healthy food. Head to ollie.com truecrime tell them all about your dog and use code trucrime to get 60% off your welcome kit when you subscribe today. Plus, they offer a happiness guarantee on the first box, so if you're not completely satisfied, you'll get your money back. That's O l l I e do and enter code truecrime to get 60% off your first box.
- [01:09]
Host/Interviewer
Hi I Survived listeners. I'm Marissa Pinson and if you're enjoying this show, I just want to remind you that episodes of I Survived as well as the A and E classic podcast, Cold Case Files, City Confidential and American justice are all available ad free on the new A and E Crime and Investigation channel on Apple Podcasts and Apple plus for just 4.99amonth or 39.99 a year. And now onto the show. This episode contains subject matter that may be disturbing to some listeners. Listener discretion is advised.
- [01:40]
Kay (Survivor)
He put a knife in my throat and was basically trying to rip my larynx out.
- [01:45]
Johnny (Survivor)
Real people I knew the clock was ticking on getting an infection that would go throughout my body and ultimately kill.
- [01:54]
Host/Interviewer
Me who faced death.
- [01:57]
Scott (Survivor)
I was more or less waiting to die and it seemed like it was.
- [02:02]
Host/Interviewer
Taking forever and live to tell how.
- [02:05]
Kay (Survivor)
At that point I made up my mind I was gonna fight. I was coming out of there. I was gonna get my son out of that house.
- [02:11]
Host/Interviewer
This is I survived. It's September 1995 in Laurel, Delaware. Kay lives with her son in a mobile home park.
- [02:27]
Kay (Survivor)
My son and I lived alone. I was a single parent. He was 12. I was a full time insurance agent. I worked a couple of side jobs. It was a small community. Everybody knew everybody. I came home from work and helped my son with his homework. While I was cooking dinner, I put Nick to bed. Around 9:00 o', clock, 9:30, Kay went to bed. About two hours later, Nick woke up and came out and said that there was a man trying to get in his window. And of course, I reassured him that nobody was trying to get in. There's always people on the streets. So I wasn't concerned. I told Nick that if he would feel safer, he could come in and sleep with me. So we went to bed and I cuddled him up and we went to sleep. About an hour later, I heard somebody knocking on the door. So I got up and I went to the door to see who was there. I stood up on my tiptoes and I looked out the window and I saw a man standing there. He was kind of kicking at the ground. They say people have an instinct, and I had. Sometimes I feel an instinct, but nothing like I did that night. When I looked out the window, it was just like looking at the devil. I mean, I could. You could just feel the evil through the door. He said his name was Jeff Wilson. He said that he had broke down and he needed to use my phone. So I said, well, I'm not going to let you in. If you want, I can make a phone call for you. So he asked me to do that and he gave me a telephone number to call. I dialed the number and the man said that he didn't know a Jeff Wilson. So I went back to the door and told him what he had told me, that he didn't know Jeff Wilson. He cursed and kind of kicked at the ground and started to walk away. When I saw him walking away, I. I was still a little frightened. I was afraid he would come back to the door. So I watched him and I watched until he crossed the street and was out of sight. And I went to the phone and I called the Delaware State Police. And I thought maybe he was drunk.
- [04:25]
Host/Interviewer
Kay went back to bed where her son was still sleeping.
- [04:29]
Kay (Survivor)
I was awakened again. I heard the front door slam and it slammed really loud. And I thought it was my boyfriend coming in because he'll go to Maryland hunting and he goes very early in the morning. I thought I was just stopping in to have coffee, so I got up and I was just kind of rubbing my eyes, going out, expecting to see my boyfriend there. As I was walking past my washer and dryer, I looked up and I saw a man crouched down beside my Trash can in the kitchen and he had a butcher knife in his hand. As soon as I saw him, I screamed and I turned to run back to my room and I thought if I could get there and get the door closed. But before I could even get all the way turned around, he had jumped up and grabbed my arm. He was just barking orders and who else is in the house? And I told him my son was in the house.
- [05:17]
Host/Interviewer
Kay's 12 year old son was asleep in her room.
