Poland's plan to resist a Russian attack

Summary

Poland's Strategic Defense Initiatives Amidst Rising Tensions with Russia

Consider This from NPR
Episode: Poland's Plan to Resist a Russian Attack
Release Date: May 13, 2025
Host: Juana Summers

---

Introduction: Strained US-European Alliances

The episode opens with Juana Summers highlighting growing European concerns over the reliability of the United States as a steadfast ally. This unease is exacerbated by remarks from then-President Donald Trump during his reelection campaign, where he questioned the commitment of NATO members to defense spending.

Donald Trump [00:18]: "One of the presidents of a big country stood up, said, well, sir, if we don't pay and we're attacked by Russia, will you protect us? I said, you didn't pay. You're delinquent. He said, yes, let's say that happened. No, I would not protect you. In fact, I would encourage them to do whatever the hell they want. You gotta pay, you gotta pay."

These comments underscored Trump's skepticism about NATO allies' financial contributions, casting doubt on the US commitment to collective defense.

European Leaders Responding to Shifting Geopolitics

Following Trump's reelection, relations between the US and its European allies remained tumultuous. President Trump's apparent rapprochement with Russian President Vladimir Putin during peace negotiations with Ukraine further strained ties. Actions such as temporarily halting US aid to Ukraine in March and imposing significant tariffs on European imports in April added to the tension, though some tariffs have since been paused.

European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen voiced the gravity of the situation:

Ursula von der Leyen [01:17]: "The world around us is changing at lightning speed. Geopolitical shifts are shaking. Alliances, decade-old certainties are crumbling, and we still have a brutal war raging at our borders."

When pressed about the US's role, von der Leyen acknowledged the US as an ally but emphasized the urgent need for Europe to enhance its defense capabilities.

Ursula von der Leyen [01:38]: "I think it's a very strong wake-up call and Europe's moment now really to step up in defense."

In response, von der Leyen has championed an ambitious plan to increase European defense spending by over $800 billion, signaling a decisive shift towards greater self-reliance in security matters.

US Perspective on NATO's Strengthening

Reflecting on these developments, U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio asserted that President Trump remains supportive of NATO but has pressed allies to bolster their defense expenditures significantly.

Marco Rubio [02:01]: "The stronger our partners in NATO are, the more capable our partners in NATO are, the stronger NATO is and everybody should be in favor of that."

This stance underscores the administration's expectation for NATO members to contribute more substantially to their collective defense, thereby enhancing the overall strength of the alliance.

Poland's Comprehensive Defense Overhaul

Amidst these geopolitical shifts, Poland has emerged as a focal point in the region's defense strategies. Given its extensive 500-mile border with Russia and its ally Belarus, Poland is proactively preparing to safeguard its sovereignty against potential aggression.

Defense Spending and Military Training

Poland has committed to an unprecedented defense budget, allocating nearly 5% of its GDP—surpassing all other NATO members, including the United States. This substantial investment is directed towards modernizing its military infrastructure and expanding its defensive capabilities.

Prime Minister Donald Tusk emphasized the importance of comprehensive defense measures:

In March, he stated that by the end of the year, every adult male in Poland would undergo war training, highlighting the nation's commitment to widespread readiness.

Notable Scene: Military Oath Ceremony

An illustrative example of Poland's mobilization is depicted through the story of Dominique Milewski, a young soldier preparing to take his oath. His partner, Anita Milewski, expresses a mix of pride and apprehension:

Anita Milewski [03:58]: "We live in difficult times, and I feel like more difficult times are coming. There's a need, she says, for courageous people, tough people. And our Dominique is a rock. He's unbreakable."

Dominique's aspiration to drive one of Poland's Abrams tanks symbolizes the nation's resolve to build a formidable military force.

Fortifying the Russian Border

Poland's defense strategy extends to physical fortifications along its borders with Russia's Kaliningrad exclave. Lieutenant Ivona Misiarc provides an on-site perspective:

Lieutenant Ivona Misiarc [06:30]: "We've learned from Ukraine's experience with Russia's invasion, and we've applied those lessons here. These hedgehogs are here so that our enemy breaks his teeth before he even thinks of biting us."

