Murder in the Bayou: Lost Soul in Lafayette

Summary

Summary of "Murder in the Bayou: Lost Soul in Lafayette" - Cold Case Files

Podcast Information:

• Title: Cold Case Files
• Host: Paula Barros
• Episode: Murder in the Bayou: Lost Soul in Lafayette
• Release Date: March 25, 2025

---

Introduction

In the gripping episode titled "Murder in the Bayou: Lost Soul in Lafayette," Cold Case Files delves into the harrowing unsolved murder of Bonnie Faye Rupert, a case that remained cold for nearly a decade before breakthroughs in forensic technology and relentless investigative efforts brought justice. Hosted by Paula Barros, the episode meticulously walks listeners through the crime, the exhaustive investigation, and the emotional resolution for the victim’s family.

The Crime Scene

On December 6, 2008, during the Cajun Country Marathon in Lafayette, Louisiana, the serene atmosphere was shattered by a gruesome discovery. A runner found the body of Bonnie Faye Rupert near Lajeuner Road, setting off an investigation that would challenge local law enforcement.

Sergeant Scott Baja [04:18]: "The body of the victim was about 20 yards inside the woods from the roadway. The victim was a white female. She was in her mid-40s. Her arms were above her head and there was a significant amount of blood in the area. The most obvious injury that we were able to tell was that her neck had been cut very deep and possibly multiple times."

The scene was described as one of the bloodiest Sergeant Baja had ever encountered, with evidence indicating a violent and personal attack. The only personal item found was a hotel room key, hinting at Bonnie's transient lifestyle.

Background of the Victim

Bonnie Faye Rupert, a 47-year-old woman from Broughton, Illinois, had a life marked by struggle and resilience. Her daughter, Nicole Teague, provides a heartfelt account of Bonnie’s tumultuous journey, shedding light on her battles with addiction and mental health issues.

Nicole Teague [06:03]: "She had really bad depression and anxiety and she was bipolar. And I think instead of her taking her meds, she would turn to the drugs and that would help numb her. But when that high came down, those problems were still there."

Bonnie’s lifestyle involved frequent traveling and intermittent relationships, which ultimately led her to Louisiana.

The Investigation Begins

Sergeant Scott Baja and the Lafayette Police Department launched an immediate investigation. Initial suspicions fell on Lambert Hatfield, Bonnie's rocky romantic partner, due to his history of domestic violence.

Sergeant Scott Baja [10:17]: "It's a very high percentage of when a woman is murdered that it's going to be some type of romantic partner or relationship going bad."

Despite Lambert Hatfield's cooperation, forensic evidence initially did not link him conclusively to the crime. His DNA was found at the scene, but no direct evidence could tie him to the brutal assault.

Sergeant Scott Baja [14:57]: "So we were fairly confident that we had the suspect's blood, we had the suspect's skin, DNA evidence that potentially could help us identify that individual that committed this heinous murder."

A Decade-Long Pursuit

As years passed without significant leads, the case seemed to drift into obscurity. However, advances in forensic technology, particularly DNA analysis, reignited hope. In February 2012, despite a lack of matches in national databases, a familial trait identified on the Y chromosome provided a new direction.

Detective [23:59]: "One of the lab technicians recognized a familial trait on the Y chromosome. That familial trait ran in the Hebert family."

Sergeant Baja took personal responsibility, requesting to be reassigned to Bonnie’s case in 2013. His persistent efforts included collecting DNA samples from the Hebert family, narrowing down potential suspects.

The Breakthrough

On March 8, 2018, nearly ten years after Bonnie’s murder, a significant breakthrough occurred. DNA analysis revealed a match with Millard Hebert, a tow truck driver from Youngsville, Louisiana.

Sergeant Scott Baja [25:59]: "We got him. ... That he had been arrested on a drug charge and booked into the Lafayette Parish Correctional center, where they obtained a swab from him during the booking process and in fact, that it was an Hebert."

Millard Hebert’s arrest marked a pivotal moment in the case, finally bringing closure to a decade-long investigation.

Confrontation and Confession

During his interview, Millard Hebert initially denied any involvement. However, under pressure and guided questioning by Sergeant Baja, he began to recount the events leading to Bonnie’s death.

Millard Hebert [29:25]: "I picked her up, I believe, on Cameron Street... I hit her in the head."

Though Hebert struggled with the memory, his admissions aligned with the forensic evidence, including multiple stab wounds and blunt force trauma inflicted upon Bonnie.

Emotional Impact and Closure

The resolution of the case brought profound relief and a sense of justice to Bonnie’s family. Nicole Teague expressed her gratitude towards Sergeant Baja and the investigative team for their unwavering dedication.