- [05:21]
Kay (Survivor)
The thoughts that I were having was basically just how to get him out of the house, give him what he wants, get him out of here, make sure my son's safe, I don't want him hurt. He took me in the living room, had me sit down. I was saying, look, if I have a checkbook in my purse, you can have my checks, you can have my car, take all of it and just leave. And he said, I know I can have anything I want. I didn't feel like he was there to rob me. I really felt like he was there to rape me. And I was just very determined that I would die before that happened. I was also at the same time looking around the room to see what I could use for a weapon. But he wouldn't let me close to anything.
- [06:01]
Host/Interviewer
The man tried to force Kay into her son's empty bedroom.
- [06:05]
Kay (Survivor)
At first I tried to block to go in there and he said, just come in here and sit down, I just want to talk to you and I'm going to leave in just a few minutes, you'll be okay. So I did. I went in and I sat on the bed. He saw that there was $5 on the stand in my son's room. And he said, whose money is that? And I said, that's my son's money here under cutting grass. He said, oh, well, I can't take that. That wouldn't be right. I have two kids too. And he told me he had a son and a daughter. He said that I was going to let him tie me up. And I was determined that wasn't happening. So I jumped up off the bed and at that point I made up my mind I was going to fight. I was coming out of there, I was going to get my son out of that house. If I couldn't get him out, I jumped up and at that point he reached for me with his left hand and with the right hand started stabbing the knife at me. And this voice in my head was saying, break it, break it. So I just reached with my left hand and just grabbed the top part of the knife and just twisted it sideways. And when I did, it broke off even with the handle. And I was shocked. I couldn't believe that the knife had broke. I took the blade and I threw it behind my son's bed thinking he would have to go get it. And he was just kind of, he hadn't realized that I broke it yet. And he was stabbing at me with the wooden part of the handle and he had actually gotten cut. And he said, isn't that something? I brought the knife and I got cut. He jumped over the bed when he realized the blade was gone to get the blade. And when he did, I ran out of the bedroom and I ran for the phone and I grabbed it and I got the first number dialed. I dialed nine and he was back in and grabbed the phone from me and hung it up. He was trying to drag me back to the bedroom and I wasn't going to go. So when we got to the door jamb, I just locked one leg around the door and. And I took my shoulder and I just thrust it into his sternum as hard as I could and knocked the air out of him. And I had him pinned to the wall.
- [07:56]
Host/Interviewer
Kay's 12 year old son was asleep in his mother's room.
- [08:00]
Kay (Survivor)
I started screaming for my son and I was yelling, nick, Nick, get up, get out of bed, come on, get out of the house. Thinking if I could just hold him. I'm sorry. He said, let me go and let me tie you up or I'm gonna call the other guy in that's outside and he's gonna kill your son. So I knew I couldn't fight two men. It was a split second decision that I had to let him tie me up.
- [08:25]
Host/Interviewer
Kay's attacker took her into her son's empty bedroom and tied her up.
- [08:30]
Kay (Survivor)
After my hands were tied, he told me to sit down on the bed. He sat down beside me. Then he started touching me and of course I tried to move away a little bit and that irritated him. He had gone into the kitchen and gotten another knife and he started cutting my clothes off and he tied my shirt around my mouth and I left my jaw out some, thinking I could leave it loose enough to get it off. And when he saw what I was doing, he pulled it tighter. At this point he was really irritated because I wouldn't listen to anything he said. He told me to roll over and put my face into the pillow.
- [09:06]
Host/Interviewer
The intruder sexually assaulted Kay.