Poland has invested over $2 billion in constructing landmine fields and installing concrete anti-tank barriers, colloquially known as "hedgehogs." These measures are designed to delay and impede any potential Russian advance.

US Military Presence and Strategic Training

The United States maintains a significant military presence in Poland, aimed at deterring Russian aggression and reinforcing NATO's eastern flank. Lieutenant Colonel William Branch, commander of the Forward Land Forces Multinational Group Poland, elaborates on the strategic importance of these deployments:

Lt. Col. William Branch [07:45]: "We have developed a strategy to encounter any kind of mass land grab or mass land invasion or incursion that would occur."

Under his command, approximately 1,000 U.S. soldiers are stationed at the Momowopisky training area in northeastern Poland. These troops are integral to defending the Suwalki Gap, a critical corridor that Russia may target to penetrate NATO territories.

Lt. Col. William Branch [08:22]: "A persistent theme in all of those visits. These countries are actively fighting to retain their sovereignty. They're actively fighting to continue to exist because there is a real threat that exists."

Poland's Strategic Alliances and Future Plans

Amidst uncertainties surrounding US commitments, Poland is diversifying its strategic partnerships. Mario Shmarshakowski, publisher of Defense24, discusses Poland's evolving security strategy:

Mario Shmarshakowski: "Poland's government has handled this question in vague diplomatic terms. But its actions show that it's beginning to look elsewhere for help."

Poland is increasingly turning to France, leveraging its extensive nuclear arsenal to enhance its security posture without the prerequisite of American consent required by the UK. Anticipated strategic agreements between Poland and France include the acquisition of advanced weaponry and the integration of Poland into France's nuclear defensive umbrella.

Mario Shmarshakowski: "In the next few months, Poland and France will sign big strategic agreements of security cooperation that may include Poland's purchase of French air tankers, submarines, and weaponry, and may also include an agreement that Poland will now be inside France's protective nuclear umbrella."

These initiatives are poised to significantly bolster Poland's defense capabilities, presenting a multifaceted approach to countering Russian threats.

Conclusion: A Nation on the Brink of Transformation

Poland's extensive defense reforms and strategic alliances signify a nation steadfastly preparing for potential conflicts. By investing heavily in military infrastructure, enhancing training programs, and forging robust international partnerships, Poland aims to secure its sovereignty and contribute meaningfully to NATO's collective defense framework.

As geopolitical tensions escalate, Poland's proactive measures serve as a blueprint for neighboring nations navigating an increasingly volatile security landscape.

---

Production Credits:
Produced by Christine Eris Smith and Connor Donovan
Audio Engineering by Nisha Hines
Edited by Nick Spicer, Jeanette Woods, and Nadia Lancet
Executive Producer: Sami Yenigun

---

This summary encapsulates the key discussions, insights, and conclusions from NPR's Consider This episode on Poland's defense strategies against potential Russian aggression. For a comprehensive understanding, listeners are encouraged to tune into the full episode.

Transcript

[Juana Summers]

It's not hard to see why Europe wonders whether the US Is still a reliable ally. Take these comments from then candidate Trump. On the campaign trail, before he was elected to a second term, he was recounting a discussion with other NATO leaders about how much spending member countries should contribute to defense.

[Donald Trump]

One of the presidents of a big country stood up, said, well, sir, if we don't pay and we're attacked by Russia, will you protect us? I said, you didn't pay. You're delinquent. He said, yes, let's say that happened. No, I would not protect you. In fact, I would encourage them to do whatever the hell they want. You gotta pay, you gotta pay.

[Juana Summers]

Not the words you want to hear from a key ally. In the months after his reelection, the relationship continued to be bumpy. President Trump appeared to side with Russian President Vladimir Putin in peace negotiations with Ukraine, stunning European allies. Then in March, he temporarily cut off U.S. aid to Ukraine. And in April, he imposed steep tariffs on imports from Europe. Some, but not all of those have since been paused. European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen told a German newspaper that, quote, the west as we knew it no longer exists. Here she is at a press conference in March.

