Crime House Daily: Night Watch — Sandra Birchmore, Part 5
Episode Date: November 21, 2025
Host: Katie Ring

Episode Overview

In the powerful conclusion to their five-part series, Crime House Daily’s Night Watch with Katie Ring digs deeply into the pursuit of justice for Sandra Birchmore, a young woman who died under suspicious circumstances after years of grooming and abuse by Stoughton, MA police officers. Despite initial rulings of suicide, Sandra’s family persists in seeking the truth, leading to new forensic findings, renewed public attention, and an eventual federal indictment. This episode not only unpacks the latest developments in Sandra’s case but also examines the broader prevalence and systemic issues of sexual abuse within law enforcement mentoring programs.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Recap of the Case and Previous Episodes

• Sandra's Background & Abuse: Sandra Birchmore was manipulated, groomed, and abused from age 15 by Officer Matthew Farwell, alongside other officers in a position of mentorship.
• Questionable Police Investigation: Her death was quickly ruled a suicide by both local and state police, despite significant evidence suggesting foul play.
• “There was a lot of evidence that Matthew Farwell was the killer, but it didn't seem like Matthew would be charged with any crimes at all. Not Sanders murder, not even the clear statutory rape and larceny that were spelled out loud and clear in their over 32,000 texts.” — Katie Ring [06:08]

2. The Family’s Fight for Justice

• Campaign for Public Attention: Sandra’s family launched a public campaign (“Justice for Sandra Birchmore”), garnering support but facing institutional resistance.
• Wrongful Death Lawsuit & Dr. Michael Baden’s Findings:
  • Hired renowned forensic pathologist Dr. Michael Baden.
  • Dr. Baden concluded: “Ms. Burchmore did not die of a suicidal hanging. The cause of Ms. Birchmore's death is strangulation, and the manner of death is homicide.” — Katie Ring, quoting Dr. Baden [08:25]
  • Hyoid bone fracture supported homicide rather than suicide.
  • Criticism of state medical examiner for not testing evidence (e.g. fetal DNA, rape kit).

3. The FBI Steps In

• Federal Investigators Launch Their Own Case:

  • Triggered in part by overlaps with the high-profile Karen Reed trial and allegations of widespread police misconduct in Canton, MA.
  • Interviews with overlooked witnesses and deeper forensic reviews.
  • Contradictions in Matthew Farwell's statements, especially around Sandra’s mental health.

• Forensic Breakthrough:

  • FBI’s Dr. Bill Smock: Confirms evidence of strangulation, identifies duffel bag strap buckle imprint on Sandra’s chest, and correlates movement data from Sandra’s health app.
  • “When Dr. Smock examined photos of Sandra's body, he identified an imprint of the duffel bag strap's buckle on her chest. According to him, it suggested blunt force trauma from an assault.” — Katie Ring [14:46]

4. The State’s Reluctance to Change Ruling

• August 2024 Meeting: FBI and Dr. Smock try to convince the Massachusetts medical examiner to change suicide ruling, but the examiner refuses to budge.
  • “If the state and federal agencies don't agree on the manner of death, this could make for an uphill battle in court.” — Katie Ring [15:40]

5. Federal Charges & Arrest

• Dramatic Arrest of Matthew Farwell (August 28, 2024):

  • “He got into his truck… but he never made it inside because as soon as he arrived, federal SWAT agents swarmed the truck. Matthew slowly climbed out with his hands up and laid face down on the ground while the agents handcuffed him.” — Katie Ring [16:32]
  • Farwell is indicted for "killing a witness or victim," alleging he murdered Sandra to silence her about federal crimes.

• New Federal Legal Developments:

  • As of this episode, Farwell faces charges carrying a life sentence or potential death penalty.
  • October 28, 2025: Additional charge for "causing the death of an unborn child,” carrying another mandatory life sentence.
  • Paternity testing post-arrest reveals Farwell was NOT the father of Sandra’s baby.
  • “Could you imagine doing all of that and the baby wasn't even yours?” — Katie Ring [19:42]

6. Other Officers and Departmental Accountability

• Robert Devine’s Decertification Hearings:

  • Hearing videos released in October 2025.
  • Devine blames Sandra, denies knowledge of others’ involvement, but has a documented history of predatory behavior.