- [09:09]
Kay (Survivor)
He said, I'm going to cut you loose before I leave. And when I do. You count to 100 before you get up. So I thought, wow, okay, he is going to let me go. He crawled on my back and he straddled me. And at first I thought he was going to cut the ties on my hands, but instead, he reached and he grabbed me by the hair and he pulled my head back and cut my throat. The first thing I thought was, who's going to take care of my son? Is there enough life insurance? And they say your life flashes before your eyes, and it really does you. You think about all the things you haven't done. Think about all the things you still want to do. After he had started cutting my throat, he tilted my head one way, and then he tilted it the other and started cutting the other side. I was just praying, please let my son be okay. And it was at that point I started saying the Lord's Prayer and I started praying, just let me go. At that point, I just. I didn't want to do it anymore. I just wanted to. I wanted to die. After he cut both sides of my neck, he kind of. He put a knife in my throat and was basically trying to rip my larynx out. And at that point, the knife broke. And I was kind of looking down, I could see the knife in my throat. And he just pulled it out the other side. And he went to the kitchen and he got another knife, and he came back, and that's when he started stabbing me in my back. I was very lucky. He had tied my hands so tight that he had pulled my shoulder blades together, and they had actually made a shield over my vital organs. He continued to stab me probably about 45 times in my back. And then he took the knife and rammed it into my ear, and he turned the knife and cut the bottom part of my ear off. When he had put the knife in the front of my throat, he had caused both my lungs to collapse. I had what they call a sucking chest wound. So I was still able to breathe, but not very well. And my mouth was just filling up with blood. And I was afraid that I was going to choke to death on the blood, so I just started spitting that out into my shirt. He took the knife and he put it in the back of my neck and started pounding it with his fist. And when he did, it went all the way through the front and gave me a tracheotomy. So now I could breathe. But I was thinking, God, you know, am I going to be paralyzed? He was asking me, are you dead yet? And for whatever reason, I was in Shock, I don't know. But I tried to answer him, and I moaned. And when I did that, I realized instantly it was a mistake. Because he started stabbing me again. And I knew he wasn't going to stop until I was dead. He was satisfied that I was dead, so I just laid there. And he got off of my back. And he stood beside me, and he grabbed me by the legs and went to roll me off of the bed. And I'm thinking, I can't try to brace myself or he'll know I'm not dead. So I let him roll me off the bed, and I just stayed limp. And he took a blanket and he just threw it over me. I heard him at the kitchen sink. I assume he was cleaning up. I was fading in and out. And then finally I heard the door close. So I started counting. And when I got to 60, I realized the door hadn't opened back up. So now I had to try to get up. I had to make sure my son was safe. All of my muscles in my neck were cut. My chin was on my chest. My right shoulder had been completely dissected, the muscle away from the bone. But I was able to force myself into a sitting position. And I was able to put my back against the bed. And I leaned sideways, and I just started pushing with everything I had. And I was able to get up. And as soon as I stood up, I started staggering sideways. I walked with my shoulder against the wall all the way out to the living room. And I knocked the phone off the hook into the floor. And as it fell, I did, too. And I was laying beside it, and I couldn't feel my hands, so I tried to dial with my feet. And I dialed the first time, and I heard a squeal. So I knew the call didn't go through. And I tried a second time. I hung the phone up and tried again, and I didn't hear anything. I started to dial the third time, and I just didn't have any more energy. So I rolled over on my stomach and I just laid there. And I was waiting to die. Next thing I know, I heard feet running across the kitchen floor. And I was so happy. I knew Nick was okay. And he came out and he said, mom, are you okay? And I just started moaning. He tried to cut the wires on my hands, and they were too tight. He ran down the steps, and I could hear him beating on the home next to us. The next thing I remember is my neighbors were there. And the mother of the boy who lived next door was trying to cut my hands, the cords on my hands. And when she did, my hands were just so limp. I heard her say, oh, God. She thought I was already dead. I passed out again, and the next thing I remembered was the paramedics coming in.
- [14:20]
Host/Interviewer
Kaye was rushed to the hospital in critical condition. It was 10 years before Kaye's attacker, Mark Eskridge, was arrested. For that entire time, he had been living in the same mobile home park as Kaye.
- [14:34]
Kay (Survivor)
I was surprised to find out that he lived in the same mobile home park, actually only a couple of streets over from where I lived. He attended the same church. He worked with a youth group there. And apparently he had seen me and I hadn't noticed him.
- [14:49]
Host/Interviewer
In order to avoid a lengthy trial, Kay agreed to a plea bargain for a 40 year sentence. The judge overruled the plea bargain and sentenced Eskridge to 777 years in prison.
- [15:02]
Kay (Survivor)
I survived because my son came out and was able to help me to go get the help that I needed. Otherwise, I wouldn't have made it. I survived because I was determined that I was gonna make it. I was gonna come through it. If nothing else, just to make sure that my son was okay.