Nicole Teague [36:34]: "When the sentencing hearing was over, I met the detective in the hallway and I gave him the biggest hug. And it was a hug of peace. He was able to give me something, and it wasn't about him, and it wasn't about making a name for himself. And I am forever grateful to him."

Giselle Carter, Bonnie’s granddaughter, reflected on her grandmother’s life and the pain of her untimely death, highlighting the emotional toll endured by the family.

Giselle Carter [37:57]: "My grandma Bonnie lived her life the way she wanted to live. Free, without a worry in this world."

Trial and Sentencing

In a surprising turn of events, Nicole Teague requested that the case not go to trial to spare Millard Hebert’s family from further pain. Instead, Hebert pled guilty to manslaughter and was sentenced to 20 years in prison.

Nicole Teague [35:56]: "I wanted this to be done and over with. I didn't want my kids to have to experience that trial."

Sergeant Baja emphasized the importance of perseverance in law enforcement, ensuring that no case is forgotten.

Sergeant Scott Baja [35:33]: "We don't stop. So the message we hope to the family is that this arrest leads to some sense of justice and some sense of closure."

Conclusion

"Murder in the Bayou: Lost Soul in Lafayette" serves as a powerful narrative of justice achieved through relentless pursuit and advancements in forensic science. It underscores the emotional journey of the victim’s family and the dedication of law enforcement officials who refuse to let a case go cold. This episode not only highlights the complexities of solving cold cases but also the profound impact such cases have on communities and families.

---

This detailed summary encapsulates the key elements, discussions, and emotional nuances of the episode, providing a comprehensive overview for those who haven't listened to "Murder in the Bayou: Lost Soul in Lafayette."

Transcript

[Mochi Health Representative]

Mochi Health is here to help you start your weight loss journey with caring, personalized support. Meet one on one with board certified obesity doctors and registered dietitians who truly listen and understand your unique needs. Eligible patients can access affordable GLP1 medications delivered right to their door each month. No insurance, no problem. Mochi Health accepts FSA and HSA making care accessible and affordable. And with 24. 7 customer service, you'll never feel alone on your path to better health. Get started with Mochi Health today. Take the free [e-mail] and use code AUDIO40 at checkout for $40 off your first month of membership. That's join M-O C-H-I.com with promo code AUDIO40.

[Marissa Pinson]

Hi cold case listeners. I'm Marissa Pinson and if you're enjoying this show, I just want to remind you that episodes of Cold Case Files as well as the A classic podcasts, I Survived, American justice and City Confidential are all available ad free on the new A and E Crime and Investigation channel on Apple Podcasts and Apple plus for just $4.99 a month or 39.99 a year. And now onto the show. This program contains subject matter that may be disturbing to some listeners. Listener discretion is advised.

[Nicole Teague]

My mom said she was going to Louisiana and next thing you know, she was gone.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

The east side of Lafayette is a very remote area, very desolate. Someone could really do some heinous things in those areas.

[Detective]

There are gators, water moccasins. It's not all fun and games when you get lost in trouble quick.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

This was probably one of the bloodiest scenes that I had seen. Her neck was cut very deep and possibly multiple times.

[Millard Hebert]

And it started fighting and others couldn't stop. I had no control.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

This was pure evil. Somebody that had no regards for life whatsoever.

[Nicole Teague]

I told them, you treat this like this was your mother because I want answers.

[Marissa Pinson]

There are over 100,000 cold cases in America. Only about 1% are ever solved. This is one of those rare stories. Stephen Baja is a sergeant with the Lafayette Police Department.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

Lafayette's located in south central Louisiana, about 50 miles west of the Mississippi River, 2030 miles from the Gulf of Mexico. It's an entertainment hub.

[Marissa Pinson]

Shea Randall is a former reporter for the Daily Advertiser.

[Giselle Carter]

Lafayette is its own little bitty piece of, like, Louisiana. It's really small. It has its own little flavor. The Cajun culture is everywhere. I mean, it's in the food. It's in the way that people live their lives. I don't think I went to as many festivals and just celebrations as I've ever been in any other place that I've lived. I felt like I could connect to people a little bit better because they're so welcoming. I still love it very much. It's still very much home for me.

[Marissa Pinson]

Just a few miles from Lafayette City center lie the murky depths of the bayou.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

As soon as you leave the city limits, you're in an area where there's no lights, there's no houses, buildings, or any kind of structures. The majority of that area is very desolate, very remote. You're in swampland, you're in a marshland.

[Detective]

You end up in bayous. And bring your hip boots because you're going to be in mud and water. There are gators, water moccasins. It's not all fun and games. When you get lost in trouble quick.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

Someone could really do some heinous things in those areas. On Saturday, December 6th of 2008, it was a typical cool morning. The Cajun Country Marathon at the time was a half on, half off road marathon that was taking place in Lafayette. A runner was warming up prior to the event and had stepped off of one of the trails to relieve himself. And when doing so, he located a female, obviously deceased, and he notified the local sheriff's deputies that were working the race off duty.

