← Crime House 24/7
Crime House 24/7
After 40 Years, a Man Is Charged in Connection with Infamous Texas Killing Fields Murders
00:28:50
Loading summary
Transcript1 lines
- [00:02]
A
Hi listeners, it's Vanessa Richardson. Real quick, before today's episode, I want to tell you about another show from Crime House that I know you'll love. America's Most Infamous Crimes. Hosted by Katie Ring. Each week Katie takes on one of the most notorious criminal cases in American history. Serial killers who terrorized cities, unsolved mysteries that keep detectives up at night, and investigations that change the way we think about justice. Listen to and follow America's Most infamous crimes Tuesday through Thursday on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music or wherever you listen to podcasts. This is Crime House. Good morning everyone. We have multiple breaking true crime cases this morning that you need to know about. And we're starting with the biggest one. After more than four decades, a man has finally been charged in connection with two of the most notorious cold cases tied to the infamous Texas killing fields. This is crime house 24 7, your non stop source for the biggest crime cases developing right now. Make sure to subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. I'm Vanessa Richardson and we have quite a lineup for you today. Here's what you need to know. This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Do you ever think about switching insurance companies to see if you could save some cash? Progressive makes it easy to see if you could save when you bundle your home and auto policies. Try it@progressive.com Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. Potential savings will vary. Not available in all states. Along a stretch of Interstate 45 southeast of Houston, Texas, investigators have been finding the bodies of women and girls for more than five decades. More than 30 victims have been found beginning in the 1970s. Dozens of cases are still unsolved. It became known as the Texas Killing Fields, one of the most enduring cold case mysteries in American history. And on Tuesday, March 31, a Galveston county grand jury foundation finally indicted someone in connection with two of those murders. 61 year old James Dolph Elmore Jr. Of Bay Cliff, Texas Was arrested that same day and is currently being held without bond in the Galveston county jail. On Wednesday, April 1, Galveston County District Attorney Kenneth Cusick held a press conference to publicly discuss the indictment and release details of the charges. Most of the victims were girls and young women who had vanished without explanation. The cases drew national attention in inspired books, films and a Netflix documentary and remain among the most haunting unsolved crime clusters in Texas history. Investigators have long believed multiple perpetrators were responsible. In 2022, Oklahoma death row inmate William Reese pleaded guilty to three murders connected to the area, including 12 year old Laura Smither and 17 year old Jessica Kane and received life sentences. He additionally pleaded guilty to the murder of 20 year old Kelly Cox, was killed in North Texas and whose body was found in Brazoria county hundreds of miles away. But dozens of other deaths still remain unsolved. The two victims at the center of Wednesday's indictment are 16 year old Laura Miller and 30 year old Audrey Cook. Miller, who was a high school student in League City, Texas, disappeared in September 1984 and her body was found in 1986 in the killing Fields. Cook, who worked as a mechanic and lived in the Houston, Channel View and Heights areas of Texas, vanished in December 1985. Her remains went unidentified for decades, known only as a Jane Doe until DNA testing confirmed her identity in 2019. Between 1984 and 1991, two additional women were found in the same rural field as Miller and Cook near Calder Road in League city. They were 25 year old Heidi Phi Villarreal and 34 year old Donna Prudhomme. Now Elmore is charged with manslaughter and felony tampering with evidence in Laura Miller's death and with an additional tampering with evidence charge in Audrey Cook's death. Prosecutors allege that Elmore assisted a man named Clyde Hedrick, described by investigators as the primary suspect in all four of the Calder Road murders. Hedrick, who was 72, died by suicide in March 2026 before a grand jury could return a decision in his case. He had served eight years of a 20 year sentence for the 1984 death of another young woman, Ellen Beeson, on an involuntary manslaughter conviction and had been released on parole in 2021. He was never charged in the Killing Fields deaths before he died and maintained his innocence. The reinvestigation of the Killing Fields cases has been underway since 2024 and has involved thousands of investigative hours and extensive lab work. Galveston County District Attorney Kenneth Cusick, who was app to his role in October, had vowed to take a deeper look at these cases and said at Wednesday's press conference that the investigation does not end with Elmore. There are active