- [15:27]
Host/Interviewer
We've all done it. Turning to your barista, your hairdresser, or even some random person in the bathroom line for advice you probably should not be unloading on them. They'll nod kindly, maybe even give you a fun perspective. But they aren't therapists. And sometimes what we're going through, whether it's anxiety, relationship struggles, or just feeling stuck, really does need the guidance of someone trained to help. That's where Betterhelp comes in. For over 10 years, they've been helping people connect with licensed therapists online. And with a 4.9 star rating from 1.7 million reviews, it's clear people have found real value in that. What makes it work is that BetterHelp does the matchmaking for you. You fill out a short questionnaire, and their system connects you to a therapist that fits your needs. And if you're not feeling it, you can switch at any time. No awkward goodbyes, no extra cost. And it's so flexible. Sessions are totally online so you can fit therapy in without rearranging the rest of your day. BetterHelp has over 30,000 licensed therapists across the US and with 5 million people already served, it's the largest online therapy platform in the world. At the end of the day, therapy isn't about venting in the group chat. It's about working with someone who's clinically trained to help you navigate life's challenges. And with BetterHelp, you can do it in a way that actually fits your life. As the largest online therapy provider in the world, BetterHelp can provide access to mental health professionals with a diverse variety of Expertise. Find the one with Better Help our listeners get 10% off their first month at betterhelp.com survived. That's betterhelp.com survived.
- [17:01]
Johnny (Survivor)
Parlez to Parli Italiano if you've used Babbel, you would Babbel's conversation based techniques teaches you useful words and phrases to get you speaking quickly about the things you actually talk about in the real world. With lessons handcrafted by over 200 language experts and voiced by real native speakers, Babbel is like having a private tutor in your pocket. Start speaking with Babbel today. Get up to 55% off your Babbel subscription right now at babbel.com wandery spelled B-A-B-B-E-L.com wandery rules and restrictions may apply.
- [17:42]
Advertiser/Promoter
From 1989 to 1995, nurse Kristen Gilbert murdered four of her patients at the Veterans Affairs Medical center in Massachusetts and she suspected of killing dozens more. On Mind of a Monster, a podcast from ID, criminal psychologist Dr. Michelle Ward dives into Kristen Gilbert's twisted mind to try and find out why she killed her patients and how she was able to do it in front of her colleagues. She speaks with detectives, journalists, nurses and victims families to unpack Gilbert's life and crimes on Ward C. Listen to Mind of a Monster the Killer Nurse wherever you get your podcasts.
- [18:32]
Host/Interviewer
It's September 1976 in Mount Hood, Oregon. Johnny has just started a new job in Oregon. He borrows a company car for a sightseeing trip to the mountains.
- [18:43]
Johnny (Survivor)
I was planning on a three day weekend. I was going to go up to Mount Rainier and explore Mount Rainier. I kind of completed what I wanted to do on Mount Rainier and instead of going back out to the highways the way I went, I decided to look for a route through the wilderness straight south to Mount Hood. The roads are windy and dangerous to the point where all of the logging companies that operate in that area don't allow company employees to be alone in a vehicle.
- [19:15]
Host/Interviewer
Dusk was approaching.
- [19:17]
Johnny (Survivor)
I was negotiating a hairpin turn that was on a bridge over a Gulf about 150 or 70ft high. I got over the bridge and as I exited the bridge I came to a portion of the shoulder that was totally washed out to the edge of the road. Immediately as soon as that shoulder was gone, the car started rolling sideways down the hill. It was being thrown from side to side around the car inside. And I knew that I was absolutely in a horrific event.
- [19:51]
Host/Interviewer
Johnny's car rolled down into the 170 foot deep ravine. It landed on a pine tree in the riverbed below.
- [20:00]
Johnny (Survivor)
One of the roots simply went through the windshield. As the car landed, my foot was in the exact place where that root came through and it crushed the foot into the dashboard. And my foot was right here in the crease of that dashboard. I was laying on my stomach on the inside roof of the car, facing the rear of the car near the passenger window. The weight of the car was basically on my foot. I couldn't move. I was pinned. I furiously pulled on my leg, which was extremely painful. I pulled on my shoe. I had just purchased new shoes and I ripped all of the rubber and material away from the shoe except where it was pinned by the car. That's how hard I pulled and how vigorously I tried to remove myself.
- [20:53]
Host/Interviewer
As a practicing nurse, Johnny knew he could bleed to death if he was wounded.