[Marissa Pinson]

Sergeant Baja makes his way to the crime scene just off Lajeuner Road, an area surrounded by thick southern oak and cypress.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

The body of the victim was about 20 yards inside the woods from the roadway. The victim was a white female. She was in her mid-40s. Her arms were above her head and there was a significant amount of blood in the area. The most obvious injury that we were able to tell was that her neck had been cut very deep and possibly multiple times. She was still fully clothed, her pants were unbuttoned. But it didn't appear that the victim had been sexually assaulted.

[Marissa Pinson]

Her killer leaves behind one identifying and vicious piece of evidence.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

We located a boot print in blood on her chest, which would have been caused after the stabbing occurred because she was found lying on her back. That made it look like there was anger involved and that it was a personal attack on her. At the time that this occurred, I was on the force for nearly eight years and this was probably one of the bloodiest scenes that I had seen.

[Marissa Pinson]

Scott Broussard is a sergeant with the Lafayette Police Department.

[Forensic Technician]

Since the body was found with no animal activity or no kind of decomposition, which happens very fast here in South Louisiana, it led us to believe that she had not been there very long.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

We were unable to find any identification, any type of purse, any type of personal belongings. There was only one thing that was located in her pocket and that was a room key to a local hotel.

[Marissa Pinson]

The key belongs to room 46 at the Regency Inn, located five miles from the crime scene.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

When detectives arrived at the Regency Inn, using the key and the room number, we went and knocked on the door, see if there were any associates that would help us identify the victim. We were able to locate a female who said that her friend Bonnie Rupert had not returned from the evening before. We learned that Bonnie Rupert was in her late 40s. She wasn't a resident of this area. She was from Illinois. With the hotel key and the statement that we obtained from the friend that we interviewed, we were fairly confident that Bonnie was the individual that we found off of Lajeuner Road.

[Marissa Pinson]

Fingerprints confirmed the victim as 47 year old Bonnie Faye Rupert. Detectives reach out to her daughter, Nicole Teague in Illinois to break the news.

[Nicole Teague]

I got off of work. I was in iga. It was me and my daughter's father. And my grandma called. She said, hey girl, are you off work? I said, yeah. I remember her saying, they found your mama dead today. I said, huh? She said, yeah, they found your mama dead today. And I remember falling in the middle of the store. And my daughter's father looked at me and he said, I know that. I know that scream. He said, his body fell. Casino. My mom was from Broughton, Illinois. My mother went through some horrible things that had happened to her by her grandfather. And at age 14, my mom decided to leave Broughton and she came to Champaign, Illinois, and she met my father. I was born, but my mom was my mom. I mean, she just had a tough fight in this world. She had really bad depression and anxiety and she was bipolar. And I think instead of her taking her meds, she would turn to the drugs and that would help numb her. But when that high came down, those problems were still there.

[Marissa Pinson]

As Bonnie struggles with addiction, she parts ways with Nicole's father. In 1981, Nicole's grandmother steps in to adopt her. While free spirited, Bonnie takes to the road.

[Nicole Teague]

My mom was a worldly woman. She was 5 11, beautiful. She had these olive skin tones and she had the most beautifulest hair and the most bubbliest personality. And she just traveled. She would be in California, Texas, Massachusetts. All I could say is she traveled very well.

[Marissa Pinson]

Two decades pass. Nicole is in her mid-20s and a mother herself. When Bonnie returns, she's welcomed with open arms. And once again makes Illinois her home. Giselle Carter is Bonnie's granddaughter.

[Giselle Carter]

When grandma Bonnie came into my life, I was about 6 or 7. She was a lively woman. She always kept herself up. Jewelry, purses, her hair done. She taught me how to do an inside out, French braid, how to take care of my hair. And she was excited about it. She was happy to be a part of her grandkids life. It was a good moment because now I had another grandmother. Spoiled me.

[Marissa Pinson]

In 2007, Bonnie's wanderlust kicks in again.

[Nicole Teague]

I came to visit my mom one day and she told me she was leaving. She said, I met this cool man. I didn't even know his name. And she said she was going to Louisiana. I said, you know what you're doing? She told me, yeah. And next thing you know, she was gone.

