Podcast Summary

Trading Cards & Collectibles Podcast – The Radcast Network

Episode Title: Gordy Bonker left Wall Street for THIS: Why Sports Cards Are the Ultimate 'Hidden' Asset Class
Air Date: December 23, 2025
Host: Ryan Alford
Guest: Gordy Bonker

Overview

This episode features Gordy Bonker, a dynamic content creator and former Wall Street recruiter, who left the world of high finance to make a name in the sports cards and collectibles industry. The conversation explores why sports cards are emerging as a serious alternative (and even “hidden”) asset class, what drives their lasting value, challenges in bringing sophistication and institutional money into the hobby, and the intersection of media, entertainment, and commerce in trading cards today.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Why Sports Cards Are a True Asset Class ([05:29]–[08:24])

Historical Context:
- Collecting is a centuries-old human behavior. Sports cards as a market have existed for over 100 years.
- True market formation and resale value started taking shape in the 1950s and 60s, with cards now displaying a robust history of appreciation.
Long-Term Confidence:
- High-end cards (e.g., Honus Wagner, Mickey Mantle, Jackie Robinson) show compound annual growth rates outpacing many collectibles.
- Bonker directly compares sports cards to art, saying:
  
  "Artwork is at the end of the day still just material ... it's really the creator ... or the scarcity ... that drives its value." ([05:29] B)
Undervalued Potential:
- Even the most expensive sports cards are undervalued compared to blue-chip art.
- Sports cards are only now starting to be viewed as serious stores of value by high-net-worth individuals.

2. The Bubble Question & Card Rarity ([09:29]–[10:36])

Cardboard Skepticism:
- Some doubt the staying power of "just cardboard" as a high-value investment.
- Bonker’s response: Rarity (population counts), demand, and historical performance separate iconic cards from speculative "bubbles."
Example:
- Jordan rookie in PSA 10 commands value due to scarcity relative to demand.

3. Institutionalization, Fractional Models & Marketplaces ([11:31]–[16:19])

Investment Funds & Indices:
- Trends like Kevin O'Leary forming a sports card index signal coming institutionalization, with more high-net-worth entry.
Fractional Ownership:
- Platforms like Rally have not yet succeeded with retail investors, due to marketing, liquidity, and (critically) regulatory hurdles.
  
  "For some reason there's a friction ... maybe it's the liquidity, maybe it's the marketing ... it just hasn't landed yet." ([13:42] B)
- Artwork has embraced such models more rapidly; sports cards could follow as sophistication increases.

4. Gambling & Entertainment: The Modern Hobby’s Double Edge ([17:16]–[24:46])

Entertainment Value:
- Ryan describes cards as entertainment first ("pay to go to the movies, walk away with nothing; with cards, you still have them").
- Gordy emphasizes the unique “cheat code” of collecting:
  
  "If I'm going to spend my free time and make money or at least at the very least, not lose it, it's why it's one of the coolest hobbies to me." ([23:31] B)
Gambling Influence:
- The rise of breaks, surprise/delight in pack opening, Fanatics’ moves into prediction markets, and wider US cultural shift to legalized betting are driving market attention (and risk).
- Distinction drawn between investing in blue-chip vintage vs. gambling on modern breaks.

5. Media, Content, and Community: The Collector as Creator ([26:54]–[47:57])

Explosive Growth in Hobby Media:
- Demand for content (YouTube, social, podcasts) is relentless; kids and adults crave education, entertainment, and connection.
- Advertisers are only just beginning to understand the captive, engaged, and often affluent hobby audience.
Monetization & Influence:
- Bonker sees opportunity in paid content, direct sales, and growing interest from high-net-worth collectors who want brokerage services.
- Still a gap in mainstream (non-hobby) brand sponsorship; he’s bullish it will shift as the space grows.
- "There's a tremendous gap ... with brands understanding that. It's a two-way street of winning." ([29:56] A)
Personal Brand & Strategy:
- Bonker credits his memorable name (“Bonker”) and calculated self-marketing for helping him break out in both finance and collecting.