- [20:57]
Johnny (Survivor)
I checked my body for bleeding. I had no bleeders. I was happy to be alive, but knew I probably had really screwed up. I thought about my job. Frankly, it was one of the first things I thought about. I'm probably going to get fired now for doing this.
- [21:13]
Host/Interviewer
Johnny had no means of contacting anyone.
- [21:16]
Johnny (Survivor)
I assumed because I heard cars up above that I would be rescued any minute that evening. I figured someone would just come down the hill and find me because I could see the lights going by up above. The reality is they're crossing a bridge that's on a hairpin turn. They weren't looking down, period.
- [21:36]
Host/Interviewer
Johnny tried to make himself comfortable through the night. Two days passed and still no one came to his rescue.
- [21:44]
Johnny (Survivor)
The first couple of days were pretty tough mentally because I just couldn't figure out why no one was helping me. I knew that I needed to get some water in me. I was fortunate in that where the car landed, I was about 15ft from water. A small river that was still running fairly well.
- [22:07]
Host/Interviewer
Johnny tried for hours to get water from the stream.
- [22:11]
Johnny (Survivor)
I had some camping equipment. I would pull the wire out of the car and tie it to a coffee pot and throw it in the stream 15ft away. And by the time it was got back, it would be spilled over. I used an empty soda can, tried the same thing. Ultimately what I did was use a T shirt wrapped up in some string from the sleeping bag and I would just Throw it into the stream, let it sit a few seconds, bring it back and squeeze it into my mouth.
- [22:46]
Host/Interviewer
Johnny's family and friends were looking for him in the wrong area.
- [22:50]
Johnny (Survivor)
When the sun came up in the morning, I would get some water, wash myself off, drink for a while, and then I would make some notes. The notes that I wrote were very short. I miss you, things like that. It was something that if they found me dead, then at least my family would know that I was thinking of them. What had happened to me in the crash was I had punctured a lung. And within the first week, my eyes started swelling up and I felt my glands. I thought I was getting an infection because my throat was swelling.
- [23:30]
Host/Interviewer
Air from Johnny's punctured lung was causing his throat and eyes to swell.
- [23:34]
Johnny (Survivor)
I could see the lights at night from the cars, and I could see the cars during the day as they passed over the bridge for a real short amount of time. There was one kind of opening in the. In the foliage so that I could. I could get a glimpse of them as they went by. By about the fifth day, I really began to realize that those cars going by can't see me. So then I began a plan, a created a plan to get them to see me or attract attention.
- [24:11]
Host/Interviewer
Although Johnny's foot was pinned, he could still move the rest of his body. He searched the car for items he could use to save himself.
- [24:19]
Johnny (Survivor)
There was string, there was wire. There was masking tape, a mirror. I had my tennis racket. There were things like the tools from the rear of the car. I taped the rear view mirror from the car to my tennis racket. When the sun was visible outside the window of the car, with my left hand, I could practice with the light. And I would flash at birds, I would follow birds. So then when a car came by, I could flash up and down the side of that car very accurately to attract attention. But ultimately that didn't work. It was a disappointment. I didn't get any sense that people could see me at all. Towards the end of the first week, I realized that I would have to get out of that vehicle myself. I knew my foot was dead by then. I had a piece of glass from broken windows and stuff, and I actually forced it into my foot and I didn't have any feeling anymore. The first thing I tried to do was use the tire tool like an axe and swing it at the root. Pine roots are very tough and rubbery, and it would bounce off. I would hit my leg, which was very painful. I had very little vertical Space to operate in. So any movements to the left or right were difficult because when I twisted my body, I would hit the roof or the crushed part of the car. Unfortunately, I couldn't see the area of or the target area because my eyes had swollen up so much because of the air entering my interstitial spaces, because I had punctured a lung in the crash.
- [26:08]
Host/Interviewer
Johnny entered the second week of his ordeal and began fearing for his life.