leads, he said, and more charges could follow. Tim Miller, the father of Laura Miller and the founder of Texas Equisearch, a nonprofit search and rescue organization he built in his daughter's name, revealed on Wednesday that over the past four years he had met with Elmore at least 2:30 times. Elmore had reportedly reached out to Miller in April 2022 wanting to, quote, get some things off his chest, end quote. Miller has not publicly disclosed what Elmore told him concerned it could jeopardize the case. He did, however, appear visibly shaken when speaking about it. Miller told reporters, quote, there were times that I left James Elmore and I had to pull over and just sob and cry with the information I got, end quote. I He also drove with Elmore to Calder Road, the very site where his daughter's remains were discovered. For Laura Miller's family and for the families of all the victims, Wednesday's announcement was simultaneously a breakthrough and a source of grief that has never fully healed. Nina Jaeger, the niece of Heidi 5 Villarreal, called it bittersweet. Her grandfather had long believed Hedrick was responsible but felt his efforts were ignored by authorities. And Tim Miller, who has given decades to search the missing, made it clear that this is not the end. He said, quote, if anybody thinks that these girls are the only ones that were killed, you're living in a delusional damn world. We've got other girls to find, end quote. And while Cusick says the investigation is far from over, we head now to Washington, D.C. where a man opened his apartment building door to two strangers who had followed him home and it cost him his life. A murder case that shocked the DC's Logan Circle neighborhood has now resulted in two arrests, the most recent coming on Wednesday, April 1st. Now both 36 year old Rico Rashad Barnes and 39 year old Alfonso Walker are in custody. On the morning of February 11, 40 year old said Hamad Hussein was found dead inside his condominium on the 1400 block of Rhode Island Avenue Northwest. And what investigators found was they entered that apartment was something interim Metropolitan Police Chief Jeff Carol described at a Tuesday press conference as a quote, particularly heinous crime, end quote. That included robbery, a violent assault and a fire set after Hussein's death. Here's how it unfolded. According to Investigators, just after 3:30am On February 11, D.C. fire and EMS were called to the building for reports of smoke in a hallway. Firefighters put out a small fire and found Hussein unconscious and not breathing inside his ground floor apartment. He was pronounced dead at the scene. Investigators determined he'd been beaten, strangled and bound and that a fire had been set after his death. The autopsy told a grim story. Multiple blunt force injuries, including skull fractures, evidence of ligature strangulation and burns to his body that were determined to have occurred post mortem. When emergency crews entered. Hussein was found lying face down with his wrists and ankles bound with neckties, according to investigators. Blood was visible on the floors, walls and furniture. Drawers had been open throughout the apartment and electronics jewelry and cash. Approximately $50,000 worth of items were missing. Investigators believe the motive was robbery. Court documents and surveillance footage helped piece together what happened. Investigators say two people had been at a nearby Popeyes restaurant that night when they observed Hussein heading home. They followed him as he walked toward his AP building. Camera footage captured one of the suspects knocking on the lobby door shortly after Hussein had entered around 1:39am Hussein opened it almost immediately. Police say an argument broke out that spilled onto the sidewalk and the two suspects then forced their way in using Hussein's key fob. Once inside, the attack continued out of camera view. The suspects reportedly left the building around 2:30am Police believe Hussein did not know his attackers and that he appeared to have been chosen at random. Commander Kevin Kentish of the Criminal Investigations Division said video evidence was key to finding the suspects. Detectives spent countless hours reviewing footage from inside the building and from surrounding areas to build the case. And on Monday, March 30, 36 year old Rico Rashad Barnes of Northwest D.C. was arrested and charged with first degree murder while armed. Two days later on Wednesday, April 1, homicide detectives charged 39 year old Alfonso Walker, also of Northwest D.C. with first degree murder while armed felony murder. Walker had already been in custody on separate unrelated charges when he was served with the murder charge in this case. Now both men face charges in Hussein's killing and the investigation remains ongoing. Chief Carroll praised the homicide unit and called it strong detective work. He also directly addressed Hussein's family saying, quote, we know that this news does not ease the pain that you're feeling, but we hope it does bring some level of closure, end quote. And from D.C. we move to Caroline County, Virginia where a community is grieving an 18 year old student whose disappearance last week ended in the worst possible way. In Caroline County, Virginia. The search for a missing 18 year old ended in heartbreak Tuesday evening. And now investigators say his death is connected to a separate homicide case where a body was discovered just days earlier. 