[Ursula von der Leyen]

The world around us is changing at lightning speed. Geopolitical shifts are shaking. Alliances, decade old certainties are crumbling, and we still have a brutal war raging at our borders.

[Juana Summers]

Asked directly about Trump, she said that, yes, the US Was still an ally, but also this.

[Ursula von der Leyen]

I think it's a very strong wake up call and Europe's moment now really to step up in defense.

[Juana Summers]

Von der Leyen has pushed a more than $800 billion plan to boost European defense spending. Secretary of State Marco Rubio says Trump supports NATO and will in the alliance, but he has urged allies to significantly ramp up their defenses.

[Marco Rubio]

The stronger our partners in NATO are, the more capable our partners in NATO are, the stronger NATO is and everybody should be in favor of that.

[Juana Summers]

One country in particular has been beefing up its defense spending, Poland. Consider this. Poland has 500 miles of border with Russia and its ally, Belarus. Whatever happens between the U.S. and NATO, Poland is preparing to defend itself. From NPR, I'm Juana Summers.

[NPR Fundraising Announcement]

You may have heard that President Trump has issued an executive order seeking to block all federal funding. To npr, this is the latest in a series of threats to media organizations across the country. Millions of people depend on the NPR network now more than ever. We're depending on you. Please donate today. Visit donate.NPR.org know that fizzy feeling you.

[NPR Pop Culture Happy Hour]

Get when you read something really good watch the movie everyone's been talking about or catch the show that the Internet can't get over. At the Pop Culture Happy Hour podcast, we chase that feeling four times a week. We'll serve you recommendations and commentary on the buzziest movies, tv, music and more, from low brow to highbrow to the stu. In between, catch the Pop Culture Happy Hour podcast from npr.

[Juana Summers]

It's Consider this from npr. For Poland, it's not just about defense spending. It's also about training. Poland's Prime Minister Donald Tusk told Poland's parliament in March that by the end of this year, every adult male in the country should be trained for war. NPR's Rob Schmitz has the story.

[Marco Rubio]

A military ban marches in front of an unwavering row of Poland's newest soldiers, dozens of men and women who have answered the call to volunteer to protect their country against Russia. Watching from the sidelines at this ceremony outside of Warsaw is Anita Milewski, whose partner, Dominique, is about to take his oath to protect and serve. How do I feel? Asks Malevsky, nervously glancing at her child, who's holding her hand. Joy, right? We're proud of him. This is a courageous step. She says that as she fumbles for the right thing to say. Tears well up in her eyes. I'm emotional, she says, and a little nervous. We live in difficult times, and I feel like more difficult times are coming. There's a need, she says, for courageous people, tough people. And our Dominique is a rock. He's unbreakable. Dominique takes his oath and the band plays the national anthem. Behind them stand a row of four Abrams tanks. After the ceremony, Dominique glances longingly at them. The past month of basic training was intense, he says. We barely had time to rest. Now I'm staying on for specialized training. It's my dream to drive one of those tanks someday. These soldiers, these tanks, they're all part of Poland's overhaul of its military. This year, the country will spend nearly 5% of its GDP on defense, more than any other NATO member, including the US As a neighbor of Ukraine's and host to more than 2 million of its war refugees, Poland has seen, heard and felt what Russia is capable of. And it's now preparing for the worst. Hundreds of miles north of the capital, along Poland's border with Russia, bulldozers clear farmland for a landmine field while crews place neat rows of concrete anti tank structures called hedgehogs that look like massive gray Lego pieces. On a work break, Polish lieutenant Ivona Misiarc gives me a tour of Poland's newly fortified border with the Russian exclave of Kaliningrad. We peer into a deep ditch filled with water, and beyond that stand rows of hedgehogs that follow the curved border for as far as the eye can see. On the other side of the ditch, beyond a fence made of razor wire, is dense birch forest. Russia We've learned from Ukraine's experience with Russia's invasion, and we've applied those lessons here, she says. These hedgehogs are here so that our enemy breaks his teeth before he even thinks of biting us. And here, she says, pointing to a strip of land as wide as a football field, is a space for a minefield. Poland recently announced it was withdrawing from the Ottawa Convention, an international treaty banning the use of landmines. What we're seeing here, says Ms. Yarts, is what much of the 500 mile long border between US and Russia and Belarus will someday look like a very long ditch, columns of concrete hedgehogs, and landmine fields. This, she says, is going to be a lot of work. Poland has set aside more than $2 billion to build this, and its treasury is buying up land from farmers along the border for this new initiative. But that's not all action that's happening along this tense border, Father Hundreds of miles east, along another stretch of the same border, US soldiers conduct training exercises.