- [26:13]
Johnny (Survivor)
The wilderness area that I was stuck in gets into the low 40s every night. That part of the country has all animals, which means it has cougars, it has bears, it has wolverines, or whatever nasty animals that are out there. So I was really concerned at night about being met or being visited, I should say, by an animal, a wild animal. I wasn't worried about starving. I knew I could live without food for at least a month or more easily. I was more worried about gangrene. I knew the clock was ticking on getting an infection that would go throughout my body and ultimately kill me. My next thought was to get a hammer, some type of heavy device, and use the tire iron as a chisel. There were numerous shot put sized rocks laying everywhere. They were about three or four feet below me. In older vehicles, the inside fabric on the roof of the car was held in place by spring steel bands. I ripped those out of the roof on one end. I bent over a hook of about 2 inches in diameter. I tied string to that hook, and with that hook and the string, I would put a web around a good sized rock and then grab that string with the hook end. Every time I had one close to the car and started lifting it that four feet, it would just fall out of the net I made. I thought the best way to get a rock inside the car would be to throw my suitcase out there. Finally, I was able to get a rock inside the suitcase. I closed my suitcase with the hook of the tire of the headliner and just brought the suitcase back into the car and I had a rock. The first thing I did was take the tire iron in one hand and take the rock in the other and swing that rock as hard as I could on that tire iron. The tire iron went deep into that root and I could feel how deep it went in. And within a couple of hours I was able to get my foot out and get free. I scrambled out of the car as quickly as I could, got down to the stream and really, really hydrated myself. I drank a lot of water and just sat there for a few minutes in that water, enjoying the Fact that I was out of that vehicle.
- [28:47]
Host/Interviewer
He climbs out of the ravine onto the road.
- [28:50]
Johnny (Survivor)
After I got up, I sat on the road for probably 15 or 20 minutes. And sure enough, a one of the construction trucks that had been going by me for a couple of weeks stopped and I got out on the road and flagged him down and told him that I had been down stuck in that ravine for over two weeks. I needed medical attention right away.
- [29:13]
Host/Interviewer
The truck driver took Johnny to the hospital where he was reunited with his family.
- [29:18]
Johnny (Survivor)
My girlfriend was just totally elated and happy and weeping and everybody was, you know, they were going through hell not knowing where I was.
- [29:30]
Host/Interviewer
Johnny's foot was amputated and he now wears a prosthetic limb.
- [29:35]
Johnny (Survivor)
After about three years of being an amputee, I began to get more active. I moved to Utah and got into cross country ski racing. And then I moved to Kansas and took up triathlon. I've done the Antarctica marathon. I won the world triathlon championships in 1998. And now I really focus the bulk of my time on providing handicapped sports for others. I believe I survived because one, I had the will to do it. I had the educational background, I had the training. And I had some luck in ending up in a place that had the natural resources available to me so that I could use my skills and take advantage of them.
- [30:22]
Host/Interviewer
Finding the one can feel impossible. And in today's world, it's even harder. False profiles, inaccurate pictures, incompatibilities, ghosting on dates. Is this sounding familiar? But if you're ready to make your move to a new place, it doesn't have to feel like dating. All it takes is a simple search on apartments.com to find your perfect match. Whether you're looking for a three bedroom condo downtown, a two bedroom duplex in a quiet neighborhood, a cozy studio in a walkable city, or even a single family home in a cul de sac, you can find a place that checks all the right boxes. So whichever stage of life you're in, settle down in your perfect home by using apartments.com. no more swiping and awkward first dates. Make it easier to get a place that gets you. Visit apartments.com, the place to find a place.
- [31:13]
Narrator/Promoter
Chicago, March 2, 1976. A savage double murder rocks the city. Two young lives snuffed out in their prime. And the killer, a privileged rich kid caught within four days only to walk free through a web of influence and power. For four years, the case gathered dust. The truth buried under the web of money, drugs and corruption. Until an unlikely hero emerged former rock musician turned star prosecutor who refused to let the justice slip away. Together with his determined partner, they dared to resurrect the case that Chicago forgot. Now, for the first time, step inside the investigation that brought a killer to trial. Convergence, the explosive new true crime book by Jonathan Dixon and Greg Owen from 26th Street Books. Convergence takes you deep inside one of Chicago's most shocking cases. Follow the evidence, witness the trial, see justice unfold. Convergence available now on Amazon and wherever books are sold.