18 year old Jaden Michael McCumber of Hopewell, Virginia was last seen leaving his home on Richmond street around 11:30pm on the night of Wednesday, March 25. The following day, March 26, Virginia State Police issued a critically Missing adult alert. His family told police his disappearance was out of character, he always communicated with them and that the circumstances were suspicious. In the days that followed, his vehicle, a gray Chevrolet Silverado, was tracked to multiple locations across Virginia, including Glen Allen, Virginia Beach, Chesapeake and King William County. His air tag also pinged in Caroline County. On the Evening of Tuesday, March 31st deputies with the Caroline County Sheriff's Office who'd been searching a pond near the boundary line between Caroline and King and Queen Counties recovered Jaden's remains. The Caroline County Sheriff's Office confirmed his death and said it is treating the case as a homicide. Hopewell City Public Schools, where Jaden was a student and a member of the swim team, posted a tribute on social media Wednesday. The school called him a beautiful soul and wrote, quote, we are deeply saddened by the outcome involving our Hopewell High School student, Jaden, a beloved swim team member, end quote. But a key discovery made just days before Jaden's body was found has intensified the case. On Friday, March 27, a property owner in Caroline county found an unidentified body on their land off Bagby Road discovered by a man riding an atv. That individual has not yet been identified. Investigators have said they believe the two cases are connected and that Jaden's body was found approximately five miles from where the unidentified woman was discovered. The the Caroline County Sheriff's Office has described the circumstances of the broader case as, quote, deeply disturbing and in a statement said, quote, the scene our deputies and investigators encountered was difficult, end quote. Investigators believe foul play is involved and that the incident was not random, although they've not disclosed what links the two cases have or a possible motive. We'll continue to follow that investigation as it develops. And for our final story this morning, we head to California where a rock legend was targeted outside of a Santa Monica building last week in what police are calling a stalking incident in Los Angeles, legendary Fleetwood Mac guitarist and vocalist Lindsey Buckingham was attacked by an unidentified woman outside a building in Santa Monica, California on Wednesday, April 1. And the incident is raising serious concerns about a pattern of alleged alleged stalking against the musician. The attack happened as Buckingham arrived for an appointment at an undisclosed location in Santa Monica. According to law enforcement sources, a woman described as a stalking suspect threw an unknown substance on Buckingham as he entered the building, then fled the scene. Buckingham was not physically injured. Police said they know who the woman is. She's known to Buckingham from prior incidents and that an arrest is expected. The LAPD's Threat Management Unit is leading the investigation in coordination with Santa Monica police. The broader context here is significant. Buckingham and his family have had a documented history of alleged stalking involving a 54 year old woman named Michelle Dick, who they obtained a restraining order against after years of alleged harassment and death threats. Court documents indicate Dick had shown up at the Buckingham family's Brentwood home on multiple occasions, made a false 911 call claiming someone at the home needed help and sent threatening messages. Dick spoke to KTLA on Wednesday and admitted to approaching Buckingham last week, claiming he is her biological father, a claim Buckingham's team has not addressed. It's not confirmed whether Dick is the woman involved in the attack. Police have not publicly identified the suspect, the LAPD said in a statement, quote, to protect the integrity of the open and ongoing investigation. No further comment will be provided at this time. End quote. Buckingham, a two time Grammy winner, was a member of Fleetwood Mac between 1975 and 1987 and from 1996 to 2018. Staring at your screen? Take a break. Get free items with TikTok and free pick items. Share a link and watch the price drop to zero. Download TikTok search free. Start slashing now. Hi listeners, it's Vanessa Richardson. I wanted to take a brief moment to tell you about another show from Crime House that I know you'll love. America's Most Infamous Crimes, hosted by Katie Ring. Each week Katie takes on a notorious crime, whether unfolding now or etched into American history, revealing not just what happened happen, but how it forever changed our society. Serial