[Lt. Col. William Branch]

We have developed a strategy to encounter any kind of mass land grab or mass land invasion or incursion that would occur.

[Marco Rubio]

Lt. Col. William Branch is commander of the Forward Land Forces Multinational Group Poland, a group of 1,000 U.S. soldiers at the Momowopisky training area in northeastern Poland. His troops helped defend NATO's eastern front along a stretch of land known as a Suwalki Gap, a corridor where military strategists say Russia would likely target if it were to attack NATO member states. Branch's soldiers have made visits to the nearby Baltic states of Lithuania, Latvia, and Estonia. And along with Poland, he says, there's.

[Lt. Col. William Branch]

A persistent theme in all of those visits. These countries are actively fighting to retain their sovereignty. They're actively fighting to continue to exist because there is a real threat that exists.

[Marco Rubio]

And while there is a real threat, agrees Mario Shmarshakowski, publisher of Defense24, a Warsaw based security magazine. He says Russia's European neighbors have had time to prepare, drawing on years worth of lessons from Ukraine to study how Russia wages war. America is accustomed to quick aerial wars, he says, but Russia has retained its arsenal from the Soviet Union days. And that means, he says, low tech land based warfare is what Poland is focusing on defending itself against. But Marci says the challenge now is figuring out President Donald TRUMP Would the U.S. defend Poland if Russia attacked? He says Poland's government has handled this question in vague diplomatic terms. But its actions, he says, show that it's beginning to look elsewhere for help. The Polish government, he says, sees hope in France, which has an extensive nuclear arsenal, and the terms under which it can use these weapons are different from Britain's, which require American consent before they deploy them. So from a security perspective, he says, France is a safer option from where to seek assistance. In the next few months, he says, Poland and France will sign big strategic agreements of security cooperation that may include Poland's purchase of French air tankers, submarines and weaponry, and may also include an agreement that Poland will now be inside France's protective nuclear umbrella. And an agreement, he says, that could be as important as defense barriers along Poland's borders or a buildup of Poland's military. Anything, he says, to stop Russia.

[Juana Summers]

NPR's Rob Schmitz in Poland this episode was produced by Christine Eris Smith and Connor Donovan, with audio engineering by Nisha Hines. It was edited by Nick Spicer, Jeanette woods and Nadia Lancet. Our executive producer is Sami Yenigun. It's consider this from NPR. I'm Juana Summers.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

When Malcolm Gladwell presented NPR's Throughline podcast with a Peabody Award, he praised it for its historical and moral clarity. On Throughline, we take you back in time to the origins of what's in the news, like presidential power, aging and evangelicalism. Time travel with us every week on the Throughline Podcast from npr.

[Tonya Moseley]

I'm Tonya Moseley, co host of Fresh air. At a time of sound bites and short attention spans, our show is all about the deep dive. We do long form interviews with people behind the best in film, books, tv, music and journalism. Here, our guests open up about their process and their lives and in ways you've never heard before. Listen to the Fresh Air podcast from NPR and whyy want to hear this.

[NPR Fundraising Announcement]

Podcast without sponsor breaks. Amazon prime members can listen to Consider this sponsor free through Amazon Music. Or you can also support NPR's vital journalism and get consider this [e-mail] that's plus.NPR.org.