• Criticism of Systemic Failures:

  • “Men like him are the very last kind of people we need working in law enforcement and pretending to protect people when they were just really grooming kids and passing this poor girl around like she was nothing.” — Katie Ring [21:28]

7. Broader Context: Police Sexual Abuse Issues

• Widespread Problem in Police Explorers Programs:

  • Since 1996, nearly 200 reported sexual abuse cases within the program.
  • Example: St. Petersburg case where 11 officers were found to have abused minors.
  • "The fact that victims aren't believed is hard enough, but the fact that they have to report their police abuser to other policemen that won't believe them is even more terrifying." — Katie Ring [25:36]

• National Statistics & Power Imbalances:

  • Study: Every five days, a U.S. police officer is caught for sexual misconduct.
  • Expert Laura Palumbo: “It is this ongoing process of of really confusing and shifting the way someone sees the world. They have lost their ability to differentiate between what behaviors are healthy and what behaviors are abusive.” — Laura Palumbo, cited by Katie Ring [27:46]

• Chief Donna McNamara’s Statement:

  • "Every good and decent police officer should be aware of and angry about the injustices inflicted upon Sandra Birchmore. Sandra idolized police officers...she was victimized as a result. Sandra Birchmore should be alive now… it wasn't just one one person that killed her. It was an entire system." — Katie Ring, quoting McNamara [28:17]

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• "Attention is the most effective way to get justice.” — Katie Ring [06:48]
• “Baden's findings brought a ton of publicity to the case and got the attention of Donna McNamara, the Stoughton PD chief of police. McNamara had ordered the internal affairs investigation... And now she's horrified by what she's reading in Dr. Baden's report. She said, quote, 'I was profoundly disturbed and troubled by what I read. The findings certainly warrant further examination. At the highest level, Sandra received not so much as a sliver of justice during her life, and we will not cease in our efforts to ensure our duty to administer justice.’” — Katie Ring [09:58]
• “Sandra was adamant that the baby was Matthew's, and based on Matthew's actions, it certainly seems like he believed it too. However, it remains to be seen how this will impact proceedings of Matthew's trial, especially because just recently, he was hit with another charge.” — Katie Ring [19:42]
• "Preventing another case like Sandra's is going to take comprehensive reform that keeps people like Robert Devine out of positions of power." — Katie Ring [26:47]
• “Sandra Birchmore should be alive now. She should have been able to live the life she wanted. But ultimately it wasn't just one one person that killed her. It was an entire system. And it's important to make sure justice is fully pursued in her case and the countless others like hers. And hopefully someday we'll be able to stop it from ever happening again." — Katie Ring [28:40]

Timestamps for Major Segments

• [00:39] – Recount of evidence that undermined suicide ruling; Farwell’s threat and abuse.
• [04:08] – Series recap and episode roadmap.
• [06:08] – Institutional resistance, campaign for justice, and Dr. Baden’s introduction.
• [08:25] – Dr. Baden’s homicide ruling; new forensic findings.
• [09:58] – Chief McNamara’s reaction and quote.
• [12:45] – FBI involvement, fresh interviews, and Sandra’s true mental health state.
• [14:44] – FBI forensics, duffel bag strap evidence, health app data contradiction.
• [16:32] – Matthew Farwell’s dramatic arrest by federal agents.
• [17:58] – Federal indictment, bail status, trial date, and new info about paternity.
• [19:42] – Revelation Farwell wasn't the baby’s father, new federal charges.
• [21:28] – Robert Devine's redacted hearing video, character and systemic critique.
• [24:15] – Wider history and statistics of police sexual misconduct in Explorer programs.
• [25:36] – Barriers victims face reporting police abuse.
• [27:46] – Laura Palumbo expert insight; grooming explained.
• [28:17] – McNamara’s statement, call for reform, final reflections.

Conclusion

Katie Ring closes the episode reflecting on the depth of Sandra’s tragedy, the tenacity of her family, and the need for reform. The case is emblematic of not only individual crimes but institutional failures. As Sandra’s federal murder trial looms, the host calls for continued public attention and reform—to ensure Sandra’s story leads to lasting change, not just for her, but for all vulnerable youth in positions of dependency on authority.

If you missed any prior episodes or want to join the ongoing conversation, subscribe to Crime House Daily on YouTube or your preferred podcast platform.