[Marissa Pinson]

Police discover Bonnie is part of a traveling group. She's been sharing a room with the man she mentioned to her daughter. His name is Lambert Hatfield, and their relationship is rocky.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

We had learned that there was a domestic incident that had several months prior out of state, where it was reported that Lambert was intoxicated and had struck Bonnie, which led her to go to a woman's shelter and to get a stay away order against him. Bonnie had checked into the women's shelter and. And then had checked out, stating that she was traveling to Mississippi to do some work, which obviously wasn't the case because she ended up here in Lafayette with Lambert. It's a very high percentage of when a woman is murdered that it's going to be some type of romantic partner or relationship going bad. And because of the injuries and how violent this crime was, the total disregard for her body and her remains, that led us to believe that someone committed the murder in a fit of rage. You would associate these types of wounds with a domestic violence incident. That would definitely raise a red flag and make Lambert suspect number one.

[Detective]

Bonnie Rupert and Lambert Hatfield had been traveling together for some time, and there's a history of domestic violence.

[Marissa Pinson]

Investigators bring Lambert in for questioning.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

Lambert said that the last time he saw Bonnie was the Friday morning prior to her death, and that as he left to go to work, she was still sleeping in the hotel room.

[Marissa Pinson]

Lambert denies any involvement in Bonnie's murder.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

Lambert said that Bonnie would disappear on occasion and that she would perform sex acts as a form of revenue so that she could purchase narcotics. It appeared that Bonnie was in this situation because of addiction, and doing that along with small, odd jobs, is the only way that she could support herself and live to see the next day, Lambert said that he didn't approve of what she was doing, but was okay with the fact that she was bringing in some type of revenue. Additional information that we learned is that Lambert had told Bonnie to get rid of all of her identification and to cut ties with all of her family in Illinois. Doing this to someone is a clear sign of them trying to isolate them from anyone that they love and could be considered potentially premeditation to commit a murder and make it difficult for law enforcement to identify the victim.

[Nicole Teague]

I started going online, searching, and I seen a picture in an article after Lambert had beat on her, and she looked sad, and she looked down and out. You got rid of her id you wouldn't let her call me anymore. Most people who do that, it's because they have something to hide and they're about to do something really, really crazy.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

Because it was such a violent crime. You look at the individual to see if they had any types of injuries or scratches on their hands, anything on their face, and Lambert didn't have any of those. Lambert's clothing was also looked at closely. His shoes were inspected not only for blood or trace evidence, but for the tread on the soles. And that was compared to any type of tread that we located on the scene, and none of those matched. And no physical evidence of blood was found on his shoes. Lambert was very cooperative with the detective that was conducting the interview. He answered all of the questions. He voluntarily gave a DNA sample and ultimately took a polygraph. The results of that test showed that he did not show any deceit. The amount of cooperation that he extended towards us, the lack of physical injuries, and just the way that he presented himself led us to believe that he wasn't involved in the murder. On December 8, 2008, an autopsy was conducted on Bonnie at the Lafayette Parish Coroner's office. The initial thought that Bonnie wasn't sexually assaulted was confirmed. The pathologist discovered that Bonnie was stabbed 11 times on her back and shoulders. She was struck with a blunt object approximately four times on her head, and that her throat was slashed six times. When looking at everything that took place in the scene, the boot print on Bonnie's chest in blood, the blunt force trauma, the multiple stab wounds, and the way that she was discarded in a trash pile, this was pure evil. Somebody that had no regards for life whatsoever.

[Giselle Carter]

Hearing the details of her death, it kind of made me hurt worse. Whoever did it, they beat her, they stabbed her all over her body, and they bashed her skull in. You really wanted to end her life. And I Just want to know why.

[Nicole Teague]

A monster did that. But that monster didn't realize who he was dealing with. Dealing with my mom. And I know my mom was a fighter. And when I tell you. Wrist was broke from her punching back. Stab wounds everywhere. That little lady fought for her life.

[Marissa Pinson]

Bonnie's battle with her killer may well provide detectives with the evidence to catch him.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

During the autopsy, it's standard procedure to get nail scrapings. In the case of Bonnie, there was skin that was located underneath her fingernails.

[Forensic Technician]

While documenting the blood stains on Bonnie rupert's shoes, a 90 degree drop was located near her laces. And on the toe of her shoe, a 90 degree blood drop is a perfect circle. This indicates to us that it came from an elevated level.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

That type of blood drop leads investigators to believe that the suspect was standing over her Whenever the blood was deposited there. It could have been from one of the items that the suspect used to stab Bonnie.

[Forensic Technician]

She could have punched the suspect in the nose, could have scratched him, could have caused him to bleed. But they led me to believe that whoever stabbed her had cut himself during the altercation and had bled on her shoes.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

So we were fairly confident that we had the suspect's blood, we had the suspect's skin, DNA evidence that potentially could help us identify that individual that committed the. This heinous murder. A swab of the 90 degree blood drop, along with Bonnie's fingernail scrapings, was sent to the Acadiana crime lab for DNA testing with the hopes of finding a suspect.