- [32:14]
Advertiser/Promoter
Did you know that parents rank financial literacy as the number one most difficult life skill to teach? Meet Greenlight, the debit card and money app for families. With Greenlight, you can send money to kids quickly, set up chores, automate allowance, and keep an eye on your kids spending with real time notifications. Kids learn to earn, save and spend wisely. And parents can rest easy knowing their kids are learning about money. With guardrails in place. Try Greenlight Risk free today@greenlight.com wondery It's.
- [32:47]
Host/Interviewer
January 1994 in Rockland County, New York. Scott and his friend Michael are college freshmen.
- [32:55]
Scott (Survivor)
I was 18 years old at the time. Michael was my best friend. We had actually met as kids on a little League field, so we had known each other since we were approximately about 8 years old. We were pretty much inseparable.
- [33:08]
Host/Interviewer
Scott and Michael were at a shopping mall.
- [33:11]
Scott (Survivor)
We noticed an individual lounging on the back of the car next to where we had parked. As we started approaching the Jeep, this individual started to approach us, and pretty much when he came eye to eye with us, he looked us dead in the eye, put his head down and continued walking. And I remember Michael saying to me, that seems kind of odd. We got into the Jeep, and as I went with my left hand to reach across to grab the seatbelt, the door opened up and the next thing I knew, I had a gun shoved in against my side. We never saw it coming, never saw him turn around, come back to the car. And all of a sudden I'm looking down and I see this gun shoved in against my side. And I'm thinking to myself, is this really happening? I was directed to get in the back of the Jeep. He told us he was going to take the Jeep and he was just going to tie us up long enough for him to get away because he didn't want to get caught.
- [34:07]
Host/Interviewer
The man told Michael to start driving.
- [34:10]
Scott (Survivor)
He was taking us in areas where I never even Knew in my 18 years of living in the county. We were both scared. Michael was scared, I was scared, and I Decided to ask questions. I asked him how old he was and where he was from, and he told me he was 23, and he told me he was from Brooklyn. The information that he was given wasn't information that you would give someone because you wanted to get away at that point in time. Going through my head was like, we're gonna die, that this isn't going to end pretty. He started taking us from to one destination where they were renovating an old house, and he made us pull in. And then when he saw that there were people there, he made us turn around. We went to a second destination, and in this second destination, there was new construction going on. And again, he saw people there and made us turn around. Michael was trying to be as calm as possible, but you could see that he was jittery and that he was scared, as was I. This is something you hear on the news or you see in a TV program. You never, ever think that this is going to be you being 18 years old at the time, there's so much life ahead of you. You're just thinking of the future. You're never, ever waking up in the morning and thinking, today might be the day I'm going to die. It was just a sick feeling because all I could think about at the time was my mother and thinking, oh, my God, she's going to be so worried when I'm not home for dinner. I continued to ask more and more questions how he knew the area and such, and he was very free with giving me the information. The more and more information that was being given, you can tell that this was very, very well planned out by this person. There was no good intentions. There was no letting us go. This was being done for a reason. This was being done to steal the jeep and to kill us. The whole time that we're driving, the gun is against Michael. It's being held low so that anybody, any passersby, can't see it. The thought went through my mind that a jeep seat has a lever under the bottom where if I could have moved my foot underneath, lifted it up and just pushed it forward, you know. But at the same time, though, thinking that, okay, well, what if I get my friend killed? Each area that we were taken to, one was more deserted than the other. That was only the third and final destination that we were told to get out of the car. He said, okay. He goes, well, you guys cooperated. He goes, now, I want you to walk behind this pile of wood chips. This area that we were in, it was a field that Was being cleared and there was evergreens all around. So we were pretty much camouflaged from the road so any passersby couldn't really see us. He then tells us, okay, I want both of you to lay face down in the snow with your hands behind your back and don't look at me.
- [37:09]
Host/Interviewer
Scott and Michael both lay down in the snow.
