Crime House Daily — Night Watch: He Kills His Pregnant Mistress and BRAGS Police Has No Evidence

Podcast Host: Katie Ring
Date: October 15, 2025

Episode Overview

In this gripping episode, Katie Ring goes deep into the horrifying case of Jose Soto Escalera, a married father of four convicted for the brutal murder of his pregnant mistress, 23-year-old Tanya Wise, in St. Lucie County, Florida. The episode unpacks the investigation, evidence, and courtroom drama culminating in Escalera’s sentencing, with chilling details and crucial insights into the ongoing fight for justice.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Introducing the Case & Victims

• Location: Port St. Lucie, Florida, typically considered "the safest large city in Florida."

• Victim: Tanya Wise, a young mother, 8.5 months pregnant, was found violently murdered on August 24, 2018.

  • Memorable Description:

    "Her throat has been slashed almost to her spine and her skull is visible through the skin." — Katie Ring [05:01]

• Perpetrator: Jose Soto Escalera, a married father of four, was discovered to be the unborn child’s father after initially denying any affair.

2. Timeline of the Murder & Discovery

• Body discovered by Christine Gavin in a drainage ditch; evidence at the scene included a condom and physical trauma.
• Witness William Mullen recalled a truck driving slowly with its lights off near the site late at night.
• Police quickly launched a homicide investigation, initially questioning Tanya’s boyfriend and other known associates.

3. Investigation & Evidence Gathering

• Suspect Pool: Police first investigated Tanya’s boyfriend, Mark Burke, her pimp, and a recent driver; DNA ruled out these men as the father.

• Jose Soto Escalera Emerges:

  • Met Tanya through her boyfriend.
  • Appeared shocked in initial interview, denied relationship, agreed to DNA swab.

• Breakthrough:

  • DNA confirmed Jose as the father.
  • Surveillance placed his truck at Tanya’s neighborhood at the time of disappearance; phone records matched.
  • A crucial witness recounted Jose’s violent past: a 1993 homicide for which he was never prosecuted due to statute of limitations.

4. Premeditation & Motive

• Motive: Jose feared losing his family and status if the affair was revealed.
• Tried to pay Tanya $500 for an abortion; angered when she kept the baby and gave the money to another man.
• Premeditated Actions:
  • Sought to acquire a "ghost gun" (untraceable firearm) from coworker Kenneth Brady Baron.
  • Confessed plans to nephew Eric Alvarado, caught on Waste Pro company truck surveillance:

    "I'm going to blow her brains out so she doesn't talk." — Jose Soto Escalera [13:45] "I had it all over the clothes. But without the evidence they can't do nothing if something happens. No one saw the bag." — Jose, recorded, describing the murder [00:54]

5. Arrest & Trial

• Police gathered enough circumstantial and direct evidence (including phone records, truck sightings, and recorded confessions) to arrest Jose.
• Jose was arrested on September 21, 2018, surrendered without incident despite being armed.
• Prosecution: Portrayed Jose as cold, calculated, and willing to eliminate Tanya to cover his tracks.
• Defense: Attempted to redirect blame to Tanya’s other abusive partners; argued pre-trial publicity and local comparisons (notably the Checkinson Sinclair case) biased the jury.
• Jose declined to take the stand; no defense witnesses called.

6. Verdict, Sentencing, and Aftermath

• After just an hour of jury deliberation:

  "They found Jose guilty of first-degree murder." — Katie Ring [17:42]

• Sentencing:

  • Jury recommended death penalty (8-4 vote).
  • Spencer hearing (unique to Florida): Jose pleaded directly to judge for leniency.
  • Ultimately not sentenced to death; details of final sentence not specified.

• Impact:

  • Emphasis on the tragedy of Tanya and her unborn son, Josiah, and the ongoing pain for their family.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Jose Soto Escalera's chilling bravado:

  "But without the evidence they can't do nothing if something happens." — Jose, recorded conversation [00:54]

• On the discovery of Tanya's body:

  "Her hand was still clutched around a clump of grass... It was clear that she was violently attacked." — Katie Ring [05:07]

• On domestic violence statistics:

  "Sixty percent of women who are murdered are murdered by a romantic partner or someone they know." — Katie Ring [06:33]

• On the rarity of justice in older cases:

  "He had shot and killed a man in Bridgeport, Connecticut... but the five year statute of limitations had already passed, meaning Jose may have gotten away with taking someone else's life." — Katie Ring [12:30]

Important Timestamps

• 00:41–01:03: Jose’s chilling confession, caught on tape, describing the murder and his evasion confidence.
• 03:39–07:35: Detailed narration of Tanya's discovery, the investigation's early steps, and her background.
• 11:46–15:00: The link to Jose is revealed via DNA, and background on his prior alleged homicide and affair with Tanya.
• 15:00–21:45: Evidence of premeditation, Jose's confession, arrest, and the build-up to the trial.
• 17:42: Jury verdict delivered: guilty of first-degree murder.
• Final 2 min: Sentencing phase, Spencer hearing explanation, and reminder of the human cost—Tanya and her unborn son’s loss.

Conclusion

Katie Ring’s careful retelling of the Tanya Wise murder case dissects both the harrowing circumstances of the crime and the methodical police investigation that brought Jose Soto Escalera to justice. With a focus on evidence, motive, and courtroom developments, the episode serves as a stark reminder of the dangers many women face from those closest to them. The tone remains urgent, empathetic, and analytical, urging continued vigilance and advocacy for victims.

For ongoing updates, listeners are encouraged to subscribe on YouTube and social channels (@crimehouse24.7).