[Marissa Pinson]

As detectives await lab results, Bonnie's body is transported north 700 miles to her hometown of Broughton, Illinois, where she is finally laid to rest.

[Nicole Teague]

We just had a small little graveside service, but before we went there, my grandmother took me, and we got the most prettiest nightgown with a house coat. And it was silky and long. She said, you don't have to get her regular clothes, Nicole. She's going to bed for the rest of her life. And they got her dressed, and I looked at her and I gave her a kiss.

[Giselle Carter]

She was so young, like she was 47. You still have a whole life ahead of you. She still had time to change. She had time to. She had time to, like, make things better. And that's not fair. It's not fair that she didn't get the chance to, like, keep being, you know, be able to be a better person.

[Marissa Pinson]

As the family grieves, detectives receive results.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

From the lab 10 days after submitting the blood swabs and fingernail scrapings from Bonnie to the kid, ANA crime lab. We received a full DNA profile of a white male. So we were fairly confident that this was the blood and DNA profile of our suspect.

[Forensic Technician]

The sample was Internet of codis, but the national database where the DNA is stored, you have to commit a felony or a violent crime, it did not match to anybody in the database at the time.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

That was extremely frustrating for us because we felt that the individual that was capable of doing a crime such as this would have had some type of criminal history. And that wasn't the case.

[Marissa Pinson]

Okay, let's talk about nutrient dense meals. They're crucial for your health, but sometimes it feels like focusing on the nutrients means sacrificing flavor. But healthy meals don't have to be bland. Thanks to CookUnity, CookUnity brings fresh flavors to every diet. Whether you're keto, gluten free or following a GLP1 balanced plan. CookUnity's all star chefs craft each meal using local in season ingredients packed with protein, fiber and healthy fats. Need a hand with achieving your weight goals? CookUnity's got you covered with meals that are both nutrient dense and delicious. The best part? They're sent fresh, not frozen, right to your door, saving you time and money. Head to cookunity.com cold or use code cold at checkout for 50% off your first week. I've been amazed by the taste and quality of these balanced meals. They leave me feeling energized and satisfied throughout the day. I recently tried their vegetable paella. The flavors were absolutely beautiful and the mix of saffron of used rice, roasted bell peppers, artichokes and a medley of seasonal vegetables created a dish that was both hearty and delicious. It's incredible how easy it is to achieve my health goals with these gourmet meals ready in minutes, I found myself snacking less and enjoying more sustained energy. I'm so impressed by the quality of the food. CookUnity's roster of chefs is seriously impressive. We're talking Food Network alums, James Beard Award winners and acclaimed restaurateurs. Take Chef inotadmoney. Known for Taim and Bala Busta, her creations are a perfect balance of flavor and nutrition. These small batch meals are made with humanely raised meat and organic ingredients. When possible, using fresh seasonal products. It's like having a Michelin starred restaurant in your own kitchen without the hassle or the hefty price tag. Crush your health goals with mouth watering chef crafted meals delivered straight to your door. Go to cookunity.com cold or enter code cold before checkout for 50% off your first week. That's 50% off your first week. By using code cold or going to cookunity.com cold. Homes.com knows that when it comes to home shopping, it's never just about the house or condo. It's about the home. And what makes a home is more than just the house or property. It's the location and neighborhood. If you have kids, it's also schools, nearby, parks, and transportation options. That's why homes.com goes above and beyond to bring home shoppers the in depth information they need to find the right home. And when I say in depth, I'm talking deep. Each listing features comprehensive information about the neighborhood, complete with a video guide. They also have details about local schools with test scores, state rankings, and student to teacher ratio. They even have an agent directory with the sales history of each agent. So when it comes to finding a home, not just a house, this is everything you need to know all in one place. Homes.com We've done your homework. After one month, the investigation is hitting a wall in Lafayette. Detectives expand their search beyond this bayou community. They look into a series of unsolved murders in neighboring Jefferson Davis parish prior to Bonnie's death.

[Giselle Carter]

Since 2005, about 40 miles down the interstate in Jennings, Louisiana, seven women have been killed and their bodies disposed of in these very remote places. Canals, wooded areas. It is alarming. Jennings is very small. It's a very everybody knows everybody type of place. All of these women lived very similar lifestyles. Some of them had to resort to doing sex work. Some of them have lived through poverty. They have some substance abuse issues.

[Marissa Pinson]

Detectives cannot ignore the eerie similarity to Bonnie's case.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

Bonnie was somewhat down on her luck. She would prostitute herself for money. So we felt like because of the victimology that Bonnie could have been a victim of their suspect.

[Giselle Carter]

We also have where these women in Jennings, their bodies have been disposed of in these very remote places. And then you have Bonnie and Lafayette, who also you find her body off into the woods. You're wondering if the same person is doing the same thing in these two very small communities.