killers who terrorized cities, unsolved mysteries that keep detectives up at night, and investigations that change the way we think about justice. Each case unfolds across multiple episodes released every Tuesday through Thursday, from the first sign that something was wrong to the moment the truth came out or didn't. These are the stories behind the headlines. Listen to and follow America's Most Infamous Crimes Tuesday through Thursday on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, or wherever you listen to podcasts. Lastly, let me tell you about what else is happening at Crime House this week. On Monday, Twisted Tales explored Ticci Toby, one of the most enduring characters to emerge from the creepypasta tradition, the genre of collaborative Internet horror fiction that that quietly became one of the defining storytelling moments of the early digital age. If you're not familiar with creepypasta, the short version is it's horror built for the Internet. Stories written to be copied, shared, screenshot, and passed around, designed to feel just plausible enough to unsettle you, just ambiguous enough that a part of your brain files them somewhere uncomfortable. The name comes from the practice of copy pasting text across forums and message boards, and the genre grew from there into something with a reach and spe that earlier forms of scary storytelling never had access to. But the underlying mechanics the story that travels, mutates, and eventually starts to feel more real than fictional are much older than the Internet. And the consequences of that feeling have never been Purely imaginary. Here are five urban legends that stopped being just stories. Number one. Spring Heeled Jack. In the winter of 1837, reports started circulating across London of a strange figure attacking people in the streets. A tall, thin entity capable of leaping extraordinary distances with clawed hands, glowing eyes, and the ability to breathe blue flame. The creature was called Spring Heeled Jack, and within weeks, the reports had spread from London into the broader English countryside. What makes the Spring Heeled Jack phenomenon remarkable is how completely it overtook public perception. Despite having no verified physical evidence behind it. Newspapers ran accounts. Police received formal complaints. Witnesses who had never encountered the figure reported seeing it simply because the story had become so vivid and so widely circulated that expectation created perception. Sightings multiplied precisely as belief spread. The figure was never identified, never caught, and almost certainly never existed in the form described. But the fear was entirely real. People changed their behavior, avoided certain streets, and reported genuine terror at encounters that investigators could never substantiate. Spring Heeled Jack is one of the earliest and most thoroughly documented examples of a fictional or misidentified threat achieving the social weight of a real one, not because people were credulous, but because the story was told often enough and with enough consistency to become its own kind of evidence. Number two, the phantom anesthetist of Mattoon. In September 1944, a local newspaper in Mattoon, Illinois, ran a story about a woman who claimed to have been attacked in her home by a mysterious prowler who used some kind of gas or chemical spray to paralyze her temporarily. The headline was dramatic. The story spread quickly. Within days, more than two dozen additional residents reported similar attacks. Symptoms included nausea, paralysis, and a str. Strange smell. Police launched an investigation. The story attracted national press attention. The town was in a genuine state of alarm. Investigators eventually concluded that there was no phantom anesthetist. There was no chemical spray. The original incident may have had a mundane explanation, possibly fumes from a nearby manufacturing plant. But the wave of subsequent reports was almost certainly a case of mass psychogenic illness, driven by the power of the original news story to prime expectation and transform anxiety into a physical symptom. What the Mattoon case illustrates is how efficiently a story, even one reported as news rather than legend, can create the reality it describes. The fear produced real symptoms in real people. The investigation was real. The disruption to the community was real. The attacker was not. Number three. The satanic panic. Throughout the 1980s, the United States was gripped by a widespread moral panic centered on the belie that networks of satanic ritual abusers were operating inside daycare centers, neighborhoods, and communities across the country. Children were interviewed using leading techniques. Adults were charged, trials were held. People went to prison. The Panic drew on a combination of sources evangelical religious literature, sensationalized journalism, true crime books, and a therapeutic community that had developed theories about recovered memory that later proved deeply unreliable. Together, these produced a narrative so widely circulated and so emotionally compelling that it