6. Live Selling as the Next Media Frontier ([39:05]–[44:49])

Live-streamed Commerce:
- Gordy highlights his success with TikTok live selling ("Sunday night, 8pm Eastern"), which began as his full-time bet after leaving finance.
- Describes it as both sales and entertainment – “like a radio show” with high engagement, and now even sponsored.
- Keys to success: Energetic, informed hosting; moving product quickly; weaving in stories and education; “no dead air.”
Advice for Aspiring Sellers:
- “You need to be engaged ... keep the audience entertained ... make it a radio show.” ([43:12] B)
- The best live sellers will dominate as platforms and content models mature.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

On why the hobby is so resilient and compelling:

“If I’m going to spend my free time and make money or at least not lose it, it’s why it’s one of the coolest hobbies to me.” (B) [00:07], [23:31]
On the collector’s edge over other hobbies:

“All of the money you put into golf is absolutely sunk ... When you think about the sports card hobby ... it is fun to actually engage in it ... I’m going to get that capital back if I ever choose to sell it.” (B) [23:31]
On the gambling aspect:

"We are all in on predicting everything ... it's up to the consumer to be able to have the discipline to not gamble ... that's where we're at." (B) [20:44]
On traditional vs. modern value:

“[For] the modern product ... do not think that buying this box of cards is going to make you money.” (B) [20:09]
On personalization and marketing:

“I want people to know who Gordy Bonker is. So I’m very calculated and always marketing my name to whatever business venture I'm moving into.” (B) [25:05]
On content and long-term business:

“Media is the hobby, hobby is media; commerce is media, media is commerce. It all feeds one another.” (A) [39:05] “Attention is currency. Content is both a long game and a short game.” (A) [39:30–40:24]

Important Timestamps

Episode Guest Introduction: [01:22]
Gordy’s Wall Street background/story: [02:58–04:24]
Asset class argument/data: [05:29–08:24]
Bubble skepticism/rareness in value: [09:29–11:28]
Fractional/card index models: [11:31–16:19]
Regulatory hurdles for fractional investment: [17:16–18:24]
Gambling/entertainment in the hobby: [18:45–24:46]
Media, creators, and advertising: [26:54–33:16]
Live selling as the hobby’s “radio show”: [39:05–44:49]
Card buying advice – sleepers under $100 / $1,000: [48:50–52:10]
- Ken Griffey Jr. Upper Deck rookie (grade 7): good buy around $100. [51:02]
- 50s/60s Hall of Fame cards (Jackie Robinson, Mickey Mantle, etc.): $100–$1,000.
Closing & how to connect with Gordy: [46:13–47:57]

Card Buying Recommendations (Listener Bonus)

Under $100:

Ken Griffey Jr. Upper Deck rookie (graded 7) [51:02]
- "That card right there ... you could get that card for around a hundred bucks right now." (B) [51:02]

$100–$1,000:

Hall of Famers from the 1950s/60s:
- Mickey Mantle’s 60s cards (earliest affordable playing years)
- Jackie Robinson 1955/56 (low grade)
- “Jackie Robinson, Mickey Mantle, those guys are never going to lose value.” (B) [48:50]

Tone & Flow

The episode is lively, honest, and deeply insightful. Ryan’s veteran marketing and business perspective creates a conversational, collaborative environment. Gordy Bonker is analytical yet accessible, combining hard asset analysis with real-world enthusiasm for the joy of collecting. Both balance investment talk with a deep respect for hobby entertainment and tradition.

Final Thoughts

This episode is a must-listen for collectors, investors, marketers, and newcomers alike. It demystifies the “sports cards as asset” thesis, highlights real trends and challenges in institutional adoption, and opens up a broader vision for media, live commerce, and passionate community in the collecting hobby.

Connect with Gordy Bonker:

Email: bonkerscards@gmail.com
Social: @bonkerscards everywhere (TikTok, Instagram, YouTube)
Newsletter/Club: bonkerscards.substack.com
The Gordy Bonker Show: Sports Cards Nonsense YouTube Channel, new episodes Wednesdays

Host: Ryan Alford

Instagram: @ryanalfrod

Podcast Summary

Trading Cards & Collectibles Podcast – The Radcast Network

Episode Title: Gordy Bonker left Wall Street for THIS: Why Sports Cards Are the Ultimate 'Hidden' Asset Class
Air Date: December 23, 2025
Host: Ryan Alford
Guest: Gordy Bonker