- [37:12]
Scott (Survivor)
Michael was pleading. He goes, we did what you asked. He's like, you said you weren't going to hurt us. He goes, shut up and listen to what I say. And I'm watching Michael this whole time as I'm laying next to him, maybe not even a foot away from him. And I hear the last words to come out of my friend's mouth was, please don't do this. I have a mother, I have a sister. And then bang. Shot him square in the back of his head. I'm watching this the whole time. I'm not supposed. My face is supposed to be in the snow and not looking at this. And now it's really starting to set in that this is it, it's over. And again, could only think of how worried my mother was gonna be. And he then points the gun at me and he tells me, I told you not to look. I told you to keep your face in the snow. He's walking around me and straddling over me. Now I'm waiting for him to just reach down and shoot me. I was more or less waiting to die. And it seemed like it was taking forever. At the same time, though, I'm not scared. I'm kind of at peace because I'm with my best friend. You know, I'd be going with my best friend. I'm not gonna be alone and, you know, start thinking about all the things that I accomplished in my 18 years. You know, I knew what it was like to hit the game winning home run. I knew what it was like to throw a no hitter. I was a bat boy for the New York Yankees. So I achieved my goal of being a Yankee. I made my mother proud, my father proud, my sister, my family. And this. All of a sudden it was. I could see like this book just like laid out and just saw from the front pages being thumbed and from birth and kind of like all the highlights in my life. And then all of a sudden the pages went blank. And then that's when I felt it and I heard it bang. Something is telling me, turn your head. At that last moment, I turned my head, I heard the bang and felt the impact of the bullet. And instead of getting Shot square in the back of the head like Michael was. I got shot right in the back of my head behind my ear. The bullet came in and went out the side of my face. I just heard ringing and then like, just throbbing. Then I heard the Jeep start up. And I then looked over the pile of wood chips again and saw the Jeep start driving away. I checked on Michael and I got a couple of faint moans from him. So he wasn't dead. He wasn't dead. He was still alive but unresponsive. So I tried to collect myself and looked around the area that we were in and noticed that in the distance across the street there were these white buildings. I ran. I got up and I ran across the street and was banging on the doors, saying, please, please, you gotta help. And I remember seeing my reflection in the window of the door and like, oh my. Was a man working there. They called 911 right away.
- [40:31]
Host/Interviewer
Using Scott's detailed description. Police stopped and arrested the killer. 25 minutes later, Scott was taken by an ambulance to a nearby hospital. Michael was airlifted to a different hospital.
- [40:43]
Scott (Survivor)
Later on that evening, when I'm in my hospital room with my mother and my father and my sister was when I had found out that Michael had passed. And I remember just crying, being confused, being angry, not understanding why the same guardian angel that was looking after me wasn't looking after him. Trying to process that I'm never gonna be able to talk to my friend, to see him again, you know, to tell him that I love him, thank him for being my best friend. It's not fair.
- [41:17]
Host/Interviewer
Michael's killer, Edward Lamont Summers, was a pre medical college student. Summers was sentenced to 75 years in prison.
- [41:26]
Scott (Survivor)
I survived because at that last second, I turned my head and if I didn't go with my inner instinct, that, that, that inner voice, what I considered to be my guardian angel being there for me. If I didn't listen to that voice, I don't think I would have been here today. And because of that, I survived.
- [41:52]
Johnny (Survivor)
This September, CBS hits are streaming free on Pluto tv. Coming in for this month only. Stream full episodes of Matlock. I'm a lawyer.
- [42:01]
Host/Interviewer
Like the old TV show Fire Country.
- [42:04]
Johnny (Survivor)
Elsbeth.
- [42:04]
Advertiser/Promoter
I do love a mystery.
- [42:06]
Johnny (Survivor)
NCIS Origins, Watson and ghosts.
- [42:09]
Host/Interviewer
What the hell?
- [42:10]
Johnny (Survivor)
This is the most amazing, amazing sight I've never seen. All for free. The CBS shows you love. This month only on Pluto TV. Stream now. Pain never.
- [42:23]
Advertiser/Promoter
I've got 20 minutes to run club meets. And it's time for a quick pre workout snack.
- [42:27]
Johnny (Survivor)
Go, go.
- [42:27]
Advertiser/Promoter
Squeeze Active Fruit Blend to the rescue. Made with select B vitamins to help release energy, it's an easy squeezable pouch made to move with me. The taste so good and made with with real fruit even better. Whether I'm hitting the trail or meeting my friends on the court, this is my go to on the go snack. Quick, easy, ready when I am. When it's go time, I go with Gogo Squeeze Active. Snag yours on your next door run. Search for Gogo Squeeze on Amazon.