[Nicole Teague]

I was scared for everyone because it wasn't just my mother. It was young ladies and women all over. Because killers move, they kill people from one town to the next town and they don't stop until they are caught.

[Giselle Carter]

You start to wonder if this is a serial killer, is he or she expanding their territory? Do we have to worry about somebody else being killed? Is this coming this way?

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

We were concerned that the serial killer that was operating 40 miles down the road, had moved his operation into our city.

[Giselle Carter]

It's a very eerie feeling that you really can't shake. And so for that to spread to somewhere like Lafayette that is happy, go lucky, community oriented, it's an unsettling thing because you don't know what's going to happen next.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

Local agencies were investigating those other murders that took place in the Jennings area. And we reached out to those agencies because of the victimology.

[Marissa Pinson]

Bobby Oudeney Sr. Is the Assistant Attorney General for the Louisiana Department of Justice.

[Detective]

There were similarities in all of those young ladies backgrounds, young women who basically live the same lifestyle as Bonnie. Substance abuse problems, some sex work.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

We contacted investigators that were in charge of those crimes, compared similarities to what was going on. Looking at the injuries to victims in that area and the extensive stab wounds that Bonnie had, we were able to determine that there were minimal similarities.

[Marissa Pinson]

While Bonnie was stabbed to death, investigators believe that most of the Jennings victims were strangled.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

We determined that Bonnie wasn't a victim of their suspect, and we were able to exclude her from that group.

[Marissa Pinson]

This is a setback for detectives who are now out of leads.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

The lead investigator in Bonnie's case worked diligently for months, exhausted all leads, exhausted all tips, and ultimately she decided to suspend the case. It's extremely frustrating when all the leads dry up. One of the worst things that can happen to an investigator is to hit that wall.

[Marissa Pinson]

After a year of effort by investigators, the case of the murdered grandmother goes cold.

[Giselle Carter]

I was angry at whoever did it. I was angry at the world because it wasn't fair. I lost my grandma and especially when I got her into my life later in life. So to get her taken away from me permanently, it was a different type of pain because, like, she can't come back this time.

[Marissa Pinson]

It's now February 2012, three years after Bonnie's murder. Though her case sits on the shelf, the crime lab continues to run DNA samples through CODIS looking for a match to their suspect. Then something catches a specialist's eye.

[Detective]

One of the lab technicians recognized a familial trait on the Y chromosome. That familial trait ran in the Hebert family. So if you were a male with the last name Hebert or your father had the last name Hebert, you were likely to carry this trait. So while there was still no hit in the database, he now had a last name.

[Marissa Pinson]

What feels like a major break in the case could be more akin to finding a needle in a haystack.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

With a little research, I was able to determine that just in the state of Louisiana, there's over 20,000 individuals that have that last name. You can narrow that down because we're looking for a male, but it's still a significant amount of people in the state. By 2013, I had been transferred to our homicide Violent crimes section. And upon my arrival in that section, I requested that I be assigned Bonnie's case. Because I was on the scene, because of how violent it was, it was always in my mind. And having the opportunity to pick it back up in 2013, I jumped at the chance. Having that full DNA profile, I knew that if we identified a very good suspect, that we could solve it. The lab was able to identify three a bears that had a very distant DNA match to our suspect. And the first thing I thought of at that time was who get as many swabs from family members along the family tree of the known individuals that we had. And if I could find a common relative, possibly I could get a suspect name and do what I could to get a swab from them to compare to our suspect.

[Marissa Pinson]

It's now March 8, 2018, nine years after Bonnie's murder. For years, Sergeant Baja collects voluntary DNA samples from Hebert family members and keeps plugging them into the system without a hit until a surprise phone call reignites the investigation.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

So in March of 2018, 10 years after Bonnie's murder took place, I was building a shed in the back of my house, and I received a phone call from the crime lab. And the technician who I'd worked with for years was extremely excited on the other side of the phone saying, we got him, we got him. And when she finally calmed down, she said that she had a match to the suspect DNA in Bonnie's case and that he had been arrested on a drug charge and booked into the Lafayette Parish Correctional center, where they obtained a swab from him during the booking process and in fact, that it was an Hebert, and it was an individual by the name of Millard Hebert. I was extremely excited because I knew that I had him looking into Millard's background. Up until 2018, Millard was was leading a clean life. He was a family man from a small town called Youngsville, just south of the city of Lafayette. We learned that he was a tow truck driver for a local tow company and that he was in his mid to late 50s. Luckily for us, Millard was still waiting to bond out on the drug charge. And I couldn't wait to get into work the next morning to hit the ground running and do what we needed to do. To make sure that he didn't harm anybody else.

[Millard Hebert]

How you doing, mister? You good? I'm cool. You cool? Yeah.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

So we arranged it with our local sheriff's department to bring him down to an interview room.