Overview

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Why Sports Cards Are a True Asset Class ([05:29]–[08:24])

Historical Context:
- Collecting is a centuries-old human behavior. Sports cards as a market have existed for over 100 years.
- True market formation and resale value started taking shape in the 1950s and 60s, with cards now displaying a robust history of appreciation.
Long-Term Confidence:
- High-end cards (e.g., Honus Wagner, Mickey Mantle, Jackie Robinson) show compound annual growth rates outpacing many collectibles.
- Bonker directly compares sports cards to art, saying:
  
  "Artwork is at the end of the day still just material ... it's really the creator ... or the scarcity ... that drives its value." ([05:29] B)
Undervalued Potential:
- Even the most expensive sports cards are undervalued compared to blue-chip art.
- Sports cards are only now starting to be viewed as serious stores of value by high-net-worth individuals.

2. The Bubble Question & Card Rarity ([09:29]–[10:36])

Cardboard Skepticism:
- Some doubt the staying power of "just cardboard" as a high-value investment.
- Bonker’s response: Rarity (population counts), demand, and historical performance separate iconic cards from speculative "bubbles."
Example:
- Jordan rookie in PSA 10 commands value due to scarcity relative to demand.

3. Institutionalization, Fractional Models & Marketplaces ([11:31]–[16:19])

Investment Funds & Indices:
- Trends like Kevin O'Leary forming a sports card index signal coming institutionalization, with more high-net-worth entry.
Fractional Ownership:
- Platforms like Rally have not yet succeeded with retail investors, due to marketing, liquidity, and (critically) regulatory hurdles.
  
  "For some reason there's a friction ... maybe it's the liquidity, maybe it's the marketing ... it just hasn't landed yet." ([13:42] B)
- Artwork has embraced such models more rapidly; sports cards could follow as sophistication increases.

4. Gambling & Entertainment: The Modern Hobby’s Double Edge ([17:16]–[24:46])

Entertainment Value:
- Ryan describes cards as entertainment first ("pay to go to the movies, walk away with nothing; with cards, you still have them").
- Gordy emphasizes the unique “cheat code” of collecting:
  
  "If I'm going to spend my free time and make money or at least at the very least, not lose it, it's why it's one of the coolest hobbies to me." ([23:31] B)
Gambling Influence:
- The rise of breaks, surprise/delight in pack opening, Fanatics’ moves into prediction markets, and wider US cultural shift to legalized betting are driving market attention (and risk).
- Distinction drawn between investing in blue-chip vintage vs. gambling on modern breaks.

5. Media, Content, and Community: The Collector as Creator ([26:54]–[47:57])

Explosive Growth in Hobby Media:
- Demand for content (YouTube, social, podcasts) is relentless; kids and adults crave education, entertainment, and connection.
- Advertisers are only just beginning to understand the captive, engaged, and often affluent hobby audience.
Monetization & Influence:
- Bonker sees opportunity in paid content, direct sales, and growing interest from high-net-worth collectors who want brokerage services.
- Still a gap in mainstream (non-hobby) brand sponsorship; he’s bullish it will shift as the space grows.
- "There's a tremendous gap ... with brands understanding that. It's a two-way street of winning." ([29:56] A)
Personal Brand & Strategy:
- Bonker credits his memorable name (“Bonker”) and calculated self-marketing for helping him break out in both finance and collecting.

6. Live Selling as the Next Media Frontier ([39:05]–[44:49])

Live-streamed Commerce:
- Gordy highlights his success with TikTok live selling ("Sunday night, 8pm Eastern"), which began as his full-time bet after leaving finance.
- Describes it as both sales and entertainment – “like a radio show” with high engagement, and now even sponsored.
- Keys to success: Energetic, informed hosting; moving product quickly; weaving in stories and education; “no dead air.”
Advice for Aspiring Sellers:
- “You need to be engaged ... keep the audience entertained ... make it a radio show.” ([43:12] B)
- The best live sellers will dominate as platforms and content models mature.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

On why the hobby is so resilient and compelling:

“If I’m going to spend my free time and make money or at least not lose it, it’s why it’s one of the coolest hobbies to me.” (B) [00:07], [23:31]
On the collector’s edge over other hobbies:

“All of the money you put into golf is absolutely sunk ... When you think about the sports card hobby ... it is fun to actually engage in it ... I’m going to get that capital back if I ever choose to sell it.” (B) [23:31]
On the gambling aspect:

"We are all in on predicting everything ... it's up to the consumer to be able to have the discipline to not gamble ... that's where we're at." (B) [20:44]
On traditional vs. modern value:

“[For] the modern product ... do not think that buying this box of cards is going to make you money.” (B) [20:09]
On personalization and marketing:

“I want people to know who Gordy Bonker is. So I’m very calculated and always marketing my name to whatever business venture I'm moving into.” (B) [25:05]
On content and long-term business:

“Media is the hobby, hobby is media; commerce is media, media is commerce. It all feeds one another.” (A) [39:05] “Attention is currency. Content is both a long game and a short game.” (A) [39:30–40:24]

Important Timestamps

Episode Guest Introduction: [01:22]
Gordy’s Wall Street background/story: [02:58–04:24]
Asset class argument/data: [05:29–08:24]
Bubble skepticism/rareness in value: [09:29–11:28]
Fractional/card index models: [11:31–16:19]
Regulatory hurdles for fractional investment: [17:16–18:24]
Gambling/entertainment in the hobby: [18:45–24:46]
Media, creators, and advertising: [26:54–33:16]
Live selling as the hobby’s “radio show”: [39:05–44:49]
Card buying advice – sleepers under $100 / $1,000: [48:50–52:10]
- Ken Griffey Jr. Upper Deck rookie (grade 7): good buy around $100. [51:02]
- 50s/60s Hall of Fame cards (Jackie Robinson, Mickey Mantle, etc.): $100–$1,000.
Closing & how to connect with Gordy: [46:13–47:57]

Card Buying Recommendations (Listener Bonus)

Under $100:

Ken Griffey Jr. Upper Deck rookie (graded 7) [51:02]
- "That card right there ... you could get that card for around a hundred bucks right now." (B) [51:02]

$100–$1,000:

Hall of Famers from the 1950s/60s:
- Mickey Mantle’s 60s cards (earliest affordable playing years)
- Jackie Robinson 1955/56 (low grade)
- “Jackie Robinson, Mickey Mantle, those guys are never going to lose value.” (B) [48:50]

Tone & Flow

Final Thoughts

Connect with Gordy Bonker:

Email: bonkerscards@gmail.com
Social: @bonkerscards everywhere (TikTok, Instagram, YouTube)
Newsletter/Club: bonkerscards.substack.com
The Gordy Bonker Show: Sports Cards Nonsense YouTube Channel, new episodes Wednesdays

Host: Ryan Alford

Instagram: @ryanalfrod

wavePod

Gordy Bonker left Wall Street for THIS: Why Sports Cards Are the Ultimate 'Hidden' Asset Class

Powered by Wave AI

Summary

Podcast Summary

Trading Cards & Collectibles Podcast – The Radcast Network

Overview

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Why Sports Cards Are a True Asset Class ([05:29]–[08:24])

2. The Bubble Question & Card Rarity ([09:29]–[10:36])

3. Institutionalization, Fractional Models & Marketplaces ([11:31]–[16:19])

4. Gambling & Entertainment: The Modern Hobby’s Double Edge ([17:16]–[24:46])

5. Media, Content, and Community: The Collector as Creator ([26:54]–[47:57])

6. Live Selling as the Next Media Frontier ([39:05]–[44:49])

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

Important Timestamps

Card Buying Recommendations (Listener Bonus)

Tone & Flow

Final Thoughts

Summary

Podcast Summary

Trading Cards & Collectibles Podcast – The Radcast Network

Overview

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Why Sports Cards Are a True Asset Class ([05:29]–[08:24])

2. The Bubble Question & Card Rarity ([09:29]–[10:36])

3. Institutionalization, Fractional Models & Marketplaces ([11:31]–[16:19])

4. Gambling & Entertainment: The Modern Hobby’s Double Edge ([17:16]–[24:46])

5. Media, Content, and Community: The Collector as Creator ([26:54]–[47:57])

6. Live Selling as the Next Media Frontier ([39:05]–[44:49])

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

Important Timestamps

Card Buying Recommendations (Listener Bonus)

Tone & Flow

Final Thoughts