became, for a significant period, treated as investigative reality rather than what it actually was folklore. Extensive subsequent investigation found no credible evidence of organized satanic ritual abuse. Convictions were overturned. Experts who had testified confidently about evidence of abuse acknowledged that their methods had been flawed. The people who served prison sentences for crimes that almost certainly never happened had their lives permanently altered by a story that achieved legal force without factual foundation. The Satanic Panic is the most consequential example in modern American history of an urban legend, a circulating story about a hidden, threatening other moving from cultural anxiety into courtroom and prison. Number four the Slender man stabbing. In May 2014, two 12 year old girls in Waukesha, Wisconsin, lured a classmate into the woods and stabbed her 19 times. She survived. When investigators asked why, both girls cited the same reason. They believed they needed to kill in order to become proxies of Slender Man, a fictional horror character created on an Internet forum in 2009 and to protect their families from his wrath. Slender man was unambiguously a made up character. He had a known origin. His creator was identifiable. He had no existence outside of collaborative Internet fiction. And yet for these two children, he had become real enough to motivate an attempted murder. The case raised questions that psychologists, educators, and legal scholars are still working through about the line between fiction and belief in developing minds, about how online horror context interacts with mental illness, and about what responsibility, if any, attaches to creators of collaborative dark fiction when their work travels beyond the communities it was made for. It also raised a simpler, harder question. What does it mean for a story to be real? Not factually real. Motivationally real. Real enough to act on. Ticci Toby emerged from the same corner of the Internet as Slenderman in the same years inside the same storytelling traditional. That context is part of why his story is worth understanding. Number five, the Hook. The Hook is one of the oldest and most widely circulated American urban legends. The basic version is two teenagers parked at a lover's lane hear a radio report about an escaped mental patient with a hook for a hand. They decide to leave. When they arrive home, they find a hook hanging from the car door handle. The story has no single origin and no confirmed instance of actually occurring. It's been collected by folklorists across dozens of states, in dozens of variations, since at least the 1950s. And yet for decades it functioned as a genuine behavioral deterrent, a story told by parents to teenagers, by teenagers to each other, that shaped where young people chose to go and what they chose to do there. Folklorists who have studied the legend note that its power came not from anyone believing it was literally true, but from the fact that it didn't have to be. It was plausible enough to introduce doubt, and doubt was sufficient. The hook didn't need to exist. The possibility of the hook was enough to change behavior in the real world. That mechanism, a story that influences action not by being believed outright, but by being believed just enough, is one of the most durable and under examined forces in human social life. And it didn't start with the Internet. It's just found a faster vehicle. What's worth remembering underneath all of it is that none of this is new. The technology is new. The platforms are new. The speed at which a story can reach a million people overnight is genuinely unprecedented. But the impulse driving all of it, the desire to sit with something frightening, to pass it to the person next to you to whisper, did you hear about this? Is about as old as human beings get. Yet every era finds its own containers for that impulse. The oral tradition gave way to the printed pamphlet, the pamphlet to the penny dreadful, the penny dreadful to the pulp magazine, the pulp magazine to the television anthology, the television anthology to the message board thread. Each transition looked at the time like something entirely new. And each one was underneath it the same thing it had always been. People gathered in the dark, passing a story between them. The camp just looks different now. For the full story behind Ticci Toby and the creepypasta tradition that built him, head over to our Crime House feed for the latest episode of Twisted Tales. You've been listening to crime house 247 bringing you breaking crime news. I'm Vanessa Richardson. We'll be back Monday morning with more developing stories. Stay safe and thanks for watching for listening. Thanks for listening to today's episode. Not sure what to listen to next? Check out America's Most Infamous Crimes hosted by Katie Ring. From serial killers to unsolved mysteries and game changing investigations, each week Katie takes on a notorious criminal case in American history. Listen to and follow Follow America's most infamous crimes now. Wherever you listen to podcasts.