[Millard Hebert]

What is this about? This is about a case that happened in 2008.

[Detective]

Just because your DNA is found at the scene doesn't mean you committed the murder. But it was blood and skin under Bonnie's fingernails.

[Millard Hebert]

Have you ever seen this? No.

[Detective]

Explaining why his DNA was present was going to be difficult.

[Millard Hebert]

Anybody by the name of Bonnie? You ever had anything with a lady by the name of Bonnie? Not that I remember.

[Marissa Pinson]

Sergeant Baja doesn't waste any time diving into the reason he's questioning Millard Hebert.

[Millard Hebert]

What I do is I investigate cold case murders. Okay? And, you know, to be blunt for it and straight honest with you, we're here mainly because you hadn't been arrested since 1987, right? That was pre DNA. Okay. And you were swabbed when you were booked on February 15, and that swab was sent to the crime lab. Okay? And your DNA came back to this homicide. When I say your DNA, your blood and your skin was on her body. Okay. At this point, we're beyond any. You saying I wasn't involved or anything like that? We're here to find out what happened. And we'd like to hear your side of what took place. But I'm trying to remember this, but I've been a mess for a while. I understand. And I don't remember anything.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

When we started the interview, Miller didn't know why we were there. But that didn't last long.

[Millard Hebert]

I know just from sitting here looking at you that you know what happened that night. I've had flashbacks of thinking something happened. What? Yeah, you remember something. Mm. But you don't know if it was reality or not. I want you to understand that I.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

Know what happened to her.

[Millard Hebert]

I was there. I saw everything. I know how she died. I believe you know, but I believe it's hard for you to say what.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

Happened at that point. I sat back in my chair, and within 30 seconds, Millard just started talking without even being asked a question.

[Millard Hebert]

I picked her up, I believe, on Cameron Street. Okay. Yeah, that I remember some map. I picked her up high, and we rolled around, pulled her off on the side there and got out the truck in the back and started fighting. And I strained a little. I freaked out. Can you stop? She cut with the knife. Then I cut her with the knife. No, I hit her. Hit her in the head. I slowed I slowed. I had no control. Do you remember how she ended up dying? I went away. She was dead. Okay. Well, the hard thing for me to believe is the wounds that she had.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

There's no way that you would not.

[Millard Hebert]

Have known that she was dead. Oh. I mean, I blacked out.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

I don't.

[Millard Hebert]

I remember hitting her. What I did after that, I can't tell you.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

I believe when Millard said he blacked out, he knew how brutal it was. He was disgusted by it. I feel, and I don't think that he could bring himself to admit fully what he had done to Bonnie.

[Millard Hebert]

What sparked it? Was there an altercation? I mean, was there an argument? Was that. Yeah, money for sex. That's what it was about. We started arguing about it, and then it just escalated from there. Threatening to call the cops on me and telling them I was picking her up in the wrecker.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

Millard said that during that argument, Bonnie threatened to call the police and she threatened to call his employment and report that he was doing this type of activity on the job. I believe that he was scared to lose his job. I would believe he was scared to be arrested. I believe that he was high on some type of narcotic and lost control.

[Millard Hebert]

Was there any blood on you that you noticed after? I had a cut on my hand. I had a scratch on my face.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

We were able to determine the blood came from his hand and the skin more than likely came from his face.

[Millard Hebert]

Ms. Avery, this is a question I ask everybody. It's not just you, but is this the only incident that you've been involved in like that? That's the only one. Nothing else? Nothing else.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

The brutality of the murder, it was shocking to us that Mirlood hadn't done it again or hadn't done it before. We were diligent in looking to see if he would have been involved in anything else. And ultimately, this appeared to be the only time that he had done that.

[Millard Hebert]

Carrying Mr. Albert 10 years. I was well respected on a light. Evil drug destroyed me. I failed me. Her family, her life.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

What surprised me is that being a tow truck driver, he had instances where he was involved with law enforcement for years on all of our accident scenes. And he was right there amongst us the entire time.

[Millard Hebert]

I feel good and I feel terrible. I don't have to live with this hidden no more. Her poor family.

[Marissa Pinson]

Sergeant Baja immediately calls Bonnie's daughter Nicole in Illinois to share the news. She's waited a decade to.

[Nicole Teague]

I was at work and my phone rung and I wasn't gonna answer it, but I said, this is a Louisiana number. And I remember it was March 9th and her birthday was March 10th and he said, we got him. And I remember saying, boy, that's the best birthday present you could have ever gave her. And I was excited and I was in the hallway jumping up and down that little piece of hope that I had held onto for all those years. It finally came true.

[Marissa Pinson]

Hey there fellow travelers. Can you feel that spring travel itch? I sure can and I'm gearing up for a fun beach getaway this summer and I am beyond excited to prep for my adventure. I've decided to treat myself to a first class quality suitcase without the hefty price tag. Thanks to Quints, vacation season is just around the corner and this year I'm all about the luxe upgrades I deserve. Quint offers high quality travel essentials at fair prices that won't break the bank. We're talking lightweight European linen styles starting at just $30. Washable silk tops that'll keep you looking chic and comfy. Lounge sets for those long flights. But it doesn't stop there. Quint has premium luggage options and stylish tote bags to carry all your essentials. The best part? All Quint's Items are priced 50 to 80% less than similar brands. How do they do it? By partnering directly with top factories, Quince cuts out the middleman and passes those sweet savings on to us. I love that Quince only works with factories using safe, ethical and responsible manufacturing practices along with premium fabrics and finishes. It's guilt free shopping at its finest. Speaking of upgrades, I've decided to level up my travel game with Quince's 21 inch hardshell. Carry on for my upcoming trip. It's lightweight at just 6.2 pounds, has a sleek design and comes with all the features I need from a TSA approved lock to a handy compression system. Plus it's a fraction of the cost of other premium brands, making it the perfect travel companion for my beach adventure. For your next trip, treat yourself to the luxe upgrades you deserve from quince. Go to quince.com cold case for 365 day returns plus free shipping on your order. That's Q-U-I-N-C-E.com coldcase to get free shipping and 365 day returns. Quince.com cold case cold case Files is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Do you ever find yourself playing the budgeting game? Shifting a little money here, a little there and hoping it all works out well with the name your price tool from Progressive, you can be a better budgeter and potentially lower your insurance bill, too. You tell Progressive what you want to pay for car insurance, and they'll help you find options within your budget. Try [e-mail] Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. Price and coverage match limited by state law. Not available in all states. On March 16, 2018, former Police Chief Toby Aguilard announces the arrest of Millard Hebert for the murder of Bonnie Rupert.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

We at the Lafayette Police Department want the public to understand that we don't put cases down here.

[Detective]

It may have taken us 10 years.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

To bring someone to justice in this case, but it's important that the public.

[Detective]

Know that we don't stop.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

So the message we hope to the family is that this arrest leads to some sense of justice and some sense of closure.

[Marissa Pinson]

As Hebert's case moves through the court, Bonnie's family makes an unusual request.

[Nicole Teague]

I asked the prosecutor not to take this to trial because I did not want to drag my mother through the mud. I want this to be done and over with. I didn't want my kids to have to experience that trial. I did think about the fact that Millard had a wife and a daughter, and I felt bad for them that they see that their father and husband had murdered someone. They had nothing to do with this. They knew nothing about it. And I had sympathy for them also. I didn't want anyone's life dragged through the mud unnecessarily.

[Marissa Pinson]

Millard Hebert pleads guilty to manslaughter and is sentenced to 20 years in prison.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

The fact that Millard openly came out and confessed made it seem like this had been a burden that had been bearing down on him for 10 years. He knew how brutal it was. He was disgusted by it. I believe Millard was truly remorseful in what he had done.

[Nicole Teague]

When the sentencing hearing was over, I met the detective in the hallway and I gave him the biggest hug. And it was a hug of peace. He was able to give me something, and it wasn't about him, and it wasn't about making a name for himself. And I am forever grateful to him.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

Of all things that makes you feel good as a law enforcement officer, it's that hug. It's the thank you and the gratification showed by the victim's family that's unexplainable.

[Marissa Pinson]

Nicole also makes a special request of Sergeant Baja.

[Nicole Teague]

I said, do you have anything left that I can have for my mom? And he had me follow him to the police station, and he said, I can't give you much. And I placed these in this napkin when he gave them to me. It's three earrings that she had on when she was killed. One set and one little one. And no, I won't wear these earrings. But these earrings give me a little peace with a little hope. And let me know, if nothing else, we always have a little piece of her.

[Giselle Carter]

My grandma Bonnie lived her life the way she wanted to live. Free, without a worry in this world. That's what I want to remember. I want to remember her happy smiling face. I want to remember the good times we had, the lessons she taught me. She was a loving person. And that's what I love. Because not everybody can find that little bit of happiness in a world full of darkness.

[Sergeant Scott Baja]

Pluto TV has all the shows and movies you love streaming for free. That means laughter is free with gut busting comedies like the Neighborhood Boomerang and Ferris Bueller's Day Off. Bueller Mystery is free with countless cases to crack from Criminal Minds Tracker and Matlock. I'm a lawyer like the old TV show and thrills are free with heart pumping hits like the Walking Dead and Pulp Fiction. Correctamundo. Feel the free Pluto TV stream now pay Never.